Study Notes on Retribution, Deterrence, and Punishment
Retribution and Deterrence in the Context of Punishment
Mean-Spirited Perspective on Punishment
Discussion focuses on punishment perceived as vengeance rather than justice.
Differentiation between retribution as a moral question and as a global question regarding its implications in the justice system.
Types of Deterrence
General Deterrence:
Defined as the idea that the mere existence of punishment can discourage crime.
Individuals do not need to have committed a crime to be influenced by the threat of punishment.
Historical context: Early forms of punishment served a general deterrent effect.
Example:
In Colonial Williamsburg or Liberty Square in Disney World, seeing individuals in stocks serves to deter the public from committing crimes (fear of public humiliation and consequence).
Specific Deterrence:
Defined as punishments that prevent the individual being punished from committing further crimes.
Incarceration removes the individual from society, thus preventing them from offending.
Incapacitation Laws
Three Strikes Laws:
A law that mandates life imprisonment without parole for individuals convicted of three qualifying felony offenses.
Represents an example of selective incapacitation aimed at specific individuals based on their criminal history.
This approach relies on the premise that past behavior is the best predictor of future behavior.