Study Notes on Trump, Trade and Tariffs

Trump, Trade and Tariffs

Guest Lecture on International Economics

DCU, 24 March 2026

Tony Foley, Emeritus Associate Professor of Economics, DCU

Objective

Overview
  • Examine the USA tariff policy.

  • Evaluate the rationale and economic impact of President Trump’s tariff policy from the perspective of the US economy.

Key Points
  • Significance: The topic is highly significant and currently relevant.

  • Constraints on Analysis:   - Uncertainty regarding the level and range of US tariffs.   - Time lags may lead to uncertainty about some impacts, including reshoring and production effects.

  • Aim: Provide a clear perspective on tariff impacts to the extent possible.   

Tariff/Trade Policy Rationale

Evaluation of Policies
  • Raise questions regarding the justification for tariff/trade policies:   - Are they considered, strategic, and justifiable?   - Are they nonsensical, wrongheaded, illogical, or unjustified?   - Policies may provoke disagreement and debate among stakeholders.

  • Examples of divergent views on trade agreements:   - The Mercosur trade agreement was well considered but generated substantial disagreement among stakeholders.   - The EU/UK Brexit exit deal was similarly contentious.

  • Notably, tariffs imposed by the US are not unprecedented; however, their recent substantial increases and the greater product scope are noteworthy.

International Trade Theory and Tariffs

Tariff Mechanisms
  • Definition: A tariff is a form of trade protectionism.

Country Dynamics

  • Large Country vs. Small Country Effects:   - Large countries can influence prices (price maker).   - Small countries take prices as given (price taker).

Tariff Types

  • Nominal Tariffs: The stated rate of duty on imported goods.

  • Effective Tariffs: The actual rate, accounting for other factors influencing the market.

  • Optimal Tariff: A tariff that maximizes a country's welfare while manipulating trade volumes.

  • Specific Tariff: A fixed fee imposed per unit of imported goods.

  • Ad Valorem Tariff: A percentage of the value of the imported goods.

Economic Models
  • Basic Evaluation Model:   - Supply/Demand Model to assess impacts on producer surplus, consumer surplus, and government revenue.

  • Desirability of Free Trade:   - Reference to the Ireland and Mercosur trade deal; trade liberalization has winners and losers.   - Historical context: Agriculture and fisheries were adversely impacted when Ireland joined the EU/EC.

Reasons for Imposing a Tariff

Motivations for Tariffs
  • Punish and Persuade:   - Utilize tariffs as financial penalties for unfair trade practices.   - Control drug trafficking and manage migration.

  • Rebalance Trade:   - Tariffs are perceived as tools to rectify perceived unfairness in previous trade concessions.

  • Government Revenue Collection:   - A source of income for the government through import duties.

  • Reduce Trade Deficit:   - Aim to lower the trade deficit with strategies to reduce imports and bolster domestic industries, especially in strategic sectors.

  • Promote Reshored FDI Projects:   - Encourage bringing factories back to the USA.

Background to the US Economy and Trade

Trade Deficits and Surpluses
  • Goods and Services: US goods are in deficit, while services show a surplus.   - President Trump often omits commentary on the services sector.

  • WTO Data 2024 Findings:   - A deficit on specific balance of payments accounts could indicate economic weakness, but context matters.

  • Merchandise Trade Dynamics:   - The US is the largest individual country concerning merchandise imports.   - Analytical approach: Treat the EU as a single trade entity for simplification, ignoring intra-EU trade nuances.

Trade Data 2024
  • Import Distribution by Region:   - US: 16.4% of global merchandise imports at €3359 billion.   - EU: 12.8% at $2638 billion.   - China: 12.6% at $2585 billion.   - UK: 4.0% at $816 billion.   - Japan: 3.6% at $718 billion.

  • Goods Classification:   - Varieties include final goods, intermediate goods, capital goods, energy, raw materials, agricultural products, and manufactured items.

Detailed US Trade Deficits in Merchandise

Merchandise Trade Balances from WTO Data 2024
  • Merchandise Trade Deficits (in $ billion):   - USA:     - Exports: 2065     - Imports: 3359     - Deficit: 1294 (63% of exports value).   - EU:     - Exports: 2795     - Imports: 2638     - Surplus: 157 (6% of exports value).   - China:     - Exports: 3577     - Imports: 2585     - Surplus: 992 (28% of exports value).   - Japan:     - Exports: 707     - Imports: 743     - Deficit: 36 (5% of exports value).

Individual Countries Trade Deficits with the USA

Major Deficits (in $ billion):

  • Data from the US Census Bureau:   - China: 202.1   - Mexico: 196.9   - Vietnam: 178.2   - Taiwan: 146.8   - Ireland: 114.2 (note: data inconsistencies).   - Germany: 73.0, Thailand: 71.9, Japan: 63.9, India: 58.2, South Korea: 56.4, Canada: 46.4, Switzerland: 34.3, Malaysia: 30.8, Italy: 30.8, Indonesia: 23.7.

US Services Trade

Services Trade Surplus
  • Contrasting Services Trade:   - While the US shows a deficit in goods, it maintains a surplus in services.   - WTO 2024 Services Trade Data (in $ billion):     - US Exports: 1122     - US Imports: 815     - Surplus: 307 (27% of exports value).     - EU Exports: 1675, EU Imports: 1471, Surplus: 204 (12% of exports value).

  • Largest Services Importers (in $ billion):   - EU: 1471 (22.5%), US: 815 (12.4%), China: 608 (9.3%), UK: 399 (6.1%), Singapore: 351 (5.4%), India: 268 (4.1%), Japan: 243 (3.7%), Switzerland: 214 (3.3%).

  • Rhetorical Reference:   - Should the US view its services surplus as evidence of unfair trade practices in services?

