Comprehensive Study Guide on Dispute Resolution and Crisis Management

Understanding Conflict and the Thomas-Kilmann Instrument

  • Definition of Conflict: According to Nicholson, M. (19921992), conflict is an activity occurring when conscious beings (individuals or groups) desire to perform mutually inconsistent acts regarding their wants, needs, or obligations. It is a natural disagreement or struggle involving physical confrontation or conflicting ideas.

  • Scope: Conflict can exist within a single person or between multiple groups/individuals. It manifests when incompatible goals exist and one party believes the other's behavior hinders their own goal achievement.

  • Etymology: The word "Conflict" is derived from the Latin term "conflingere," which translates to "coming together for a battle."

  • Thomas-Kilmann Instrument (TKI): Developed by Kenneth Thomas and Ralph Kilmann (20152015), the TKI measures behavior in "conflict situations"—scenarios where the concerns of two individuals appear incompatible.

  • Dimensions of Behavior: Behavior in conflict is assessed along two primary axes:

    • Assertiveness: The degree to which an individual attempts to satisfy their own concerns.

    • Cooperativeness: The degree to which an individual attempts to satisfy the other person’s concerns.

  • Five Conflict Resolution Strategies:

    • Avoiding: Unassertive and uncooperative. The person ignores the conflict, sidesteps issues, postpones them, or withdraws from threatening situations.

    • Competing: Assertive and uncooperative. A power-oriented mode where one pursues personal concerns at the expense of others. It involves standing up for rights or defending a position believed to be correct. It is common in sports/war but poor for group problem solving.

    • Accommodating: Unassertive and cooperative (the opposite of competing). The individual neglects their own concerns for the sake of the other person. Features elements of self-sacrifice, selfless generosity, or yielding to another's point of view.

    • Collaborating: Both assertive and cooperative (the opposite of avoiding). It involves digging into an issue to find a creative solution that fully satisfies all underlying needs of both parties.

    • Compromising: Moderate in both assertiveness and cooperativeness. The objective is an expedient, mutually acceptable solution that partially satisfies both parties. It involves "splitting the difference" or exchanging concessions.

Conflict versus Dispute: Theoretical Distinctions

  • John Burton’s Logic (19901990): While often used interchangeably, Burton distinguishes them based on duration and negotiability.

  • Dispute: A short-term disagreement involving issues that are negotiable; it can be resolved with specific settlements.

  • Conflict: A long-term struggle with deeply rooted, "non-negotiable" issues.

Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) Modes

  • Negotiation: The preeminent mode, usually attempted first. It is informal, flexible, and allows parties to control both the process and the outcome through verbal interaction.

  • Mediation: A voluntary process where a neutral mediator facilitates communication to help parties reach a voluntary agreement. The decision-making authority stays with the parties.

    • Classification of Mediation:

      • Non-Court Annexed: Includes Ad Hoc (any mediation outside a court/institution) and Institutional (conducted under the rules of a specific mediation institution).

      • Court Annexed: Includes Court-Annexed Mediation (CAM) (conducted under court auspices after acquiring jurisdiction) and Court-Referred Mediation (CRM) (court-ordered based on a pre-existing contract/arbitration clause).

  • Cases Subject to CAM:

    • Civil cases (except those prohibited by law under Article 20352035 of the New Civil Code).

    • Special proceedings for estate settlements.

    • Civil aspect of Quasi-Offenses (Title 1414, Revised Penal Code).

    • Civil aspect of criminal cases with penalties not exceeding 66 years of imprisonment.

    • Civil aspect of theft (non-qualified), estafa (non-large scale), and libel.

  • Conciliation: An interest-based process where a neutral third party (conciliator) assists in reaching an amicable settlement. Unlike a mediator, a conciliator may be asked to provide a non-binding settlement proposal.

  • Arbitration: A voluntary process where an Arbitrator renders an "Award" (a partial or final decision) that is legally binding.

