1st Amendment
The First Amendment protects religious liberty by balancing individual rights against governmental interests. While freedom of religious belief is absolute, freedom of religious practice can be restricted to balance the interests of the majority and the free exercise of minority groups.
Constitutional Foundations
First Amendment Text: "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof."
Establishment Clause: Prohibits the federal government from establishing an official national religion or church.
Free Exercise Clause: Protects citizens' rights to practice their religious beliefs without arbitrary government interference.
Wall of Separation:
Phrase coined by Thomas Jefferson in a letter interpreting the First Amendment as creating a strict boundary between church and state.
The Johnson Amendment (1954): Added by Senator Lyndon B. Johnson to a tax bill, requiring that tax-exempt organizations, including churches, refrain from endorsing political candidates from the pulpit to retain their tax-exempt status.
Required Supreme Court Precedents
Engel v. Vitale (1962)
Constitutional Issue: Establishment Clause.
Context: The New York State Board of Regents authorized a short, voluntary, nondenominational prayer for recitation in public schools.
Ruling: State-sponsored prayer in public schools is unconstitutional.
Impact: Justice Hugo Black invoked Jefferson's "wall of separation," ruling that the government has no business writing prayers for citizens, thus protecting individual religious liberty against state-backed religious exercises.
Wisconsin v. Yoder (1972)
Constitutional Issue: Free Exercise Clause.
Context: Amish parents challenged Wisconsin's compulsory school attendance law, which required children to attend school until age 16, arguing that high school attendance conflicted with Amish community values and religious traditions.
Ruling: Compelling Amish students to attend school past eighth grade violated their free exercise rights.
Impact: Upheld individual religious practice over a state's interest in mandatory educational requirements.
Limits to Free Exercise
Employment Division v. Smith (1990):
Addressed whether the Free Exercise Clause protects religious practices that violate neutral, generally applicable criminal laws (involving sacramental peyote use).
Ruling: The Court held that religious freedom is not absolute; individuals are not excused from complying with neutral, generally applicable laws, meaning illegal acts are not shielded by the Free Exercise Clause.
Active Recall on all the Cases:
Schneck v US (Free Speech)
Constitutional Issue: Free Speech
Context: Schneck would hand out fliers during wartime to try to get people to not sign up for the military draft.
Ruling: the supreme court ruling for this case was not in favor of Schneck’s free speech because his actions were violating the military draft (clear and present danger) to the militia
tinker v Des moines
Constitutional Issue: free speech
Context: students wore black armbands to protest the Vietnam war.
ruling: protected the students’ free symbolic speech because they were not protesting during educational instruction
wisconsin v yoder
constituitonal issue: free exersice clause
context: it was an amish family religious tradition to stop sending their children to school after 8th grade. however, wisconsin’s compulsory law to have kids go to school up until the age of 16 violated their tradition
ruling: wisonsin’s compulsory education law violated the amish families’ free exercie clause, so the ruling protected the amish familiies rights to practice their minority religion without government interference
engel v vitale
consituitional issue: establishment clause
context: school prayer was invoked in new york public school systems. engel sued the school because their evidence was that it violated the establishment clause of invoking prayer.
Engel’s arguments: it would get kids to support religion that their parents did not support; government had no expertise to be invoking religious prayers; if kids left the classroom during the prayer they might feel ashamed
Vitale’s arguments: the prayer was meant to be flexible for any religion; kids did not have to participate in the prayer (they could either leave the classroom or be silent during the prayer); it was nondemonational and a short and simple prayer that did not violate the esablishment clause because governmnet wasn’t setting a certain religion that needed to be practiced with this prayer;
ruling: engel’s arguments won. government should have no interference with religion, and it violated the establishment clause. one of the pieces of evidence used to support this was jefferson’s “wall of separation” used to define the barrier between church and govnerment