Untitled

Analysis of Ulysses S. Grant's Presidency

Background on Grant's Political Inexperience

  • Ulysses S. Grant was described as a political novice during his presidency.

  • His cabinet selections faced criticism for being ill-considered and naive, as he did not consult anyone before appointing them.

  • This lack of consultation led to many unsuitable individuals being appointed.

Influence and Naivety

  • Grant was easily influenced by others and lacked a mindset to suspect ulterior motives.

  • Gifts given to him were seen as gestures of friendship, but they sometimes clouded his judgment, leading to poor decisions.

  • In the early months of his presidency, he befriended questionable figures, notably Jay Gould and James Fisk.

Jay Gould and the Gold Market Manipulation

  • Jay Gould, described as corrupt, was involved in unethical business practices, earning him the nickname "the Mephistopheles of Wall Street."

  • Gould and his associate James Fisk collaborated to manipulate the nation's gold market with the help of Abel Corbin (Grant's brother-in-law).

  • Their plan included creating a public frenzy for gold, raising its price, which would collapse if the US Treasury sold large amounts of gold.

  • Grant, seen in public holding gold, was mistakenly believed to support their scheme.

  • Tension peaked on September 24, 1869, known as Black Friday, leading to a market crash that devastated investors.

  • Criticism emerged around Grant's acceptance of gifts from Gould and Fisk, with political figures implying his incompetence.

Corruption and Scandals During Grant's Administration

  • A series of scandals marred Grant's presidency, including:

    • His secretary of war's wife accepting bribes from merchants.

    • Whiskey distillers bribing treasury agents to evade taxes involving 300 individuals, including Grant’s private secretary, Orville Babcock.

  • Grant previously stated, “Let no guilty man escape,” but later intervened on behalf of Babcock during a trial.

  • The perception of Grant shifted from a war hero to a target of corruption accusations.

Division Among Republicans and Rise of Liberal Republicans

  • Political corruption and the implications of Reconstruction divided the Republican Party into:

    • Liberals (or Conscience Republicans): Led by Senator Carl Schurz, sought government honesty and efficiency, promoting civil service reform.

    • Stalwarts: Favored the status quo and backing Grant.

  • The Liberal Republicans held a convention in 1872, nominating Horace Greeley, a figure known for his chaotic advocacy across various causes, even though he faced ridicule during the campaign.

The 1872 Election and Greeley’s Failure

  • Greeley ran against Grant, losing decisively, which contributed to his mental decline and eventual death shortly after the election.

  • The election was marred by controversy, including an incident where women, notably Susan B. Anthony, voted illegally, leading to her arrest and a trial that became a platform for women's suffrage.

Reconstruction and the Ku Klux Klan

  • Grant enacted measures to combat the KKK, an organization formed by Confederate veterans to terrorize freedmen and white Republicans.

  • The KKK engaged in horrific violence against African Americans, leading to congressional passage of force bills giving Grant extraordinary powers to act against them.

  • Grant used these powers, successfully prosecuting over 300 Klan leaders.

Economic and Political Discontent

  • By the mid-1870s, Northern discontent grew regarding the ongoing Reconstruction efforts, exacerbated by economic depression.

  • The Democrats regained control of the House of Representatives, reflecting public fatigue over Reconstruction and economic issues.

Decline of Reconstruction and Court Rulings

  • Significant Supreme Court cases, such as the Slaughterhouse Cases and U.S. v. Cruickshank, weakened federal protections for African Americans.

  • The courts ruled that states, rather than the federal government, were responsible for protecting citizens' rights.

Grant’s Declining Political Capital and End of Presidency

  • Amid scandals and declining popularity, Grant decided not to seek a third term in 1876.

  • The Republicans chose Rutherford B. Hayes, a relatively obscure candidate, to run against Democratic nominee Samuel J. Tilden, known for his role in prosecuting corrupt officials, including Boss Tweed.

Conclusion: Lasting Impact of Grant's Administration

  • Grant's presidency is often cited as a period of significant corruption, referred to as the "era of good stealings."

  • The discussion will continue into the Gilded Age—a period characterized by economic growth but steeped in corruption and inequality.