Study Notes on Trump, Trade and Tariffs
Trump, Trade and Tariffs
Guest Lecture on International Economics
DCU, 24 March 2026
Tony Foley, Emeritus Associate Professor of Economics, DCU
Objective
Overview
Examine the USA tariff policy.
Evaluate the rationale and economic impact of President Trump’s tariff policy from the perspective of the US economy.
Key Points
Significance: The topic is highly significant and currently relevant.
Constraints on Analysis: - Uncertainty regarding the level and range of US tariffs. - Time lags may lead to uncertainty about some impacts, including reshoring and production effects.
Aim: Provide a clear perspective on tariff impacts to the extent possible.
Tariff/Trade Policy Rationale
Evaluation of Policies
Raise questions regarding the justification for tariff/trade policies: - Are they considered, strategic, and justifiable? - Are they nonsensical, wrongheaded, illogical, or unjustified? - Policies may provoke disagreement and debate among stakeholders.
Examples of divergent views on trade agreements: - The Mercosur trade agreement was well considered but generated substantial disagreement among stakeholders. - The EU/UK Brexit exit deal was similarly contentious.
Notably, tariffs imposed by the US are not unprecedented; however, their recent substantial increases and the greater product scope are noteworthy.
International Trade Theory and Tariffs
Tariff Mechanisms
Definition: A tariff is a form of trade protectionism.
Country Dynamics
Large Country vs. Small Country Effects: - Large countries can influence prices (price maker). - Small countries take prices as given (price taker).
Tariff Types
Nominal Tariffs: The stated rate of duty on imported goods.
Effective Tariffs: The actual rate, accounting for other factors influencing the market.
Optimal Tariff: A tariff that maximizes a country's welfare while manipulating trade volumes.
Specific Tariff: A fixed fee imposed per unit of imported goods.
Ad Valorem Tariff: A percentage of the value of the imported goods.
Economic Models
Basic Evaluation Model: - Supply/Demand Model to assess impacts on producer surplus, consumer surplus, and government revenue.
Desirability of Free Trade: - Reference to the Ireland and Mercosur trade deal; trade liberalization has winners and losers. - Historical context: Agriculture and fisheries were adversely impacted when Ireland joined the EU/EC.
Reasons for Imposing a Tariff
Motivations for Tariffs
Punish and Persuade: - Utilize tariffs as financial penalties for unfair trade practices. - Control drug trafficking and manage migration.
Rebalance Trade: - Tariffs are perceived as tools to rectify perceived unfairness in previous trade concessions.
Government Revenue Collection: - A source of income for the government through import duties.
Reduce Trade Deficit: - Aim to lower the trade deficit with strategies to reduce imports and bolster domestic industries, especially in strategic sectors.
Promote Reshored FDI Projects: - Encourage bringing factories back to the USA.
Background to the US Economy and Trade
Trade Deficits and Surpluses
Goods and Services: US goods are in deficit, while services show a surplus. - President Trump often omits commentary on the services sector.
WTO Data 2024 Findings: - A deficit on specific balance of payments accounts could indicate economic weakness, but context matters.
Merchandise Trade Dynamics: - The US is the largest individual country concerning merchandise imports. - Analytical approach: Treat the EU as a single trade entity for simplification, ignoring intra-EU trade nuances.
Trade Data 2024
Import Distribution by Region: - US: 16.4% of global merchandise imports at €3359 billion. - EU: 12.8% at $2638 billion. - China: 12.6% at $2585 billion. - UK: 4.0% at $816 billion. - Japan: 3.6% at $718 billion.
Goods Classification: - Varieties include final goods, intermediate goods, capital goods, energy, raw materials, agricultural products, and manufactured items.
Detailed US Trade Deficits in Merchandise
Merchandise Trade Balances from WTO Data 2024
Merchandise Trade Deficits (in $ billion): - USA: - Exports: 2065 - Imports: 3359 - Deficit: 1294 (63% of exports value). - EU: - Exports: 2795 - Imports: 2638 - Surplus: 157 (6% of exports value). - China: - Exports: 3577 - Imports: 2585 - Surplus: 992 (28% of exports value). - Japan: - Exports: 707 - Imports: 743 - Deficit: 36 (5% of exports value).
Individual Countries Trade Deficits with the USA
Major Deficits (in $ billion):
Data from the US Census Bureau: - China: 202.1 - Mexico: 196.9 - Vietnam: 178.2 - Taiwan: 146.8 - Ireland: 114.2 (note: data inconsistencies). - Germany: 73.0, Thailand: 71.9, Japan: 63.9, India: 58.2, South Korea: 56.4, Canada: 46.4, Switzerland: 34.3, Malaysia: 30.8, Italy: 30.8, Indonesia: 23.7.
US Services Trade
Services Trade Surplus
Contrasting Services Trade: - While the US shows a deficit in goods, it maintains a surplus in services. - WTO 2024 Services Trade Data (in $ billion): - US Exports: 1122 - US Imports: 815 - Surplus: 307 (27% of exports value). - EU Exports: 1675, EU Imports: 1471, Surplus: 204 (12% of exports value).
Largest Services Importers (in $ billion): - EU: 1471 (22.5%), US: 815 (12.4%), China: 608 (9.3%), UK: 399 (6.1%), Singapore: 351 (5.4%), India: 268 (4.1%), Japan: 243 (3.7%), Switzerland: 214 (3.3%).
Rhetorical Reference: - Should the US view its services surplus as evidence of unfair trade practices in services?
