Gene loss

.

1. Pseudogenes

  • A pseudogene is a non-functional or semi-functional version of a gene that remains intact in related organisms.

  • Pseudogenes typically arise through:

    • Partial gene deletions.

    • Mutations.

  • Gene inactivation can occur when mutations disrupt the normal function of a gene.

  • Comparing pseudogenes with functional genes in related organisms can help identify changes associated with gene loss.

2. Mechanisms of gene loss

The lecture identifies three main mechanisms.

A. Single-base mutations

  • Include:

    • Insertion — addition of a nucleotide.

    • Deletion — removal of a nucleotide.

    • Substitution — replacement of one nucleotide with another.

  • Mutations can disrupt gene function.

  • DNA damage and ineffective DNA repair can contribute to mutations.

  • Examples of damaging agents mentioned in the lecture include:

    • Ultraviolet (UV) radiation.

    • Chemicals.

B. Larger insertions and deletions

  • Larger DNA regions can be inserted or removed.

  • Homologous recombination is one mechanism associated with these larger genetic changes.

  • These rearrangements can alter genes or remove entire regions of DNA.

C. Loss of mobile genetic elements (MGEs)

  • Plasmids and phages can be lost because of instability.

  • If an MGE carries genes needed for a particular function, losing that element can result in the loss of those genes.

  • MGEs can also contribute to gene inactivation and rearrangement before they are lost.

3. Nucleotide substitutions and tautomeric shifts

  • Nucleotide substitutions occur when one nucleotide is replaced by another.

  • The lecture highlights tautomeric shifts as a cause of mutations during DNA replication.

  • Tautomeric shifts involve temporary alternative chemical forms of DNA bases.

  • These forms can change base-pairing behaviour.

  • If an incorrectly paired base is not corrected, the error can become a permanent mutation following replication.

Key takeaway: Mutations can arise during replication when bases temporarily adopt forms that allow incorrect pairing.

4. The role of MGEs in gene inactivation

  • Mobile genetic elements can disrupt the function of existing genes.

  • Their insertion into a gene can interrupt its coding sequence or normal regulation.

  • MGEs can also contribute to:

    • DNA rearrangements.

    • Inversions.

    • Deletions.

    • Gene excision.

  • The lecture specifically highlights IS26-mediated rearrangement as an example of MGE-associated genetic change.

Remember: MGEs are involved in both gene gain and gene loss. They can introduce genetic material, but they can also disrupt, rearrange or remove it.

5. Evolutionary bottlenecks

  • An evolutionary bottleneck occurs when a population is reduced or passes through a restrictive set of conditions.

  • The resulting population may be genetically simplified compared with the founding population.

  • Bottlenecks are common in evolution.

  • They can involve both:

    • Gene loss — genetic material is lost.

    • Gene gain — for example, the acquisition of antibiotic resistance genes.

Examples of conditions that cause bottlenecks

  • Nutrient limitation.

  • Competition with other microbes.

  • The host immune response.

  • Changes in the environment or ecological niche.

Genome reduction in intracellular bacteria

The lecture asks which genes an intracellular bacterium might evolve to disable or lose.

  • Motility genes

    • May become unnecessary if the bacterium remains within host cells and no longer needs to move independently.

  • Metabolic genes

    • Some functions may be supplied by the host, reducing the need for the bacterium to maintain its own pathways.

  • Virulence genes

    • Some may become unnecessary in a particular environment, although others may be essential for infection.

  • Mobile genetic elements

    • Some may be lost if they no longer provide a benefit or are not stably maintained.

These are potential evolutionary outcomes to consider, rather than universal rules for all intracellular bacteria.

6. Genomic “black holes”

  • A genomic black hole refers to a gene or genomic region that has been lost in a particular lineage, despite being present in related organisms.

  • The lecture explores the hypothesis that losing certain genes can increase pathogenicity.

  • This is important because evolution does not always make organisms more pathogenic by adding genes; losing a gene can also change how a pathogen behaves.

Example: CadA in E. coli and Shigella

  • CadA encodes lysine decarboxylase.

  • CadA is present in approximately 90% of E. coli, according to the lecture.

  • It is consistently deleted in:

    • Shigella.

    • Enteroinvasive E. coli (EIEC).

