First Year Seminar (Making a Summary)
Advice on Making a Focused Summary of an Article or Essay
A focused summary is a short encapsulation of the main ideas of the piece you read. It is not a list of what the author talked about–the points s/he made—or your views about what they wrote. The goal of a focused summary is to capture in your own words the author's project, plus enough details so that someone who hasn't read the article can get the gist.
So, most article summaries begin with a one or two sentence summation of the author's project and then you decide how much detail of the author's support for their focus you need to bring in—-usually 3-4 sentences in your own words that elaborate on the super-condensed encapsulation.
Note: what I mean by "project" is not just the main idea but also your sense of what the author was responding to---why they felt it was important to write the piece?--and WHO you think they had in mind as their audience?
So, here are some more details that can help you quickly size up an author’s “project”:
→ If the author is making an argument, you should be able to fit it into one of Aristotle's 5 categories of argument:
• evaluation: X is good or X is a good Y. (Articles that function as "critiques" belong to this category).
• cause/consequence (causality): X causes Y or X results from Y
• definition: X consists of A, B, C or X is a kind of Y that Q
• proposal: We shd do X b/c Y
• analogy: X is very like Y
If you see an evaluation argument, then say that and then also speculate from what you have read why the author felt the need to make that argument.
Of course, there’s more motives to writing than arguing a position on a question.
→Sometimes the author is:
• sharing some surprising new information/discovery or
• creating connections between ideas that the author believes hadn’t occurred to anyone before or
• analyzing/exploring something or
• diving deep into personal memories in an effort to understand something
• doing two or more of the above things
SO: a focused summary of an article or essay should try to capture the author’s main idea(s) but also your sense of what the purpose of the writing is—what their “project” is. Who do they want to reach? Why did they set out to write something?
MOST IMPORTANT: it is essential that your summary is YOURS, ALL in your OWN WORDS. Not AI. A focused summary is not something a robot can do because a robot cannot bring a focus to the work you are summarizing. A focus is kinda like an angle, a pov that is special to you because you are you and not someone else.