Overarching Policy Issues in Criminal Procedure
Purpose and Core Norms of Criminal Procedure
Core Balance: Criminal procedure balances protecting the public from crime against protecting individual rights and liberties.
Major Goals:
Accurate determination of guilt or innocence.
Protection of constitutional rights.
Fair treatment of suspects.
Efficient law enforcement.
Public confidence in the justice system.
Limiting government abuse of power.
Consequences of Violations: Unconstitutional police actions or procedural violations can result in excluded evidence, dismissed charges, or overturned convictions.
Alternative Models of Criminal Justice
Herbert Packer's Two Models:
Crime Control Model:
Primary Goal: Reduce crime through efficiency, speed, and swift justice.
Key Assumptions: Police generally act appropriately; most suspects are guilty; delays reduce effectiveness.
Characteristics: Expanded police discretion, efficient processing, plea bargaining, finality of convictions, and reliance on police reliability.
Criticisms: Risk of wrongful convictions, potential police misconduct, and reduced judicial oversight.
Due Process Model:
Primary Goal: Protect individuals from government abuse, prioritizing fairness over speed.
Key Assumptions: Government officials make mistakes; police may violate constitutional rights; judicial oversight is vital.
Characteristics: Presumption of innocence, constitutional safeguards, and careful review of evidence.
Criticisms: Slows investigations, may permit guilty offenders to avoid punishment, and burdens police with procedural rules.
Practical Application: The American criminal justice system blends both models, placing crime control practices (preventive policing, rapid arrests, plea bargaining) alongside due process safeguards (Miranda warnings, search warrants, right to counsel, exclusionary rule).
Truth and Constitutional Values
Truth vs. Rights: While determining factual truth is critical, courts exclude reliable evidence obtained through unconstitutional means to compel government compliance with the Constitution and prevent illegal police conduct.
Competing System Values:
Accuracy: Convicting the guilty while acquitting the innocent.
Fairness: Impartial and equal treatment for all individuals.
Privacy: Safeguarding citizens from unreasonable government intrusion.
Accountability: Holding government actors answerable for their conduct.
Liberty: Protecting individual freedom against state overreach.
Accusatorial vs. Inquisitorial Systems
Accusatorial System (United States):
Characteristics: Adversarial framework featuring two opposing sides, a neutral judge as referee, an independent jury, a presumption of innocence, and prosecution carrying the burden of proof.
Trade-offs: Protects defendant rights through vigorous advocacy and prevents judicial bias, but is expensive, time-consuming, and subject to outcome disparities based on wealth.
Inquisitorial System (Europe and Beyond):
Characteristics: Active judicial investigation into factual truth, written investigative files, and less reliance on juries or opposing attorneys.
Trade-offs: Offers higher efficiency and lower costs, but provides reduced procedural protections for defendants and concentrates significant power in the judge.
Disparities in Race, Gender, and Economic Class
Procedural Disparities: Disparities exist across police stops and searches, arrests, charging decisions, bail determinations, plea bargaining, trial outcomes, and sentencing.
Analytical Distinctions in Racial Disparities:
Individual Discrimination: Intentional bias by individual officers or officials.
Structural Inequalities: Systemic patterns embedded in policies and institutions.
Legitimate Law Enforcement: Race-neutral policing based on localized crime patterns.
Gender and Class Factors:
Gender: Influences offender outcomes, victimization patterns, and distinct policy responses in domestic violence and sexual assault cases.
Economic Class: Wealth dictates access to private attorneys, expert witnesses, and bail; indigent defendants rely on overburdened public defenders.
Sources of Criminal Procedural Rules
Four Primary Sources:
The Constitution: Establishes minimum constitutional protections via the 4th, 5th, 6th, and 14th Amendments.
Legislatures: Pass statutes regulating law enforcement authority and judicial procedure.
Courts: Interpret text, statutes, and precedent to generate operational rules.
Law Enforcement Agencies: Draft internal policies and training standards that can exceed constitutional minimums.
Debate Over Rule-Makers:
Courts: Insulated from majoritarian political pressures to protect individual rights.
Legislatures: Democratic bodies able to gather empirical evidence and reflect public will.
Police: Administrative leaders who understand operational needs and can create detailed rules.
Formulating Procedural Rules and Controversies
Bright-Line Rules vs. Case-by-Case Adjudication:
Bright-Line Rules: Fixed standards (e.g., Miranda warnings) providing predictability, clear training, and uniformity, but risking rigidity.
Case-by-Case Adjudication: Context-sensitive evaluations (e.g., totality of circumstances) providing flexibility and fairness, but creating uncertainty for law enforcement.
Objective vs. Subjective Standards:
Objective Standards: Measure police action against a "reasonable officer" standard regardless of intent.
Subjective Standards: Focus on actual officer state of mind, which is hard to prove.
Pretextual Conduct:
Occurs when an officer uses a minor infraction (e.g., broken taillight) as a pretext to investigate a separate suspected crime.
Policy Issue: Lawful if supported by objective legal cause, but criticized for encouraging discriminatory enforcement.