Study Notes on U.S. Imperialism and the Frontier Concept

Introduction

  • Period of discussion involves the United States and its imperialistic behaviors during various historical events.

  • Key figures and concepts include Social Darwinism, Josiah Strong, and Frederick Jackson Turner.

  • Mentioning the location: North America, Solar System, Milky Way.

Social Darwinism and Josiah Strong

  • Social Darwinism: Application of Darwin's theory of evolution to society, suggesting superiority of select races.

  • Josiah Strong:

    • Authored Our Country.

    • Believed white Americans had a moral obligation to civilize other parts of the world, reflecting a racist mentality.

    • His ideas were used to justify imperialism.

Frederick Jackson Turner and the Frontier

  • Frederick Jackson Turner:

    • Wrote The Significance of the Frontier in American History.

    • His thesis centered around the idea of the "frontier" being the edge of civilization.

    • Explored the concept of why American expansion was necessary:

    • As civilization expanded, the moving frontier was a pressure release for societal discontent.

    • Noted the historical movement of the frontier:

    • Initially the Appalachian Mountains (13 Colonies).

    • Followed by the Ohio Valley and then westward to the Oregon Trail.

    • Described various groups and efforts moving into these frontiers (farmers, trappers, cowboys, exodusters).

  • The Closing of the Frontier:

    • Noted that by Turner's time (1890), the frontier was closed.

    • Suggested that without a frontier, Americans could face societal chaos, leading to imperialism.

Analogies and Implications of the Frontier Concept

  • Described frontier as a "pressure valve":

    • Release of societal pressure to prevent conflict (revolution, chaos, etc.).

    • Illustrates how American society needed new lands to settle discontented populations.

  • Critique of Turner’s thesis by contemporary historians;

    • Noted that while land was acquired, it didn’t result in mass migrations to acquired territories.

Early Examples of American Imperialism

Matthew Perry and Japan (1853)

  • Matthew Perry:

    • An American naval officer who sailed warships into Tokyo, Japan.

    • Aimed to open Japan to American trade, leveraging military intimidation as a key tactic.

    • Japan was closed off from the outside world due to historical isolation.

    • Outcome: Japan opened for negotiations, marking a shift in their isolationist policies; a precursor to Japan’s own imperial ambitions.

Acquisition of Alaska (1867)

  • Purchase of Alaska from Russia for $7,200,000.

  • Negotiated by William Seward, Secretary of State.

  • Initially mocked as “Seward’s folly” or “Seward's Icebox.”

  • Later revealed to be a lucrative purchase due to natural resources (gold, lumber, oil).

Pan-American Conference

  • Conducted by Secretary of State James Blaine.

  • Aimed to unify Latin American countries under U.S. influence.

  • Demonstrated U.S. dominance by insisting on trade agreements and road constructions such as the Pan American Highway.

  • Perceived arrogance from the U.S. when dealing with weaker Latin American countries.

Venezuela and Great Britain Crisis

  • A territorial dispute between Venezuela and Great Britain over borders.

  • U.S. Intervention:

    • Stepped in to mediate, showcasing its emerging role as a significant player in global politics.

    • Illustrated American assertiveness, which angered Great Britain but improved U.S.-British relations.

    • Critically disadvanted Venezuela, leading to resentment toward the U.S.

Annexation of Hawaii

  • Queen Liliʻuokalani sought to limit American business influence in Hawaii.

  • American businessmen revolted against her reign, backed by U.S. military without proper authority.

  • Sanford Dole led the overthrow of the queen, pushing for annexation of Hawaii.

  • President William McKinley eventually supported the annexation, claiming benefits for trade and cultural influence.

    • Accused of imperialist motivations, illustrating American exploitation of native populations.

Conclusion

  • These early examples of imperialism set the foundation for complex U.S. foreign policy.

  • Showcases the transition from expansionism to more aggressive imperialist practices by the U.S.