Lesson 4

Cortés in Mexico

We begin with Hernan Cortés, who arrived in the new world in 1504 at the young age of 19, seeking

adventure, and determined to make a name for himself. After reaching the new world, Cortés

began to hear reports of the wealth of the Aztec Empire, including gold, silver, and other valuable

resources. These reports fueled his desire to explore and conquer new territories. Ultimately,

Cortés would go on to play a pivotal role in the Spanish conquest of the Aztec Empire in Mexico

during the early 16th century.

His efforts there were greatly aided by a young Native woman named “Malinche” whom Cortés and

the other Spaniards called Marina. Malinche had been sold into slavery as a young girl, and soon

learned to speak several native languages in service to her captors. She was subsequently

presented as a slave to Cortés, and she served as a very capable interpreter for Cortés and his

men. Without her, Cortés’ expedition would not have been nearly so successful.

Cortés was further assisted by the fact that the newly created Aztec empire had many enemies. In

August 1519, Cortés and his men began their march inland to find Moctezuma. In many cases,

they were assisted by local tribes, but Cortés didn’t hesitate to attack the Natives when he thought

it in his best interest. Once he reached the Aztec capital in November, Cortés quickly took the

Mexican Emperor hostage. He later ignited a revolt by the citizens of Tenochtitlán, who killed

Moctezuma because they viewed him as a puppet of the Spanish and mounted a ferocious attack

on the Spaniards. In the spring of 1521, Cortés and tens of thousands of Indian allies mounted

campaign against the Aztec capital. By August they were victorious.

Cortés’ conquest of Mexico only whetted his and other Spaniards’ appetites for gold and glory.

From Tenochtitlan, Spanish conquerors or “Conquistadors” fanned out in search of other sources

of treasure.

The Conquistadors in North America

The most spectacular prize fell to Francisco Pizarro who conquered the Incan empire in Peru.

Pizarro and his small force captured the Inca emperor Atahualpa in 1532, held him for ransom, and

eventually executed him despite receiving a vast amount of gold and silver. The Spanish then

marched on the Inca capital of Cuzco, securing control over the region and marking the beginning

of Spanish dominance in South America.

Others were less fortunate. Juan Ponce de Léon sailed to Florida in 1521 in search of riches, but he

died from wounds suffered in a battle with the Calusa Indians in S. Florida. Lucas Vázquez de

Ayllón also attempted to explore the Atlantic coast of Florida. Ayllón established a small

settlement on the Georgia coast, the first Spanish attempt to establish a foothold in what is now

United States, but sickness and hostile Indians soon destroyed the settlement. Pánfilo de Narváez

2

surveyed the Gulf Coast from Florida to Texas in 1528, but the expedition ended in a shipwreck.

Finally, in 1539, Hernando de Soto landed in Florida and worked his way through much of

southeastern North America for three years, but he never found rich majestic civilizations, and he

died near the Mississippi River.

Despite many disappointments, Spanish adventurers continued their efforts to find gold and glory.

Francisco Vasquez de Coronado searched the southwest and Great Plains of North America in the

mid sixteenth century, hoping to find the rumored “Seven Cities of Cibola” that were supposed to

be fabulously wealthy, but the rumors amounted to nothing. Another explorer, Juan Rodríguez

Cabrillo, led another expedition in 1542 that sailed along the coast of California. Cabrillo would die

on Santa Catalina Island, and while his men journeyed on without him, they didn’t find much either.

After a half century of exploration, Spain had very little to show for its efforts. Significant silver

deposits were found in the 1540s in regions such as Potosí in present-day Bolivia and Zacatecas in

Mexico, leading to extensive mining operations that contributed greatly to Spain's wealth, but the

Spanish also concluded that while enormous territories stretched northward from Mexico, there

were no more majestic civilizations to conquer.

Settlements in Florida and New Mexico

Disappointed by the explorers' failure to discover riches in North America, the Spanish monarchy

ultimately decided to establish settlements in Florida and New Mexico to solidify the extensive

territorial claims Spain did make. Additionally, settlements in Florida would provide protection for

Spanish ships from pirates and privateers along the southeastern coast, who targeted the Spanish

treasure fleet laden with gold and silver bound for Spain.

