Deviation, Rejection, and Communication – Schachter 1950
Key Terms:
Cohesiveness: the total field of forces acting on members to remain in the group
Internal power of the group: the magnitude of change the group can induce on its members.
Relevance: the ordering, in terms of importance to the group, of the activities over which the internal power of the group extends.
Research Question
How do groups respond to members who disagree with group norms, and how do group cohesiveness and issue relevance influence communication and rejection?
Methods
Conducted an experiment involving 32 discussion groups of male college students.
Groups differed in cohesiveness (high vs. low) and issue relevance (relevant vs. irrelevant).
Each group included three confederates:
Deviate: Consistently disagreed with the group
Mode: Agreed with the group's majority opinion
Slider: Initially disagreed but eventually conformed
Researchers observed communication patterns and measured rejection through group rankings and committee assignments.
Findings
Groups initially directed communication toward deviants in attempts to change their opinions.
Members who consistently disagreed were eventually rejected, while those who conformed were generally accepted.
Rejection tended to be stronger in highly cohesive groups and when disagreement concerned an issue important to the group.
Members who maintained deviant opinions were more likely to be assigned undesirable, low-status group roles.
Key takeaway: Groups can pressure its members to conform to shared norms. Individuals who consistently resist conformity may be rejected or excluded from groups to maintain agreement.