Human Geography Nature and Scope Study Guide

Nature of Geography as an Integrative Discipline

  • Link with Mother Discipline: Geography as a field of study is characterized as integrative, empirical, and practical. It serves as the foundation from which various branches, including human geography, sprout.

  • Extensive Reach: The discipline covers every event or phenomenon that varies over space and time.

  • Core Components of Earth: The earth comprises two major components:

    • Nature: The physical environment.

    • Life Forms: Including human beings.

  • Core Concern: The primary objective of geography is to understand the earth as the "home of human beings" and to study all elements that have sustained them. This necessitates a dual emphasis on nature and humans.

  • The Dualism Debate: Historically, geography has been subject to debates regarding its methodology and approach:

    • Nomothetic vs. Idiographic: Whether the discipline should be law-making and theorizing (nomothetic\text{nomothetic}) or descriptive (idiographic\text{idiographic}).

    • Regional vs. Systematic: Whether the subject matter should be organized by regions or through a systematic approach.

    • Theoretical vs. Historic-Institutional: Whether phenomena should be interpreted through theory or through historical and institutional lenses.

  • Holistic View: Modern geography appreciates that the dichotomy between physical and human geography is not valid; nature and humans are inseparable elements that must be viewed holistically.

Anthropomorphic Metaphors in Geography

Geographers often use symbols from human anatomy to describe physical and human phenomena:

  • Physical Features:

    • "Face" of the earth.

    • "Eye" of the storm.

    • "Mouth" of the river.

    • "Snout" (nose\text{nose}) of the glacier.

    • "Neck" of the isthmus.

    • "Profile" of the soil.

  • Human Features:

    • Regions, villages, and towns are described as "organisms."

    • German geographers specifically describe the "state/country" as a "living organism."

    • Transport networks (roads, railways, and waterways\text{roads, railways, and waterways}) are referred to as "arteries of circulation."

Defining Human Geography

  • Ratzel: Defines it as "the synthetic study of relationship between human societies and earth’s surface." His focus is on synthesis.

  • Ellen C. Semple: Defines it as "the study of the changing relationship between the unresting man and the unstable earth." Her focus is on dynamism.

  • Paul Vidal de la Blache: Describes it as a "conception resulting from a more synthetic knowledge of the physical laws governing our earth and of the relations between the living beings which inhabit it."

Nature of Human Geography

  • Interaction: Human geography studies the inter-relationship between the physical environment and the socio-cultural environment created by humans.

  • Physical Environment Elements: These include landforms, soils, climate, water, natural vegetation, and diverse flora and fauna.

  • Cultural Landscape Elements: These include houses, villages, cities, road-rail networks, industries, farms, ports, and items of material culture.

  • Interdependence: While humans modify the physical environment, it also impacts human lives. Technology is the key tool used by humans to interact with the environment, and it serves as an indicator of a society's cultural development.

Naturalisation of Humans (Environmental Determinism\text{Environmental Determinism})

  • Core Concept: In early stages of history, low technological levels and primitive social development meant humans were greatly influenced by nature. They adapted to nature's dictates.

  • Characteristics: Humans listened to nature, feared its fury, and worshipped it. This state is known as "environmental determinism," featuring a "naturalised human."

  • Case Study: Benda in Abujh Maad:

    • Setting: Benda lives in a village of three huts in the wilds of central India.

    • Activities: He wears a loin cloth and uses an axe. His tribe practices "penda" (shifting cultivation\text{shifting cultivation}) by burning forest patches to use ash as fertilizer.

    • Flora and Spirits: He values trees like Mahua, Palash, and Sal. He thanks the forest spirit, Loi-Lugi, after drinking from a stream. He collects herbs like Gajjhara and Kuchla for bartering at the tribal fair (madhai\text{madhai}) during the full moon.

    • Relationship: Nature is "Mother Nature"—a powerful force that is worshipped, revered, and conserved due to direct resource dependence.

Humanisation of Nature (Possibilism\text{Possibilism})

  • Core Concept: As humans develop better technology and social/cultural understanding, they move from a "state of necessity" to a "state of freedom." They create possibilities using environmental resources.

  • Characteristics: Nature starts bearing the imprints of human endeavor, such as health resorts on highlands, urban sprawls, orchards, coastal ports, and satellites in space. This is known as "possibilism."