In 1565, the Spanish king dispatched Pedro Menéndez de Avilés to establish Saint Augustine in

Florida, making it the first permanent European settlement within what would later become the

United States.

Later in 1598, Juan de Oñate founded an outpost in present-day New Mexico. When Oñate and his

expedition reached the pueblos near present-day Albuquerque and Santa Fe, he dispatched

scouting parties in search of the ocean, which he believed to be nearby. It was, of course, nowhere

close. Meanwhile, Oñate’s soldiers were ready to mutiny, and tensions with the indigenous Acoma

pueblo people were reaching a boiling point over well-founded fears that the Spanish intended to

take the lands and impose their religion.

In January 1599, following a dispute between the Acoma people and Spanish soldiers, violence

erupted in the Acoma Pueblo Revolt. The Acoma launched a coordinated attack on the Spanish

settlement, killing several soldiers and settlers.

Oñate brutally suppressed the uprising, resulting in the deaths of 800 men, women, and children.

While Oñate's response demonstrated Spain's military dominance, it failed to bring lasting peace.

After a second pueblo uprising in 1599, numerous Spaniards returned to Mexico, leaving the new

outposts as modest reminders of Spanish claims to the North American Southwest.

Despite its many setbacks, Spain remained the dominant European power in the western

hemisphere during the sixteenth century. In part, this was because the other European powers

3

focused on either trade with the East Indies or conflicts within Europe. Soon, it would manage to

establish a new and distinctive colonial society we call “New Spain.” Its success was based

largely on two things: the Encomienda, a system that linked governance and personal enrichment

for local Spanish rulers, and a racial stratification which ultimately imparted important powers and

benefits to those of European descent.

The Encomienda System

To institutionalize their conquests, the Spanish monarchy claimed ownership of the land in

Western Hemisphere, but they gave the conquistadors an incentive to do the “dirty work” by

claiming only one fifth (“the royal fifth”) of any confiscated goods. The terms for the Conquerors

were thus pretty good. Cortés, for example, made out quite well. But the distribution of wealth

beyond Cortés and his favorites dwindled out quickly. So, Cortés provided his soldiers with Indian

towns instead.

This basically institutionalized the system of encomienda, which empowered conquistadores to

rule the Indians and the lands in and around their towns. In theory, the encomendero (or, the

person who owned the town) was supposed to encourage the Indians to convert to Christianity, to

be responsible for their material well-being, and to guarantee peace and justice in the town. In

return, the Indians were to pay the encomendero the tribute that they previously had paid to the

Mexican Empire. In reality, however, the encomienda system was open to much abuse. While

missionaries labored earnestly to convert Indians, the encomendero subjected Indians to chronic

overwork and mistreatment.

The encomienda system engendered two groups of influential critics. 1) First, missionaries who

found that the cruel mistreatment of the Indians by the encomenderos made it difficult to convert

them to Christianity; and 2) second, royal officials who moved to replace encomenderos with Royal

bureaucrats. Based on their objections to the crown, in 1549, the Spanish monarchy imposed the

repartimiento, an important reform that limited the labor an encomendero could command from

the Indians. Notably, while the repartimiento was supposed to limit the forced labor of Natives, it

didn’t challenge the principle of forced labor itself, and mistreatment continued.

The worst conditions were likely those encountered in the Spanish silver mines, which--from the

viewpoint of Spain, were the single most important economic activity in new Spain. The mines

were incredibly profitable for Spain, but they were deadly for the Natives forced to work them.

Life in New Spain

For Spaniards, life in New Spain was relatively easy. During the 16th century, about 225,000

Spaniards settled in the colonies. Virtually all were poor young men who made up no more than

one or two percent of total population. The tiny number of Spaniards, the masses of Indians and

the frequency of intermarriage between Spanish men and Indian women soon resulted in a steep

social hierarchy defined by perceptions of social origin and race and established a precedent for

what would become pronounced pattern in the European colonies of the new world.

Natives of Spain were called peninsulares. They enjoyed the highest social status in New Spain.

Below them were the creoles, the children born in the New World to Spanish men and women.

Together, peninsulares and creoles made up barely 1 or 2% of the population. Below them were the

4

mestizos, the offspring of Spanish men and Indian women, who made up 4-5% of the population.

