Bisexual Health Disparities, Sexual Stigma, and Anti-Bisexual Bias
Overview of Bisexual Health Disparities and Syndemic Theory
Epidemiological Context of Bisexuality:
- Data from the 2010 National Survey of Sexual Health and Behavior (NSSHB) indicates that of adult men and of adult women in the United States self-identify as bisexual.
- Among adolescents aged 14 to 17, of males and of females self-identify as bisexual.
- Across populations, a substantially higher percentage of individuals engage in sexual behavior with both men and women than self-identify using the bisexual label.
Manifestations of Health Disparities:
- Bisexual individuals experience profound disparities in physical, mental, and sexual health when compared to exclusive heterosexual and homosexual cohorts.
- Psychosocial and Mental Health: Bisexual individuals exhibit heightened rates of anxiety, depression, recent psychological distress, negative affect, substance abuse, eating disorder symptomatology, violence victimization, and suicidality. In Australia and North America, bisexual individuals report elevated mood disorders compared to heterosexual and gay/lesbian peers, with young bisexual women reporting the highest rates of suicidality among all LGB youth.
- Sexual and Reproductive Health: Young bisexual women are less likely to utilize condoms during vaginal intercourse compared to heterosexual women and exhibit significantly higher rates of sexually transmitted infection (STI) diagnoses than both heterosexual and lesbian women. They also face higher frequencies of sexual victimization compared to lesbian women, higher rates of intimate partner violence compared to heterosexual women, lower health-related quality of life, and increased rates of emergency contraception usage and pregnancy termination.
Syndemic Framework:
- Bisexual health disparities operate as synergistic epidemics (syndemics), wherein multiple health issues (e.g., substance abuse, mental distress, sexual risk, victimization) interact in a chain reaction.
- These syndemic interactions are driven and exacerbated by early-life adversity, trauma, societal discrimination, and pervasive sexual stigma.
Frameworks of Minority Stress, Double Discrimination, and Biphobia
Limitations of the Minority Stress Framework:
- The standard minority stress model posits that sexual minorities experience excess stress due to identity marginalization and sexual stigma (the devaluing and unequal power afforded to sexual minorities).
- However, traditional minority stress fails to account for bisexual-specific disparities: bisexual individuals often report fewer instances of general same-sex sexual orientation discrimination than gay and lesbian individuals, yet suffer worse health outcomes. This indicates that factors beyond generic same-sex sexual stigma drive bisexual health disparities.
Double Discrimination and Biphobia:
- Bisexual individuals face a unique double discrimination, experiencing prejudice, stigma, and devaluation from both heterosexual ("straight") and homosexual ("gay/lesbian") communities.
- Anti-bisexual prejudice (biphobia) encompasses distinct stereotyping, erasure, and exclusion that operate independently of homophobia.
Social Support and Isolation:
- Community attachment and social support function as critical protective factors that foster resilience against syndemic risk.
- Bisexual individuals exhibit significantly lower levels of community attachment both inside and outside sexual minority spaces.
- Feelings of social isolation, marginalization, invisibility, and being "not queer enough" erode protective buffers, compounding mental distress.
- Reluctance to disclose bisexual identity to healthcare providers—driven by fear of biphobic stigma—limits the uptake of STI/HIV prevention, testing, and care services.
Liminal Social Spaces:
- Bisexual identity exists in a liminal space ("between two worlds"). This mirrors the social position of biracial and multiracial individuals.
- Shared positionality in liminal spaces aligns with evidence that biracial and multiracial individuals demonstrate lower levels of bi-negative attitudes, suggesting an enhanced empathy for dual or non-binary identities.
Quantitative Assessment of Anti-Bisexual Attitudes: The BIAS Scales
Development of the Bisexualities: Indiana Attitudes Scale (BIAS):
- Item Elicitation: Administered open-ended classroom surveys to undergraduate students at Indiana University – Bloomington in July 2010 to capture descriptive perspectives on bisexuality generally, as well as toward bisexual men and women separately.
- Scale Construction: Elicited themes informed the creation of two 33-item sub-scales: BIAS-m (attitudes toward bisexual men) and BIAS-f (attitudes toward bisexual women). An expert panel of 3 doctoral-level researchers established content integrity.
- Survey Administration: Deployed online via Qualtrics in June 2011 to a convenience sample across diverse networking platforms ( total consented, with an approximate full completion rate). Evaluated items on a 5-point Likert response format.
Exploratory Factor Analysis (EFA) and Scale Refinement:
- EFA was conducted using principal axis factoring with orthogonal rotation on a Pearson correlation matrix. Five bivalent items were removed prior to final extraction.
- Factor 1 (Bisexual Confusion, Hypersexuality, and Danger): Explained of response variance for BIAS-m ( items; factor loadings ranging from to ) and of response variance for BIAS-f ( items; factor loadings ranging from to ).
