Chapter 5: Executing the offering, Research, and Reg M

Contracts and compensation

Underwriting Agreement: Also called the purchase agreement; between the issuer and the syndicate

Market out clause: lets the underwriter terminate if a material adverse event occurs

What the prospectus shows: Names of underwriters and the gross spread; NOT the spread breakdown and NOT the full UA.

AAU: Also called the syndicate contract, master underwriting agreement or purchase group agreement. May require good faith deposit from each member.

FINRA corporate financing rule: Governs underwriting terms of most public offerings, shelf offerings included

Items of value: Count as compensation; right of first refusal, exclusivity, pre-paid fees. FINRA looks back 180 days before filing.

Road Shows: Analysts cannot attend (stocks, preferred or debt). Keep internal memos out of sight; stick to facts

At the market offering: New shares sold directly into the market at the current price; good for issuers needing capital regularly.

Section 18: Exchange listed securities are exempt from state registration. States can still enforce antifraud laws.

Fixed price offering: Rule 5141: everyone pays the public offering price; only syndicate and selling group buy at a discount

Marketing timeline: Fully marketed (longest, most risk), one day marketed, overnight (least risk).


Conflicts and QIUs

QIU qualification: Took part in at least 3 public equity offerings in the last 3 years each at least 50% of the new deals anticipated proceeds

No QIU needed: If a conflicted firm is not the syndicate manager, or the securities already trade publicly.

Ownership conflict: A broker dealer earning more than 10% of the issuer has a conflict. (BD owns 25% of Little tech and underwrites its IPO); IPO needed. Use of proceeds: 5% to repay a loan.


FINRA Rule 5130 (IPO restrictions)

Restricted persons: Member firms and their employees, finders and fiduciaries (lawyers and accountants) of the lead underwriter and others

Broker dealer employees: Generally barred from buying common stock IPO, whether or not on the deal

Employee of the issuer: A restricted person who is an issuer employee can buy. Both is generally OK

Eligibility: Account owners must represent eligibility within the prior 12 months

Filing: Book runner riles with FINRA 3 business days after the offering date

Immediate family: Prohibited. Parents, in-laws, siblings, children, spouse. Not grandparents, nieces, nephews, aunts, unclu’s, cousins, ex spouses.

Family restricted when: They live in the employee’s home or receive material support from the employee.


Research Extras

Bankers and research: Bankers may give feedback or suggest coverage but cannot order research to be published

Inducements: No favorable rating or price targets in exchange for business.

Quiet periods: Managers and co managers; 10 calendar 10 days after IPO; 3 after a follow on

Analyst at a firm not in the IPO: Can appear publicly right after the IPO

Research report: Rule 139; an equity research report goes to 15 or moer recipients

Rule 137: Research by firms not underwriting or taking part in the distribution is not treated as an offer.

Disclosure: Banking business with the subject in the past 12 months, including PIPEs


Reg M (rule by rule)

101: Distribution participants cannot bid or buy the covered security during the restricted period

102: same idea for issuers and selling shareholders

103: Nasdaq passive market making: net purchases capped at the greater of 30% of the market maker’s average daily trading volume or 200 shares.; bids no higher than the highest independent bid; bids identified; FINRA noticed in advance.

104: Stabilization and penalty bids. Stabilizing bid is the greater of the last trade and the highest independent bid but never above the offering price. Principal market= largest volume in the prior 12 months. Intent must be in prospectus. SEC notified daily. Penalty bid allows the managing underwriter to reclaim the selling concession from a syndicate member when shares that member sold are subsequently repurchased in a syndicate covering transaction. Goldman manages IPO, MS a syndicate member sells 1000 IPO shares, MS earns selling concession, The customers quickly sell their shares (flipping), the underwriting syndicate buys those shares back while covering its short position. Goldman may reclaim the selling concession to discourage syndicate members from allocating IPO shares to investors who immediate flip them.

105: No buying in an offering after short selling in the restricted window unless the short was covered before the effective date. 0 days (actively traded) ADTV of at least 1 million and public float of at least 150mm; 1 business day: ADTV of at least 100k and public float of at least 25 million; 5 business days: securities that don’t meet the thresholds for the shorter periods. In a merger or exchange offer, the restricted period starts when proxies or offering materials go out. Convertible bonds: both the bond and the common stock are covered. Penalty bids: must be announced to syndicate members before the effective date and cannot be imposed after the fact. Rule 17a-2 sets recordkeeping for stabilizing and penalty bids. Instead of stabilizing, underwrites can oversell and cover the short in the market.


Settlement and DPPs:

Syndicate settlement: FINRA rule 11880: final settlement within 90 days of the syndicate settlement date. Manager tells FINRA operations of a closing delay.

DPPS and unlisted reits: Rule 2310. Organization and offering expenses capped at 15% of gross proceeds; underwriting compensation capped at 10%.

Due diligence expense: Counts under the 15% cap but not the 10%

Payments to a registered person: Always underwriting compensation even if that person works for the issuer.