Study Notes: Egoism, Obligation, and the Ethics of Promising in Jane Austen's Sense and Sensibility

Theoretical Foundations of Promising in Eighteenth-Century Moral Thought

  • Natural Law Theories of Obligation:

    • Natural law philosophers such as John Locke (Second Treatise of Government, 16901690) and Samuel Pufendorf (Of the Law of Nature and Nations, 17031703) maintained that promises derive their binding force directly from the wills and intentions of promisors.
    • In this view, promissory obligations precede civil society and serve as the moral foundation that justifies the formation of the social contract.
  • Hobbesian Scepticism:

    • Thomas Hobbes (Leviathan, 16511651) posited that human words and promises are inherently weak, asserting that obligations hold strength not from their own nature but from the fear of evil consequences following a breach.
  • Utilitarian and Expectation-Based Theories:

    • David Hume (A Treatise of Human Nature, 17391739–17401740; An Enquiry concerning the Principles of Morals, 17511751) classified promise keeping as an "artificial virtue" rather than a natural disposition.
      • Hume argued that human beings are naturally selfish or endowed with confined generosity, requiring reciprocal advantages to perform actions for strangers.
      • The duty of promise keeping arose to establish mutual trust and confidence necessary for human commerce.
      • Hume maintained that self-interest and reputation ensure fidelity: an individual who breaks a promise loses the trust of society, making enlightened egoism a guarantor of social constancy.
    • Adam Smith (Lectures on Jurisprudence, 17621762–17631763; The Theory of Moral Sentiments, 17591759) argued that promissory obligation cannot stem solely from the will of the promisor.
      • A promise made without internal intention to perform remains fully binding because it produces dependence and disappointment in the promisee.
      • Smith evaluated reasonableness and expectation through the perspective of a hypothetical "impartial spectator."
    • William Paley (The Principles of Moral and Political Philosophy, 17851785) emphasized that human conduct is regulated by expectation.
      • Confidence in assurances is essential to social intercourse.
      • Paley established that a promise obligates in the precise sense in which the promisor believed that the promisee accepted it, prioritizing reasonable interpretations of promisees over secret intentions of promisors.
  • Scottish Common Sense Philosophy:

    • David Fordyce (The Preceptor, 17481748; The Elements of Moral Philosophy, 17541754) rejected Hobbesian utility, asserting that the moral sense is an innate instinct interwoven into human nature.
      • Fordyce held that the duty to keep promises is antecedent to human conventions.
      • His work formed the entry for "Moral Philosophy" in William Smellie's Encyclopædia Britannica (17711771).
    • Thomas Reid (Essays on the Active Powers of Man, 17881788) claimed that social intercourse is an innate faculty provided by the Creator.
      • Good faith and trust are formed by nature in young minds before individuals comprehend utility or interest.
    • Henry Home, Lord Kames (Principles of Equity, 17671767; Essays on the Principles of Morality and Natural Religion, 17511751) asserted that promises make benevolence a duty independent of pecuniary interest.
      • The moral sense connects the living with the dead, obligating individuals to fulfill the dying wishes of friends to quiet human minds regarding futurity.
  • Radical and Conservative Critiques of the 1790s1790\text{s}:

    • William Godwin (Enquiry Concerning Political Justice, 17931793, 17961796) condemned promises as inherently restrictive evils.
      • Godwin advocated a case-by-case evaluation of utility, arguing that any engagement must be violated if adherence hinders general happiness or justice.
    • Edmund Burke (Reflections on the Revolution in France, 17901790) rejected modern commercial contracts as temporary partnerships comparable to trade agreements in pepper, coffee, or tobacco.
      • Burke argued that social stability depends on unchosen, inherited hereditary ties and entailed estates to check the selfish will and prevent society from dissolving into the "dust and powder of individuality."

