Exhaustive Study Guide: Entitlement Theory and Distributive Justice
Conceptual Framework of Entitlement Theory
The Minimal State Limit: The minimal state is the most extensive state that can be justified. Any state more extensive violates people's rights.
Non-Neutrality of "Distributive Justice":
The term "distributive justice" is inherently biased because it leads most people to presume that a central entity or mechanism uses a specific principle or criterion to dole out a supply of resources.
Such a frame implies that errors can creep into the distribution process, opening the question of whether redistribution is required to correct poor initial allocations.
Absence of Central Distribution:
Society is not equivalent to children receiving portions of pie cut by a parent who makes last-minute adjustments for careless cutting.
There is no central distribution, nor any single person or group entitled to control all resources or decide jointly how they are to be doled out.
Mechanisms of Resource Acquisition in a Free Society:
What each person receives, they receive from others who give to them in exchange for something or as a gift.
Diverse persons control different resources, and new holdings arise exclusively out of voluntary exchanges and actions.
The distribution of holdings is no more a central "distributing" than the distribution of romantic partners is a central "distributing of mates" in a society where persons freely choose whom to marry.
The total social result is the direct product of innumerable individual decisions that individuals are fully entitled to make.
Terminology Shift:
Neutral terminology replaces "distributive justice" with people's holdings.
A principle of justice in holdings describes what justice requires concerning holdings without presupposing a central distributor.
The Three Principles of Justice in Holdings
1. Principle of Justice in Acquisition:
Concerns the original acquisition of holdings, specifically the appropriation of unheld things.
Encompasses the processes by which unheld things come to be held, which things can be held, the extent of holdings acquired through specific processes, and the boundaries of initial holdings.
2. Principle of Justice in Transfer:
Concerns the transfer of holdings from one person to another.
Defines legitimate processes for acquiring a holding from someone else who holds it, such as voluntary exchange, gifts, and divestment (passing a holding back into an unheld state).
Excludes illegitimate transfer mechanisms such as fraud, theft, and forced labor.
3. Principle of Rectification of Injustice:
Addresses past violations of the principles of acquisition and transfer (e.g., theft, fraud, enslavement, seizure of product, forced exclusion from exchange).
Establishes what ought to be done to rectify past injustices, the obligations of wrongdoers to victims, the nature of compensation, and the treatment of descendants or secondary beneficiaries.
Inductive Definition of Justice in Holdings:
A person who acquires a holding in accordance with the principle of justice in acquisition is entitled to that holding.
A person who acquires a holding in accordance with the principle of justice in transfer, from someone else entitled to the holding, is entitled to the holding.
No one is entitled to a holding except by (repeated) applications of rules 1 and 2.
Complete Axiom of Distributive Justice:
A distribution is just if everyone is entitled to the holdings they possess under the distribution.
Whatever arises from a just situation by just steps is itself just.
Analogy to Logic (Justice-Preserving Transformations):
The principle of justice in transfer acts like a truth-preserving rule of inference in logic: repeated application of legitimate transfer steps to a just baseline preserves justice, just as repeated application of valid inference rules to true premises preserves truth.
Failure of the Analogy: In logic, if a conclusion could have been deduced from true premises, it is true. In entitlement theory, that a situation could have arisen via just steps does not prove its justice. Holdings depend strictly on actual history (e.g., a thief is not entitled to stolen goods simply because the victim could have voluntarily given them as a gift).
Subjunctive Counterfactuals in Rectification:
The principle of rectification utilizes historical information regarding past injustices and projects subjunctive counterfactual descriptions: what would have occurred (or a probability distribution using expected value) had the injustice not taken place.
If current actual holdings deviate from the description yielded by the principle of rectification, one of the descriptions yielded by rectification must be realized.
Where rectification yields multiple valid structural descriptions, considerations of equality or pattern may legitimately play a secondary role in choosing which specific description to realize.
Historical Principles versus End-Result Principles
Historical Principles:
Hold that whether a distribution is just depends entirely upon how it actually came about.
Past actions or circumstances of people create differential entitlements or differential deserts.
The entitlement theory of justice in holdings is strictly historical.
Current Time-Slice (End-Result / End-State) Principles:
Hold that the justice of a distribution is determined solely by how things are distributed (who has what) at a given moment, as judged by structural principles of just distribution.
All necessary information is contained within a distributional matrix representing the profile of current holdings.
Two structurally identical distributions are judged as equally just under an end-state theory, regardless of who occupies particular slots.
