Making Teaching Interactions Engaging Across the Lifespan
Rationale and Core Principles of Engaging Teaching Interactions
Lowering Escape-Maintained Problem Behavior: Increasing the engaging and enjoyable qualities of teaching interactions lowers rates of problem behavior maintained by social negative reinforcement (escape).
Skill Acquisition: Higher levels of active engagement directly correlate with accelerated skill acquisition.
Addressing Core Deficits of Autism:
Engaging in fun teaching interactions facilitates rapport building and models socially appropriate interactions.
Social interaction deficits represent one of the core diagnostic features of autism spectrum disorder.
Children with autism typically demonstrate lower baseline levels of active engagement relative to their neurotypical peers.
Pairing and Rapport Building:
Definition: Pairing involves an instructor associating themselves with highly reinforcing items and activities prior to placing demands.
Mechanism: Establishes the instructor as a form of conditioned reinforcement for the learner through stimulus-stimulus pairing.
Implementation Guidelines:
Limit demands completely during initial pairing sessions.
Refrain from placing instructions, asking questions, or running formal teaching trials.
Engage actively by joining the learner's activity, making positive comments about toys, and establishing trust.
Empirical Support: Kelly and colleagues in 2015 utilized a multiple baseline across participants design to demonstrate that brief pre-session pairing significantly decreased challenging behavior during work tasks.
Conceptual Framework of Motivation and Motivating Operations
Intrinsic vs. Extrinsic Motivation:
Intrinsic Motivation: Driven by internal rewards or the inherent reinforcement of executing a task successfully.
Extrinsic Motivation: Driven by external reinforcers such as money, tokens, tangible items, or preferred activities.
Motivating Operations (MOs):
An environmental variable that temporarily alters:
The reinforcing effectiveness of a stimulus, object, or event (value-altering effect).
The current frequency of all behavior that has been reinforced by that stimulus, object, or event (behavior-altering effect).
Establishing Operations (EOs):
Increase the temporary reinforcing effectiveness of a stimulus.
Increase the current frequency of behaviors that have historically produced that stimulus.
Clinical Example: Running a program to teach novel food acceptance when the learner is hungry (e.g., prior to lunch) establishes food as an effective reinforcer via an EO.
Abolishing Operations (AOs):
Decrease the temporary reinforcing effectiveness of a stimulus.
Decrease the current frequency of behaviors that have historically produced that stimulus.
Clinical Example: Conducting mand training for preferred snacks immediately following a meal creates an AO (satiation), reducing the effectiveness of snacks as reinforcers and abating mands for food.
Dynamic and Multi-Faceted Nature of Motivation:
MOs fluctuate dynamically based on states of deprivation and satiation.
Internal states (e.g., physical illness, physiological discomfort) and ambient environmental variables (e.g., ambient noise) alter motivation, decrease task engagement, and evoke disruptive escape behavior.
Multiple concurrent motivators often operate simultaneously (e.g., motivation to escape a task combined with motivation to access a preferred iPad game).
Measuring Happiness and Clinical Utility
Operational Definition: Parsons, Reeves, and Latimore defined happiness as a unique set of overt observable behaviors that vary across individuals.
Overt Indicators: Smiling, laughing, patting other people on the back, and patting one's own stomach.
Clinical Applications:
Evaluating whether leisure activities and leisure skill instruction actually produce genuine enjoyment for the learner.
Identifying environmental contexts or tasks that evoke unhappiness, enabling instructors to adapt or alter instruction.
Evaluating behavior reduction treatment programs by tracking increases in positive affect alongside decreases in challenging behavior.
Engagement Strategies for Early Learners (Ages 3 through 10)
Play-Based Instruction:
Play is the primary vehicle through which young children learn about the world.
Provides an opportunity to model socially appropriate interactions, play comments, actions, and toy manipulations.
Must occur across diverse contexts: desk setups, play mats, playgrounds, all parts of the home, and with different instructors/peers to promote generalization.
Embedded Discrete Trial Teaching (DTT):
Procedure: Temporarily pause an ongoing preferred play activity, present one or a few teaching trials, and immediately resume the play activity as reinforcement.
Target Types: Can utilize target skills that are directly related or completely unrelated to the ongoing play context.
Examples:
Swing Activity: Pause the swing mid-air, present a social question trial, and resume pushing.
Video Watching: Pause a movie clip, present a color labeling target (via screen element or flashcard), and resume video playback.
Puzzle Assembly: Pause puzzle completion, present a picture identification trial, and deliver the puzzle piece.
Block Play: Pause block building, present an action imitation trial, and resume building.
Modifying Traditional DTT Format:
Traditional desk-based DTT can become repetitive and demotivating.
