Comprehensive Study Notes on Event Project Management and Bidding to Host Events
Foundations and Definition of the Event Bidding Process
Definition of Bidding:
- A bid constitutes a structured proposal and persuasive case establishing why an event should be conducted in a specific destination (Allen et al., 2005).
- The foundation of any bid is anchored in at least a pre-feasibility study wherein preliminary figures and estimates for both operational costs and projected benefits are formally assigned (Getz, 1997).
Strategic Destination Motivations and Associated Risks (Getz, 1997):
- Specific destinations and host communities intentionally target and seek to attract new, often one-time events that possess substantial media value and high tourist draw.
- Hosting events of this magnitude requires a substantial financial commitment, a large operational budget, and sophisticated marketing capabilities.
- A major associated risk in pursuing one-time, high-profile events is the potential alienation of local residents due to disruption, redirection of public resources, or lack of civic alignment.
Procedural Frameworks of the Bidding Process
The Bidding Process Model by Bowdin et al. (2006):
- Resource Identification: Locating and identifying all tangible and intangible resources that can be employed and mobilized to support event execution.
- Critical Path Development: Constructing a critical path project timeline dedicated to the preparation, synthesis, and final presentation of the bid document to the official event 'owners'.
- Organizational Understanding: Formulating a deep and thorough understanding of the governing body or organisation conducting the event, as well as the exact nature, scope, and technical parameters of the event itself.
- Precedent Analysis: Identifying and dissecting the core elements, formats, and tactics of past successful bids to guide the preparation of the bid document.
- Bid Presentation and Submission: Submitting and formally presenting the completed bid proposal directly to the owners or governing board of the event.
- Lobbying Initiatives: Conducting sustained lobbying efforts to build political and organizational advocacy in direct support of the bid.
The Bidding Process Model by Getz (1997):
- Viability Assessment: Confirming that the core event idea is operational, logistically viable, and realistic.
- Risk Tolerance: Ensuring that all associated financial, reputational, and operational risks are within acceptable thresholds.
- Formal Commitment: Securing formal, binding institutional and stakeholder commitments to bid and host.
- Bidding Group Formation: Assembling a specialized bidding committee or group tasked with executing the bid project.
- Marketing Group Formation: Establishing a dedicated marketing arm to handle presentation, collateral, and external engagement.
- Competitive Evaluation: Rigorously analyzing and assessing competing bidder cities, destinations, and rival proposals.
- Promotional Execution: Utilizing both formal promotional presentations and informal promotional tactics to sway decision-makers.
Core Bidding Elements by Catherwood & Van Kirk (1992):
- Bid Lists and Preferred Suppliers: Managing preferred supplier lists, vendor registers, and established contractor relationships.
- Follow-up and Continuous Contact: Maintaining consistent, ongoing communication and follow-up with the event sanctioning body throughout the bid cycle.
- Lobbying and Politicking: Navigating internal organizational politics, networking, and executing strategic lobbying to secure preferred positioning.
Requests for Proposals (RFPs) in Event Management
Definition and Core RFP Mechanics (Catherwood & Van Kirk, 1992):
- An RFP is an official document distributed by the sanctioning or governing body of an event.
- It specifies mandatory guidelines, requirements, and administrative procedures for submitting a compliant bid proposal.
- It provides explicit technical specifications detailing the expected form, layout, structure, and content of the submission.
- It frequently incorporates a standardized list of specific operational, financial, and logistical questions that must be addressed.
- It often outlines the precise criteria, scoring weights, and methodological guidelines used during the proposal evaluation process.
- The document explicitly spells out logistical demands, operational scope, and the exact facilities and venues required.
Evolution from the Public to the Private Sector:
- Public and Governmental Sector Origins: RFPs were historically developed and utilized within public sector and government procurement. They were characterized by rigorous procurement rules, solicitations of competitive bids from both incumbent vendors and new entrants, and dense, highly technical language.
- Modern Universal Adoption: The RFP structure has transitioned from purely public procurement to become the universal standard used by virtually every special event committee to select the optimal host community, venues, and event promoters or managers.
- Private Sector Transition and Impact: Prior to the adoption of standardized RFPs in the private sector, host organizations had to review disparately structured proposals, which made direct comparison and objective evaluation exceptionally difficult. The introduction of RFPs established a standardized protocol where all competing bidders answer identical questions and supply matching categories of data.
