Williams
Law Exam Analysis: The Othello Problem
Initial Office Encounter:
A first-year law student, K., comes to an office early on a Tuesday morning in tears after being labeled an "activist" by a school administrator.
The context involves a political environment during a presidential election year where the term "liberal" is treated as a synonym for "better dead," shifting the word "activist" to mean "troublemaker."
K. had expressed concern regarding a criminal-law examination problem based on Shakespeare's Othello.
Details of the Othello Law Exam:
The exam question presented an updated version of Shakespeare's Othello, describing Othello as a "black militaristic African leader" who marries "young white Desdemona" and subsequently kills her in a fit of "sexual rage."
The problem instructed law students to identify the elements of murder.
According to the model answer, points were awarded for a student's ability to "individualize the test" of provocation by recognizing that "a rough untutored Moor might understandably be deceived by the wiles of a more sophisticated European."
Institutional and Administrative Escalation:
K. first approached the criminal-law professor to object that the exam was racist; the professor denied the charge, asserting that Shakespeare, not he, created the underlying facts.
K. then met with a school administrator, who told her she should be less concerned about the package in which law comes and more concerned about learning the law, ultimately labeling her an activist.
K. expressed deep anxiety regarding the label, stating: "Just make sure he understands I'm not an activist… This could ruin my career."
Literary Theory and Legal Interpretation:
The opening paragraph of the exam explicitly informed students that reading the play Othello was unnecessary to understand the legal dynamic, thereby stripping away all complex dramatic motivations, ironies, and character development.
Insights from literary theory applied to law demonstrate a critical relation between reader and text, focusing on how a reader transforms meaning.
Objective, static meaning cannot simply be sliced from a literary work and served up on a law exam with its essentialism retained.
Accepting the defense that "Shakespeare made race part of the problem" blindly accepts the authority of Shakespeare as a universalized canon while ignoring that Shakespeare was an Elizabethan figure operating in a historically racist society.
The exam reduced complex human dilemmas to flat racial stereotypes, using generalizations (black, militaristic, unsophisticated, insecure, jealous, sexually enraged) that mirror historical justifications for subjugation.
The pedagogical frame forces black students to speak against themselves and accept racist constructions as truth to obtain high grades. Refusing to adopt a racist analytical framework results in point deductions under the model answer, a penalty often rationalized as an inability to "think like a lawyer."
Institutional Responses and Pedagogical Debates
Confrontation with Professor L.:
Professor L. defended the Othello exam problem as a good-faith attempt to respect minority and feminist efforts to incorporate issues of race, class, and gender into the core law curriculum.
The counterargument highlights that incorporating these themes without critical self-examination transforms empowering experiential narratives into cynical, gratuitous stereotyping and voyeurism.
Comparative Example: Lurid Wife-Battering Hypothetical:
Another professor at a different law school distributed a detailed, violent wife-battering problem: a man knocks out his wife's teeth, urinates on the floor, throws their baby into the urine, rips off her blouse, calls her a "castrating bitch," and arranges for a friend to rape her.
The top of the exam included a disclaimer stating that the problem reflected "the world" containing violence against women and noted that the legal system had shifted responses in light of organized feminist concerns.
This example illustrates the voyeuristic harm of inserting traumatic violence and identity markers without examining the pedagogical method or framing.
Professor L. rejected any comparison between his exam and the wife-battering problem.
Academic Freedom versus Pedagogical Responsibility:
Professor L. questioned whether the critique implied that race and gender issues should be censored from law school classrooms.
Framing race as either entirely irrelevant (the colorblind ideal) or deeply influential highlights a structural catch-22:
Colorblindness falsely assumes removing words like "black" and "white" eliminates division.
Real life requires using identity terms to name and resist the psychological and cultural power of racial constructions.
Relying on classical authority ("these are Shakespeare's facts, not mine") attempts to disclaim personal interpretive power and teaching responsibility.