Movement-Based Variation Example: A labeling people program modified by placing target photographs around the room (on a trampoline, held by peers/staff) allowed a learner with high physical activity needs to move around, jump, and interact while successfully completing identical trial counts with visible happiness indices (smiling, bodily movement).
Creative Contexts for Sight Word Reading:
Traditional DTT: Instructor presents flashcard, states SD "Read", prompts verbally, and delivers item.
Incidental Teaching Context: Learner initiates for a preferred item; instructor presents the corresponding written word label, requires the learner to read the label, and delivers the item as the natural reinforcer.
Twister Game Context: Affix target sight words onto color circles on the Twister mat. The learner reads the word before placing a hand or foot on the specified color after spinning.
Basketball Game Context: Print sight words on half-sheets of paper and scatter them across the room. The learner identifies and reads the designated word, crumples the paper, and shoots it into a basket (can be played competitively in teams if motivating).
Naturalistic and Incidental Teaching Procedures:
Naturalistic Teaching: Incorporates core ABA principles (MOs, SDs, responses, reinforcement, error correction) within everyday natural routines (e.g., teaching lunchbox opening immediately prior to lunch; teaching swing pumping when swinging is earned).
Incidental Teaching Mechanics:
Learner initiates vocally or gesturally for an item, activity, or information.
Instructor prompts a target elaboration (language, academic, expressive, or descriptive skill).
Learner emits the target elaboration.
Instructor delivers the requested item, activity, or information as the reinforcer.
Captured vs. Contrived Opportunities:
Captured: Exploiting naturally occurring initiations throughout the day (e.g., learner reaches for a block -> prompt color label or expanded mand "Can I have the block, please?").
Contrived: Environmental sabotage to evoke initiations (e.g., locking a preferred iPad in a cabinet prior to session -> prompt questions like "Where is it?", "Help", or "Open").
Target Applications: Mand expansions, reading, picture identification, counting, coin value identification, color identification, prepositions, and expressive question-asking (e.g., "What's that?").
Step-by-Step Incidental Teaching Protocols (Video Curricula):
Reading Words:
Step 1: Teach reading the word for a single object. Present preferred items in view. Upon initiation, hold up word (e.g., "Square"), prompt by modeling, fade prompts across trials, provide praise and item upon independent reading. Teach in sets (e.g., "Circle").
Step 2: Teach reading words corresponding to novel objects (e.g., "Catch", "Go", "Ball").
Step 3: Teach reading words corresponding to additional objects (e.g., "Computer").
Step 3 Helpful Hints: Test learned words across items ("Split", "Computers", "Cycle").
Labeling Colors:
Step 1: Teach labeling a set of colors during a preferred multi-colored activity. Prompt with full verbal model (e.g., "Green", "Pink"), fade model, deliver item upon correct response. Present learned colors in random order.
Step 2: Introduce new color set (e.g., "Red", "Blue"). Fade prompts to independence across varied activities.
Step 3: Randomly present all learned colors without prompts. Use error correction (wait a few seconds before prompting if an error occurs).
Identifying Coin Values:
Set up a mock store with preferred toys (e.g., spaceship priced at ).
Upon learner initiation to purchase, state "This costs , give me ". Prompt physical exchange of the specific coin, deliver toy, fade prompts to independent coin identification and exchange.
Asking "What's That?":
Step 1 (Single Context): Present novel, unfamiliar items (e.g., popping lamp, noisy hammer, top shooter, alien popper). Prompt "Say 'What's that?'", answer the query, and grant immediate play access. Fade prompts to independent spontaneous question asking.
Step 2 (Another Context): Re-apply procedure across different novel items (e.g., kaleidoscope, matchup game, popping ice cream cone).
Step 3 (Additional Contexts): Scatter novel items around the room (e.g., water toy, fluffy items, light-up toys). Prompt combined gesture/pointing and vocalization "What's that?".
Capitalizing on Circumscribed / Restricted Interests:
Literature Evidence: Gunn and Della Filipat in 2016 reviewed 20 published studies regarding incorporating restricted interests into instruction.
All papers reported gains in motivation, learning, communication, social engagement, or behavior reduction.
Only two papers noted negative effects, which were related to increased distractibility with the physical objects.
Practical Applications:
Animal Interest: Utilizing magnetic animals on a slant board accelerated math counting acquisition for a 5-year-old learner.
Transit/Direction Interest: Utilizing driving, walking, and subway transit maps/schedules for a 10-year-old to teach distance math calculation, reading comprehension, and social studies map skills.
Dinosaur Interest: Integrating dinosaur texts for reading comprehension, dinosaur figurines for math graphing, addition, and preposition targets.