The proposed hypothesis is that the loss of cadA contributes to increased pathogenesis.

Experimental investigation: Maurelli et al. (1998)

The lecture describes experiments examining the relationship between CadA and toxin activity.

  • Introducing a plasmid encoding CadA into the cell decreased toxin activity.

  • Adding supernatant from growing CadA-positive cells to wild-type cells also decreased toxin activity.

  • These findings suggested that a substance produced by CadA-positive cells could reduce toxin activity.

Cadaverine and toxin activity

  • CadA catalyses the decarboxylation of lysine.

  • Cadaverine is produced as a result of this reaction.

  • The lecture identifies cadaverine as the molecule responsible for reducing toxin function.

  • Loss of cadA therefore removes a pathway that produces a molecule capable of reducing toxin activity.

The proposed relationship is:

Functional cadA gene

CadA produces cadaverine from lysine

Reduced toxin activity

Loss of cadA → less CadA-dependent cadaverine production → removal of this toxin-reducing effect

  • The lecture also notes that cadA inactivation occurred independently in all four Shigella species.

  • This supports the importance of gene loss as a potential contributor to pathogen evolution.

7. Rickettsia species and genome reduction

- Rickettsia species are:

  • Non-motile.

  • Gram-negative.

  • Obligate intracellular parasites.

  • Causative agents of typhus and spotted fever.

  • Transmitted by arthropods, such as ticks.

Genome reduction

The lecture compares the core genome of Rickettsia with its proposed ancestral genome, R0.

Genome feature

Number of genes

Percentage reported

Core genome

743

52–86% of total

Ancestral genome R0

1,252

66–89% of total

  • These figures illustrate changes in gene content across Rickettsia lineages.

  • The ancestral genome estimate contains more genes than the core genome.

  • The lecture also examines how different gene categories have been lost to different extents during evolution.

  • Some genes were proportionally less affected by loss, whereas others were proportionally more affected.

Evolutionary history

The lecture's evolutionary diagram highlights:

  • Gene sets that were retained in all subsequent lineages.

  • Gene exchange with other bacteria within amoebae.

  • A transition to multicellular eukaryotic hosts.

These changes provide context for understanding how host association and genome evolution are related in Rickettsia.

Key concept: Obligate intracellular bacteria can undergo genome reduction as their evolutionary relationship with the host changes.

8. Further example: Mycobacterium leprae

  • Mycobacterium leprae is the bacterium responsible for leprosy.

  • The lecture identifies it as an example of genome reduction through large-scale deletions.

  • Less than half of its genome contains functional genes.

  • This illustrates how extensive gene loss can occur during bacterial evolution.

9. Summary: key points to remember

  • A pseudogene is a non-functional or semi-functional version of a gene that remains intact in related organisms.

  • Gene loss can occur through:

    • Single-base mutations.

    • Larger insertions and deletions.

    • Loss of mobile genetic elements.

  • Tautomeric shifts can cause incorrect base pairing during replication.

  • MGEs can disable genes, cause DNA rearrangements and facilitate gene excision.

  • Evolutionary bottlenecks can simplify the genetic composition of populations.

  • Genomic black holes illustrate how gene loss can contribute to increased pathogenicity.

  • In Shigella, loss of cadA removes CadA-dependent cadaverine production, which the lecture links to reduced toxin activity when CadA is present.

  • Rickettsia is an example of genome reduction in an obligate intracellular pathogen.

  • Mycobacterium leprae is another example, with extensive deletions and fewer than half of its genome containing functional genes.

Quick revision questions

Try answering these before revealing the answers.

1. What is a pseudogene?

Reveal answer

2. What are the three main mechanisms of gene loss covered in the lecture?

Reveal answer

3. How can a tautomeric shift cause a mutation?

Reveal answer

4. How can MGEs contribute to gene loss?

Reveal answer

5. What is an evolutionary bottleneck?

Reveal answer

6. What is a genomic black hole?

Reveal answer

7. What does CadA do?

Reveal answer

8. What was the relationship between CadA, cadaverine and toxin activity in the lecture?

Reveal answer

9. What is significant about cadA inactivation in Shigella?

Reveal answer

10. Why is Rickettsia a useful example in this lecture?

Reveal answer

11. What is the significance of Mycobacterium leprae?