Study Notes on Retribution, Deterrence, and Punishment

Retribution and Deterrence in the Context of Punishment

  • Mean-Spirited Perspective on Punishment

    • Discussion focuses on punishment perceived as vengeance rather than justice.

    • Differentiation between retribution as a moral question and as a global question regarding its implications in the justice system.

  • Types of Deterrence

    • General Deterrence:

    • Defined as the idea that the mere existence of punishment can discourage crime.

    • Individuals do not need to have committed a crime to be influenced by the threat of punishment.

    • Historical context: Early forms of punishment served a general deterrent effect.

    • Example:

    • In Colonial Williamsburg or Liberty Square in Disney World, seeing individuals in stocks serves to deter the public from committing crimes (fear of public humiliation and consequence).

    • Specific Deterrence:

    • Defined as punishments that prevent the individual being punished from committing further crimes.

    • Incarceration removes the individual from society, thus preventing them from offending.

  • Incapacitation Laws

    • Three Strikes Laws:

    • A law that mandates life imprisonment without parole for individuals convicted of three qualifying felony offenses.

    • Represents an example of selective incapacitation aimed at specific individuals based on their criminal history.

    • This approach relies on the premise that past behavior is the best predictor of future behavior.