Role of International Trade in the US Economy
Economic Impact
Components of US GDP (2024): - C: 67.9%, I: 18.2%, G: 17.1%, X: 10.9%, M: 14.2%. - Contrasts sharply with Ireland’s M and X as a percentage of GDP; Ireland's M is at 105%, X at 138%.
Central Question: - How can Ireland’s export ratio exceed its GDP?
Liberation Day - Tariffs Overview
Historical Context and Justification
Reciprocal Tariffs: - Examination of new US tariffs imposed on individual countries. - Overview of the tariff levels necessary to eliminate merchandise trade deficits.
Example Case: - Imports of goods from the EU in 2024 amounted to €605.8 billion, with a corresponding US deficit of €235.6 billion. - Claims that the US deficit stems entirely from unfair practices and lenient US policies.
Hypothetical Elimination of Trade Deficits
To address the US trade deficit with the EU:
- Proposed reductions would need to lower imports by €235.6 billion or approximately 39%. - Tariffs increase the price of imports, thereby reducing demand: Assuming a price elasticity of 2, a 20% tariff leads to a 40% reduction in quantity demanded potentially balancing the deficit.
Specific Tariff Rates
US Tariff Rates by Country
Proposed Rates (2025): - European Union: 20% - United Kingdom: 10% - China: 34% - Japan: 24% - Switzerland: 31% - Brazil: 10% - Australia: 10% - India: 26% - South Korea: 25% - Vietnam: 46%.
Analysis of US Tariff Policy
Critiques and Economic Arguments
Critique Points: - Simplistic reasoning, ignoring service deficits and other contributing factors. - Suggestion of EU intentions to undermine US economic interests is flawed. - The EU aims to enhance economic vitality as a counterweight to US influence through larger markets and competitive advantages through economies of scale.
Presidential Statements on Tariff Policy
Rationale for Increased Tariffs by Donald Trump
Presidential Declaration: - Trump identifies non-reciprocal trading practices and structural imbalances in the trading system as an extraordinary threat to US national security and economy.
Statistics from Presidential Actions: - Investigative actions initiated from January 20, 2025, directly examining factors causing trade deficits, including a national emergency declaration.
US Trade Deficits Severity
Observations on Trade Deficits
Consequences of Deficits: - Viewed as detrimental, contributing to the manufacturing sector's decline, dependency on foreign supply chains, and risks to national defense capacities.
Long-standing Trade Policy Principles: - US trade policy has historically been based on reciprocal engagement since 1934, yet has deteriorated over time leading to mounting trade deficits.
Assumptions of the Trading System
Flaws in Economic Theories
Post-War Trading System Paradigm: - Incorrect assumptions regarding tariff liberalization leading to balanced trade and increased consumption. - Insufficient reciprocation has resulted in substantial goods trade deficits.0
WTO's Tariff Binding Issues
Pricing Discrepancies Among Countries
Binding Agreement Issues: - WTO Members did not implement consistent low tariff levels or reciprocal duties. - The US has low MFN average tariff rates compared to trading partners like Brazil, China, and India, which report significantly higher rates.
Sector-Specific Tariff Rates: - Example disparities: The US imposes lower tariffs on products like vehicles compared to the EU and India, revealing an unbalanced trade dynamic.
Winners and Losers in Trade
Economic Disparity
Trade Winners: - Economic gains are not uniformly distributed; sectors like entertainment and technology thrive (e.g., New York, California).
Trade Losers: - Sectors such as steel and manufacturing in Rustbelt states (Indiana, Illinois, Michigan) face economic challenges.
Political Repercussions
Political Dynamics: - Disparities in economic impact contribute to political divides, with regions benefiting from globalization politically aligned with different parties.
Economic Impact of Tariffs
Political Influences
Political Persuasion: - Tariffs can be used as leverage for negotiation, indicating complexities beyond pure economic metrics.
Revenue Generation
Government Revenue Significance: - Increased tariff revenue has implications for the federal balance of payments. - Rising consumer prices and the effect of tariffs leads to a deeper analysis of production possibilities.
Tariff Revenue Details
Financial Aspects of Tariffs
Estimated Tariff Revenue (2025): - €264 billion projected, with a historical increase from €78.9 billion in 2024. - Context of US financial deficit at €1700 billion in 2025, indicating tariffs account for approximately 16% of the annual deficit.
Changes in Tariff Incidence
Domestic Costs Overview
Who Bears the Costs of Tariffs? - The burden largely falls on US domestic users, challenging initial assumptions from the US government regarding price transfer to exporters.
Analysis Findings: - An analysis indicates that 96% of tariff costs are absorbed by US consumers, not foreign exporters.
Research Data Insights: - Studies confirm a significant pass-through of tariffs to import prices, further isolating the economic impact within the US.
Overall Tariff Implications
Broader Economic Conclusions
Pass-Through Mechanisms: - Immediate and substantial pass-through of tariffs results in increased domestic prices over time.
Manufacturing Recovery Considerations: - Potential reshoring and increased domestic production are uncertain due to tariff volatility and existing logistical frameworks.
Conclusions and Future Outlook
Strategic Logic Behind Tariffs
Support for US Manufacturing: - Trump’s tariff policy reflects a strategic aim to bolster local manufacturing while addressing perceived unfair trade dynamics.
Regional Impacts: - The resultant trade policy highlights geographical disparities in the benefits and burdens of free trade.
Overall Dynamics of Trade: - Tariffs ultimately borne by US consumers and producers generate governmental revenues but only show limited short-term effects on domestic production.