Historical Methodology: External Criticism, Internal Criticism, Content Analysis, and Contextual Analysis
Scientific Analysis of Historical Sources
All sources of historical data must be subjected to rigorous scientific analysis to determine both their authenticity and their accuracy. Scientific evaluation of historical data relies on two primary analytical practices: external criticism and internal criticism.

External Criticism
External criticism, sometimes referred to as "lower criticism", is the practice of verifying the authenticity of evidence by examining:
- Physical characteristics of the artifact or document.
- Consistency with the historical characteristics of the time period when it was produced.
- Materials used to construct or record the evidence (e.g., ink, paper, parchment, tools).

Key Investigative Questions in External Criticism
- When Written? Determining the exact date or time period of creation.
- Where Was It Written? Establishing the geographic location of origin.
- Why Did It Survive? Understanding the preservation history and provenance.
- Who Was the Real Author? Confirming the true identity of the creator rather than relying on attributions.
- Is It Authentic? Verifying whether the document is genuine or a forgery.
Internal Criticism
Internal criticism, sometimes referred to as "higher criticism", examines the honesty and factuality of the proof. It analyzes the substance of the source and the conditions under which it was generated.

Analytical Focus of Internal Criticism
- Creator of the Source: Assessing the credibility, position, and background of the author.
- Unique Situation: Examining the environmental and situational backdrop of generation.
- Motivation: Investigating the underlying motives driving the creation of the document.
- Informing Information: Identifying the source material or data that informed the creator.
- Planned Purpose: Clarifying the intended function or goal of the source among audiences.
Key Investigative Questions in Internal Criticism
- Eyewitness or Secondhand Account? Determining the proximity of the author to the event.
- Why Was It Written? Uncovering the author's primary objectives.
- Literal Meaning? Dissecting the exact textual message.
- Internal Consistency? Checking if statements within the text contradict one another.
- Connotations? Identifying subtle tone, underlying assumptions, or implied meanings.
- Meaning in Context? Interpreting textual claims relative to the era's linguistic and cultural norms.
Content Analysis in Research
Content Analysis is a qualitative research tool used to determine the presence and meaning of concepts, terms, or words within one or more pieces of recorded communication. It serves as a systematic and replicable technique that allows researchers to compress extensive textual data into fewer content categories based on explicit coding rules.
Objectives and Applications
- Enables inferences regarding:
- The author (individuals, groups, organizations, or institutions).
- The audience.
- The prevailing culture and time period (Stan).
- Covers communication artifacts across diverse formats: text documents, pictures, audio, and video recordings.
- Allows social scientists to examine communication patterns in a replicable, systematic manner.
Disciplines and Methodologies
Practices and philosophies of content analysis vary across academic fields, but all center on systematic reading or observation of artifacts. Artifacts are assigned labels (known as codes) to flag meaningful content pieces:
- Quantitative Analysis: Systematically coding a body of text enables quantitative measurement of content patterns using statistical methods.
- Qualitative Analysis: Focuses on interpreting deeper, context-dependent meanings of content within texts.
- Historical Simulation: Historical researchers whose subjects and contexts are no longer directly accessible for direct qualitative study use content analysis as an indirect method to simulate contact and infer past events from texts positioned in their historical contexts.
Data Types and Approaches in Content Analysis
When conducting content analysis, researchers distinguish between two types of content data:
- Explicit Data: Transparent, obvious, and straightforward to identify.
- Implicit Data: Requires subjective interpretation to uncover underlying meaning.
Primary Types of Content Analysis
- Conceptual Analysis: Focuses on counting the frequency with which a specific concept occurs within a dataset; primarily targets explicit data.
- Relational Content Analysis: Goes beyond frequency counts to evaluate the connections and relationships between different concepts, analyzing the broader contextual setting in which concepts appear.
Scope and Physical Records of Communication
Content analysis is applied in studies aiming to understand human factors such as behaviors, attitudes, values, emotions, and opinions. It is applicable whenever a physical record of communication exists.
Three Categories of Communication Records
