New Deal
Essay Assignment Overview
Task: Select one propaganda poster and one advertisement to write essays on.
Essays: 500 words for each image, totaling 1000 words; can be one document or two.
Submission: Submit via Canvas by Friday midnight.
Image Selection
Choose one image from each category: - Propaganda Poster
- Advertisement
Essay Objectives
Understand the arguments presented in the selected images.
Analyze the advertising or propaganda techniques employed.
Evaluate the effectiveness of the image's messaging.
Technical Instructions
Outline is not required, only the essays themselves.
Focus on clarity and detail in your explanations of the selected images.
The New Deal Overview
Introduction to the New Deal
A series of programs initiated by President Franklin D. Roosevelt to combat economic hardship during the Great Depression.
The emphasis was on relief, recovery, and reform.
First New Deal vs. Second New Deal
First New Deal: - Focused on immediate relief and recovery efforts during the first 100 days.
Second New Deal: - Launched in 1935, focused on long-term economic security and structural changes. - Resulted from political gains by Democrats and public desire for economic equality.
Key Programs of the Second New Deal
Rural Electrification Agency (REA): - Brought electric power to rural homes.
United States Housing Act (1937): - First national effort to build affordable housing for the poor.
Works Progress Administration (WPA): - Created jobs for white-collar professionals and blue-collar laborers, focusing on public works.
National Youth Administration (1935): - Provided job training and employment for youth.
Labor Reforms
National Labor Relations Act (Wagner Act, 1935): - Known as the Labor Magna Carta; protected unions and workers' rights to organize. - Outlawed unfair labor practices such as firing union organizers.
Fair Labor Standards Act (1938): - Established minimum wage (initially 40¢ per hour), banned child labor, and mandated overtime pay.
Labor Movement: - Growth of unions like the Congress of Industrial Organizations (CIO); - Notable events include the 1937 sit-down strike at General Motors in Flint, Michigan.
Social Security Act (1935)
Established the first entitlement program in the U.S.
Provided pensions, unemployment insurance, and aid to the elderly and disabled.
Funded through a Revenue Act that increased taxes on the wealthy.
Marked a shift towards government responsibility for citizens' welfare.
Introduction of the Welfare State
Social Security contributed to the establishment of a welfare state in America.
Shift from a temporary relief mindset to a permanent system of support.
Criticism of the New Deal
Herbert Hoover
Former President Hoover’s opposition based on the fear that the New Deal would undermine American democracy.
Emphasized the need to restore the economy by continuing traditional policies rather than government intervention.
Huey Long
Advocated for wealth redistribution through his “Share Our Wealth” program.
Proposed a minimum wealth threshold for every citizen (citing a specific figure) to combat poverty.
Franklin D. Roosevelt's Reelection Speech
Roosevelt argued for the continuation of the New Deal, emphasizing its successes and the need for perseverance.
Supreme Court Challenges
The Supreme Court struck down several key New Deal policies, citing constitutional issues. - Example: Unconstitutionality of the National Recovery Act and Agricultural Adjustment Act.
Roosevelt’s failed court-packing plan aimed to influence the Court composition in his favor.
The Roosevelt Recession (1937-1938)
Economic downturn due to budget cuts and decreased spending after initial recovery efforts.
Unemployment rose significantly during this period, leading to a renewed focus on government spending.
Keynesian Economics
The Roosevelt administration's shift towards Keynesian economics highlighted deficit spending as a means to stimulate demand.
Government involvement became crucial for economic recovery.
The End of the New Deal
Transition to the Third New Deal
Focus shifted from long-term security issues to immediate consumption boosts.
Public spending became a key strategy against ongoing economic challenges.
Political Realignment and Legacy
Established an enduring belief in government responsibility for economic welfare.
Realigned political loyalties, particularly among African Americans and urban voters.
Introduced a framework for future government interventions in the economy.
Summary of Achievements and Failures
The New Deal alleviated immediate suffering but did not resolve the Great Depression or radically redistribute power.
It initiated changes in government policy and public perception about economic intervention.
Political cartoons from the era illustrate mixed public sentiment towards government expansion and New Deal effectiveness.
Conclusion
The New Deal represented both progress and limitation in American governmental efforts. It instilled hope but also faced significant challenges, which would define American political philosophy for decades to come.