Role of International Trade in the US Economy

Economic Impact
  • Components of US GDP (2024):   - C: 67.9%, I: 18.2%, G: 17.1%, X: 10.9%, M: 14.2%.   - Contrasts sharply with Ireland’s M and X as a percentage of GDP; Ireland's M is at 105%, X at 138%.

  • Central Question:   - How can Ireland’s export ratio exceed its GDP?

Liberation Day - Tariffs Overview

Historical Context and Justification
  • Reciprocal Tariffs:   - Examination of new US tariffs imposed on individual countries.   - Overview of the tariff levels necessary to eliminate merchandise trade deficits.

  • Example Case:   - Imports of goods from the EU in 2024 amounted to €605.8 billion, with a corresponding US deficit of €235.6 billion.   - Claims that the US deficit stems entirely from unfair practices and lenient US policies.

Hypothetical Elimination of Trade Deficits
  • To address the US trade deficit with the EU:
      - Proposed reductions would need to lower imports by €235.6 billion or approximately 39%.   - Tariffs increase the price of imports, thereby reducing demand: Assuming a price elasticity of 2, a 20% tariff leads to a 40% reduction in quantity demanded potentially balancing the deficit.

Specific Tariff Rates

US Tariff Rates by Country
  • Proposed Rates (2025):   - European Union: 20%   - United Kingdom: 10%   - China: 34%   - Japan: 24%   - Switzerland: 31%   - Brazil: 10%   - Australia: 10%   - India: 26%   - South Korea: 25%   - Vietnam: 46%.

Analysis of US Tariff Policy

Critiques and Economic Arguments
  • Critique Points:   - Simplistic reasoning, ignoring service deficits and other contributing factors.   - Suggestion of EU intentions to undermine US economic interests is flawed.   - The EU aims to enhance economic vitality as a counterweight to US influence through larger markets and competitive advantages through economies of scale.

Presidential Statements on Tariff Policy

Rationale for Increased Tariffs by Donald Trump
  • Presidential Declaration:   - Trump identifies non-reciprocal trading practices and structural imbalances in the trading system as an extraordinary threat to US national security and economy.

  • Statistics from Presidential Actions:   - Investigative actions initiated from January 20, 2025, directly examining factors causing trade deficits, including a national emergency declaration.

US Trade Deficits Severity

Observations on Trade Deficits
  • Consequences of Deficits:   - Viewed as detrimental, contributing to the manufacturing sector's decline, dependency on foreign supply chains, and risks to national defense capacities.

  • Long-standing Trade Policy Principles:   - US trade policy has historically been based on reciprocal engagement since 1934, yet has deteriorated over time leading to mounting trade deficits.

Assumptions of the Trading System

Flaws in Economic Theories
  • Post-War Trading System Paradigm:   - Incorrect assumptions regarding tariff liberalization leading to balanced trade and increased consumption.   - Insufficient reciprocation has resulted in substantial goods trade deficits.0

WTO's Tariff Binding Issues

Pricing Discrepancies Among Countries
  • Binding Agreement Issues:   - WTO Members did not implement consistent low tariff levels or reciprocal duties.   - The US has low MFN average tariff rates compared to trading partners like Brazil, China, and India, which report significantly higher rates.

  • Sector-Specific Tariff Rates:   - Example disparities: The US imposes lower tariffs on products like vehicles compared to the EU and India, revealing an unbalanced trade dynamic.

Winners and Losers in Trade

Economic Disparity
  • Trade Winners:   - Economic gains are not uniformly distributed; sectors like entertainment and technology thrive (e.g., New York, California).

  • Trade Losers:   - Sectors such as steel and manufacturing in Rustbelt states (Indiana, Illinois, Michigan) face economic challenges.   

Political Repercussions
  • Political Dynamics:   - Disparities in economic impact contribute to political divides, with regions benefiting from globalization politically aligned with different parties.

Economic Impact of Tariffs

Political Influences
  • Political Persuasion:   - Tariffs can be used as leverage for negotiation, indicating complexities beyond pure economic metrics.

Revenue Generation
  • Government Revenue Significance:   - Increased tariff revenue has implications for the federal balance of payments.   - Rising consumer prices and the effect of tariffs leads to a deeper analysis of production possibilities.

Tariff Revenue Details

Financial Aspects of Tariffs
  • Estimated Tariff Revenue (2025):   - €264 billion projected, with a historical increase from €78.9 billion in 2024.   - Context of US financial deficit at €1700 billion in 2025, indicating tariffs account for approximately 16% of the annual deficit.

Changes in Tariff Incidence

Domestic Costs Overview
  • Who Bears the Costs of Tariffs?   - The burden largely falls on US domestic users, challenging initial assumptions from the US government regarding price transfer to exporters.

  • Analysis Findings:   - An analysis indicates that 96% of tariff costs are absorbed by US consumers, not foreign exporters.

  • Research Data Insights:   - Studies confirm a significant pass-through of tariffs to import prices, further isolating the economic impact within the US.

Overall Tariff Implications

Broader Economic Conclusions
  • Pass-Through Mechanisms:   - Immediate and substantial pass-through of tariffs results in increased domestic prices over time.

  • Manufacturing Recovery Considerations:   - Potential reshoring and increased domestic production are uncertain due to tariff volatility and existing logistical frameworks.

Conclusions and Future Outlook

Strategic Logic Behind Tariffs
  • Support for US Manufacturing:   - Trump’s tariff policy reflects a strategic aim to bolster local manufacturing while addressing perceived unfair trade dynamics.

  • Regional Impacts:   - The resultant trade policy highlights geographical disparities in the benefits and burdens of free trade.

  • Overall Dynamics of Trade:   - Tariffs ultimately borne by US consumers and producers generate governmental revenues but only show limited short-term effects on domestic production.