American Federalism Notes

Introduction to Federalism

  • Throughout the establishment of the Articles of Confederation, founding father James Madison feared that states acting independently during national emergencies would undermine collective goals, such as during a pandemic or immigration crisis. Thus, the system of federalism in the Constitution was established.

    • Federalism effectively grants dual citizenship in the federal system of the United States, with authority divided between the national and state governments.

    • Power is not fixed, but rather is changing in response to political needs and ideologies.

    • Each level can act on behalf of the people based on specific authorities.

      • Today, this leans towards national authority as society becomes more interdependent.


Structure and Power

  • Early on, the Articles of Confederation failed to create national unity due to the national government being too weak. Thus, the Constitution gave the federal government direct authority, national supremacy, and shared sovereignty without abolishing states, addressing the lack of a strong defense and integrated economy.

    • This did not come without conflict, though. Some were opposed to a stronger national government, seeing the states as more fit to govern their own people. However, the government’s position at this time was unable to fulfill even basic duties without greater power — such as the power to raise taxes.

Governmental Levels

  • A new structure of government was formed to preserve autonomy as a result.

    • Both levels of the government are directly elected by the people but assigned different functions.

    • Amendments to the national government require a supermajority in Congress for broader support among the states.

    • Specific branches of government exist to allow for a degree of autonomy from each other; whenever conflicts arise, federal courts adjudicate proceedings.

Enumerated and Reserved Powers

  • Enumerated powers are spelled out in the Constitution to be specifically granted to the federal government.

    • These include the power of taxation and the power to provide for the common defense.

    • However, the national government also holds implied powers — through the "necessary and proper" or “elastic” clause, the government is given more means to fulfill policy responsibilities.

  • Reserved powers are given to the states that are not specifically named in the Constitution.

    • This is outlined in the 10th Amendment: Powers not delegated to the United States, nor prohibited to it by the States, are reserved to the States respectively.

    • Note that some of these have grown to no longer exclusively under state domain.

      • The federal government now has more involvement in states' affairs, regulating health, safety, welfare, and interstate commerce.

      • These are called concurrent powers — powers shared between the states and federal government.

    • Federalism thus becomes a system of checks and balances — a people opposed by one structure of government can turn to the other.

Restricted Powers

  • Some powers are restricted to the federal or state governments.

    • The federal government cannot suspend the writ of habeas (the ability to litigate imprisonment) or pass a legislative action (bill of attainder) declaring someone guilty.

    • States cannot enter treaties, coin money, or violate personal freedoms under the Constitution (like the federal government).

Constitutional Clauses

  • The full faith and credit clause (Article 4.1) requires states to accept the court decisions and contracts of other states.

  • The privileges and immunities clause (Article 4.2) prevents states by discriminating against non-citizens by denying them Constitutional guarantees.

    • However, some differences in treatment for certain matters (like state university tuition or voting) may be allowed.

  • The supremacy clause (Article 6) declares that the Constitution and federal law are the supreme law of the land. Federal law thus prevails in a conflict between state and national law.


Federalism in Action

The National Bank

  • Historically, federalism can be seen in action through creation of a national bank.

    • Congress has no enumerated power to create a national bank. When the Second Bank of the United States was created in 1812, some states argued against it, stating that the government was infringing upon states’ liberties. McCulloch v. Maryland litigated this.

      • When the state of Maryland tried to tax an agent of the Second Bank of the United States as another out-of-state bank, the of whether the national bank was Constitutional or whether states could tax federal property was raised.

        • The Supreme Court sided with the government, stating that the implied powers and the supremacy clauses granted Congress a vaster source for power.

Interstate Commerce

  • Federalism can also be seen in action with the authority to regulate interstate trade being placed in the national government’s domain.

    • In the Supreme Court case Gibbons v. Ogden, New York's legislated steamboat monopoly sued a New Jersey franchisee in New York waters. The Court ruled that interstate commerce could not be regulated by the states, and thus not enforce the monopoly when considering other states.

Nullification

  • The doctrine of nullification dates back to the late 1700s, when John Adams signed the 1798 Sedition Act outlawing speech against the government.

    • In response, the states of Kentucky and Virginia established the doctrine of nullification, rejecting the law through an action as they deemed it unconstitutional.

