Cold War Expansion and Americanism

The Cold War's Complexity

  • The Cold War expanded and shifted over time, lacking a clear internal logic and driven by paranoia and anxieties rooted in the 1930s.
  • It involved repackaged old and new American politics and defied simple logic, necessitating a careful examination of its developments.

Postwar Americanism: Three Key Concepts

  • Unity and Collaboration:
    • A belief in a unified American identity despite political disagreements.
    • Trust in the state as a representation of the people's unity.
    • Cultural unity symbolized by shared American culture (film, music, literature).
    • Rejection of Victorian-era divides based on class, race, and fear of contamination.
    • Example: Sinatra representing the best of all Americans, bridging vaudeville traditions with high culture.
  • Racial Inclusion:
    • Necessity of racial diversity and integration due to the logic of the GI Bill.
    • Makes no sense to have segregated armed forces.
    • Makes no sense to have segregated baseballs.
    • Makes no sense to have segregated spaces.
    • Veterans should have access to education and homes regardless of race.
  • Gender Roles:
    • Less emphasis on gender inclusivity compared to racial inclusivity.
    • Expectation of women returning to traditional roles after wartime contributions.
    • Idealized vision of functioning, ordered families with a working father and a consuming mother.

The Cold War Paradox and Anticommunism

  • The Cold War introduces the paradox of unity versus the presence of subversives and un-American activities.
  • The shift from anti-fascism during the war to anti-communism after the war leads to the investigation of anything resembling communism.
  • HUAC (House Un-American Activities Committee) investigates un-American activities, sometimes reflecting older Victorian ideals.
    • Example: the Klan, being seen as an American institution.
  • HUAC investigations focused on alleged communists, including those who collaborated with communists during the 1930s and 1940s due to shared political interests.

HUAC and Concerns Raised

  • HUAC asked not just about current affiliations but also past associations with communism.
  • This highlights a tension between the aspirational postwar period and the paranoid anxieties of the Cold War.

Duck and Cover

  • School children were educated to "Duck and Cover" to prepare for atomic bomb attacks.
  • This strategy was taught through films like "Bert the Turtle" to simplify the complexities of the Cold War for children.
  • The goal was to instill fear and encourage trust in the state for protection, though the effectiveness of "duck and cover" was questionable.
  • It served to keep the public vigilant and trusting of the government.

Distrust of the State Growing

  • As awareness of the true extent of atomic weapons' damage grew, distrust in the state increased.
  • The Oppenheimer trials focused on loyalty rather than the creation of destructive weapons.
  • The key issue was how the Soviets obtained the bomb and the loyalty of individuals involved.

Post War Visions vs Reality

  • The postwar world was envisioned to be built on:
    • Keynesian economics
    • Collaborative and cooperative relationships
    • A functional United Nations.
    • The Bretton Woods Agreement.
    • The end of European empires.
  • The US containment policy towards the Soviets was influenced by Kennan doctrine.
    • Push back, don't give up ground, but don't try and take ground.
    • Greece and Turkey and the Truman Doctrine (aid, money, guns).
    • The Domino Theory.
  • Internal subversion became a concern, exemplified by HUAC.
  • The "loss" of China to communism triggered intense political debate in the US (Who lost China?).
  • The US committed to defending South Korea, emphasizing the importance of containing communism in Asia.

Rise of McCarthyism

  • Joe McCarthy's accusations of communist infiltration in the State Department created political upheaval.
  • McCarthy targeted Ivy League graduates and alleged political and sexual deviants.
  • The Army-McCarthy hearings were televised, leading to McCarthy's downfall due to his bullying tactics and lack of evidence.
  • Key argument: Don't trust the State Department.
  • Elite education is bad.
  • HUAC remained influential, focusing on Hollywood and cultural figures, with Richard Nixon as a prominent figure.

Politics in 1948

  • The progressive wing broke, the Dixiecrats broke, but Truman still won.
  • After '48 radicals became known as communists.
  • Dixiecrats linked back to the Democratic party.
  • Republicans reinvented themselves as moderates.
  • A new consensus emerged, based on anti-communism, Keynesian economics (defense spending), capitalism, Christian values, and domestic order.

The Eisenhower Era and Massive Retaliation

  • Eisenhower's strategy of "massive retaliation" threatened a full-scale atomic response to any communist aggression.
  • John Foster Dulles advocated "brinksmanship," emphasizing the need to be willing to go to the brink of war.
  • The public Cold War involved symbolic victories and propaganda, while the covert Cold War involved covert actions and interventions led by the CIA.
  • Brinksmanship is choosing when you're willing to go to the edge.
  • Newell report: We must do whatever we can, but it must be kept secret.
  • The US overthrew the democratic government of Iran and install a king.
  • The US supported the military dictatorships in Cuba.

Covert Actions and the CIA

  • The CIA, led by Allen Dulles, engaged in espionage, sabotage, and support for military coups.
  • The Duval Commission report emphasized the need to subvert and destroy enemies, even if it meant violating rules and committing war crimes.

Failure in Cuba.

  • The Bay of Pigs invasion to overthrow Castro failed, leading to the Cuban Missile Crisis, bringing the world to the brink of nuclear war.
  • External subversion and internal subversion caused a constant state of tension.