Notes on The Fictional in Autofiction
The Fictional in Autofiction — Study Notes
Theoretical tension: autofiction appears to challenge traditional theories of fiction and fictionality, which tend to insist on a clear border between fiction and nonfiction.
Serge Doubrovsky’s initial definition (Fils, 1977): autofiction is a fiction based on strictly real events and facts; language’s adventure produces fiction even if events are real. The back cover phrases it as a form of ‘fiction’ built from real events; the front cover labels the work as a ‘roman’ (novel).
Critics argue this creates a paradox: autofiction sits between autobiography and fiction, resisting simple categorization.
The chapter’s aim: show that theories of fiction and fictionality can illuminate autofiction, and autofiction can illuminate theories of fiction.
Core problem fields addressed:
How autofiction engages with theories of autobiography and with theories of fiction.
Whether autofiction can be reconciled with existing definitions of ficitonality.
How autofiction uses formal devices and narrative frames to foreground either referential force or ficionalization.
How autofiction handles reception and ambiguity in readers’ responses.
Autobiography, fiction, and the pact: Lejeune’s framework vs Doubrovsky’s practice
Philippe Lejeune’s 1975 model: autobiography centers on the identity of author, narrator, and character, possibly grounded in an explicit autobiographical pact (the “truth swap” between life and text).
Lejeune’s chart of autodiegetic narratives includes cases where proper name and pact may be missing or indirect (cases 2b, 2c, 3a); traditionally, the identity of author, narrator, and character grounds the pact.
Doubrovsky’s Fils challenges Lejeune’s model: the narrator is named Serge Doubrovsky, yet the text is presented as a novel; autofiction emerges as a practice that sits in the empty square of Lejeune’s chart, emphasizing auto rather than strictly fictional organization.
The claim: autofiction is not simply a genre, but a literary practice with divergent aims (autobiographical vs. linguistic/psychoanalytic focus).
Scholarly readings note: autofiction’s ambiguity can be productive or obstructive depending on whether one treats fictionality as referential or as a linguistic/constructed maneuver.
Critics such as Zipfel and Schmitt point out tensions between naming self-narrators after authors (autofabulation) and the claim that autofiction is a form of non-referential discourse.
Key theoretical approaches to fiction and fictionality (foundations for autofiction analysis)
Semantic theories: fiction depends on reference structures and the ontological status of named entities; fictionality is tied to referential status rather than purely stylistic features.
Philosophical discussions on nonexistent entities (e.g., Frege, Kripke, Lewis) inform debates about whether fictional characters have sense but no referent, or whether they can have referents in possible worlds.
Hamburger (The Logic of Literature): separates reality statements (originating from a real I-Origo) from fiction (I-Origines); excludes first-person narratives from fiction proper due to autobiographical origins in the statement system. This is a stringent stance and not universally adopted.
Searle (pretended illocutions): fictional utterances suspend truth commitments through a convention of pretended assertions.
Genette (Fiction and Diction): fiction vs factual narrative is clarified through the relationship between author and narrator; veracity is not seriously assumed by the author in fiction; the key is the identification or nonidentification of author and narrator.
Dorrit Cohn (The Distinction of Fiction): presents “signposts of fictionality” that mark fiction’s domain, notably the two-tier structure (story vs. discourse), non-referential modes (consciousness presentation), and the duplication of the narrative instance (author and narrator).
Cohn’s positioning of autofiction as a crossbreed: autofiction is a mode where the self-narrator is named after the author, blurring fiction and nonfiction.
Walton (Mimesis as Make-Believe) and Schaeffer (Why Fiction?) emphasize make-believe and ludic feints as pragmatic contracts that authorize fiction; similar themes surface in Lejeune and Searle’s frameworks.
Caïra (Définer la fiction): extends fiction to non-mimetic forms (e.g., rule-based games) via documentary vs. fictional framing operations.
