115-117
Measurement Steps in Research
Progression of Measurement Steps
Transition from vague sense of terms to specific measurements.
Key steps include:
Conceptualization
Conceptual definition
Operational definition
Real-world measurements
Impact of Initial Conceptualization
Reflect on personal definitions (e.g., recidivism) and compare with established meanings.
Operationalization Choices
Understanding Operationalization
Operationalization is critical; it’s the process of developing operational definitions.
Research is not a strictly linear process; definitions may evolve during study.
Important considerations include selecting appropriate data collection methods.
Example: Crime Seriousness
Conceptualize crime seriousness through legal penalties.
Initial definitions clarify the study focus:
Crime seriousness: Degree of punishment as per state criminal codes.
Example operational definitions:
Crimes punishable by death -> most serious.
Crimes with prison sentences over one year -> serious.
Crimes with less than a year’s jail or fines -> least serious.
Data collection strategy involves legal research into the Texas Criminal Code.
Alternative Conceptualization of Crime Seriousness
Public Perception
Crime seriousness viewed through public beliefs concerning victim harm, motivations, and circumstances.
New operationalization: Survey students on their perceptions of crime seriousness via questionnaire.
Critical decisions required for clear operationalization:
How to describe crimes?
Indicators for seriousness?
Ranking systems or detailed comparisons?
Understanding Recidivism
Definition and Measurement
Recidivism: Recurrence of criminal behavior post-offense.
Rate of recidivism: Proportion of offenders engaging in criminal behavior within a set timeframe (e.g., re-arrests, reconvictions, reincarcerations).
Challenges in Measurement: Many behaviors go unreported, affecting accuracy.
Recommended Measurement Approach (1991)
Recidivism defined by counting offenders reincarcerated due to technical violations or new offenses within uniform at-risk periods.
Use of centralized data sources recommended to reduce errors.
Measurement as Scoring
Understanding Measurement
Measurement involves assigning numbers/labels to represent conceptual properties.
Examples:
Grades for student performance.
Counts of pages for study hours.
Ratings of Supreme Court nominees.
Measurement encompasses making observations and assigning scores based on defined concepts.
Systemwide Recidivism Rates
Types of Recidivism Rates
Reported rates can include all offenders, those released from prisons, or those under community supervision.
Example statistic: 48% of offenders released in 1991 were reincarcerated by 1994.
Recidivism Rates by Offense Type
Example rates three years after release:
Burglary: 56%
Robbery: 54%
Homicide: 40%
Etc.
Recidivism Rates by Age Group
Younger offenders tend to have higher recidivism rates.
Important Considerations for Recidivism Rates
Avoid using systemwide rates to evaluate institutional program performance; external socio-economic factors play a significant role.
Population characteristics can influence recidivism outcomes, as evidenced by changes in offense characteristics over time.
Performance must be contextualized within systemic changes and service delivery.
Challenges in Measurement
Complexity of Concepts
Fundamental criminal justice concepts are often difficult to define clearly, complicating operationalization and measurement efforts.
Variability in Results
Different definitions can yield varying statistics, as demonstrated in studies of domestic violence rates across contexts.
Example: Higher domestic violence rates in studies focused explicitly on family conflict versus general victimization surveys.