  • Judicial Dispute Resolution (JDR): A pre-trial process where a "JDR Judge" uses conciliation or mediation to settle a case. If JDR fails, a different "Trial Judge" hears the case.

  • Litigation: Resolving rights-based disputes through the formal court system (lawsuit, discovery, trial, appeal). It is public and governed by the Rules of Court.

The Office for Alternative Dispute Resolution (OADR) and ADR Act of 2004

  • Republic Act No. 92859285: The ADR Act of 20042004. Its policy is to promote party autonomy, achieve speedy justice, and declog court dockets.

  • Exceptions to the ADR Act: Labor disputes, civil status of persons, validity of marriage, legal separation grounds, jurisdiction of courts, future legitime, criminal liability, and disputes that cannot be compromised.

  • OADR Organization: An agency attached to the Department of Justice (DOJ), led by an Executive Director appointed by the President.

  • Advisory Council: Composed of representatives from the Mediation profession, Arbitration profession, ADR organizations, IBP, and the Academe.

  • Staff and Service Divisions:

    • Secretariat: Administrative support.

    • Public Information and Promotion: Disseminating ADR info.

    • Training Division: Formulating standards and certifying practitioners.

    • Records and Library: Repository of ADR laws and jurisprudence.

  • Powers and Functions: Acts as an appointing authority for mediators/arbitrators, conducts training programs, certifies professional completion, and recommends statutory changes to Congress.

Detailed Mediation Rules and Ethics

  • Mediator Selection: Parties are free to select their mediator; OADR provides rosters if requested.

  • Qualifications: No special background required unless specified in the mediation agreement.

  • Waiver: A party can waive the right to legal representation in writing, but this is rescindable at any time.

  • Withdrawal Grounds: A mediator may withdraw if a party requests it, if they lack competence, if impartiality is questioned, if ethical standards are violated, or if the safety of parties is at risk.

  • Ethical Duties:

    • Impartiality: Must disclose facts likely to affect neutrality (financial/personal interest).

    • Confidentiality: Highest level of confidence for all information obtained during the process.

    • Self-Determination: The responsibility for settling the dispute rests primarily with the parties.

    • Fees: Fees must be explained; no contingent fee agreements based on the settlement amount. Unearned fees must be returned upon withdrawal.

  • Mediation Stages: 11) Opening statement, 22) Individual narration, 33) Exchange, 44) Summary of issues, 55) Generation/evaluation of options, 66) Closure.

The Arbitration Law (Republic Act No. 876876)

  • Disqualifications: Infants or persons judicially declared incompetent cannot arbitrate unless the court approves a petition by a guardian.

  • Powers of Arbitrators: Authority to issue Subpoena Duces Tecum (documents) and Ad Testificandum (witnesses).

  • Award Timeline: Must be rendered within 3030 days after hearings close (unless specified otherwise in writing).

  • Confirmation: Parties apply for a court order confirming the award within 11 month.

  • Vacating an Award: Grounds include fraud, corruption, partiality, misconduct (refusing to hear evidence), or exceeding powers. Notice to vacate must be served within 3030 days after the award is filed.

Katarungang Pambarangay Law (Barangay Justice System)

  • PD 15081508 and RA 71607160: Established the procedure for amicable settlement at the barangay level to help the courts.

  • Lupong Tagapamayapa: Composed of the Punong Barangay (Chairman) and 1010 to 2020 members. They serve for a term of 33 years without compensation (though honoraria and state scholarships for children are possible).

  • Pangkat ng Tagapagkasundo: A conciliation panel of 33 members chosen by the disputing parties from the Lupon list.

  • Subject Matter Jurisdiction: All disputes except where the government is a party, disputes involving public officers/employees, offenses with penalties over 11 year or fines over P5,000.00P5,000.00, or disputes involving real property in different cities.

  • Venue Rules:

    • Same barangay: Where parties reside.

    • Different barangays within the same city: Where the respondent resides (complainant's choice).

    • Real property: Where the property is situated.