- RFP Structure and Communication Guidelines: For major events, RFPs are framed in practical, accessible, how-to language so that any promoter possesses the ability to answer the questions clearly. RFPs sequence questions in the exact order the sanctioning body expects them to be answered. Bidders are explicitly encouraged to engage in direct discussions with the sanctioning organization whenever questions or ambiguities arise regarding the RFP requirements.
Competitive Dynamics, RFP Restrictions, and the Super Bowl Case Study
Limiting Competition through Strategic RFP Design (Catherwood & Van Kirk, 1992):
- Sanctioning bodies intentionally draft RFPs to restrict the field of contenders by requiring resources, capacities, and capabilities that only a select tier of elite bidders can provide.
- RFPs feature lengthy, highly involved questions spanning complex logistics, specialized venue specifications, stringent financial requirements, extensive housing guarantees, transportation thresholds, and diverse event-specific prerequisites.
Super Bowl RFP Specifications as a Benchmark:
- Hotel and Accommodation Guarantees: Requires firm, legally binding advance commitments rather than tentative reservations. Bidders must supply explicit guarantees establishing maximum room rack rates and mandated minimum lengths of stay from area hotels (with a recommended stay requirement of three or four days).
- Transportation Fleet Guarantees: Bidders must secure firm, legally binding rate guarantees and total capacity commitments from local transit and livery providers, including buses, limousines (noting limited guarantees), taxis, and rental cars.
- NFL Fleet Requirements: The National Football League (NFL) specifically mandates guaranteed commitments for 425 buses and 65 limousines, requiring exclusively signed agreements to be formally documented within the bid submission.
- Auxiliary Fleet Demands: The proposal must provide exhaustive costings and access agreements for up to 100 school buses dedicated exclusively to servicing the logistical needs of the pre-game and half-time entertainment shows.
Implied versus Required Bids and Strategic Differentiation:
- Bidders must execute an in-depth analysis of the RFP to identify the underlying requirements versus implied expectations.
- Success hinges on determining what distinct added value can be delivered beyond baseline compliance.
- Bidding organizations must acknowledge direct competition and formulate deliberate "do one better" strategies to outmaneuver rival bids across quality, service, financial underwriting, or legacy delivery.
Sectoral Distinctions: Public versus Private Bidding Dynamics
Major Civic Events versus Commercial Concerts (Catherwood & Van Kirk, 1992):
- Major events cannot be treated like standard commercial entertainment (such as a music concert).
- Major events fundamentally engage entire cities, regional jurisdictions, and surrounding communities.
- In a major event bid, the event promoter or committee acts as a representative agent negotiating on behalf of the whole community rather than a single commercial interest.
Public Funding Realities and Objectives:
- Major events rarely sit purely in the private sector; the broad public and local taxpayers ultimately foot the bill and absorb financial liabilities.
- Promoters and organizing bodies are employed primarily to enhance civic image, build destination profile, and drive long-term positive economic impact.
- Direct commercial event profit is not the prime motivating factor for host municipalities and public bodies.
Promoter Motivations and Contractual Formalities:
- Private Promoters: Operate with a core commercial focus on direct financial profit. Private promoters organize events that the public sector avoids. In private transactions, lengthy formal RFPs and cumbersome bid packages are routinely replaced by simple proposals, term sheets, or letters of agreement.
- Public Promoters: Focus primarily on broader societal drivers, including sporting development, cultural enhancement, and municipal profile generation.
Unsolicited Concepts, Lobbying, and Informal Influence
Generating the "Big Ideas" Outside the RFP Process (Catherwood & Van Kirk, 1992):
- Event organizers and host destinations do not need to wait passively for sanctioning bodies to issue RFPs.
- Self-originated, internally conceptualized events can be developed locally and grown organically into major destination attractions.
- Self-developed events present the operational advantage of eliminating the need to negotiate with, adhere to, or yield operational control to external international or national governing bodies.
Behind-the-Scenes Lobbying Realities:
- Not all major international events rely purely on exhaustive written responses to technical RFPs.
- Many major events are awarded on the strength of straightforward, direct proposals combined with aggressive, highly focused behind-the-scenes lobbying.
- A bid team must conduct intelligence studies on competing candidate cities and communities.
- Bid teams must pinpoint exactly who the ultimate individual decision-makers are and cultivate focused relationships to influence their voting choices.
Comprehensive Components of the Bid Document
- Twelve Core Bid Document Components (Getz, 1997):
- Personalized Letter of Transmittal: A formal, personalized letter addressed directly to the client or governing/sanctioning body.