Structural Identity Example: A matrix where person has and person has is structurally identical to a matrix where person has and person has .
Welfare economics and utilitarianism represent classic current time-slice principles.
Flaws of End-State Principles:
They ignore relevant historical context such as criminal desert, penalties, and earning history.
Socialist Inconsistency: A traditional socialist who believes workers are entitled to the full fruits of their labor relies on historical entitlement (earning and producing). Such a socialist cannot accept an end-state principle that equates a distribution where capital owners take the fruits of labor with one where workers receive them, even if the structural profiles match.
Evaluating time sequences of current time-slice profiles (e.g., compensating past low shares with higher current shares) remains an unhistorical end-result approach that fails to capture real historical entitlements.
Patterned Principles of Distributive Justice
Definition of Patterning:
A principle of distribution is patterned if it specifies that a distribution is to vary along with some natural dimension, a weighted sum of natural dimensions, or a lexicographic ordering of natural dimensions.
Examples of Natural Dimensions: Moral merit, usefulness to society, need, I.Q., effort, or marginal product.
Maxims of Patterning: "To each according to his ."
Unpatterned Nature of Entitlement Principles:
The entitlement principles of acquisition and transfer are not patterned.
No single natural dimension or small combination of dimensions accounts for entitlement distributions.
Realized holdings in an entitlement system result from varied sources: marginal productivity, gambling winnings, spousal income sharing, foundation gifts, loan interest, fan donations, investment returns, self-made products, and luck.
Though pattern strands run through entitlement distributions (such as variance explained by market value), the overarching set of holdings is unpatterned.
Hayek's View on Market Distribution:
F. A. Hayek rejects imposing a deliberately chosen pattern (equality or inequality).
Hayek observes that a free capitalist society distributes according to value (perceived benefit of actions/services to others) rather than moral merit.
The patterned strand in capitalism is expressed as: "To each according to how much he benefits others who have the resources for benefiting those who benefit them."
This benefit strand is only one part of an entitlement system and does not encompass gifts, charity, or inheritances.
Intelligibility Without Patterns:
An entitlement distribution is completely intelligible even if unpatterned, because it is generated by a small set of legitimate principles (acquisition and transfer).
Transfers in a free system are not random or arbitrary; individuals transfer holdings to achieve specific personal aims, goals, and perceived gains.
Integration of Production and Distribution: Entitlement theory does not treat production and distribution as separate issues. Objects do not appear out of nowhere; they come into the world already attached to individuals who have entitlements over them.
Slogans of Entitlement:
Comprehensive Maxim: "From each according to what he chooses to do, to each according to what he makes for himself (perhaps with the contracted aid of others) and what others choose to do for him and choose to give him of what they've been given previously… and haven't yet expended or transferred."
Simplified Summary: "From each as they choose, to each as they are chosen."
The Instability of Patterns: How Liberty Upsets Patterns
The Argument Structure:
Assume an initial distribution is realized, conforming strictly to a favored non-entitlement patterned pattern (e.g., perfect equality).
Assume every individual is fully entitled to control the resources they hold under .
The Wilt Chamberlain Thought Experiment:
Wilt Chamberlain signs a one-year contract with a basketball team: for every home game, from the price of each admission ticket goes directly to him in a special box.
Over the course of the season, fans voluntarily attend home games, cheerfully dropping their into Chamberlain's box because they are excited to watch him play.
Chamberlain earns in additional income, resulting in a new distribution , where Chamberlain holds a far greater income than the average person.
Evaluating Justice in Distribution :
If was a just distribution, and individuals voluntarily transferred parts of their legitimate shares to Chamberlain, must also be just.
Third parties retain their full, legitimate shares; their holdings are entirely unchanged.
Third parties have no legitimate claim of distributive justice against Chamberlain's new holdings, because they had no claim over the fans' legitimate holdings prior to the voluntary transfer.
Spontaneous Capitalist Acts in Non-Capitalist Systems:
Overtime in Socialism: An individual in a socialist society whose needs are met might choose to work overtime, write private books, or lecture to acquire extra personal amenities (such as resources comparable to Widener Library in their back yard).
Private Production Example: A person melts down personal possessions held under , builds a machine, and offers weekly philosophy lectures to others in exchange for them cranking the handle on the machine. They trade the resulting products with third parties for additional goods.
To prevent such private sector developments, a socialist society must explicitly forbid capitalist acts between consenting adults.
The Principle of Continuous Interference:
No end-state principle or patterned distribution can be continuously realized without continuous state interference in people's lives.