Genette’s claim about literary fiction vs. nonfiction’s status: fiction is constitutively literary; nonfiction’s status is conditional on diction and aesthetic judgment.
Marie-Laure Ryan’s panfictionality: critiques the idea that all narrative is fiction, while recognizing autofiction’s specific hybridity rather than dissolving all forms into fiction.
The shift to “non-communicational” readings of fiction (e.g., Sylvie Patron): rethinks the speaker’s role and whether a narrator is strictly necessary; links Hamburger’s ideas to Banfield and Kuroda.
Overall implication: no single theory of fiction easily accounts for autofiction; oscillating readings are needed to capture autofiction’s dynamic and hybrid nature.
Autofiction as a test bed for theory: the dialectical approach
Autofiction exposes disjunctions between theory and practice in life-writing and in the broader field of fiction.
It creates space to re-evaluate the fact/fiction divide and to analyze local signposts of fictionality within nonfiction contexts.
It challenges panfictional readings that collapse all narrative into fiction and instead highlights graded degrees of fictionality and sites of fictionalization.
The oscillation between autodiegetic and heterodiegetic elements shows that readers can switch between reading modes, depending on textual cues and paratexts.
Reading practices and reader responses to autofiction
Some scholars (Ferreira-Meyers, Lavocat) stress that readers can demarcate fact from fiction while attending to the hybrid forms.
Walsh, Nielsen, Phelan, and Walsh (2007, 2014) distinguish fictionality as a “rhetorical resource” in serious discourse, with local (passages within nonfiction) and global (overall genre) dimensions.
Autofiction often foregrounds signposts of fictionality in nonfiction contexts, producing hybrid effects without erasing borders.
The local/global distinction helps theorize how autofiction can function as a bridging form without collapsing borders.
Case studies and illustrative configurations (overview of cases used in the text)
I/Not I: The fundamental autofictional paradox expressed as It is I and it is not I; conceptually a core tension in autofiction across genres.
Annie Ernaux: uses a transpersonal I to examine social and familial reality; Les Années (The Years) employs deixis with on, elle, and nous to explore collective memory; the I-Origo anchors but becomes destabilized through pronoun play; this work remains broadly non-fictional but leverages first-person experimentation.
Édouard Louis: En finir avec Eddy Bellegueule (The End of Eddy) foregrounds a split between the child and the narrating author, yet the work remains within a broadly autobiographical pact and is often labeled autofiction due to its onomastic and formal signals; the cover’s labeling as novel (roman) is part of a broader negotiation of truth claims.
Rachel Cusk: Outline/Transit/Kudos trilogy features a narrator who appears primarily through interactions with others; the central technique is “anti-description” and the externalized thought of others; the narrator is not the sole source of interiority, generating an autofictional effect through multiplicity of voices and a self-reflective, multicentered subjectivity.
Olivia Laing: Crudo carries a disclaimer that it is a work of fiction, with incidents and characters imagined or counterfactualized; the text foregrounds referential ambiguity through framing devices, including counterfactual references to Kathy Acker and other figures; the counterfactuality and the deictic frame invite autofictional readings despite the stated disclaimer.
Christophe Boltanski: La Cache (The Safe House) uses spaces and the in-between (e.g., the storage space where a relative hid during war) to structure a family narrative; the text plays with names and anonymity, and with “immersion vectors” that create a fictionalized transposition of private lives into a readable narrative; this case demonstrates how autofiction can emerge from a hybrid of factual grounding and speculative/fictionalized renderings.
Karl Ove Knausgård: My Struggle presents granular, minute daily details that create a reality-like texture; the “reality effect” is heightened by non-fictional context yet reads as fiction-like due to its close narration of mundane acts; the text is a hybrid that foregrounds phenomenology and constructed realism.
Camille Laurens: Dans ces bras-là (In His Arms) uses confessional dialogues with a psychoanalyst and frames the confessional within a hypothetical future book; the assertion I would not be the woman in the book suggests a meta-narrative pact that edges toward autofiction while maintaining a strong autobiographical trace; the strategy acts as a self-protective, publishing-era device to navigate privacy concerns.
