Socials third unit

DURHAM REPORT

The Need for the Durham Report:

  • Government model

    • Governors appointed by Britain

    • Small elite ruled (Family Compact and Chateau Clique)

  • Rebellions – need for change

Mission:

  • Lord Durham sent from Britain to

    • identify root causes of unrest

    • propose solutions

  • Travelled through Upper and Lower Canada interviewing diverse groups

    • did not include Indigenous peoples

Durham’s Assessment:

  • Existing government was outdated and unfair

  • Cultural divide between French and English Canadians

Durham’s Recommendations:

  • Upper and Lower Canada unite

    • simplify governance

  • Introduce responsible government

    • Empower locals, reduce dominance of appointed officials

  • Promote British culture and immigration

    • Assimilate French Canadians

Outcome:

  • Act of Union (1840)

ACT OF UNION

  • Created the Province of Canada

    • Upper Canada – Canada West

    • Lower Canada – Canada East

  • Equal representation in Legislative Assembly

    • Canada West – 42 seats with 400,000 people

    • Canada East – 42 seats with 600,000 people

  • English sole official language

  • Responsible government still not achieved

Impact and Significance:

  • Increased political tension between Canada East and West

  • Strengthened French Canadian unity

  • Helped lead to Confederation

ROBERT BALDWIN & LOUIS-HIPPOLYTE LAFONTAINE

Robert Baldwin

  • Canada West (Upper Canada/Ontario)

  • Leader of the Reform Movement

Louis-Hippolyte La Fontaine

  • Canada East (Lower Canada/Quebec)

  • Supporter of the Parti Patriote but did not support violence

The Beginning of a Responsible Government

  • LaFontaine lost his seat in Canada East

    • Many French Canadians saw him too willing to support English Canadians

    • Baldwin invited and supported him to run in Canada West

    • LaFontaine won

  • Baldwin lost his seat in Canada West

    • LaFontaine supported him to run in Canada East

    • Baldwin won

  • Reformers won the majority in the election

  • Governor General Lord Elgin asked LaFontaine to head government

  • LaFontaine accepted if Baldwin was joint leader

THE GREAT COALITION OF 1864 (TEST SUMMARY)

Brief Overview

  • Early 1860s: Province of Canada faced political deadlock and instability.

  • Political parties could not agree on solutions.

  • Great Coalition (1864) brought rival political groups together.

  • Helped pave the way for Confederation in 1867.

Political Instability in the Province of Canada

  • Act of Union joined Canada East and Canada West into one colony.

  • Both regions had the same number of seats despite different populations.

  • Immigration increased Canada West’s population.

  • By 1861, Canada West had over 250,000 more people than Canada East.

  • Canada West wanted representation by population (“Rep by Pop”).

  • Canada East feared losing political power and protection for French culture.

  • Political alliances became complicated, causing government deadlock.

Possible Solutions to the Problem

Representation by Population (Rep by Pop)

  • Seats based on population size.

  • Supported by George Brown.

  • Opposed by many French Canadians.

Dissolve the Union

  • Separate Canada East and Canada West into two colonies.

  • Some Reformers supported this.

  • Concerns about minority rights and U.S. influence.

Double Majority

  • Laws would need majority support in both Canada East and Canada West.

  • Protected regional interests.

  • Difficult to make decisions.

Federalism

  • Create separate provinces under one central government.

  • Supported by George Brown and George-Étienne Cartier.

  • Became the preferred solution.

Key Political Leaders

George Brown

  • Reform leader from Canada West.

  • Strong supporter of Rep by Pop.

  • Later supported federalism.

John A. Macdonald

  • Conservative leader from Canada West.

  • Wanted political stability.

  • Supported a larger union of British North American colonies.

George-Étienne Cartier

  • Leader from Canada East.

  • Protected French Canadian interests.

  • Supported federalism.

Other Reformers

  • Luther Holton and Antoine-Aimé Dorion.

  • Supported constitutional reform and eventually federalism.

FORMATION OF THE GREAT COALITION (1864)

Why the Coalition Formed

  • American Civil War (1861–1865) created fears of U.S. invasion.

  • Britain encouraged colonies to unite for defence.

  • Political deadlock needed a solution.

