Contexts

Contexts of Moral Development

Learning Objectives

  • Analyze how various contexts influence adolescent moral development, including:

    • Family

    • School

    • Peers

    • Culture

    • Media

Moral Values

  • Reflection Prompt:

    • Think of a moral value you strongly hold (examples include honesty, loyalty, fairness, faith, social justice).

    • Consider where this value originated from.

Dimensions of Parenting

Parenting Characteristics

  • Demandingness: the degree to which parents set rules and expectations for their children.

  • Responsiveness: the degree to which parents are sensitive to their children’s needs and express warmth and love.

Parenting Styles According to Diana Baumrind (1960)

  • High Demand, High Responsiveness: Authoritative

  • High Demand, Low Responsiveness: Authoritarian

  • Low Demand, High Responsiveness: Permissive

  • Low Demand, Low Responsiveness: Disengaged

Parental Discipline Techniques

  • Love Withdrawal: A method where the parent withholds attention or love as a form of discipline.

  • Power Assertion: A method where the parent attempts to gain control over the adolescent or their resources through threats or removal of privileges.

  • Induction: A method where the parent uses reasoning and explains how the adolescent's actions affect others, fostering empathy for others.

Parenting Styles Characteristics

  • Authoritative:

    • Solves problems collaboratively with the child.

    • Sets clear rules and expectations.

    • Maintains open communication and allows natural consequences.

    • Generally warm and accepting.

  • Permissive:

    • Child-driven approach, rarely enforces rules.

    • May overindulge the child to avoid conflict.

  • Authoritarian:

    • Parent-driven, sets strict rules and punishments.

    • Characterized by one-way communication, with little regard to the child’s social-emotional needs.

    • Generally cold and unaccepting.

  • Neglectful:

    • Involves being uninvolved or absent.

    • Provides little nurturance or guidance.

    • Indifferent to the child’s social-emotional and behavioral needs.

Case Study: Ava

  • Scenario: Ava's parents frequently discuss ethical issues during dinner and explain the consequences of dishonesty, such as how trust functions.

  • Questions for Analysis:

    • What type of discipline is utilized in this scenario?

    • How does this method promote moral internalization?

    • How would an authoritarian response differ from the method applied?

    • What could be the long-term influences on Ava’s moral identity?

Schools: The Hidden Curriculum

  • Defines the moral atmosphere present in every school, involving:

    • Classroom norms

    • Discipline policies

    • Service learning initiatives

  • Critical Question: If a school has a culture that tolerates cheating, what is the impact on individual morality in aspects such as moral thinking, behavior, and feelings?

Peer Influence in Moral Development

  • Importance as a Socializing Context:

    • Adolescents spend substantial time with peers, increasing their exposure to shared norms and values.

    • Adolescents exhibit heightened sensitivity to peer feedback, which shapes what they consider important.

Mechanisms of Peer Influence

  • Selection: Adolescents often choose friends who already have similar values, creating a rewarding social environment.

  • Socialization: Peers gradually influence values over time through:

    • Shared experiences

    • Discussions

    • Observational learning

Social Media's Role

  • Question for Reflection: How does social media enhance peer selection and socialization compared to face-to-face interactions?

Culture and Media's Influence on Adolescents

  • Adolescents typically spend approximately 7-9 hours daily engaged with various media environments.

  • Media can impact:

    • Moral norms

    • Moral emotions

    • Moral identity

    • Perceptions of justice

    • Propensity for prosocial behavior and aggression

Moral Amplification and Disengagement

  • Moral Amplification: The process through which moral issues gain more intensity and visibility.

  • Moral Disengagement: The phenomenon where individuals convince themselves that ethical standards are not applicable in certain situations (e.g., through reframing or minimizing personal responsibility).

  • Social Media's Influence: Can amplify moral outrage through mechanisms like likes and shares, thereby facilitating easier disengagement from moral responsibilities.

  • Critical Inquiry: What makes moral disengagement more accessible within online environments?

Adolescent Moral Development

  • Characteristics: Adolescent moral development is recognized as dynamic, contextual, emotional, cognitive, and social.