Contexts
Contexts of Moral Development
Learning Objectives
Analyze how various contexts influence adolescent moral development, including:
Family
School
Peers
Culture
Media
Moral Values
Reflection Prompt:
Think of a moral value you strongly hold (examples include honesty, loyalty, fairness, faith, social justice).
Consider where this value originated from.
Dimensions of Parenting
Parenting Characteristics
Demandingness: the degree to which parents set rules and expectations for their children.
Responsiveness: the degree to which parents are sensitive to their children’s needs and express warmth and love.
Parenting Styles According to Diana Baumrind (1960)
High Demand, High Responsiveness: Authoritative
High Demand, Low Responsiveness: Authoritarian
Low Demand, High Responsiveness: Permissive
Low Demand, Low Responsiveness: Disengaged
Parental Discipline Techniques
Love Withdrawal: A method where the parent withholds attention or love as a form of discipline.
Power Assertion: A method where the parent attempts to gain control over the adolescent or their resources through threats or removal of privileges.
Induction: A method where the parent uses reasoning and explains how the adolescent's actions affect others, fostering empathy for others.
Parenting Styles Characteristics
Authoritative:
Solves problems collaboratively with the child.
Sets clear rules and expectations.
Maintains open communication and allows natural consequences.
Generally warm and accepting.
Permissive:
Child-driven approach, rarely enforces rules.
May overindulge the child to avoid conflict.
Authoritarian:
Parent-driven, sets strict rules and punishments.
Characterized by one-way communication, with little regard to the child’s social-emotional needs.
Generally cold and unaccepting.
Neglectful:
Involves being uninvolved or absent.
Provides little nurturance or guidance.
Indifferent to the child’s social-emotional and behavioral needs.
Case Study: Ava
Scenario: Ava's parents frequently discuss ethical issues during dinner and explain the consequences of dishonesty, such as how trust functions.
Questions for Analysis:
What type of discipline is utilized in this scenario?
How does this method promote moral internalization?
How would an authoritarian response differ from the method applied?
What could be the long-term influences on Ava’s moral identity?
Schools: The Hidden Curriculum
Defines the moral atmosphere present in every school, involving:
Classroom norms
Discipline policies
Service learning initiatives
Critical Question: If a school has a culture that tolerates cheating, what is the impact on individual morality in aspects such as moral thinking, behavior, and feelings?
Peer Influence in Moral Development
Importance as a Socializing Context:
Adolescents spend substantial time with peers, increasing their exposure to shared norms and values.
Adolescents exhibit heightened sensitivity to peer feedback, which shapes what they consider important.
Mechanisms of Peer Influence
Selection: Adolescents often choose friends who already have similar values, creating a rewarding social environment.
Socialization: Peers gradually influence values over time through:
Shared experiences
Discussions
Observational learning
Social Media's Role
Question for Reflection: How does social media enhance peer selection and socialization compared to face-to-face interactions?
Culture and Media's Influence on Adolescents
Adolescents typically spend approximately 7-9 hours daily engaged with various media environments.
Media can impact:
Moral norms
Moral emotions
Moral identity
Perceptions of justice
Propensity for prosocial behavior and aggression
Moral Amplification and Disengagement
Moral Amplification: The process through which moral issues gain more intensity and visibility.
Moral Disengagement: The phenomenon where individuals convince themselves that ethical standards are not applicable in certain situations (e.g., through reframing or minimizing personal responsibility).
Social Media's Influence: Can amplify moral outrage through mechanisms like likes and shares, thereby facilitating easier disengagement from moral responsibilities.
Critical Inquiry: What makes moral disengagement more accessible within online environments?
Adolescent Moral Development
Characteristics: Adolescent moral development is recognized as dynamic, contextual, emotional, cognitive, and social.