SOCIETY, CULTURE, AND REFORM, 1820-1860

  • The antebellum period (before the Civil War, starting in 1861) marked a time of significant social reform movements in the United States.
  • Reformers during this time focused on various causes including:
      - Establishing free (tax-supported) public schools.
      - Improving treatment of the mentally ill.
      - Controlling or abolishing the sale of alcohol.
      - Winning equal rights for women.
      - Abolishing slavery.
  • The enthusiasm for reform stems from several historic sources:
      - The Puritan sense of mission.
      - Enlightenment beliefs in human goodness.
      - Politics of Jacksonian democracy.
      - Changing relationships among men and women, social classes, and ethnic groups.
  • Religious beliefs appeared to be the most significant source of reform enthusiasm.

Religion: The Second Great Awakening

  • The early decades of the 19th century experienced a wave of religious revivals in the United States.
  • These revivals were partly a backlash against Enlightenment rationalism, which prioritized human reason.
  • Calvinist teachings of original sin and predestination faced rejection as believers embraced more liberal doctrines (e.g., Unitarian Church).
  • Revivalism began among educated individuals, notably Reverend Timothy Dwight, president of Yale College.
  • Dwight's revivals inspired a generation of evangelical preachers focused on audience accessibility and the promise of salvation for all.

Revivalism in New York

  • Charles G. Finney, a Presbyterian minister, initiated a series of emotional revivals in upstate New York in 1823.
  • Finney's sermons emphasized emotional appeal over rational argument, urging people to publicly declare their faith.
  • His ideas of salvation through faith and hard work were particularly attractive to the rising middle class.
  • Due to such frequent revivals, Western New York earned the nickname "burned-over district."

Baptists and Methodists

  • Southern and western frontier revivalists included Baptist and Methodist circuit preachers like Peter Cartwright.
  • These preachers held dramatic outdoor revivals (camp meetings) that attracted large audiences.
  • By 1850, Baptists and Methodists became the largest Protestant denominations in the U.S.

Millennialism

  • Many people believed the world would soon end with the second coming of Jesus, leading to increased religious enthusiasm.
  • William Miller, a preacher, forecasted a specific date for Jesus's return (October 21, 1844) but was proven wrong.
  • The Millerites evolved into the Seventh-Day Adventist church despite the failed prediction.

Mormons

  • The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints, founded by Joseph Smith in 1830, linked American Indians with the lost tribes of Israel through the Book of Mormon.
  • Smith faced persecution, leading to migration with followers under Brigham Young to the Utah Territory where they established the New Zion.
  • Their social organization allowed them to thrive in the wilderness, although polygamy caused tension with the U.S. government.

The Impact of the Second Great Awakening

  • The Second Great Awakening led to social divisions between newer evangelical sects and older Protestant churches.
  • This religious fervor triggered various social reform movements primarily in northern states, enhancing the role of activist religious groups in reform efforts.

Culture: Ideas, the Arts, and Literature

  • Romanticism emerged in early 19th century Europe, characterized by a shift from Enlightenment values of order to intuition, individualism, and nature.
  • In America, transcendentalists, a group of New England thinkers, embodied these romantic ideals criticizing organized religion and materialism.

The Transcendentalists

  • Notable transcendentalists include:
      - Ralph Waldo Emerson: Advocated for self-reliance, cultural independence from European models, and was a strong critic of slavery.
      - Henry David Thoreau: Conducted a two-year experiment in simple living, later publishing "Walden" (1854) and promoting civil disobedience through works like "On Civil Disobedience."
      - Thoreau’s actions inspired future nonviolent movements led by figures like Gandhi and Martin Luther King Jr.
Brook Farm
  • Founded in 1841 by George Ripley, Brook Farm was a communal experiment aimed at uniting intellectual and manual labor.
  • Notable figures included Emerson and Margaret Fuller, but the experiment failed by 1849 due to financial difficulties.

Communal Experiments

  • The antebellum period was marked by a rise in communal experiments reflecting diverse reform ideas.
  • Examples include:
      - The Shakers: A religious community with about 6,000 members by the 1840s who prohibited marriage and sexual relations, leading to a decline by the mid-1900s.
      - The Amana Colonies: Comprised of Germans focusing on communal living, allowing marriage, and surviving into present times but no longer practicing communalism.
      - New Harmony: A failed secular community in Indiana founded by Robert Owen to address Industrial Revolution inequalities.
      - Oneida Community: Founded by John Humphrey Noyes, advocated for economic and social equality with a controversial system of cooperative marriage; it thrived economically by producing high-quality silverware.
      - Fourier Phalanxes: Communities based on Charles Fourier’s ideas on shared living; however, they quickly declined due to American individualism.

Arts and Literature

  • The Age of Jackson influenced artistic expression in painting, architecture, and literature through democratic and reform ideals.

Painting

  • Genre painting depicting everyday life became extensive, with notable artists, including:
      - George Caleb Bingham, focusing on ordinary citizens in various activities.
      - Thomas Cole and Frederick Church, part of the Hudson River School, capturing American landscapes' beauty and encouraging a romantic view of nature.

Architecture

  • Architects adapted classical Greek styles to reflect democratic values, with public buildings showcasing columned facades reminiscent of ancient temples.

Literature

  • As nationalism grew post-1812, American literature blossomed with authors focusing on domestic themes:
      - Washington Irving and James Fenimore Cooper highlighted American settings.
      - Nathaniel Hawthorne’s works like "The Scarlet Letter" critiqued societal norms.
      - Herman Melville’s "Moby-Dick" represented theological and cultural conflicts, exploring deeper themes within American society.

Reforming Society

  • Reform movements evolved, initially focusing on moral persuasion and later transitioning to political action with the establishment of new institutions.

Temperance

  • The temperance movement emerged as a response to high alcohol consumption rates (avg. 5 gallons of liquor per person in 1820), aiming to curb societal ills caused by drinking.
  • The American Temperance Society was founded in 1826 to promote total abstinence pledges.
  • The Washingtonians formed in 1840 advocating for alcoholism identified as a disease needing treatment.
  • Supported by workers and factory owners, Maine became the first state to prohibit liquor's manufacture and sale in 1851, with several states following.
  • The temperance movement would resurge in the late 1870s, culminating in the 18th Amendment in 1919.

Movement for Public Asylums

  • In the 1820s and 1830s, reformers highlighted the plight of criminals, mentally ill individuals, and paupers.
  • Proposals arose for state-supported institutions like prisons, mental hospitals, and poorhouses to provide humane treatment.
Mental Hospitals
  • Dorothea Dix, horrified by the treatment of the mentally ill, led a nationwide crusade in the 1840s resulting in numerous state legislatures improving mental health care.