Formation of the Great Coalition

  • May 1864: George Brown created an All-Party Committee.

  • Politicians discussed possible solutions:

    • Rep by Pop

    • Dissolving the Union

    • Double Majority

    • Federalism

  • Most agreed federalism was the best option.

  • John A. Macdonald and George Brown formed an alliance despite political differences.

  • Agreed to work toward a federal system.

From Coalition to Confederation

  • September 1864: Charlottetown Conference held in Prince Edward Island.

  • Province of Canada joined discussions.

  • Focus shifted to uniting British North American colonies.

  • Delegates agreed in principle to create Confederation.

  • Details would be worked out later.

Why the Great Coalition Matters

  • Ended years of political deadlock.

  • Showed rival political groups could cooperate.

  • Led directly to Confederation in 1867.

  • United the Canadas with the Maritime colonies.

  • Demonstrated the importance of compromise and cooperation in building Canada.

Most Important Test Facts

  • Durham Report → Recommended union and responsible government.

  • Act of Union (1840) → Created Province of Canada.

  • Canada West = Upper Canada; Canada East = Lower Canada.

  • Equal representation caused political tensions.

  • Baldwin + LaFontaine worked together for responsible government.

  • Great Coalition formed in 1864 to solve political deadlock.

  • George Brown = Rep by Pop.

  • Federalism became the preferred solution.

  • Charlottetown Conference (1864) led toward Confederation.

  • Confederation happened in 1867.

PRE-CONFEDERATION

Colonies & Territories of British North America:

  • British Columbia

  • New Brunswick

  • Newfoundland

  • North-Western Territory (HBC)

  • Nova Scotia

  • Province of Canada (Canada East and West)

  • Prince Edward Island

  • Rupert’s Land (HBC)

  • Vancouver Island (merged with BC in 1866)

REASONS FOR CONFEDERATION

Economics

  • Corn Laws repealed

    • this allowed Canadian grain to enter Britain with minimal tariffs

  • US ended the Reciprocity Treaty with Britain which previously allowed trade with reduced taxes

  • Confederation meant colonies could trade amongst themselves freely

  • A central government could build an intercontinental railway for both trade and defense

Strong Central Government

  • End political deadlock

  • Would allow the federal system to concentrate on decisions that affect all regions, such as military and transportation

  • Provincial governments could focus on local matters, such as education and healthcare

Security

  • Western BNA (BC and Rupert’s Land) would be safe from annexation

    • US had the Manifest Destiny — a belief they had the right to take over all of North America

    • American Civil War had just ended, leaving a very strong army in the North

      • Britain had supported the South

  • Fenian Raids: Irish immigrants from the US invaded British North America to force the British government to release Ireland

    • Thomas D’Arcy McGee was assassinated — the first political assassination in Canada

Annexation: Forcible acquisition over one state’s territory by another territory, usually following military occupation.

CONFERENCES LEADING TO CONFEDERATION

Charlottetown Conference (September, 1864)

  • Originally a meeting of the Maritime colonies to discuss a union

    • (Newfoundland did not attend)

  • Delegates of the Province of Canada asked if they could attend

    • Shared their ideas of Confederation

  • Agreed to meet again

Quebec Conference (October, 1864)

  • Maritime colonies were looking towards a union with Canada, and no longer were considering a Maritime union.

  • Newfoundland attended, but did not participate in the conference

  • Produced the Quebec Resolutions — a blueprint for Confederation

  • NB, NS, and the Province of Canada joined

  • PEI and Newfoundland remained independent

  • Had to formally ask Britain for permission

London Conference (December 1866)

  • NB, NS, and the Province of Canada attended

  • British Parliament passed the BNA Act, creating the Dominion of Canada.

SELECT TERMS OF CANADIAN CONFEDERATION

• The federal government would consist of two houses: 

  • The lower house, or House of Commons - representation based on population size

  • The upper house, or Senate - regional representation

• The Province of Canada would be split into two provinces: 

  • Canada East would become Quebec, 

  • Canada West would become Ontario

• A railway would be built to link the Maritimes with the other provinces

• The federal government would be responsible for all dealings with the Indigenous peoples of Canada

• The federal government would take on the existing debts of the individual colonies

• The federal government would be responsible for all the major sources of revenue and would give funding to the provinces based on population size.

