Civil rights are guarantees of equal opportunity and protection established through obligations imposed on government to protect individuals.
Key Ideals:
Liberty
Equality
Justice
Civil rights encompass:
The right to vote
The right to attend desegregated schools
The right of individuals with disabilities to be free from discrimination
Focus of civil rights law:
Granting equal rights of citizenship to historically discriminated groups.
Civil Liberties vs. Civil Rights
Distinction between civil liberties and civil rights:
Civil Liberties:
Basic personal freedoms established in the Bill of Rights.
Civil Rights:
Evolved over time as different groups organized for new rights.
Often require an expansion of government power to enforce equality (e.g., desegregating schools).
Contrast: Civil liberties limit government action (e.g., protecting against unreasonable searches).
Key Civil Rights Amendments and Legislation
Thirteenth Amendment - Abolished slavery (1865)
Civil Rights Act of 1866 - First civil rights law; guaranteed citizenship to all persons born in the U.S. (1866)
Fourteenth Amendment - Established equal protection of the laws (1868)
Fifteenth Amendment - Granted the right to vote to men of all races (1870)
Nineteenth Amendment - Granted women the right to vote (1920)
Indian Citizenship Act - Guaranteed citizenship to Indigenous peoples (1924)
Civil Rights Act of 1964 - Banned discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, and national origin (1964)
Voting Rights Act - Prohibited voting discrimination (1965)
Americans with Disabilities Act - Prohibited discrimination against individuals with disabilities (1990)
Achieving Civil Rights
Civil rights are primarily achieved through social movements.
Social Movements:
Sustained campaigns on behalf of disadvantaged populations for political or social goals.
Collective Action:
Group organizing and acting based on shared goals, increasing effectiveness.
Strategies Used by Social Movements
Inside Strategy:
Movement leaders work within the political system to pass legislation or win court cases.
Outside Strategy:
Movements organize to shift public opinion through protests and demonstrations.
Public Opinion and Social Movements
Raising Awareness:
Social movements aim to spotlight injustices, influencing voters and public opinion.
As movements gain support, they shift strategies between public demonstrations and lobbying Congress.
Social Movements and the President
Presidential action can be influenced by social movements.
Example: 1965, President Lyndon B. Johnson gave a speech supporting voting rights legislation, reinforcing connections to the civil rights movement's goals.
Social Movements and Congressional Legislation
Historically slow process to build a congressional majority for civil rights legislation.
Successful movements have involved drafting legislation and lobbying legislators.
The Role of the Supreme Court
Equal Protection Clause:
Part of the Fourteenth Amendment; ensures equal rights and protections under the law.
Supreme Court case examples:
Brown v. Board of Education (1954): declared racial segregation in education unconstitutional.
Limitations of court-centered strategies: Court decisions require enforcement and may encounter societal backlash.
Levels of Scrutiny under the Equal Protection Clause
Rational Basis:
Lowest scrutiny level; burden of proof on the plaintiff.
Rarely successful for plaintiffs.
Intermediate Scrutiny:
Higher burden on government.
Typically for gender and sexual orientation cases.
Strict Scrutiny:
Highest scrutiny; government must prove law serves a compelling interest and is the least restrictive means.
Applied to cases involving race, national origin, and fundamental rights.
Historical Context of Civil Rights Movement
Coexistence of individual liberty with a history of slavery and racial discrimination in the U.S.
Long Civil Rights Movement:
Continuous struggles for citizenship and equality for African Americans since the founding of the U.S.
Slavery and the Abolitionist Movement
Enslaved individuals resisted through revolts and paths to freedom like the Underground Railroad.
The abolitionist movement emerged in the 1830s, gaining traction through public speeches and literature, notably led by figures like Frederick Douglass.
Landmark Court Case: Dred Scott v. Sanford
The Supreme Court ruled that enslaved persons and all Black people were not citizens of the U.S.
Scott was denied freedom despite being taken to free territories, intensifying debates over slavery and leading toward civil war.
The Civil War Amendments
Emancipation Proclamation (1863):
Freed enslaved people in Confederate states, but required military victory to enforce.
Post-war: Three crucial amendments were passed:
Thirteenth Amendment: abolished slavery.
Fourteenth Amendment: granted equal protection and due process.
Fifteenth Amendment: enfranchised African American men.
Reconstruction Era
After the Civil War (1865-77), African Americans sought social, economic, and political freedom.
Federal enforcement through troops to uphold Reconstruction amendments and the Civil Rights Act of 1866, defining citizenship and ensuring equal protection.
Aftermath of Reconstruction
Ended in 1877 with the withdrawal of federal troops, leading to Jim Crow laws upholding racial segregation.
Plessy v. Ferguson (1896): sanctioned the “separate but equal” doctrine, legitimizing racial discrimination.
Organizing Against Racial Violence
Over 4,000 African Americans lynched from 1877-1950, with minimal convictions for perpetrators.
The formation of the NAACP in 1909 aimed to combat violence and advocate for civil rights through media, protests, and lobbying.
Education Equality and Legal Challenges
NAACP targeted segregated education through legal action, culminating in Brown v. Board of Education (1954), which overturned the basis of segregation in schools.
Civil Rights Movement's Increasing Activism
By the 1960s, large-scale nonviolent actions emerged, including the Montgomery Bus Boycott, Student Sit-Ins, March on Washington, and the Selma to Montgomery marches, emphasizing the push for voting rights.
Legislative Achievements
Civil Rights Act of 1964: outlawed segregation in public accommodations and employment discrimination.
Voting Rights Act of 1965: eliminated barriers to voting for African Americans, including literacy tests and discriminatory practices.
Continued Struggles and Emerging Movements
Ongoing civil rights challenges addressed through various movements, including women's rights, LGBTQ rights, and advocacy for disabled Americans.
Conclusion
The civil rights movement remains a critical ongoing struggle reflecting the need for equality across various demographics.
The importance of sustaining advocacy for all neglected rights within a multi-racial democracy is emphasized.