To maintain a pattern, the state must either:
Continually interfere to stop people from transferring resources as they wish, or
Continually (or periodically) interfere to confiscate holdings that persons voluntarily transferred to others.
Sen's Paradox and Social Choice:
Amartya Sen's social choice results demonstrate that individual rights cannot be represented as choices within a social ordering; rights act as external co-possible constraints on social choice.
If individual rights allow holdings to be disposed of freely, social choice is constrained by those choices. Enforcing patterns overriding these choices requires continuous restriction of individual liberty.
Redistribution, Property Rights, and Self-Ownership
Asymmetry of Choice in Patterned Systems:
Patterned principles allow individuals to expend resources on themselves, but restrict them from expending resources on others if doing so alters the favored distributional profile
Impact on Families: Patterned principles cannot accommodate family dynamics. Transfers of affection and gifts within a family upset distributional patterns. Patterned theories must either reduce families to single distributional units or prohibit expressions of familial care.
Recipient Justice versus Giver Rights:
Patterned theories are exclusively theories of recipient justice; they focus entirely on criteria for who should receive goods.
They completely ignore the rights of givers, transferrers, and producers, neglecting whether an owner has the right to choose that another hold resources in their place.
Taxation as Forced Labor:
Taxation of earnings from labor is morally on a par with forced labor.
Taking the earnings of \,hours of labor is equivalent to taking \,hours from the person and forcing them to work \,hours for another's purpose.
Inequity Between Leisure and Material Preferences: Taxation unfairly penalizes the individual who works extra hours to acquire material pleasures (such as a movie ticket) while leaving unburdened the individual who prefers non-material pleasures attainable without extra labor (such as viewing a sunset).
Shift from Self-Ownership to Partial Ownership of Persons:
Property rights over consist of the right to determine what shall be done with .
Patterned and end-state distributional principles grant every citizen an enforceable claim to a portion of the total social product created by others.
Granting persons enforceable claims over others' labor and products gives them partial decision-making power over those laborers.
End-state principles abandon the classical liberal principle of self-ownership in favor of instituting (partial) property rights in other people.
Moral Side Constraints:
Achieving a patterned distribution requires actions that directly violate moral side constraints against aggressive intervention and coercion.
The Problem of Emigration:
Compulsory schemes of social provision struggle logically with emigration.
If a nation forbids internal opting-out of welfare schemes but permits external emigration to avoid participation, it exhibits an inconsistency unless it relies on coercing fraternal sentiment or restricting basic movement.
Locke's Theory of Acquisition and the Lockean Proviso
Lockean Labor Mixing:
John Locke posits that property rights in an unowned object originate when a person mixes their labor with it.
Theoretical Difficulties with Labor Mixing:
Boundary Problem: It is unclear what specific area labor attaches to (e.g., clearing a plot on Mars vs. owning the entire planet; spraying pink enamel paint on driftwood vs. improving it).
Ownership Transfer Mechanism: It is unexplained why mixing owned labor with unowned matter gains the matter rather than simply losing the labor.
Tomato Juice Counterexample: Spilling a can of owned tomato juice into the ocean mixes owned molecules with unowned space; this results in losing the tomato juice, not owning the ocean.
Value Added: If entitlement stems from added value created by unpleasant labor, ownership should logically extend only to the added value, not the entire object. No coherent value-added property system exists.
The Lockean Proviso:
Locke conditions original acquisition on the requirement that there be "enough and as good left in common for others" (Section 27 of the Second Treatise).
The proviso ensures that the position of others is not worsened by the appropriation of unowned objects.
The "Zipper Argument" Against Acquisition:
If land becomes fully appropriated, person is left with no unowned land to acquire, worsening 's situation.
Therefore, the prior appropriator violated the proviso by leaving without enough, making 's acquisition invalid.
By induction, 's prior acquisition worsened 's situation, tracing all the way back to original appropriator , theoretically invalidating all permanent private property rights.
Stringent versus Weaker Proviso:
Stringent Requirement: Prohibits worsening another's position either by removing the opportunity to appropriate or by removing the ability to use freely.
Weaker Requirement: Prohibits worsening another's position only by removing the ability to freely use what they previously could. The zipper argument fails under the weaker proviso if non-appropriators can still freely use unowned goods or receive counterbalancing compensation.
Social Considerations Supporting Private Property:
Systemic private property satisfies the intent of the Lockean proviso by preventing overall baseline worsening through several mechanisms:
Increases social product by placing production factors with efficient users.