Immigration and the Building of Canada

Loyalists

  • 40,000 to 50,000 Loyalists settled in the Maritimes or Upper or Lower Canada

  • to avoid persecution, remain loyal

  • Lord Dorchester Proclamation 1789

    • gave 200 acres to the children of Loyalists once they come of age or married

Black Loyalists and Enslaved

  • Black Loyalists who fought for Britain in the American Revolution were promised freedom and land

  • Book of Negroes

    • book of black slaves that were granted freedom by joining British lines

    • they escaped to Nova Scotia after American Revolution

  • Imperial Statute of 1790

    • Allowed Loyalists moving to Canada to bring property, including slaves

  • Black people found many hardships, racism and discrimination once coming to Canada

Irish Immigrants

  • Potato Famine and British rule caused many Irish to leave

  • Travelled in “coffin ships”

    • many sick and died

  • Quarantined on Grosse Ile

  • also faced discrimination and hardships once in Canada

European Immigration

  • Western Migration - expanding westward after Confederation

  • Dominion Lands Act of 1872

    • granted land to head of families or 18

      • pay a fee

      • cultivate land

      • build house


      • stay on land for 3 years

    • Indigenous not considered

    • example of preferred immigrants, however non-British still discriminated

Chinese and Indian Immigration

  • Chinese workers build the railroad

    • dangerous, cheap labour, exploited

  • 1885 Chinese Head Tax

    • after railway built

    • started at $50 tax to enter Canada; grew to $500

  • Continuous Journey Regulation, 1908

    • all immigrants to Canada had to come direct (non-stop)

    • restricted immigration from India and Japan


    • RED RIVER SETTLEMENT

  • Present-day southern Manitoba

  • Several cultures, but a very strong Metis community

  • HBCo sold Rupert’s Land; the Red River Settlement lay in the tracks of the railroad and new settlements

Video: Louis Riel by Metis Nation of BC

Louis Riel

  • Metis leader in Red River Settlement

  • Metis drove out government surveyors and occupied Fort Garry (present-day Winnipeg)

  • Established a provisional government

Metis Bill of Rights:

  • Elected legislature

  • French and English language rights

  • Representation in federal government

  • English Protestant settlers tried to overthrow Riel and his government

    • Thomas Scott was arrested, tried, and executed under Riel’s leadership

  • Outrage in Ontario (English)

  • Parliament passed the Manitoba Act, 1870

    • land rights to Metis (by application)

    • English and French language rights

    • Manitoba a province (elected government)

  • Government sent troops to Manitoba to settle the area

  • Riel fled to the USA

  • Riel returned to fight for Metis land rights

  • Metis not being granted land as promised

  • Riel was arrested, tried and executed

  • Legacy as a martyr for Metis rights

THE INDIAN ACT OF 1876

Video: The Indian Act: A Summary

Series of laws to define “Status Indian” and their rights

  • Could be stripped of status (eg. marriage, university educated)

Some of these “rights” included:

  • Federal government controlled “the reserves, lands, moneys, and property” of First Nations

  • Created the residential school system

  • Began the process of language destruction by imposing European names

  • Created and imposed band council systems – external forms of government

  • Banned cultural practices such as potlaches and powwows

How did the Indian Act put these rights into action:

  • Management of land – the Numbered Treaties

Video: CBC Kids and Numbered Treaties

  • 1870’s–1921 Canadian government negotiated 11 treaties to obtain more land for settlers and extract resources

  • Negotiations needed translators and Indigenous understanding of oral agreement; what was recorded in English, and what was practiced were not the same.

Residential Schools

  • 1884 under Canadian laws, Indigenous children were required by law to attend school

  • Run by Anglican, Catholic, Presbyterian, and United Churches

  • Forced to move away from families, speak only English or French and forbidden to practice their own culture and spiritual traditions

  • Approximately 150,000 children were forced to attend

  • Difficult to visit children – some required government-issued passes to leave the reserve.

  • most schools taught skills but not academics 

  • some stripped of names and replaced with numbers 

  • abused, malnourished, isolated 

  • estimated 6000 (national centre for for truth and reconciliation) children died in residential schools from abuse, illness, suicide, or runnin away