Ch 9:
Campaigns and Voting Behavior
Presidential Nomination Process
Overview: The presidential nomination process is a two-phase system, with the Constitution remaining silent on nominations.
Nomination Stage: Candidates aim to accrue a majority of delegates at their respective national party conventions.
General Election Stage: Candidates strive to collect a majority of electoral votes to triumph in the election.
Nomination Stage
Rules of the Game for Major Party Candidates: The primary objective for candidates is to gather support from a majority of delegates to the national party conventions.
Winning Delegates:
Invisible Primary: This involves candidates garnering support from electoral officials, influential fundraisers, and skilled political aides. The premise asserts success hinges on winning elite leaders' backing in the political party.
Primaries and Caucuses: Candidates engage in state-based contests to secure delegates.
Differences Between Caucuses and Primaries
Participating Voter Types: The nature of voters participating varies between caucuses and primaries.
Candidate Strategy: Strategies differ based on whether it’s a primary or a caucus.
Democratic vs. Republican Delegate Accumulation:
Republicans: More prevalent winner-take-all systems.
Democrats: Generally employ proportional delegate systems (vary by state), including the concept of “super-delegates,” which saw their role limited starting in 2020.
Historical Context
Evolution of the System: Previously, gaining backing from party leaders was sufficient. This changed post-McGovern-Fraser Commission (1970s), which tied delegate support closely to primary and caucus performance, necessitating candidates to gain popular support.
Candidate Strategy Implications:
Establish strong organizational structures and raise funds early.
Perform well in early contests to build momentum.
Criticisms of the Nomination System
Disproportionate Attention: Early caucuses receive excessive focus, marginalizing later states.
Frontloading: States aim to hold contests early for relevance.
Challenges for Prominent Politicians: Straining their ability to balance duties with campaigning.
Money Influence: Significant money involvement in caucuses and primaries.
Matching Funds: Available to candidates adhering to spending limits.
Low Participation rates: Primaries and caucuses often have low voter turnout and unrepresentative demographics.
Regional Bias: Decision-making can skew based on regional factors.
Media Influence: Media plays a substantial role in shaping campaign expectations.
Party Conventions
Formal Functions:
Certifying delegate credentials.
Setting party rules for the next four years.
Developing and adopting a party platform.
Officially nominating presidential and vice-presidential candidates.
Other Functions:
Serve as a rallying event for party members.
Provide extensive media coverage opportunities.
General Election Strategies
Electoral College:
Basics: The system involves state-by-state contests, compelling candidates to focus efforts on states with substantial electoral votes they can realistically win.
Battleground States: States where polls indicate competitive races require more attention.
Criticism: The Electoral College has been criticized for its structure and implications for fairness in elections.
Role of Money in Elections
Financial Overview: Approximately $6.4 billion spent in US elections in 2016 for congressional and presidential elections.
Comparisons:
Vitamins: $28 billion (2012)
Pet Food: $21.3 billion (2013)
Deodorant: $2.3 billion (2006)
Potential Problems with Money:
Distribution: Resource imbalances.
Source Transparency: Concerns about where money originates and expectations of reciprocity (corruption).
Time Investment: Politicians may spend excessive time fundraising, detracting from other responsibilities.
Ethical Challenge: Balancing the freedom to raise money while minimizing negative impacts.
Regulations Governing Money in Elections
Federal Election Campaign Act: Established in the early 1970s, aimed at enhancing transparency and imposing contribution limits.
Contribution Limits:
Individuals: $2,800 per election.
Political Action Committees (PACs): $5,000 per election.
Federal Election Commission (FEC): Oversees compliance and enforcement of campaign finance laws.
Public Funding: $3 checkoff system for taxpayers, with a low participation rate (7% of Americans).
Existing Loopholes in Regulations
Soft Money: Eliminated by the BCRA (McCain-Feingold) in 2002.
527 Groups: Engage in issue advertising only without being directly tied to Candidate campaigning.
Citizens United v. FEC (2010): Ruled that there can be no limits on spending by wealthy individuals, corporations, and unions for advocating candidates, barring direct coordination with campaigns.
SuperPACs: Independent expenditure-only groups raised and spent unlimited funds without being able to coordinate with candidates.
Campaign Influence on Election Outcomes
Impact of Campaigns:
Campaigns can reinforce existing voter preferences, activate voter engagement (contributing money or volunteer work), and have the potential to convert undecided voters.
Research indicates that campaigns rarely convert voters due to selective perception, where voters favor information aligning with their beliefs.
Key Influencers:
Party Identification: Strongly guides voting behavior.
Incumbency Advantage: Candidates often hold name recognition benefits.
In competitive races, effective campaign strategies can be crucial for success.
Factors Influencing Voter Turnout
Voter Characteristics Affecting Turnout:
Education: Higher education levels correlate with increased turnout.
Age: Older individuals are generally more likely to vote.
Race and Ethnicity: Different demographic groups have varying turnout rates.
Gender: Gender divisions affect political engagement.
Marital Status: Married individuals tend to vote more than single individuals.
Government Employment: Those employed by the government may have higher civic engagement.
Influential Attitudes:
Recognition of policy differences between parties.
A sense of civic duty increases likelihood of voting.
High levels of political efficacy, or the belief that personal actions can influence government.
Influences on Voting Decisions
Key Elements:
Party Identification: Essential for predicting voting patterns.
Candidate Evaluations: Personal assessments of candidates can sway decisions.
Policy Voting: Voters may choose candidates based on alignment with personal policy preferences.