- Civic Letters of Invitation and Support: Official letters of endorsement and invitation signed by key local organizations, institutions, and civic/government officials.
- Executive Summary: A concise synthesis encapsulating the core highlights, advantages, and structure of the proposal.
- Bidder Organizational Profile: A comprehensive profile of the bidding organization, verifying legal standing and demonstrating explicit acceptance of operational responsibility for the event and its financial liabilities.
- Record of Acquired Support: Clear documentation of existing institutional, political, and commercial support already locked in for the bid.
- Event Concept Summary: A well-articulated overview defining the event vision, theme, and overarching format.
- Operational Plan Details: Detailed breakdowns of all functional event areas, operational schedules, facilities, and physical logistics.
- Attendance Projections and Marketing Strategy: Data-driven attendance forecasts paired with an actionable marketing and promotions plan.
- Financial Plan, Feasibility, and Budget: Formal assertion of economic and financial feasibility, verified by an itemized event budget and capital financing plan.
- Impact Forecasts and Contingency Planning: Detailed projections of social, environmental, and economic impacts alongside robust risk mitigation and contingency plans.
- Legacy Highlights: Strategic exposition of the enduring physical, social, sporting, or economic legacy the event will leave within the host destination.
- Competitive Advantages: A clear statement of distinct competitive advantages that elevate this submission above rival bidder destinations.
Key Success Factors in the Event-Bidding Process
Core Institutional and Relational Success Factors (Saayman et al., 2004):
- Accountability: Transparent governance, clear fiscal tracking, and institutional integrity throughout the proposal and delivery lifecycle.
- Political Support: Explicit, multi-level backing and formal guarantees from municipal, regional, and national political leaders.
- Relationship Marketing: Proactive cultivation of long-term networks and collaborative ties with governing federations, sanctioning committees, and influential delegates.
Organizational, Operational, and Technical Factors (Saayman et al., 2004):
- Ability to Organise the Event / Technical Expertise: Proven management capability, institutional capacity, and demonstrated operational track record in executing complex events.
- Infrastructure and Suprastructure: Adequacy of physical municipal utilities, transit networks, and transport links (infrastructure), combined with specialized facilities, sports arenas, hospitality stock, and convention venues (suprastructure).
- Partnership, Funding, and Sponsorship: Secured commercial brand partners, institutional sponsors, and committed public funding pipelines.
- Organizational Structure: A well-defined, legally sound administrative framework with clear reporting lines, responsibilities, and governance oversight.
Social, Environmental, and Strategic Execution Factors (Saayman et al., 2004):
- Community Participation: Meaningful local engagement, volunteerism, and active buy-in from residents to ensure event harmony and support.
- Human Resources: Access to skilled labor, experienced event professionals, operational managers, and an adequate volunteer labor pool.
- Destination Image: A compelling, trustworthy, and attractive global profile and destination brand.
- Safety and Security: Rigorous emergency planning, public policing capability, crowd control frameworks, and comprehensive risk mitigation protocols.
- Cost: Competitive, realistic pricing, transparent budget estimation, and cost-efficient operational delivery.
- Timing: Alignment of the event date with seasonal calendars, governing body requirements, local activities, and international schedules.
- Geographical Location and Climate: Favorable location accessibility, convenient transport access, and optimal climate/weather patterns to support event activities.
Core Academic Literature and References
Primary References:
- Bowdin, G., Allen, J., O’Toole, W., Harris, R. & McDonnell, I. (2006) Events Management, 2nd ed. UK: Elsevier.
- Catherwood, D.W. & Van Kirk, R.L. (1992) The Complete Guide to Special Event Management, Business Insights, Financial Advise and Successful Strategies from Ernst & Young, Advisors to the Olymipcs, the Emmy Awards and the PGA Tour. USA: John Wiley & Sons.
- Getz, D. (1997) Event Management & Event Tourism. USA: Cognizant Communication Corporation.
Further Reading:
- Emery, P.R. (2002) 'Bidding to Host a Major Sports Event: the Local organising committee Perspective', The International Journal of Public Sector Management, 14(4), pp. 316–355.
- Steynberg, L. and Saayman, Melville (2004) 'Event Management: identifying key success factors for bidding', in Long, P. & Robinson, M. (eds.) Festivals and tourism: marketing, management and evaluation. Sunderland: Business Education Publishers, pp. 67–86.