Professor L. characterized the critique of his framing as "the very antithesis of academic freedom."
Survey of Law School Exams as a Genre of Power
National Pattern of Gratuitous Exam Problems:
A broader investigation of law exams from law schools across the United States revealed a systemic pattern of gratuitous race, gender, class, and sexuality references:
Tax Law: Calculating tax implications for Kunta Kinte's master after slavecatchers sever his foot.
Securities Regulation: A professor speculating whether white-collar defendants should go to prison, arguing that "unlike ghetto kids" they are unequipped for prison environments.
Constitutional Law: Providing the text of a hate-filled polemic titled "How To Be a Jew-Nigger" and requiring students to construct a First Amendment defense for it.
Criminal Law Descriptions: Characterizing a "typical criminal" as "a young black male with an I.Q. of who is one of eight children and has always lived on welfare and who spends his time hanging out in pool halls with his best friend Slick."
Racialized Crime Patterns: Exam sets featuring exclusively black, Hispanic, or Asian perpetrators and exclusively white victims.
AIDS and Sexuality: Prompts depicting gay men as the exclusive spreaders of AIDS while asking students to analyze elements of murder.
Gendered Violence: Pornographically detailed depictions of women being beaten, raped, and killed, standing in stark contrast to streamlined, non-detailed questions involving male victims.
Structural Critique: Faculty Memorandum on Exam Content
Analytical Framework of Law Exams:
Law school examinations function as a legal writing genre that exercises complex power, establishing boundaries of acceptable thought, formulating ideals, and conveying stereotypes.
Three Major Structural Faults Identified in Exams:
1. Misapplication of Irrelevance and Red Herrings:
While law students must master separating relevant facts from red herrings, these exams use race, ethnicity, class, and gender as pure gratuity with no connection to rule manipulation.
When an identity trait is relevant (e.g., a gay male prostitute tried for murder via AIDS transmission), exams explicitly order students to suppress it (e.g., "while we're all concerned about homophobia, don't consider it in answering this problem").
Messages delivered to students include: "M. is black, N. is a white racist, but you, you're colorblind" or "O. is battered wife, P. is her vicious spouse-battering husband, but you, you must not consider provocation if O. hits P."
Important social issues become unexamined background, teaching students that addressing stereotypes in law is irrelevant or taboo.
2. Forced Suppression of Personal Knowledge and Social Conscience:
Exams privilege the "impersonal" over the "personal" and the "objective" over the "subjective," forcing marginalized groups (blacks, battered women, gays, lesbians) to write against their personal knowledge.
Example: An exam scenario where a white woman premeditatedly lures a \text{-year-old} black would-be thief to her balcony and kills him out of racial hatred. The exam asks students to make the best argument for her full exculpation while ignoring general incapacity defenses.
This forces students to construct insidious rationalizations for racial hatred or suppress their social conscience for grades, devaluing humanistic insights as "merely experiential."
3. The Fallacy of Mirroring "Real Life":
Professors defend stereotypical hypotheticals by arguing that such events happen in the real world.
Open-ended reliance on "what happens" can justify any depraved scenario and ignores that law teachers actively construct "miniworlds" that define legitimacy.
Repeatedly featuring minority criminality while omitting white identifiers signals that white is the norm ("everyone") and non-whites are the "other."
Black students are forced to objectify themselves by taking the perspective of an exclusionary "everybody."
Personal History and the Psychology of the Outsider
The Fourth-Grade Valentine's Day Incident:
In the fourth grade, a young black girl was the only black child in her elementary classroom.
On Valentine's Day, while the teacher was briefly out of the room, all her white classmates tore up the valentines she had made and dumped them onto her desk.
The trauma silenced the child, causing her to stop participating and temporarily halt all academic performance.
Her mother encouraged her to respond by outperforming her peers, but the intrinsic joy of education was severely impaired for both her and her sister, who had helped make the valentines.
Psychological Outcomes of Outsider Status:
Being designated an