HCOM 235 Chapter 1: Introduction to Argumentation

Fundamental Nature and Definition of Argumentation

  • Core Definition of Argumentation:

    • Argumentation is defined as a form of instrumental communication that relies on reasoning and proof to influence belief or behavior through the use of spoken or written messages.

  • Reason-Giving as the Essence of Argument:

    • The primary essence of an argument is the act of reason-giving.

    • An arguer cannot simply make a standalone assertion; she or he must offer a supporting reason or proof.

  • Human Significance:

    • The ability to argue is essential to human existence.

    • It helps justify personal and collective decisions.

    • It serves as a primary driver for pushing change within society.

Cultural and Instrumental Dimensions of Argumentation

  • Cultural Variations in Argumentation:

    • Argumentation norms and practices differ across various cultural traditions, including:

      • Eurocentric traditions.

      • Indigenous traditions.

      • African traditions.

    • Cultural perspectives highlight distinct conceptual tensions, such as:

      • Common knowledge versus domination.

      • Capital "T" Truth versus lowercase "t" truth.

  • Instrumental Value vs. Terminal Value:

    • Arguing is usually a means to an end (possessing instrumental value) rather than being the end itself.

    • By contrast, other forms of human interaction possess terminal value, where the interaction or conversation itself is the ultimate goal.

Cognitive Processing of Argumentation: The Elaboration Likelihood Model (ELM)

  • Argumentation as Rational Influence:

    • Arguing is a form of influence or persuasion.

    • The emphasis in argumentation is placed on rational appeals rather than emotional appeals.

    • It prioritizes central processing over peripheral processing.

  • Involvement as the Key Variable:

    • The key variable determining how a message is processed is involvement.

    • Involvement is defined as the extent to which an individual is willing and able to think about the position advocated and its supporting materials.

  • Central Processing Route:

    • Mechanism: Actively thinking about ideas and processing available information through reflective, analytical decision-making.

    • Audience Prerequisites: High motivation and high ability to think about the message.

    • Processing Depth: Deep processing focused directly on the quality of the message arguments.

    • Persuasion Outcome: Results in lasting change that actively resists fading over time and resists counterattacks.

    • Practical Examples:

      • Reading product reviews before purchasing.

      • Looking up consumer ratings.

      • Seeking out objective, expert opinions.

  • Peripheral Processing Route:

    • Mechanism: Relying on mental shortcuts or "heuristic" cues for habitual, reflexive decision-making.

    • Audience Prerequisites: Low motivation or low ability to think about the message.

    • Processing Depth: Superficial processing focused on surface features, such as the communicator's attractiveness.

    • Persuasion Outcome: Results in temporary or weak persuasion outcomes that easily fade or succumb to counterarguments.

    • Practical Examples:

      • Relying on celebrity endorsements.

      • Giving in to brand loyalty.

      • Basing a decision on superficial "bells and whistles".

Core Characteristics and Dynamics of Argumentation

  • Focus on Disagreement and Controversy:

    • Arguing focuses inherently on disagreement and controversy.

    • People usually only engage in an argument if one of them is uncertain of the outcome.

    • If a conclusion is certain and inescapable, there is no need to argue.

  • Audience-Centered Nature:

    • Arguing is strictly audience-centered; arguments are fashioned with specific listeners in mind.

    • Effective arguments are geared directly to the receiver's frame of reference.

    • An argument that appeals to one audience may fail to appeal to another.

  • Uncertainty and Probabilistic Outcomes:

    • Arguing is always inherently "iffy" because there is no guarantee the other person or persons will agree.

    • In argumentation, success is usually a matter of degree.

    • There is always the possibility that the other person might convince us instead.

Rules and Conventions Governing Argumentation

  • Formal Rules:

    • Conventions for arguing are governed by both formal and informal rules depending on the context.

    • Legal Argumentation: Dictated by formal rules such as the admissibility of evidence and the exclusionary rule.

    • Social Science Argumentation: Evaluated through formal methodological standards, including the p<.05p < .05 level of significance, scale reliability, and replication.

    • Sports Arguments: Regulated by formal systems such as NFL challenges and instant replay rules.

  • Informal Rules:

    • Everyday argument is regulated by informal social conventions, including:

      • Turn-taking norms.

      • Managing interruptions.

      • General fairness.

      • Requirements for supporting evidence.

      • Prohibitions against ad hominem attacks.

      • The availability condition.

Philosophical Perspectives on Argumentation

  • Rhetorical Perspective:

    • Views arguments as inherently audience-centered.

    • Frames arguing as strategic action: arguments must be adapted to the listener's frame of reference.

    • Holds that standards for evaluating arguments are person-specific and situation-dependent.

  • Dialectical Perspective:

    • Views argument as a back-and-forth, give-and-take interactive process.

    • Considers arguments to be multilateral, evolving, changing, and developing over time.

    • Involves testing arguments in the "marketplace of ideas," operating under the assumption that the strongest arguments will prevail.

  • Logical Perspective:

    • Presumes that objective, universal standards exist for evaluating arguments.

    • Views arguments as unilateral, complete, and self-contained units.

    • Based upon formal logic and rigid standards for determining validity or invalidity.

Ethical Frameworks and Principles in Argumentation

  • Teleological Ethics (Consequentialism):

    • Focuses primarily on consequences and outcomes.

    • Holds that the outcome is what matters most, seeking the greatest good for the greatest number.

    • Applied Examples:

      • Lying is considered sometimes necessary and even desirable.

      • Abortion is viewed as justified under certain circumstances.

  • Deontological Ethics (Duty-Based):

    • Grounded strictly in moral absolutes.

    • Holds that principles do not change due to situations or changing circumstances.

    • Based on a priori moral standards.

    • Applied Examples:

      • Torture is considered morally wrong regardless of context.

      • Abortion is categorized as murder.

      • Eating meat is viewed as immoral.

  • Core Ethical Standards in Argumentation:

    • Clarity: Making arguments clear and concise while actively avoiding purposeful ambiguity.

    • Honesty: Being candid and refusing to rely on deceit, distortion, or misrepresentation.

    • Efficiency: Involving the audience and ensuring the form and content of the argument are effective.

    • Relevance: Adapting arguments specifically to the listener's frame of reference.

Practical Functions and Value of Argumentation

  • Decision-Making and Problem-Solving:

    • Arguing is a key ingredient in both individual and group decision-making and problem-solving processes.

  • Transparency of Positions:

    • Arguing gets issues out in the open, allowing participants to know where everyone stands.

  • Conflict Resolution:

    • Arguing serves as a peaceful, non-violent means of resolving conflicts.

Critical Questions and Ethical Considerations

  • Distinguishing Ethical Behavior:

    • A critical domain of study involves evaluating what constitutes ethical versus unethical behaviors in argumentation practices.