  • Process: Complainant files →\rightarrow Punong Barangay summons for mediation →\rightarrow Failure leads to Pangkat constitution within 1515 days →\rightarrow Pangkat resolves within 1515 days.

  • Effect of Settlement: Has the force of a final court judgment if not repudiated within 1010 days. Repudiation is based on Fraud, Intimidation, or Violence (FIV).

  • Arbitration in the Barangay: Parties sign a written agreement to arbitrate; repudiation of the agreement must happen within 55 days. The award is rendered within 1010 days.

Restorative versus Retributive Justice

  • Restorative Justice (RA 93449344): Focuses on repairing harm through involvement of the victim, offender, and community. Embraces healing, forgiveness, and reintegration into society.

  • Retributive Justice: Focuses on punishment fitting the crime (Lex Talliones). Crime is viewed as an act against the State.

  • Key Distinctions:

    • Control: Restorative lies with the community; Retributive lies with the criminal justice system.

    • Focus: Restorative focuses on the future and consequences; Retributive focuses on the past and blame.

    • Relationship: Restorative focuses on dialogue; Retributive focuses on adversarial processes.

Crisis and Disaster Management

  • Crisis: Greek "krisis" (to separate). A turning point involving unplanned incidents, death, or severe impact on organization image.

  • Common Elements: Threat to organization, Surprise, Short decision time.

  • Emergency: Latin "emergentia." Unforeseen circumstances calling for immediate action.

  • Disaster: Serious disruption exceeding a community's capacity to cope using its own resources.

  • Comparison: Emergency is controllable/containable; Crisis is beyond normal control; Disaster is when even the instigator cannot control the effects.

  • PNP Alert Levels (Human-Induced):

    • Level 11 (Low): No specific info suggesting an incident.

    • Level 22 (Moderate): Possible but not likely.

    • Level 33 (High): Strong possibility within a short time.

    • Level 44 (Extreme): Occurred or just been preempted.

  • PNP Disaster Stages:

    • Level 11 (Green): Pre-Disaster.

    • Level 22 (Red): Disaster Report (actions being taken).

    • Level 33 (White): Post-Disaster (recovery efforts).

Crisis Management Committee (CMC) and Planning

  • Five Critical Tasks: Sense making, Decision making, Meaning making, Terminating, and Learning.

  • Phases of Crisis Management:

    • Pro-Active: Prediction (intel/threat analysis), Prevention (security measures), Preparation (training/equipment).

    • Reactive: Performance (implementation of plans), Post-Action (investigation, documentation, prosecution).

  • Threat Group Analysis:

    • Political Terrorist: Ideologically inspired (e.g., CPP/NPA).

    • Criminals: Personal/financial gain.

    • Mentally Deranged: Psychiatric disturbance (impulsive/unpredictable).

Hostage Situation Protocols

  • Hostage Situation: Suspected law violator holding a person captive via force/threat while in contact with law enforcement.

  • The I-C-E-R Method: Isolate (onlookers), Contain (inner perimeter), Evaluate (gather info), Report (confirm circumstances).

  • Stages of Hostage Situation:

    • Alarm: Most traumatic/dangerous.

    • Crisis: HT consolidates position; danger of isolation/claustrophobia.

    • Accommodation: Longest stage; boredom mixed with terror; potential for Stockholm Syndrome (mutual positive feelings between hostage and HT).

    • Resolution: HT fatigued; increased effectiveness of negotiation techniques.

  • Types of Negotiators:

    • Primary: Principal conversationalist.

    • Secondary: Support and interprets tactics; substitution for primary.

    • Coach: Usually a psychologist; assesses HT status.

    • Intelligence/Recorder: Maintains logs and provides profiles.

  • The Incident Commander’s Planning Responsibilities:

    • Breakout Plan: Priorities for exits and counter-actions.

    • Delivery Plan: Coordinating food/tangible items to build rapport.

    • Surrender Plan: Release of hostages prior to actual HT surrender.

    • Collection Plan: How police safely gather evidence/intel.