Scholarly Debates on Jane Austen's Ethical and Political Orientation

  • Conservative Burkean Readings:

    • Alistair M. Duckworth (The Improvement of the Estate, 19711971) and Marilyn Butler (Jane Austen and the War of Ideas, 19751975; Romantics, Rebels and Reactionaries, 19821982) established a tradition viewing Austen as an adherent of Burkean conservatism.
    • These scholars argue that Austen's novels support inherited structures of value, duty, principle, and the sacrifice of private inclination to traditional social hierarchy, opposing individualist moral judgment.
    • Additional scholars supporting conservative or non-volitional readings include Warren Roberts (Jane Austen and the French Revolution, 19791979), Daniel M. Stout (Corporate Romanticism, 20172017), Sandra Macpherson (20032003), and Mary Poovey (19841984).
  • Reformist and Feminist Readings:

    • Claudia L. Johnson (Jane Austen: Women, Politics, and the Novel, 19881988), Margaret Kirkham (19861986), Helena Kelly (20172017), and Anne K. Mellor (20022002) challenge the Burkean paradigm.
    • Johnson demonstrates that Austen aligns with reformist novelists such as Elizabeth Inchbald and William Godwin by dramatizing promise keeping and breaking as functions of power relations, showing how powerful overlords breach promises when convenient while compelling underlings to observe them.
  • Centrist, Intersubjective, and Speech-Act Interpretations:

    • Mark M. Hennelly, Jr. (20022002) and Eric Lindstrom (20112011) analyze Austen through J. L. Austin's speech act theory, distinguishing between performative and constative utterances and examining infelicitous promises.
    • Hennelly notes that female characters in Austen demonstrate greater mastery over promissory intersubjectivity than male characters.
    • Scholars such as E. M. Dadlez (20092009), Peter Knox-Shaw (20042004), Hina Nazar (20122012), Karen Valihora (20102010), David Kaufmann (19921992), and Deborah Weiss (20172017) position Austen within centrist Enlightenment philosophy, emphasizing her affinities with Hume and Smith in balancing individual autonomy with social obligation.

Intellectual Context and Philosophical Influences on Austen

  • Library Contexts and Family Influence:
    • George Austen, Rector of Steventon, possessed a library exceeding 500500 volumes spanning diverse literature.
    • Jane Austen read Thomas Percival's A Father's Instructions; Consisting of Moral Tales, Fables and Reflections (17681768), a gift from her brother Edward, which featured selections from Cicero, Shaftesbury, Hume, Smith, and Voltaire.
    • During her visits to her brother Edward's estate, Godmersham Park (totalling approximately 1010\,months between 17981798 and 18131813), Austen had access to a library containing:
      • William Paley's The Principles of Moral and Political Philosophy (2nd2\text{nd} edn, 17861786)
      • Edmund Burke's Reflections on the Revolution in France (8th8\text{th} edn, 17911791)
      • Samuel Pufendorf's Of the Law of Nature and Nations (17031703)
      • John Locke's Two Treatises of Government (5th5\text{th} edn, 17281728)
      • Robert Dodsley's The Preceptor (17481748), featuring Samuel Johnson's preface and story The Vision of Theodore
      • Thomas Hobbes's Leviathan (16511651)
      • Jean-Jacques Burlamaqui's The Principles of Natural Law (17481748)
      • David Hume's History of England (17621762) and Essays, Moral and Political (17421742)
    • Austen explicitly references Hume's History of England in Northanger Abbey and shows familiarity with Maria Edgeworth's Belinda (18011801) and Practical Education (17981798), which cite Adam Smith's Theory of Moral Sentiments.

Promissory Obligations Across the Austen Canon

  • Northanger Abbey (18171817):

    • Isabella Thorpe and John Thorpe repeatedly compel Catherine Morland to break commitments to Eleanor and Henry Tilney, and Isabella breaks her marriage engagement to James Morland.
    • Henry Tilney reflects critically on "the fidelity of promising," identifying a theoretical contradiction in the phrase given how easily individuals break their word.
  • Pride and Prejudice (18131813):

    • George Wickham reneges on his promise to take Lydia Bennet to Gretna Green, agreeing to marry her only after financial bribery from Fitzwilliam Darcy.
    • Lydia promptly violates her solemn pledge of secrecy regarding Darcy's presence at her wedding.
  • Mansfield Park (18141814):

    • Characters rehearse Elizabeth Inchbald's translation of August von Kotzebue's Lovers' Vows, a play centered on broken commitments.
    • Maria Bertram violates her marital vows by absconding with Henry Crawford.
  • Persuasion (18171817):

    • Anne Elliot breaches her original engagement to Captain Frederick Wentworth under persuasive pressure from Lady Russell.
    • Charles Musgrove denies making a promise to attend a family event, claiming he merely smirked, bowed, and said the word "happy."