  • Case Study: Kari in Trondheim:

    • Setting: Trondheim experiences fierce winds and heavy snow, remaining dark for months in winter.

    • Technology: Kari drives a powerful car with special winter tyres and headlights. Her office is kept at a comfortable internal temperature of 23 ∘C23\,^{\circ}\text{C}.

    • Artificial Environment: The university campus is under a glass dome that controls temperature and lighting, allowing warmth in summer and excluding snow in winter.

    • Global Connectivity: Despite the weather, she eats tropical fruits like bananas and kiwis flown in from warmer regions. She networks with colleagues in New Delhi via computer and can fly to London in the morning and return for evening television.

    • Personal Health: At age 5858, she appears fitter than typical 3030-year-olds in other regions due to her technology-enabled lifestyle.

Neodeterminism (Stop and Go Determinism\text{Stop and Go Determinism})

  • Introduction: Introduced by geographer Griffith Taylor.

  • The Middle Path: It represents a middle ground (Madhyam Marg\text{Madhyam Marg}) between environmental determinism and possibilism.

  • Traffic Light Metaphor:

    • Red Light: "Stop."

    • Amber Light: "Get set" (the gap between red and green).

    • Green Light: "Go."

  • Philosophical Stance: There is neither absolute necessity nor absolute freedom. Humans can conquer nature by obeying it. Possibilities can be created within environmental limits.

  • Warnings: Unregulated "free runs" (extreme development) lead to environmental crises like the green house effect, ozone layer depletion, global warming, receding glaciers, and land degradation.

Broad Stages and Approaches of Human Geography

Period

Approach

Broad Features

Early Colonial period

Exploration and description

Imperial/trade interests prompted discovery. Accounts were encyclopaedic.

Later Colonial period

Regional analysis

Detailed description of all aspects of a region. Idea: the part reflects the whole earth.

1930s1930\text{s} through inter-War period

Areal differentiation

Finding the uniqueness of a region and how it differs from others.

Late 1950s1950\text{s} to late 1960s1960\text{s}

Spatial organisation

Use of computers and statistics. Quantitative Revolution. Application of physics laws to map human phenomena.

1970s1970\text{s}

Emergence of schools

Inclusion of Humanistic, Radical, and Behavioural schools. Focus on socio-political reality.

1990s1990\text{s}

Post-modernism in geography

Questioning grand generalizations; emphasis on local context and unique rights of individuals.

Schools of Thought in Human Geography (1970s1970\text{s})

  • Welfare or Humanistic School: Concerned with social well-being, specifically housing, health, and education.

  • Radical School: Used Marxian theory to explain poverty, deprivation, and social inequality. Linked social problems to capitalism.

  • Behavioural School: Focused on lived experience and the perception of space based on ethnicity, race, and religion.

Fields and Sub-fields of Human Geography

Human geography is highly inter-disciplinary, sharing interfaces with several social sciences:

  • Social Geography: Sociology.

    • Sub-fields: Behavioral Geography (Psychology\text{Psychology}), Geography of Social Well-being (Welfare Economics\text{Welfare Economics}), Cultural Geography (Anthropology\text{Anthropology}), Gender Geography (Sociology, Anthropology, Women’s Studies\text{Sociology, Anthropology, Women’s Studies}), Historical Geography (History\text{History}), Medical Geography (Epidemiology\text{Epidemiology}).

  • Urban Geography: Urban Studies and Planning.

  • Political Geography: Political Science.

    • Sub-fields: Electoral Geography (Psephology\text{Psephology}), Military Geography (Military Science\text{Military Science}).

  • Population Geography: Demography.

  • Settlement Geography: Urban/Rural Planning.

  • Economic Geography: Economics.

    • Sub-fields: Geography of Resources (Resource Economics\text{Resource Economics}), Geography of Agriculture (Agricultural Sciences\text{Agricultural Sciences}), Geography of Industries (Industrial Economics\text{Industrial Economics}), Geography of Marketing (Business Studies, Economics, Commerce\text{Business Studies, Economics, Commerce}), Geography of Tourism (Tourism and Travel Management\text{Tourism and Travel Management}), Geography of International Trade (International Trade\text{International Trade}).