Chapter 8 Attitudes and Persuasive Communications

The Power of Attitudes

  • Definition

    • Attitude = lasting, general evaluation (positive or negative) of people, objects, ads or issues.

    • Anything evaluated is an Attitude Object (Ao).

  • Importance

    • Attitudes often predict purchase intention & behavior.

    • Useful to researchers for segmenting, targeting, positioning.

  • Functions of Attitudes (Katz’s Functional Theory)

    • Utilitarian

    • Based on reward–punishment calculus.

    • E.g., choosing a soft drink for taste rewards.

    • Value-Expressive

    • Reflects consumer’s self-concept / core values.

    • Product choice signals “who I am.”

    • Ego-Defensive

    • Protects from external threat or internal anxiety.

    • E.g., deodorant ads that raise fear of body odor, then offer protection.

    • Knowledge

    • Provides order/meaning—reduces ambiguity.

    • Activated in new or ambiguous situations.

/

ABC Model of Attitudes

  • Affect – feelings/emotions about Ao.

  • Behavior – intentions/actions toward Ao.

  • Cognition – beliefs/knowledge about Ao.

  • Emphasizes interrelationships among “knowing, feeling, doing.”

Hierarchies of Effects (Sequence Matters)

  • High-Involvement: Think → Feel → Do

    • Problem-solving, cognitive processing precedes affect & behavior.

  • Low-Involvement: Think → Do → Feel

    • Limited knowledge; evaluation follows trial.

  • Experiential: Feel → Do → Think

    • Hedonic consumption; driven by emotions (emotional contagion).

Formation & Strength of Attitudes

  • Levels of Commitment

    • Compliance (surface, reward/punishment driven)

    • Identification (imitate/ conform to group or person)

    • Internalization (deep-seated, value-system level)

  • Consistency Principle

    • People strive for harmony among thoughts, feelings, behaviors.

    • Inconsistency → tension → motivation to change (cognitive dissonance).

  • Self-Perception Theory

    • Infer attitudes from observing own behavior.

    • Explains foot-in-the-door technique.

  • Balance Theory (Heider)

    • Triad: Person (P), Ao (O), Other person/object (X).

    • Unit relations vs. sentiment relations.

    • Marketing link: celebrity endorsements to balance triad (P likes X who likes O ⇒ P likes O).

Attitude Models

  • Multi-Attribute Attitude Models

    • Attitude toward Ao depends on beliefs and evaluations of multiple attributes.

    • Elements

    • Attributes (aia_i)

    • Beliefs (bib_i): perceived Ao–attribute linkage strength.

    • Importance Weights (eie_i): priority of each attribute.

    • Fishbein Model (salient beliefs version)

    • Equation: A<em>o=∑</em>i=1nb<em>ie</em>iA<em>{o}=\sum</em>{i=1}^{n} b<em>{i}e</em>{i}

    • Components: salient beliefs, object–attribute linkages, evaluation.

  • Marketing Applications

    • Capitalize on relative advantage.

    • Strengthen perceived attribute linkages.

    • Add new attribute(s).

    • Influence competitors’ ratings.

From Attitude to Behavior

  • Problem: Attitudes ≠ always predict behavior.

  • Theory of Reasoned Action (Extended Fishbein)

    • Incorporates

    • Behavioral Intention (BI)

    • Subjective Norm (SN) = ∑NB×MC\sum NB \times MC

      • NB: normative belief about others’ expectations.

      • MC: motivation to comply.

    • Attitude toward Act (A_{act}) – consequences of buying.

    • Recognizes social pressure & act-specific attitudes.

  • Obstacles to Prediction

    • Unintentional behavior (impulse, situational change).

    • Outcomes beyond control (e.g., spouse veto).

    • Time lag between measurement & action.

    • Indirect vs. direct experience (direct stronger; attitude accessibility perspective).

Persuasion – Changing Attitudes

  • Six universal principles (Cialdini)

    • Reciprocity, Scarcity, Authority, Consistency, Liking, Consensus (Social Proof).

  • Tactical Questions for Campaigns

    • Who is audience? How to frame message? Which media? Audience traits?

Elements of Communication

  • Traditional Model

    • Source → Message → Medium → Receiver → Feedback (loop).

  • Interactive Update

    • Consumers = active, control exposure.

    • Permission Marketing: communicate with opt-in consumers.

The Source

  • Source Credibility

    • Expertise, objectivity, trustworthiness.

    • Influential when receiver is novice.

    • Issues: disclaimers, fake news, knowledge bias, reporting bias.

    • Sleeper Effect: impact of low-credibility source increases over time.

    • Native Advertising blends with editorial content.

  • Source Attractiveness

    • Social value (appearance, status, similarity).

    • Platforms leverage peer endorsements (FB, Google shared endorsements).

  • Star Power (Celebrity Endorsers)

    • Celebs = cultural meaning conveyors (status, class, personality).

    • Risk: negative publicity, cost, overshadow product.

  • Non-Human Endorsers

    • Spokescharacters (e.g., Geico Gecko) enhance recall & brand attitude.

The Message

  • Pictures vs. Words

    • Visuals evoke affect; words convey facts.

    • Dual coding: picture + framed caption most effective.

  • Repetition

    • Mere Exposure increases liking.

    • Two-Factor Theory: familiarity benefit vs. boredom wear-out.

  • Message Structure

    • Supportive (one-sided) vs. Two-Sided arguments.

    • Refutational two-sided boosts credibility (addresses & negates negative issue).

  • Comparative Ads

    • Direct brand comparisons; may trigger skepticism (source derogation).

New Message Formats & Reality Engineering

  • Social Media Revolution – user-generated + advertiser content.

  • Martyrdom Effect – donations rise when effort/suffering required.

  • Guerrilla Marketing – unconventional tactics to spur WOM.

  • Product Placement – real brands in fiction.

  • Advergaming – games intertwined with ads; precise targeting.

Types of Message Appeals

  • Emotional vs. Rational

    • Choice depends on product type & consumer–product relationship.

  • Sex Appeals

    • Attract attention; may distract or offend; cultural norms matter.

  • Humor Appeals

    • Grab attention, inhibit counter-arguing; mixed impact on recall.

  • Fear Appeals

    • Highlight negative consequences; effectiveness depends on moderation (too much fear can backfire).

  • Literary Devices

    • Allegory: story symbolizing abstract concept.

    • Metaphor: "A is B" linkage (e.g., car = bullet).

    • Simile: "A is like B" (comparative).

    • Resonance: pun or wordplay paired with image.

Source vs. Message: The Elaboration Likelihood Model (ELM)

  • Central Route (High Involvement)

    • Consumers carefully process message arguments; attitude change via cognitive responses; outcomes durable & predictive.

  • Peripheral Route (Low Involvement)

    • Focus on surface cues (source attractiveness, context, music).

    • Attitudes less resistant & less predictive; format/presentation critical.

Real-World & Ethical Considerations

  • Responsible use of celebrity or fear to avoid manipulation.

  • CSR messages require authentic, credible sources to avoid skepticism.

  • Permission marketing respects privacy & reduces clutter.

  • Native advertising blurs editorial/advertising lines ⇒ ethical transparency essential.