laura

Introduction to Revision in Writing

  • Cathleen Breidenbach Quote

    • "The standard perception that revision is something that happens at the end of the writing process is a good place to start revising ideas about revision."

  • The common belief that good writers produce perfect sentences effortlessly is inaccurate.

    • The reality is that all writers, regardless of experience, need revision.

    • Revision is crucial for creating clearer, stronger, more persuasive, and passionate writing.

    • Writing often comes with stress, especially under time constraints, which emphasizes the need for revision.

  • Key Concept: Revision is not a discrete end step; rather, it is an integral part of the writing process itself.

Differentiating Revision from Proofreading

  • Revision is distinct from proofreading or copy editing.

    • Proofreading focuses on grammar, spelling, and style.

    • Effective revision requires deep engagement with fundamental questions:

    • Purpose: Why am I writing this?

    • Audience: Who am I writing for?

    • Structure: How is my writing organized logically and effectively?

Perceptions of Writers and Their Process

  • Writing can be a daunting task, and even published authors experience similar struggles as novice writers.

  • Writers experience a social writing process including feedback from peers and instructors.

    • Extension of the modern definition of writing to include composing in various mediums reinforces the idea of revision as a fundamental part of writing.

Everyday Writing and Revision

  • Individuals engaging in casual writing (e.g., on social media) are still part of the writing community, even if they don't label themselves as writers.

    • Features like editing on platforms (e.g., Facebook's post edit feature, Google Docs' revision history) reflect the omnipresence of revision in modern communication.

  • Autocorrect features in texting and other digital communications also highlight the continual nature of revision.

Case Study: Martin Luther King Jr. and Revision

  • King’s famous "I Have a Dream" speech exemplifies the importance of revision.

    • This speech was not a single event but a cumulation of many revisions tailored for different audiences.

    • King’s approach to public speaking involved adapting content dynamically, illustrating the live nature of revision.

Critique of Revision Practices

  • Concerns regarding revision often include it being viewed as procrastination or avoidance.

    • Critics argue that excessive tinkering detracts from efficiency and can delay the writing process.

    • Acknowledging that writing is inherently social and intended for audience engagement counters this critique.

  • Research by Paul Anderson, Chris Anson, and others highlights that targeted interventions in the writing process significantly enhance writing proficiency rather than sheer volume of writing.

Metaphor of Writing

  • The metaphor of writing as a seed encapsulates the essence of revision, suggesting growth through iterative processes.

    • Revision is signified not as weakness but as an integral part of writing itself.

    • Continuous revision leads writers to blend roles of writer and ideal reader, enhancing engagement with both their work and audience.

Revision as a Social and Communal Practice

  • Writing and revision are communal acts responsive to reader feedback and expectations.

  • King’s revisions of his speeches illustrate the process of crafting a message capable of resonating with diverse audiences.

Professional Practices in Revision

  • Professional writers may seem to manage revisions more deftly, enduring many drafts through patience.

    • Example: Tim Weninger’s research paper, which involved 463 revisions, illustrating dedication to thorough revision.

    • Most revisions in professional writing focus on substantial changes rather than mere surface-level edits.

Understanding Effective Revision

  • The number of revisions does not equate to quality writing; effective revision is about strategic improvements.

    • Stephen King’s concept of the 'ideal reader' represents an internalized audience that writers bounce their ideas against during the revision process.

    • This dynamic creates a collaborative relationship

Cathleen Breidenbach explains that the common understanding of revision as a final step in writing is itself a concept that needs to be revised. Her insight emphasizes that revision is not merely an end-of-process task but rather an integral part of the entire writing journey. This perspective is important because it highlights that all writers, regardless of experience, require revision to produce clearer, stronger, more persuasive, and passionate writing. It reframes revision from a discrete last step to a continuous and crucial component of effective communication.