Egoism, Property Entail, and Breach of Promise in Sense and Sensibility

  • Inequities of the Hereditary Entail:

    • Sense and Sensibility (18111811) opens by demonstrating the destructive consequences of patriarchal property entail at Norland Park.
    • The elder Dashwood alters his will to bequeath the entire estate to his nephew Henry Dashwood, and subsequently to Henry's son John Dashwood and John's 4-year-old4\text{-year-old} son.
    • This legal structure strips Henry Dashwood of power to provide for his second wife, Mrs Dashwood, and his three daughters (Elinor, Marianne, and Margaret), leaving them with only 1000proposal pounds1000 proposal\,\text{pounds} a-piece (3000 pounds3000\,\text{pounds} total).
  • John Dashwood's Moral Degradation and Rationalization:

    • On his deathbed, Henry Dashwood urges John Dashwood with urgency to assist his stepmother and stepsisters.
    • John Dashwood makes a broad, unwritten, and unwitnessed pledge to "do every thing in his power to make them comfortable."
    • Sequence of Promissory Breach:
      • Initial Intent: John meditates giving his sisters 1000 pounds1000\,\text{pounds} a-piece (3000 pounds3000\,\text{pounds} total), feeling generous due to his incoming income of 4000 pounds4000\,\text{pounds} a year.
      • First Reduction: Prompted by his selfish wife Fanny, who argues that 3000 pounds3000\,\text{pounds} would impoverish their son Harry, John reduces the sum to 500 pounds500\,\text{pounds} a-piece (1500 pounds1500\,\text{pounds} total).
      • Second Reduction: John lowers the pledge to an occasional gift of 50 pounds50\,\text{pounds} now and then.
      • Third Reduction: John rationalizes that his father had no intention of him giving actual money at all.
      • Final Outcome: John concludes his obligation will be strictly fulfilled by looking out for a comfortable small house, helping them move, and sending seasonal gifts of fish and game—tokens he ultimately fails to deliver.
  • Failure of the Impartial Spectator:

    • John initially views his generosity through Smith's "impartial spectator" framing ("It would be liberal and handsome!"), but quickly abandons objective distance.
    • Fanny shifts his focus away from the expectations of the promisees ("we are not to think of their expectations: the question is, what you can afford to do").
    • Because the dying father is deceased, the absence of enforcement enables John's breach, exposing the limits of Hume's reliance on reputation and Kames's belief in natural moral fidelity.

Implicit Promises and the Intersubjective Ethics of Willoughby and Marianne

  • Constructing an Implicit Engagement:

    • John Willoughby establishes intense intimacy with Marianne Dashwood over 2 weeks2\,\text{weeks} in Devonshire, sharing literature, music, and art.
    • Willoughby offers explicit gestures of engagement: presenting Marianne with a white mare, cutting off a lock of her hair, taking her alone in his curricle to Mrs Smith's estate at Allenham, and requesting a promise from Mrs Dashwood never to alter Barton Cottage.
    • Willoughby departs abruptly for London, claiming to Mrs Dashwood and Elinor: "I am unable to keep my engagement with you."
  • Philosophical Evaluation of Implicit Assurances:

    • In alignment with Hume, Smith, and Paley, obligation arises when a party knowingly and voluntarily excites reasonable expectations in another mind.
    • Marianne considers herself "as solemnly engaged to him, as if the strictest legal covenant had bound us to each other."
    • Elinor evaluates the empirical evidence and concurs that a tacit engagement existed between them.
  • Willoughby's Breach and Cold Rejection:

    • Willoughby abandons Marianne after his seduction and abandonment of Colonel Brandon's ward, Eliza, is exposed, causing Mrs Smith to threaten disinheritance.
    • To secure a fortune, Willoughby pursues Sophia Grey, who dictates a cold rejection letter that Willoughby sends to Marianne.
    • In the letter, Willoughby attempts to evade responsibility by framing his actions around his own intentions ("if I have been so unfortunate as to give rise to a belief of more than I felt, or meant to express…").
    • Elinor and Marianne judge that nothing can acquit Willoughby, placing moral weight on the raised expectations of the promisee rather than the promisor's subjective disclaimers.
  • Confession and Re-acknowledgment of Duty at Cleveland:

    • Upon learning of Marianne's life-threatening illness, Willoughby travels to Cleveland and secures an audience with Elinor, who is bound by her own promise to hear him.
    • Willoughby confesses his moral failure, admitting the absurdity of "scrupling to engage my faith where my honour was already bound."
    • Willoughby acknowledges the binding nature of the tacit expectations he created, though his reputation remains permanently tarnished.

The Conflation of Wish and Expectation in Social Relations

  • Epistemological Fallacy of Emotional Projection:

    • Mrs Dashwood and Marianne operate under an ethical flaw where subjective desire is substituted for objective evidence: "to wish was to hope, and to hope was to expect."
    • Mrs Dashwood prematurely assumes serious attachments and marriages for both Elinor with Edward Ferrars and Marianne with Willoughby based on initial friendly behavior.
    • Marianne continues to expect Willoughby's return long after his unresponsiveness and cold behavior at Lady Middleton's ball make such expectations unreasonable.
  • Social Amplification of Unfounded Expectations:

    • Intermeddling acquaintances such as Charlotte Palmer and Mrs Jennings spread unconfirmed reports of Marianne's engagement throughout London, generating self-perpetuating gossip that exacerbates Marianne's suffering.
  • Displacement of Moral Obligation:

    • John Dashwood attempts to ground promissory expectations in wishful thinking to relieve his own guilt.
    • In London, John asserts that Mrs Jennings's kindness to Elinor creates an expectation of a testamentary legacy, arguing that Mrs Jennings cannot act kindly without being aware of the expectation she raises.
    • Elinor corrects John by noting Mrs Jennings has two married daughters and no property to dispose of to strangers; John uses this false expectation to justify withholding his own financial aid.

Fortitude, Moral Duty, and Release in Edward Ferrars and Elinor Dashwood

  • Elinor's Rigorous Empirical Judgment:

    • Elinor Dashwood refrains from assuming contractual commitments without verified evidence, scrutinizing Edward's behavior and the hair ring he wears before drawing conclusions.
    • When Lucy Steele reveals her secret 4-year4\text{-year} engagement to Edward, Elinor accepts the complete body of evidence despite its contradiction with her personal wishes.
    • Elinor maintains strict fidelity to her pledge of secrecy given to Lucy, suffering severe emotional distress without breaking her word to her family.
  • Edward's Sacrificial Fidelity:

    • Edward Ferrars remains committed to his secret engagement to Lucy Steele despite losing his affection for her and falling in love with Elinor.
    • Unlike William Godwin's framework—which recommends breaking promises when circumstances alter utility—Edward chooses disinheritance and family banishment by Mrs Ferrars, Fanny, and John Dashwood rather than break his word.
    • Marianne recognizes Edward's moral integrity, identifying him as possessing a scrupulous conscience fearful of wounding expectation and incapable of selfishness.
  • Lucy Steele's Infidelity and Moral Resolution:

    • Lucy Steele's conduct is governed entirely by self-interest; upon Edward's disinheritance, she shifts her alliance and secretly marries his wealthy younger brother, Robert Ferrars.
    • Lucy's breach of faith frees Edward from an unwanted obligation, enabling his marriage to Elinor and providing both formal and moral closure.
    • While individual promise breaking is condemned throughout Sense and Sensibility, the dissolution of an unviable engagement through the secondary party's infidelity illustrates a pragmatic alignment where release from a pledge yields maximum human happiness.