Comparative Advantage and Trade Notes

Comparative Advantage and Trade

Production Possibilities Frontier (PPF)

  • The Production Possibilities Frontier (PPF) is a graph that shows the combinations of two goods that an economy can possibly produce given the available resources and the available technology.
  • Example with Butter and Guns:
    • If all resources are used for butter, the economy can produce 100 units of butter and 0 guns.
    • If all resources are used for guns, the economy can produce 1000 units of guns and 0 butter.
    • Various combinations are possible (97 butter & 200 guns, 90 butter & 400 guns, 80 butter & 600 guns, 60 butter & 800 guns, 0 butter & 1000 guns), illustrating the trade-off.
  • Efficiency:
    • Points on the PPF are efficient; resources are fully utilized.
    • Points inside the PPF are inefficient; resources are not fully utilized.
    • Points outside the PPF are unattainable with current resources and technology.

Straight-Line PPF

  • A simplified PPF can be represented as a straight line, making analysis easier.
  • Example with Cars and TVs:
    • Country 1 can produce 800 cars and 0 TVs or 400 TVs and 0 cars.
    • Combinations include 600 cars & 10 TVs, 400 cars & 20 TVs, 200 cars & 30 TVs, 0 cars & 40 TVs.

Another Country’s PPF

  • Different countries have different PPFs based on their resources and technology.
  • Example with Country 2 (Cars and TVs):
    • Country 2 can produce combinations such as 0 cars & 400 TVs, 20 cars & 300 TVs, 40 cars & 200 TVs, 60 cars & 100 TVs, 80 cars & 0 TVs.
  • Opportunity Cost:
    • Opportunity cost of a car in Country 2: the number of TVs that must be forgone to produce one more car.
    • Opportunity cost of a TV in Country 2: the number of cars that must be forgone to produce one more TV.

Absolute Advantage vs. Comparative Advantage

  • Absolute Advantage: The ability to produce a good using fewer inputs than another producer.
  • Comparative Advantage: The ability to produce a good at a lower opportunity cost than another producer.

Advantage: Comparative

  • In the example:
    • Country 1: Opportunity cost of a car is 20 TVs; opportunity cost of a TV is 120\frac{1}{20} car.
    • Country 2: Opportunity cost of a car is 5 TVs; opportunity cost of a TV is 15\frac{1}{5} car.
  • Country 2 has a comparative advantage in cars (lower opportunity cost).
  • Country 1 has a comparative advantage in TVs (lower opportunity cost).

Specialization

  • Countries should specialize in producing goods for which they have a comparative advantage.
  • Country 2 should specialize in cars.
  • Country 1 should specialize in TVs.

Specialization (cont’d)

  • Country 1 completely specializes in TVs, producing 400 TVs and 0 cars.
  • Country 2 completely specializes in cars, producing 80 cars and 0 TVs.

Trade

  • Acceptable trading price: determined by the opportunity costs in each country such that both countries benefit from the trade
  • A trade occurs such that Country 1 trades some TVs for some cars from Country 2.
  • After the trade, each country consumes a combination of TVs and cars that is more than what they could have produced on their own.

Gains from Trade

  • The gains from trade are illustrated by consumption points outside the original PPFs of each country.
  • Example:
    • Country 1 specializes in TVs, producing 400 TVs and 0 cars.
    • Country 2 specializes in cars, producing 80 cars and 0 TVs.
    • Through trade, both countries can consume beyond their individual PPFs.

PPF Example – You Try!

  • Orange Country and Purple Country Example:
    • Orange Country PPF:
      • 0 million apps, 6 million chips
      • 4 million apps, 4 million chips
      • 8 million apps, 2 million chips
      • 12 million apps, 0 million chips
    • Purple Country PPF:
      • 0 million apps, 3 million chips
      • 3 million apps, 2 million chips
      • 6 million apps, 1 million chips
      • 9 million apps, 0 million chips
  • Tasks:
    • Determine absolute advantage.
    • Determine comparative advantage.
    • Determine how much each country produces if fully specialized.
    • Determine a feasible trading price.
    • Determine the quantity traded.
    • Determine the quantity consumed after trade.
    • Calculate the gains from trade.
  • Assumptions:
    • Same resources.
    • Complete specialization.