New Deal

Essay Assignment Overview

  • Task: Select one propaganda poster and one advertisement to write essays on.

  • Essays: 500 words for each image, totaling 1000 words; can be one document or two.

  • Submission: Submit via Canvas by Friday midnight.

Image Selection

  • Choose one image from each category:   - Propaganda Poster
      - Advertisement

Essay Objectives

  • Understand the arguments presented in the selected images.

  • Analyze the advertising or propaganda techniques employed.

  • Evaluate the effectiveness of the image's messaging.

Technical Instructions

  • Outline is not required, only the essays themselves.

  • Focus on clarity and detail in your explanations of the selected images.

The New Deal Overview

Introduction to the New Deal

  • A series of programs initiated by President Franklin D. Roosevelt to combat economic hardship during the Great Depression.

  • The emphasis was on relief, recovery, and reform.

First New Deal vs. Second New Deal

  • First New Deal:   - Focused on immediate relief and recovery efforts during the first 100 days.

  • Second New Deal:   - Launched in 1935, focused on long-term economic security and structural changes.   - Resulted from political gains by Democrats and public desire for economic equality.

Key Programs of the Second New Deal

  • Rural Electrification Agency (REA):   - Brought electric power to rural homes.

  • United States Housing Act (1937):   - First national effort to build affordable housing for the poor.

  • Works Progress Administration (WPA):   - Created jobs for white-collar professionals and blue-collar laborers, focusing on public works.

  • National Youth Administration (1935):   - Provided job training and employment for youth.   

Labor Reforms

  • National Labor Relations Act (Wagner Act, 1935):   - Known as the Labor Magna Carta; protected unions and workers' rights to organize.   - Outlawed unfair labor practices such as firing union organizers.

  • Fair Labor Standards Act (1938):   - Established minimum wage (initially 40¢ per hour), banned child labor, and mandated overtime pay.

  • Labor Movement:   - Growth of unions like the Congress of Industrial Organizations (CIO);   - Notable events include the 1937 sit-down strike at General Motors in Flint, Michigan.

Social Security Act (1935)

  • Established the first entitlement program in the U.S.

  • Provided pensions, unemployment insurance, and aid to the elderly and disabled.

  • Funded through a Revenue Act that increased taxes on the wealthy.

  • Marked a shift towards government responsibility for citizens' welfare.

Introduction of the Welfare State

  • Social Security contributed to the establishment of a welfare state in America.

  • Shift from a temporary relief mindset to a permanent system of support.

Criticism of the New Deal

Herbert Hoover

  • Former President Hoover’s opposition based on the fear that the New Deal would undermine American democracy.

  • Emphasized the need to restore the economy by continuing traditional policies rather than government intervention.

Huey Long

  • Advocated for wealth redistribution through his “Share Our Wealth” program.

  • Proposed a minimum wealth threshold for every citizen (citing a specific figure) to combat poverty.

Franklin D. Roosevelt's Reelection Speech

  • Roosevelt argued for the continuation of the New Deal, emphasizing its successes and the need for perseverance.

Supreme Court Challenges

  • The Supreme Court struck down several key New Deal policies, citing constitutional issues.   - Example: Unconstitutionality of the National Recovery Act and Agricultural Adjustment Act.

  • Roosevelt’s failed court-packing plan aimed to influence the Court composition in his favor.

The Roosevelt Recession (1937-1938)

  • Economic downturn due to budget cuts and decreased spending after initial recovery efforts.

  • Unemployment rose significantly during this period, leading to a renewed focus on government spending.

Keynesian Economics

  • The Roosevelt administration's shift towards Keynesian economics highlighted deficit spending as a means to stimulate demand.

  • Government involvement became crucial for economic recovery.

The End of the New Deal

Transition to the Third New Deal

  • Focus shifted from long-term security issues to immediate consumption boosts.

  • Public spending became a key strategy against ongoing economic challenges.

Political Realignment and Legacy

  • Established an enduring belief in government responsibility for economic welfare.

  • Realigned political loyalties, particularly among African Americans and urban voters.

  • Introduced a framework for future government interventions in the economy.

Summary of Achievements and Failures

  • The New Deal alleviated immediate suffering but did not resolve the Great Depression or radically redistribute power.

  • It initiated changes in government policy and public perception about economic intervention.

  • Political cartoons from the era illustrate mixed public sentiment towards government expansion and New Deal effectiveness.

Conclusion

  • The New Deal represented both progress and limitation in American governmental efforts. It instilled hope but also faced significant challenges, which would define American political philosophy for decades to come.