    • This new doctrine resulted in a crisis when South Carolina challenged national tariffs in 1833. In response, Congress passed the Force Bill, authorizing the use of force in the enforcement of national laws.

  • Despite this, nullification would continue to influence American history.

    • The Civil War started after the election of Abraham Lincoln in 1860, challenging the institution of slavery.

      • The Union victory allowed Congress to pass amendments banning slavery and defending legitimate national laws, thus tilting power in the United States toward the federal government.

    • The Supreme Court case Brown v. Board of Education declared that educational segregation was unconstitutional.

      • This ruled against state governments enforcing segregation and led to the enactment of laws ending segregation in schools, jobs, housing, and accommodations.


Federalist Structures

  • Several methods of dividing power in federalism have emerged.

Dual and Cooperative Federalism

  • Dual Federalism states that the two spheres of government must be clearly delineated.

    • Much of American history has proceeded under this system, where Supreme Court rulings defended the separation of powers.

  • However, Cooperative Federalism — emerging during the Great Depression and Great Society eras of the 1930s and 1960s, respectively — allowed states and the national government to coordinate their actions.

    • This has led to a nationalization of politics to address broader problems, increasing the size of the federal government and creating a greater flow of grant money to the states.

New Federalism

  • New Federalism attempted to reverse the process of nationalization, attempting to create state authority for better administrative efficiency.

    • This was created in a process called devolution, where powers were delegated to subnational units. This allowed states to regulate with their greater proximity to citizens.

  • General revenue sharing programs allowed for more unrestricted funds, giving states more discretion over spending federal money.

    • However, the enactment of this program would not be completely successful after leaders of New Federalism attempted to devolve aid programs. This led to the eventual termination of general revenue sharing in 1986.

  • Some Supreme Court like United States v. Lopez have defended New Federalism, where the Court struck down state laws banning firearm possession in school zones.

    • However, the years since 9/11 have swung the pendulum back in the direction of more centralized federal power and governmental authority.

  • Thus, some involvement in state activities is necessary to create collective action and avoid competition between states.


Divisions of Power

Interdependency

  • The concept of interdependency has increased national authority, as the federal government enacts national solutions with cooperation from the states.

    • Medicaid, created under the Great Society in 1965, is jointly funded by the national and state governments, with some state authority over eligibility and benefits.

    • Natural disaster relief is provided by the national government.

    • The benefits of these interdependent programs to the states make federal programs rarely end.

  • The federal government's taxation capability also prevents excessive competition between states in their "race to the bottom".

    • The federal government is thus able to raise more money for national programs.


Fiscal Federalism

  • Fiscal federalism refers to the expenditure of federal funds on programs run through the partnership between state and national governments.

    • Grants in aid are given to states and municipalities to spend on federal programs.

    • Categorical grants are restricted to certain programs and sometimes come with crossover sanctions to enforce national policy, like a healthcare bill requiring spending on construction projects.

      • Project grants are competitive grants for certain projects, included under categorical grants.

    • Formula grants are derived from state statistics for the specific allocation of funds.

    • Block grants are used for broad goals, like the development of social services, generally with more discretion in spending given to the states.

    • All of these grants enable the federal government to gain more leverage over states. While some may speak out against this, these programs are all meant to serve the public interest, allowing more spending on programs the states could not otherwise afford.

  • Underfunded mandates may require more money to be spent by the states as a result of Congress enforcing but not adequately budgeting for a program.

    • Unfunded mandates put burdens directly on the states, such as in basic issues like school segregation, environmental protection, or prison construction.

  • Opponents of fiscal federalism have called some parts of it coercive federalism, capturing the national government’s ability to promote policy objectives.


Venue Shopping

  • Federalism creates many access points to the government through the differences in state and national authority.

    • Venue shopping refers to the act of strategizing about which level and branch of government to target in order to achieve a goal.

      • This has been seen through abortion regulations targeting state (instead of national) regulations.

      • Sometimes, regulation is created to intentionally conflict with federal law, triggering Supreme Court reviews to enable further litigation.

      • Thus, losing in one venue does not end the conflict to push for a specific goal, showing how national policy can emerge from state action.