Civil Rights Study Notes

Civil Rights

Defining Civil Rights

  • Civil rights are guarantees of equal opportunity and protection established through obligations imposed on government to protect individuals.
  • Key Ideals:
    • Liberty
    • Equality
    • Justice
  • Civil rights encompass:
    • The right to vote
    • The right to attend desegregated schools
    • The right of individuals with disabilities to be free from discrimination
  • Focus of civil rights law:
    • Granting equal rights of citizenship to historically discriminated groups.

Civil Liberties vs. Civil Rights

  • Distinction between civil liberties and civil rights:
    • Civil Liberties:
    • Basic personal freedoms established in the Bill of Rights.
    • Civil Rights:
    • Evolved over time as different groups organized for new rights.
    • Often require an expansion of government power to enforce equality (e.g., desegregating schools).
    • Contrast: Civil liberties limit government action (e.g., protecting against unreasonable searches).

Key Civil Rights Amendments and Legislation

  1. Thirteenth Amendment - Abolished slavery (1865)
  2. Civil Rights Act of 1866 - First civil rights law; guaranteed citizenship to all persons born in the U.S. (1866)
  3. Fourteenth Amendment - Established equal protection of the laws (1868)
  4. Fifteenth Amendment - Granted the right to vote to men of all races (1870)
  5. Nineteenth Amendment - Granted women the right to vote (1920)
  6. Indian Citizenship Act - Guaranteed citizenship to Indigenous peoples (1924)
  7. Civil Rights Act of 1964 - Banned discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, and national origin (1964)
  8. Voting Rights Act - Prohibited voting discrimination (1965)
  9. Americans with Disabilities Act - Prohibited discrimination against individuals with disabilities (1990)

Achieving Civil Rights

  • Civil rights are primarily achieved through social movements.
  • Social Movements:
    • Sustained campaigns on behalf of disadvantaged populations for political or social goals.
  • Collective Action:
    • Group organizing and acting based on shared goals, increasing effectiveness.

Strategies Used by Social Movements

  • Inside Strategy:
    • Movement leaders work within the political system to pass legislation or win court cases.
  • Outside Strategy:
    • Movements organize to shift public opinion through protests and demonstrations.

Public Opinion and Social Movements

  • Raising Awareness:
    • Social movements aim to spotlight injustices, influencing voters and public opinion.
  • As movements gain support, they shift strategies between public demonstrations and lobbying Congress.

Social Movements and the President

  • Presidential action can be influenced by social movements.
  • Example: 1965, President Lyndon B. Johnson gave a speech supporting voting rights legislation, reinforcing connections to the civil rights movement's goals.

Social Movements and Congressional Legislation

  • Historically slow process to build a congressional majority for civil rights legislation.
  • Successful movements have involved drafting legislation and lobbying legislators.

The Role of the Supreme Court

  • Equal Protection Clause:
    • Part of the Fourteenth Amendment; ensures equal rights and protections under the law.
  • Supreme Court case examples:
    • Brown v. Board of Education (1954): declared racial segregation in education unconstitutional.
    • Limitations of court-centered strategies: Court decisions require enforcement and may encounter societal backlash.

Levels of Scrutiny under the Equal Protection Clause

  1. Rational Basis:
    • Lowest scrutiny level; burden of proof on the plaintiff.
    • Rarely successful for plaintiffs.
  2. Intermediate Scrutiny:
    • Higher burden on government.
    • Typically for gender and sexual orientation cases.
  3. Strict Scrutiny:
    • Highest scrutiny; government must prove law serves a compelling interest and is the least restrictive means.
    • Applied to cases involving race, national origin, and fundamental rights.

Historical Context of Civil Rights Movement

  • Coexistence of individual liberty with a history of slavery and racial discrimination in the U.S.
  • Long Civil Rights Movement:
    • Continuous struggles for citizenship and equality for African Americans since the founding of the U.S.

Slavery and the Abolitionist Movement

  • Enslaved individuals resisted through revolts and paths to freedom like the Underground Railroad.
  • The abolitionist movement emerged in the 1830s, gaining traction through public speeches and literature, notably led by figures like Frederick Douglass.

Landmark Court Case: Dred Scott v. Sanford

  • The Supreme Court ruled that enslaved persons and all Black people were not citizens of the U.S.
  • Scott was denied freedom despite being taken to free territories, intensifying debates over slavery and leading toward civil war.

The Civil War Amendments

  • Emancipation Proclamation (1863):
    • Freed enslaved people in Confederate states, but required military victory to enforce.
  • Post-war: Three crucial amendments were passed:
    1. Thirteenth Amendment: abolished slavery.
    2. Fourteenth Amendment: granted equal protection and due process.
    3. Fifteenth Amendment: enfranchised African American men.

Reconstruction Era

  • After the Civil War (1865-77), African Americans sought social, economic, and political freedom.
  • Federal enforcement through troops to uphold Reconstruction amendments and the Civil Rights Act of 1866, defining citizenship and ensuring equal protection.

Aftermath of Reconstruction

  • Ended in 1877 with the withdrawal of federal troops, leading to Jim Crow laws upholding racial segregation.
  • Plessy v. Ferguson (1896): sanctioned the “separate but equal” doctrine, legitimizing racial discrimination.

Organizing Against Racial Violence

  • Over 4,000 African Americans lynched from 1877-1950, with minimal convictions for perpetrators.
  • The formation of the NAACP in 1909 aimed to combat violence and advocate for civil rights through media, protests, and lobbying.

Education Equality and Legal Challenges

  • NAACP targeted segregated education through legal action, culminating in Brown v. Board of Education (1954), which overturned the basis of segregation in schools.

Civil Rights Movement's Increasing Activism

  • By the 1960s, large-scale nonviolent actions emerged, including the Montgomery Bus Boycott, Student Sit-Ins, March on Washington, and the Selma to Montgomery marches, emphasizing the push for voting rights.

Legislative Achievements

  • Civil Rights Act of 1964: outlawed segregation in public accommodations and employment discrimination.
  • Voting Rights Act of 1965: eliminated barriers to voting for African Americans, including literacy tests and discriminatory practices.

Continued Struggles and Emerging Movements

  • Ongoing civil rights challenges addressed through various movements, including women's rights, LGBTQ rights, and advocacy for disabled Americans.

Conclusion

  • The civil rights movement remains a critical ongoing struggle reflecting the need for equality across various demographics.
  • The importance of sustaining advocacy for all neglected rights within a multi-racial democracy is emphasized.