Interdisciplinary Collaboration:
Collaborate with outside experts (yoga instructors, specialty art instructors, adaptive exercise trainers, sensory activity specialists, social group coordinators, after-school gym/taekwondo instructors) to identify novel reinforcing routines to embed into academic sessions.
Engagement Strategies for Adolescents and Young Adults (Ages 10 through 21)
Age Appropriateness vs. Individual Preference:
Evaluate interactions against neurotypical peer norms to maintain client dignity while preserving reinforcer value.
Systematic Alternatives:
Replace tickles with high fives, tag races, bike riding, or catch.
Replace infant/toddler television shows (e.g., Sesame Street) with age-appropriate animated shows (e.g., Phineas and Ferb, SpongeBob SquarePants).
Replace board books with magazines, visual books, or thematic novels.
Replace park slides with trampoline parks or indoor action centers.
Building Standing Endurance and Mobility:
Transitioning instruction away from sedentary desk setups to standing, walking, and active movement tasks directly prepares learners for adult employment and vocational settings requiring physical stamina.
Functional Programming Tailored to Interests:
Culinary/Domestic Skills: Teach preparing favorite snacks, incorporating kitchen safety, knife skills, and measuring math (volume/weight).
Spelling and Typing: Teach typing preferred movie characters or song titles into search bars (YouTube, Google, Netflix) to build functional digital literacy.
Scavenger Hunts: Embed academic clues across multiple locations to promote movement and problem-solving.
Interactive Computerized Match-to-Sample:
Numeral Identification Case: A learner struggling with traditional numeral identification utilized a digital matching layout. Selecting an audio box played a recorded number (e.g., "27"). Matching the correct numeral triggered visual displays of favorite movie posters and cheer audio, successfully building independent numeral identification that transferred to traditional print.
Expanding Leisure Repertoires from Existing Repertoires:
Matching & Schedule Following Skills -> Piano playing (matching letter labels to keys), mosaic assembly, color-by-number, sticker-by-number, card games (Go Fish played independently or in pairs).
Technology Integration -> Digital drawing/painting apps, Google Image scrapbooking, digital PowerPoint slide creation, specialized coding classes designed for neurodivergent individuals.
Gamifying Self-Care and Domestic Routines:
Utilize specialized toothbrushing apps featuring interactive timers and animations.
Implement race-against-the-clock routines with earned rewards for timely dressing or task completion.
Transform laundry sorting into a game (e.g., shooting dirty clothes into a hamper basket).
Utilize visual reward charts and chore checklists to track task completion.
Nose-Blowing Instructional Game: To address nose-blowing deficits (where the learner sucked air in or blew out of the mouth), a board attached to a clipboard featured the rule: "Blow air out of your nose to get to the finish line and win a prize. Remember to cover your mouth with one hand and use the air from your nose to win the prize." The learner blew a cotton ball across the board using nasal airflow to reach a candy reinforcer at the finish line.
Embedded DTT for Older Learners:
Basketball Target Identification: Affix target word/picture cards in front of three laundry baskets; require the learner to throw a ball into the basket corresponding to the named target (e.g., "Water bottle").
Catch with Social Questions: Throw a ball back and forth; require answering a targeted social question upon catching before throwing back.
Puzzle Reading: Print target words on the back of puzzle pieces; reading each word grants the piece for assembly.
Jenga Task Completion: Write written instructions or reading targets on wooden Jenga blocks (e.g., "Bring a stapler to the office"); the player draws the block, reads/executes the command, and returns to the game.
Empirical Literature on Embedded Instruction:
Geiger et al. in 2012: Compared traditional vs. embedded DTT for receptive picture identification in children with autism.
Target accuracy was higher during the embedded condition.
Instructional duration to criterion was slightly longer for embedded DTT (indicating traditional DTT was more time-efficient).
Both participants preferred embedded DTT over traditional DTT, displaying higher positive affect.
Ledford and colleagues in 2017: Compared progressive time delay in massed trials vs. embedded trials during games.
Preference was mixed across participants, but faster learners demonstrated a clear preference for embedded trial contexts.
Bannerman and colleagues 1990: Highlighted balancing the client's right to habilitation (effective, efficient treatment) with their right to personal liberties ("the rights of people with developmental disabilities to eat too many donuts and take a nap").
Incorporating Choice and Autonomy:
BACB Ethical Guidelines:
Guideline 4.02 (Involving Clients in Planning and Consent): Behavior analysts involve the client in the planning of and consent for behavior change programs.
Guideline 2.09 (Treatment Intervention Efficacy): Clients have a right to effective treatment based on research literature and adapted to the individual client.
Research Findings on Choice:
Newman and colleagues: Alternating treatments design demonstrated that while acquisition speed was equivalent between teacher-choice and student-choice conditions, student choice significantly reduced competing problem behavior.