Encourages experimentation by decentralized resource holders.
Enables specialized risk-bearing.
Protects future generations by encouraging resource preservation for future markets.
Provides alternative employment options so unpopular workers need not convince a single central authority to hire them.
Application of the Lockean Proviso: Monopoly, Patents, and Scarcity
Mechanism of the Proviso:
Appropriation that worsens others' baseline usage rights is illegitimate unless the appropriator compensates those affected to ensure their net position is not worsened.
The proviso imposes a historical limitation on subsequent transfers: an owner cannot transfer holdings to create a complete monopoly over a life-sustaining resource.
Scarcity and Monopolies:
A person cannot appropriate or purchase the entire drinkable water supply in the world, nor charge arbitrary prices for a sole remaining water hole in a desert when all other water holes dry up due to natural catastrophe.
A castaway on a private island cannot be ordered off as a trespasser.
These limitations are not external, ad hoc overrides of property rights; they are internal limitations built directly into the entitlement theory of acquisition and transfer.
Medical Discoveries and Synthesis:
A medical researcher who synthesizes a new drug out of abundant chemicals and refuses to sell it except on specific terms does not violate the Lockean proviso.
The researcher does not deprive others of existing resources; without the discovery, others would not have possessed the drug anyway.
Patents and Independent Invention:
An inventor who patents a device does not deprive others of objects that would exist without the invention.
However, enforcing an absolute permanent patent would restrict independent co-inventors who later discover the same device from using their own creation.
Because proving independent discovery is difficult, standard time limits on patents serve as a practical approximation of how long it would have taken for independent discovery to occur in the absence of the original invention.
Market System Operation:
The free operation of an uncoerced market system will virtually never run afoul of the Lockean proviso.
Key Philosophical Connections, Footnotes, and Literature
F. A. Hayek (The Constitution of Liberty):
Rejects deliberately chosen distributional patterns.
Notes that capitalist systems distribute based on perceived value to others rather than moral desert.
Argues that free capitalist economies raise the absolute position of the least well-off over time better than alternative structures (satisfying the functional goal of the difference principle).
Irving Kristol ("When Virtue Loses All Her Loveliness"):
Speculates that the public will not tolerate systems distributing resources based on market value rather than moral merit.
John Henry MacKay (The Anarchists):
Highlights the conflict between individualist anarchism and communist anarchism regarding voluntary labor exchange and private land usage.
Noam Chomsky (Introduction to Daniel Guérin's Anarchism):
Asserts that consistent anarchists must oppose private ownership of production and endorse socialism.
Amartya Sen (Collective Choice and Social Welfare):
Demonstrates structural impossibilities in social choice theory when individual libertarian rights are treated as preferences inside social orderings.
Gregory Vlastos ("The Individual as an Object of Love in Plato"):
Analyzes how love attaches historically to unique individual persons rather than to non-historical bundles of characteristics.
Armen Alchian and Harold Demsetz ("Production, Information Costs and Economic Organization"):
Examines property rights structures, decision constraints, and firm formation.
Ronald Coase ("The Nature of the Firm"):
Analyzes why economic activity is organized into firms rather than individual micro-contracts.
Robert Paul Wolff ("A Refutation of Rawls' Theorem on Justice"):
Critiques baseline comparative metrics in contractarian theories.
Charles Fourier:
Argued that society owes a guaranteed minimum provision to citizens as compensation for depriving them of primitive natural rights (gathering, pasturing, hunting).
Hastings Rashdall ("The Philosophical Theory of Property"):
Presents the hypothetical scenario of a traveler appropriating the sole water hole in a desert ahead of others.
Ayn Rand ("Man's Rights" in The Virtue of Selfishness):
Derives property rights from a general right to life, which entitlement theory criticizes for failing to establish property boundaries prior to rights claims.
John Rawls (A Theory of Justice):
Difference Principle: Maximizes the position of the least well-off group.
Natural Lottery: Rawls views natural talents and abilities as arbitrary from a moral perspective and proposes treating natural assets as a collective social resource.
Lexical Priority: Orders liberty prior to economic distribution, which entitlement analysis finds inadequately justified given the stringency of the Difference Principle.
Micro vs. Macro Principles: Rawls argues that macro-level distributive principles apply to institutional structures even if they are inappropriate for micro-situations (such as family dynamics).
Isaiah Berlin ("Equality"):
Identifies the analytical assumption that equal distribution is self-justifying and requires no special reasons, whereas departures from equality require justification.