Some worked as artisans and labor overseers and lived well, especially if their skin was light.

Below them, was everyone else.

Spain's conquests had a devastating impact on Native peoples. By 1560, major centers of Indian

civilization had been conquered, their leaders ousted, their religion disrespected, and their people

coerced into servitude for the Spaniards. Additionally, the introduction of Old-World diseases

decimated the native population of New Spain, causing a rapid decline in the availability of Indian

labor, which was highly valued by the colonists. To address the labor shortage, colonists began

importing African slaves, although their numbers remained relatively low throughout the sixteenth

century.

European Developments

In Europe, the wealth of New Spain fueled Spain's Golden Age in the 16th century. After the deaths

of Queen Isabella and King Ferdinand, their 16-year-old grandson ascended to the throne as King

Charles I of Spain in 1516. Three years later, he became the Holy Roman Emperor Charles V, ruling

over the largest empire in Europe's history. Charles used his vast wealth to advance his interests in

Europe and promote orthodox Christianity, particularly in response to the Protestant Reformation.

The influence of the Spanish monarchy demonstrated that a New World empire could finance Old

World ambitions.

The Protestant Reformation will have some importance for our story as we make our way through

this class. It began in 1517 when Martin Luther, an obscure Catholic priest decided to go public

with his criticisms of the Catholic church. Luther's objections centered on his doctrine of

justification by faith, asserting that individual Christians could attain salvation solely through their

faith in God's saving grace, rather than through monetary offerings, church rituals, or the

intermediation of priests. Although Luther aimed to reform the Catholic Church, his ideas instead

led to a permanent fracture in the unity of Christianity in Western Europe.

Charles V of Spain and his successor, Philip II, both sought to eradicate Luther's Protestant heresy

and maintain the established order of sixteenth-century Europe. Spanish ambitions were fueled by

the wealth derived from the Americas, particularly Mexican silver. However, the constant need for

warfare exceeded Spanish revenues. To cover expenses, both kings raised taxes in Spain by over

five times during the 16th century. Since wealthy aristocrats were exempted from taxation, the

burden largely fell upon the peasants. This tax burden impoverished many and pushed the state to

the brink of collapse. Despite these challenges, most Spaniards viewed New Spain as a source of

national pride, celebrating their military, religious, and economic achievements despite the high

costs.

Spain's New World conquests served as a significant lesson for its European rivals, emphasizing

the potential to expand European wealth and influence through colonization. France and England,

in particular, sought to emulate Spain's example by sending explorers to search for a northwest

passage along the Atlantic coast of North America.

For instance, in 1524, France dispatched Giovanni da Verrazzano to explore the Atlantic coast of

North America from North Carolina to Canada, aiming to find a Northwest Passage to the East

5

Indies. Eleven years later, France had ventured farther north with Jacques Cartier's voyage up the

St. Lawrence River. Although Cartier returned to the region with settlers in 1541, the colony they

established ultimately failed.

England's efforts to establish North American settlements were slower and equally unsuccessful.

Nearly 80 years after John Cabot's voyages, in 1576, England attempted to find a Northwest

Passage with Martin Frobisher's voyages into the frigid waters of northern Canada. Like many

explorers inspired by Spain's example, Frobisher believed he had discovered gold, but the tons of

"ore" he brought back to England turned out to be worthless.

Similarly, English attempts to establish North American settlements, such as Sir Humphrey

Gilbert's endeavors in Newfoundland and Sir Walter Raleigh's efforts on Roanoke Island off the

coast of North Carolina, ended in failure. These experiences mirrored England's unsuccessful

quest for a northern route to China.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Spanish weaponry and the impact of Old-World diseases played crucial roles in

Spain’s conquests of the Aztec and Incan empires. Despite numerous attempts to replicate these

successes elsewhere, Spain ultimately built a vast empire centered on these two initial conquests.

The encomienda system and racial hierarchies introduced by the Spanish further solidified their

control over the continents.

In Europe, the wealth derived from New Spain fueled Spain's Golden Age in the 16th century and

financed its wars against the Protestant Reformation. Additionally, Spain's New World conquests

served as a significant lesson for its European rivals, highlighting the potential for expanding

European wealth and influence through colonization.