Ulke Kerkoglu and colleagues in 2010: Providing choices between activities or materials significantly increased on-task behavior compared to no-choice conditions.
Toussaint and colleagues in 2016: Choice opportunities increased treatment efficacy for 2 out of 3 participants, and all 3 participants demonstrated explicit preference for choice-making conditions.
Practical Choice Implementations:
Allowing learners to choose order of task execution or set their daily schedule.
Embedding choices within independent activity schedules (e.g., app choices on iPad schedules paired with timers).
Offering backup reinforcer options in token economies.
Providing choices of instructional locations via picture icons prior to each 30-minute block.
Engagement Strategies and Quality of Life in Adulthood
Shift in Core Focus: Adult programming shifts focus toward Quality of Life (QoL), dignified leisure, functional communication, and competitive or supported employment.
Dignity and Adult Appropriateness:
Eliminate non-age-appropriate reinforcers (e.g., lap sitting, piggyback rides, physical tickles).
Apply evaluative filters: "Would I do it?" and "Does it preserve my client's dignity?".
Eight Core Quality of Life Domains (Rentie and Reuters in 2006):
Emotional Well-Being
Interpersonal Relationships
Material Well-Being
Personal Development
Physical Well-Being
Self-Determination
Social Inclusion
Preservation of Rights
Empirical Predictors of Quality of Life:
Burgess and Goodstein in 2007: Longitudinal data indicate adults with autism often experience low QoL in job satisfaction, independent living, self-determination, and social support despite completing basic or higher education.
Purposeful Daytime Activity: Engagement in competitive employment, coursework, or structured volunteer work strongly predicts overall adult QoL.
Support Perceptions (Rentie and Reuters in 2006): Perception of available informal social support is positively correlated with QoL, whereas the number of unmet formal support needs is negatively correlated.
Desirable Employment Traits (Burgess and Goodstein in 2007): Employers prioritize motivation/enthusiasm, flexibility/adaptability, initiative, functional communication, and teamwork.
Match Employment to Learner Profile ("Go Where the Dream Makes Sense"):
Physical/Sensory Preferences: Fine-motor manual work vs. gross-motor mobile work.
Attire Requirements: Comfort/sweatpants vs. structured/collared clothing.
Social Environment: Solitary work tasks vs. high-person interaction settings.
Functional Social Skills and Behavioral Skills Training (BST):
Social Factors in Job Retention: Deficiencies in social skills lead to job termination significantly more often than non-social task-performance deficits (Webb and colleagues in 2004).
Structural vs. Functional Social Competence: Structural knowledge (reciting social rules) must be translated into functional competence (applying rules fluently with real peers/coworkers).
Four Components of BST:
Instructions: Clear verbal or written breakdown of the target skill.
Modeling: Instructor demonstrates the skill correctly.
Rehearsal: Learner practices the skill in role-play scenarios.
Feedback: Immediate corrective feedback and enthusiastic praise.
The SCORE Program (Webb and colleagues in 2004):
Utilized BST across 10 adolescents with autism in a multiple baseline across skills design to teach five core workplace social skills:
Sharing ideas
Complementing others
Offering help or encouragement
Recommending changes nicely
Exercising self control
Results demonstrated significant acquisition of all five skills across all participants.
Programming in Adult Day Centers:
Incorporate choice into routines, implement "Fun Friday" community outings, focus on functional leisure, monitor indices of happiness, and conduct continuous needs assessments.
Virtual Instruction and Distance Learning Strategies
Service Delivery Models: Direct 1:1 instruction (synchronous or asynchronous) or Parent Training/Coaching (synchronous or asynchronous).
Curricular Adaptation:
Shift focus toward functional home-based routines (e.g., independent toothbrushing, bed-making, meal planning/preparation, self-directed leisure skills).
Embed gamified elements, home scavenger hunts, and embedded DTT.
Educational Technology Applications:
Boom Learning / Go Learning: Platform allowing creation of individualized student accounts and custom interactive learning decks.
Custom Subtraction Deck Example: Built for single-digit subtraction using preferred interest images (National Monuments / Liberty Bell). Instructions stated: "Drag the pictures into the box to take away and count what is left." Included recorded teacher audio prompts and touch-screen answer selection.
Flashlight I Spy Deck: Darkened farm scene requiring active visual scanning with a moveable digital flashlight to locate and select target objects.
Interactive Laundry Deck: Features embedded instructional video modelling laundry sorting, followed by digital sorting tasks and naturalistic home practice.
Interactive PowerPoints: Utilized for both 1:1 direct trials and interactive small-group virtual instruction to maintain high response opportunities and active engagement.