Key Insights on Income Inequality and Health

Overview

  • A large body of literature examines the relationship between income inequality and health, indicating worse health outcomes in more unequal societies.

  • Recent studies reinforce the evidence of a causal link between income differences and various health issues, including violence.

Key Findings

  • Evidence supports that income inequality negatively affects population health and wellbeing, meeting various criteria for causality: temporality, biological plausibility, consistency, and lack of alternative explanations.

  • Most studies showing no association can be attributed to inappropriate measurement scales, subjective health measures, or short follow-up periods.

Historical Context

  • The hypothesis linking inequality to poor health has roots in criminology and sociology, with significant studies done over the last 40 years.

  • The notion has evolved to include not just physical health but also mental health and societal issues related to social status disparity.

Causality Criteria

  • Consistency: Approx. 300 studies support a link between income inequality and health outcomes, with variations in results stemming from geographic scale.

  • Temporality: Many studies establish that changes in income inequality precede changes in health.

  • Strength of Association: Higher correlations found in mental health and teenage birth rates compared to infant mortality.

  • Specificity: Outcomes with a clear social gradient tend to have links with income inequality.

  • Dose-Response Relationship: Evidence suggests that greater inequality consistently correlates with poorer health outcomes.

  • Cessation of Exposure: Evidence from studies on immigrants shows that moving to more equitable environments correlates with improved health.

Alternative Explanations

  • Prior studies suggesting ethnicity or individual income explains the income inequality-health association have been disproven by more recent analyses which confirm contextual effects of inequality.

  • The relationship holds even when accounting for factors like ethnic heterogeneity.

Implications

  • Reducing income inequality can lead to better population health outcomes, and significant health improvements could result from lowering the Gini coefficient.