- Factor 2 (Sexual Appeal to Others): Explained of response variance for BIAS-m ( items; factor loadings ranging from to ) and of response variance for BIAS-f ( items; factor loadings ranging from to ).
- Two items were eliminated due to low communalities (): "Compared to other men, I think bisexual men are more open to new sexual experiences" (communality ) and "Compared to other men, bisexual men are less constrained by social norms" (communality ).
- Final Scale Metrics:
- BIAS-m: Retained items (), demonstrating high internal consistency with Cronbach's .
- BIAS-f: Retained items (), demonstrating high internal consistency with Cronbach's .
Statistical Findings from the Bisexualities: Indiana Attitudes Survey
Demographics of BIAS Validation Samples:
- BIAS-m Sample (): Median age range 18–24 (mean = years, SD = , range 18–73). Gender breakdown: male, female, transgender/genderqueer. Racial identity: White, biracial/multiracial, Black, Hispanic. Sexual orientation: heterosexual, bisexual, gay/lesbian, uncertain/other. Annual income : .
- BIAS-f Sample (): Median age range 25–34. Gender breakdown: male, female, transgender/genderqueer. Racial identity: White, biracial/multiracial, Hispanic, Black. Annual income : .
Generalized Linear Model (GLM) Predictors of Anti-Bisexual Bias:
- BIAS-m (Bisexual Men): Mean score = (SD = ). Female gender significantly predicted lower bi-negative attitudes (, ). Racial/ethnic minority status showed a marginal positive association with bi-negativity (, ).
- BIAS-f (Bisexual Women): Mean score = (SD = ). Female gender significantly predicted lower bi-negative attitudes (, ). Racial/ethnic minority status significantly predicted higher bi-negative attitudes (, ).
- Total BIAS ( completing both scales): Sub-scale scores were highly correlated (, ). Female gender significantly predicted lower total anti-bisexual bias (, ).
Impact of Respondent Sexual Identity on Bi-Negativity:
- BIAS-m Scores: Heterosexual respondents = ; Homosexual (Gay/Lesbian) respondents = ; Bisexual respondents = .
- Heterosexual vs. Homosexual: Mean difference = , SE = , .
- Heterosexual vs. Bisexual: Mean difference = , SE = , .
- Homosexual vs. Bisexual: Mean difference = , SE = , .
- BIAS-f Scores: Heterosexual respondents = ; Homosexual respondents = ; Bisexual respondents = .
- Heterosexual vs. Homosexual: Mean difference = , SE = , .
- Heterosexual vs. Bisexual: Mean difference = , SE = , .
- Homosexual vs. Bisexual: Mean difference = , SE = , .
- Total BIAS Scores: Heterosexual respondents = ; Homosexual respondents = ; Bisexual respondents = .
- Heterosexual vs. Homosexual: Mean difference = , SE = , .
- Heterosexual vs. Bisexual: Mean difference = , SE = , .
- Homosexual vs. Bisexual: Mean difference = , SE = , .
Gender-Based Target Differences and Legitimacy Opinions:
- Comparative analysis () revealed that negative attitudes toward bisexual men were significantly higher than toward bisexual women by (, mean difference = , SE = , , Wilcoxon ).
- Overall, of respondents did not recognize bisexuality as a legitimate sexual orientation.
- Heterosexual males were significantly more likely than any other gender/sexuality group to deny the legitimacy of bisexuality (BIAS-f Adjusted Odds Ratio [AOR] = , ; BIAS-m AOR = , ).
Biracial and Multiracial Subgroup Analysis:
- Within racial/ethnic minority respondents, biracial/multiracial identity was significantly associated with lower bi-negativity scores on BIAS-m (, ) and BIAS-f (, ), controlling for income, gender, age, and sexual minority status.
Qualitative Perspectives of Young Bisexual Women on Stigma and Health
Study Design and Methodology (Toronto Study):
- A qualitative, community-based focus group study conducted in Toronto, Canada (August 2014) in partnership with the Centre for Addiction and Mental Health, University of Toronto, and Planned Parenthood Toronto.
- Ethics & Governance: Approved by the University of Toronto. An advisory committee of 7 young bisexual women (aged 16–29; including 1 trans woman, 1 non-binary person, 5 cisgender women; 3 women of color) assisted in research design and thematic validation.
- Sampling & Screening: Recruitment yielded 56 telephonically screened applicants; purposive sampling selected participants across four 2-hour focus groups ( to participants per group). Compensation included a $10 honorarium and public transit fare.
- Analytical Approach: Constructionist grounded theory using open, axial, and selective coding via NVivo 9 software, employing the constant comparative method.
Demographics of Focus Group Participants ():
- Gender Identity: Woman (), Genderqueer (), Trans woman (), Femme (), Ambiguous (), Bigendered ().