Reading contracts and oscillations in autofiction
Autobiographical pact vs. self-fictionalization vs. autofabulation: autofiction defies a single model, often oscillating among autobiographical truth claims and fictionalized frames.
Readers often switch between interpreting a text as factual or fictional depending on cues such as naming, paratexts (e.g., label roman), narrative technique, and the presence of explicit or implicit pacts.
The practice of using disclaimers or counterfactual markers can prompt autofictional readings even when a text is marketed as fiction.
The oscillation between reading modes is a central feature of autofiction studies and a focus in recent scholarship (as echoed in the work of Wagner-Egelhaaf, Effe, and Gibbons in Chap. 2 and 4 of this volume).
The structure and aims of autofictional analysis
Aims to map where fictionality operates within autobiographical-writing practices.
Seeks to identify the sites of signposting—pragmatic, narratological, and rhetorical devices—that foreground either factuality or fictionality.
Emphasizes the range of configurations: global vs local fictionality, and the ways in which forms of deictic displacement (I, you, we) contribute to reading positions.
Underlines that autofiction is not a single genre but a spectrum of hybridity with varying degrees of referential ground and fictionality.
Implications for theory and reception
Autofiction challenges ontological theories (which try to define reality vs fiction) and pragmatic theories (which explain how readers interpret signposts and pacts).
It can illuminate debates about the status of nonfiction in contemporary literature, the boundary-work of life-writing, and the politics of truth-telling in a post-truth era.
Autofiction provides empirical material to test and refine theories of fiction and discourse, including how readers interpret signposts of fictionality and where those signposts may be intentionally or unintentionally misleading.
Key takeaways
Autofiction sits at the intersection of autobiography and fiction, often complicating the traditional borders between the two.
Various theoretical frameworks offer useful tools to analyze autofiction, but none singlehandedly accounts for all its forms; a pluralistic approach is necessary.
Local signposts of fictionality (within otherwise factual discourse) are essential for understanding autofiction’s effects and reader reception.
The field invites ongoing dialogue between theory and practice, with autofiction offering a fertile ground for testing and refining theories of fiction and fictionality.
Notes and references (selected, from the transcript):
Doubrovsky, S. Fils (1977); later discussions about autofiction as a postmodern variant of autobiography.
Lejeune, P. Le Pacte autobiographique; the concept of autobiographical pact and the cases of identity and pact in autodiegetic narratives.
Hamburger, K. The Logic of Literature; distinction between I-Origo and I-Origines and the status of first-person narratives in fiction.
Searle, J. R. The Logical Status of Fictional Discourse; pretense/pretended illocutions.
Genette, G. Fiction and Diction; author-narrator identity and the boundaries of factual narrative.
Cohn, D. The Distinction of Fiction; signposts of fictionality; bi-level narrative models; fiction vs nonfiction.
Walton, K. L. Mimesis as Make-Believe; ludic feint and the make-believe contract.
Schaeffer, J.-M. Why Fiction?; pragmatic contracts and the logic of fiction.
Caïra, O. Définir la fiction; framing operations in documentary vs fictional communication.
Walsh, R.; Nielsen, J.; Phelan, J.; The Rhetoric of Fictionality; local vs global fictionality in nonfiction contexts.
Patron, S. Le Narrateur; optional-narrator approach and non-communicational theories of narration.
Rousseau, Darrieussecq, Ernaux, Cusk, Laing, Boltanski, Louis, Knausgaard, Laurens; case examples cited in the chapter illustrating autofictional effects and reading contracts.
This compilation presents the major and minor points from the chapter in a structured, study-friendly format. It highlights the theoretical tensions, key positions, and representative case studies that illuminate how autofiction negotiates the borders between fact and fiction, and how readers and scholars alike parse its complex signposts of fictionality.