- Independently and Internally Generated Records: Created by the subject organization or individual independent of the research process (e.g., newspaper articles, archived household consumption records).
- Internally Generated and Externally Directed Records: Produced by an institution for external audiences (e.g., verbatim transcripts of legislative hearings or committee debates in parliaments, which reflect or obscure political decision-making processes).
- Researcher-Produced Records: Generated directly by researchers specifically for the analysis (e.g., video recordings of television news broadcasts, commercials, town council debates, or legislative proceedings).
Klaus Krippendorff's Six Fundamental Questions
Klaus Krippendorff established six core questions that must be addressed in every content analysis project:
- Which data are analyzed?
- How are they defined?
- What is the population from which they are drawn?
- What is the context relative to which the data are analyzed?
- What are the boundaries of the analysis?
- What is the target of the inferences?
Methodological Rules and Document Abandonment
To ensure replicability, data examined in content analysis must be durable. Researchers must abandon content analysis under specific conditions:
- Missing Data: When a significant portion of documents from the targeted population is missing or unavailable, the analysis must be abandoned.
- Uncodable Documents: When retrieved documents meet baseline requirements but cannot be properly coded due to incomplete text or ambiguous content, they must be abandoned.
Contextual Analysis and Cultural Archaeology
Contextual Analysis assesses a text within its historical and cultural setting while evaluating its textuality (the specific qualities that make a text a text).
It combines formal textual analysis with "cultural archaeology"—the systematic study of the social, political, economic, philosophical, religious, and aesthetic conditions present at the time and place of creation. Contextual analysis situates the text within its historical milieu and examines the roles of authors, readers, and commentators.
The Role and Importance of Historical Context
Source: Grace Fleming, edited by Stacy Jagodowski (January 28, 2018)
Historical context encompasses the surrounding details of an occurrence, specifically the social, religious, economic, and political conditions of a given time and place. It allows scholars to interpret historical or future events based on the standards of their era rather than evaluating them solely through contemporary standards.
Context vs. Cause
- Context: The environment in which an action and outcome take place; it provides meaning to details.
- Cause: The specific action that produces an outcome.
Without historical context, observers only see an isolated fragment of an event without grasping the full influence of time and place.
Practical Applications Across Fields
- Scholars & Educators: Analyze and interpret art, literature, music, dance, and poetry.
- Architects & Builders: Guide the design of new structures and the restoration of historic buildings.
- Judges: Interpret legal texts and legislative intent.
- Historians: Reconstruct and understand motivations behind past human behavior.
Seven Key Questions for Contextual Analysis
When evaluating texts through contextual analysis, researchers apply seven key questions:
What does the text reveal about itself as a text?
- Characterize the language (words and vocabulary) and rhetoric (the arrangement of words to achieve a purpose), which together constitute style.
What does the text tell us about its apparent intended audience(s)?
- What reader did the author envision based on language and rhetoric?
- What qualifications are required of the reader?
- What reader groups appear to be excluded?
- Is there more than one intended audience?
What seems to have been the author's intention?
- Why was the text written, and why was it composed in this specific manner rather than alternative ways?
- Every text reflects deliberate authorial choices; researchers must analyze:
- What the author said (selected words).
- What the author omitted (unselected words).
- How the author expressed the message.
What is the occasion for this text?
- Is it written in response to a specific contemporary incident or event?
- Is it a general observation regarding human affairs and experiences?
- Is it prompted by a definable set of cultural circumstances?
Is the text intended as a call to action?
- Who is called to act, and why?
- What specific actions does the author want readers to take?
Is the text intended as a call to reflection or consideration rather than direct action?
- What does the author want readers to think about, conclude, or decide?
- Why does the author want readers to undergo this reflection, and who stands to gain?
Can non-textual circumstances affecting creation and reception be identified?
- Historical or political events.
- Economic factors.
- Cultural practices.
- Intellectual or aesthetic issues.
- Personal circumstances of the author's life.