- Sexual Identity: Bisexual (), Queer (), Pansexual (), Other (; including universal, dyke, poly, kinky, multisexual, fluid).
- Ethnocultural Background: White (), Black Caribbean (), Jewish (), Black African (), Filipino (), South Asian (), Chinese (), West Asian (), West Indian ().
- Age Distribution: aged 16–18 (), aged 19–21 (), aged 22–24 (), aged 25–27 (), aged 28–29 ().
- Education: some high school (), some trade school (), some college/university (), completed college/university (), some post-graduate (), completed post-graduate ().
- Annual Income: (), (), (), (), ().
Conceptual Model of Bisexual Stigma and Health Outcomes:


- The model maps the structural pathway from stigma to health disparities:
Dynamics of Bisexual Erasure, Stereotypes, and Monosexism
Bisexual Erasure:
- Bisexual erasure comprises social processes that render bisexuality invisible, enforced by monosexist norms (the systemic assumption that attraction is limited to a single gender).
- Public perception infers sexual identity strictly from the gender of an individual's current partner: bisexual women partnered with women are labeled lesbians, those partnered with men are labeled heterosexual, and monogamous bisexuals are assumed to have "chosen" a monosexual identity.
Prominent Bisexual Stereotypes:
- Transitional Identity: The assumption that bisexuality is a temporary phase preceding a gay/lesbian or heterosexual identity.
- Hypersexuality and Promiscuity: Stereotyping bisexual individuals as inherently slutty, untruthful, incapable of monogamy, or prone to infidelity.
- Concurrent Partner Expectation: The belief that an individual must actively engage in simultaneous romantic or sexual relationships with multiple genders to maintain bisexual status.
Performative Bisexuality vs. Slut Shaming:
- Performative Bisexuality: Engagement in public sexualized behavior between women for the gratification of male onlookers while identifying as heterosexual. This phenomenon leads observers to invalidate genuine bisexual identity as mere attention-seeking behavior.
- Competing Sexual Double Standards: Young bisexual women face contradictory societal demands. Non-monogamous bisexual women are victimized by "slut shaming," while monogamous bisexual women are accused of being "not queer enough" or erasing their identity ("damned if you do, damned if you don't").
Internalized Biphobia:
- Persistent exposure to erasure and stereotypes fosters internalized biphobia, resulting in self-doubt regarding sexual authenticity, fear of public misperception as heterosexual, and anxiety over inadvertently reinforcing negative stereotypes.
The Structural Burden of Proof and Behavior Modification
The Structural Burden of Proof:
- Monosexism imposes an asymmetric "burden of proof" on bisexual individuals, requiring continuous empirical verification of their attraction to multiple genders.
Pressure to Modify Behavior:
- Skepticism from peers and partners pressures bisexual women to validate their identity through sexual acts, even when unprepared regarding safer-sex knowledge or personal boundaries.
- External demands induce pressure to maintain concurrent "checklists" of multi-gender partners to prove identity beyond doubt.
- Individuals experience acute anxiety over being misidentified as heterosexual, driving compulsory coming-out disclosures to assert queerness.
Behavioral Modification and Health Disparities:
- Relationship Sabotage: Participants reported intentionally disrupting happy monogamous relationships by introducing non-monogamous dynamics solely to avoid monosexist erasure, resulting in clinical depression.
- Interpersonal Distancing: Women reported physically distancing themselves from male partners in public settings to signal queer identity, inducing emotional distress and romantic conflict.
- Healthcare Information Concealment: Fear of being judged as inexperienced or "not really queer" by lesbian-identified partners prevents bisexual women from asking questions about safer same-sex practices, increasing exposure to STIs.
Public Health Implications, Clinical Applications, and Future Directions
Public Health Interventions:
- Educational initiatives must target both heterosexual and LGBTQ communities to decouple sexual behavior from sexual identity.
- Campaigns must dismantle LGBTQ gatekeeping practices that evaluate whether individuals are "queer enough" to access community support.
Social Marketing Strategies:
- Adapt evidence-based frameworks, such as the Acceptance Journeys campaign model, to reduce bi-negative attitudes among high-bias groups: heterosexual males, gay/lesbian communities, and racial/ethnic minority communities.
Clinical and Health Care Delivery:
- Healthcare practitioners must receive training on bisexual-specific minority stressors and non-judgmental care.
- Clinical settings must establish protocols that facilitate identity disclosure and provide tailored referrals, ensuring bisexual clients are not alienated by gay-centric or heteronormative frameworks.
Future Research Priorities:
- Investigate the intersectional dynamics of biphobia, monosexism, sexism, race, and disability.
- Validate the BIAS-m and BIAS-f instruments in large, probability-based national samples to yield generalizable population estimates.
- Utilize reworded BIAS measures to evaluate internalized biphobia and measure the efficacy of anti-stigma interventions.