Comprehensive Notes on Criminal Justice System

Criminal Justice: The Process and System

Criminal Justice Definition

  • Criminal justice is the process by which the state responds to behavior it deems unacceptable.
  • It involves a series of stages: charge, prosecution, trial, sentence, appeal, and punishment.
  • The agencies carrying out these processes are collectively known as the criminal justice system.

Components of the Justice System

1. Police
  • Investigate crimes, arrest suspects, and collect evidence.
  • Operate at municipal, provincial, and federal levels.
  • Any city with more than 10,000 people is responsible for developing its own police services.
  • Three provincial police services:
    • Ontario Provincial Police (OPP)
    • Sûreté du Québec
    • Royal Newfoundland Constabulary
  • The RCMP enforces laws created by parliament.
2. Courts
  • Adjudication determines whether a person is guilty and sets punishment.
  • Three levels of courts (excluding Nunavut):
    • Lower courts: Provincial courts
    • Superior courts: Court of King's Bench/Supreme Court
    • Highest court: Appeal court
  • Supreme Court of Canada is the highest level of authority regarding criminal matters.
3. Corrections
  • Takes over after a guilty verdict.
  • Incarceration:
    • Provincial/territorial level for sentences of 2 years less 1 day.
    • Federal level for sentences of 2 years or more via Correctional Service Canada (CSC).
    • Probation can also be a sentence.

Definition of Crime

  • An action prohibited by law.
  • A penalty is attached to it.
  • Deemed a public evil.
  • All laws are measured against the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

Different Definitions of Crime

  • Legal: Behavior prohibited by criminal law.
  • Social Norm: Behavior violating social norms.
  • Social Construct: Product of social interaction.
  • Legally, a person is innocent until proven guilty.

Caveats to Criminal Acts

  • Some acts are legal under specific circumstances (e.g., police officers killing someone in the line of duty).

Purpose of Criminal Justice

  • Protection of the public.
  • Social control.
  • Reinforcing expected behaviors.

What is Justice?

  • In terms of crime, justice often means punishment.
  • People behave because they believe it’s the right thing to do.

Informal and Formal Controls

  • Informal controls: Caring about others' opinions.
  • Formal control: The criminal justice system as a last resort.
    • Police, courts, and correctional system.

Normative Approach to Criminal Justice

  • Discovery of the truth.
  • The rule of law.
  • Protection of legal rights.
  • Access to justice for everyone.
  • Guarantee of fairness and equality.
  • Adversarial system: Both sides (Crown and defense) present their case.

Substantive vs. Procedural Justice

Substantive Justice
  • Truthfulness of allegations.
  • Accuracy of verdict.
  • Appropriateness of sentence.
  • Factual guilt.
  • An innocent person found “not guilty”.
Procedural Justice
  • Rights of individuals upheld through fair procedures.
  • Legal guilt (proven beyond a reasonable doubt).
  • A guilty person may be acquitted if unfair procedures were used.

Rule of Law: Three Basic Elements

  • Scope of the law: Everyone is equal before and under the law.
  • Character of the law: The law should be public and understandable.
  • Institution of the law: Independent judiciary and written laws.
  • Access to justice: Everyone should have access, including public interest laws and legal aid.

Legitimacy of Criminal Justice Institutions

  • Public agreement with and support of police, courts, and corrections.
  • Rooted in procedural justice.
Perceptions of Legitimacy
  • Participation: Being heard in the process.
  • Neutrality: Impartial decision-making.
  • Trustworthiness of authorities.
  • Treatment with dignity and respect.

Models of the Criminal Justice System

Crime Control Model (Packer)
  • Assembly line justice, emphasizing efficiency.
  • Focuses on factual guilt.
  • Goal: Public safety and punishing offenders.
  • Aims for a high rate of conviction.
Due Process Model (Packer)
  • Obstacle course emphasizing fairness, equality, and justice.
  • Focuses on legal guilt.
  • Goal: Protection from the powers of the state.
  • Search for truth.
Medical (Rehabilitation) Model (King)
  • Focuses on the needs and treatment of the offender.
  • Emphasizes discretion of judges and expertise of treatment personnel.
  • Goal: Community reintegration.
Bureaucratic Model (King)
  • Focuses on the management of criminals, speed of case processing, and efficiency of system.
  • Emphasizes management of resources and administrative discretion.
Punitive Model (Roach)
  • “Roller coaster” approach focusing on factual guilt.
  • Emphasis on victims' rights and a victim focus throughout the system.
  • Goal: Greater punishment.
Non-Punitive Model (Roach)
  • Circle approach: healing, cooperation, restoration.
  • Focuses on victims' needs, reduction of harm, and non-adversarial emphasis.
  • Goal: Reduced involvement of criminal justice actors.

Unified Goals of the Criminal Justice System (Ruth and Reitz)

Goal #1: Reduce Crime
  • Include immediate reactions and alternative dispute resolutions.
Goal #2: Confront Fear
  • Prevent a society that is divided, distrustful, and distracted.
Goal #3: Justice for All
  • Include crime victims, potential future victims, and the offender.
  • Requires just laws, fair enforcement processes, and even-handed administration.
Goal #4: Sustain Moral Legitimacy
  • Create and sustain broad faith in its moral legitimacy.
  • Address perceptions of injustice.
Goal #5: Proper Scope of Crime Response
  • Use criminal justice only for behavior severe enough to be condemned as criminal.

Pretrial Criminal Procedure

Arrest
  • Police can arrest with or without a warrant.
  • Appearance notices are for minor offenses (e.g., mischief, theft under, shoplifting).
  • Bail hearing within 24 hours before a Justice of the Peace.
Denial of Bail
  • Reasons to deny bail:
    • Not showing up to court.
    • Imminent risk of committing another serious offense.
    • Releasing the accused would result in the police looking very bad.
  • Bail must be granted unless there is a “just cause” to hold in custody.
  • Usually, the Crown has the onus to show cause for detention; sometimes, there is reverse onus on the accused to show why they should be released.
  • The accused must be released after arrest unless there is a compelling reason to detain.
Steps After Arrest
  • Arrest can lead to:
    • Lay information leading to a warrant (if no warrant at arrest).
    • Appearance notice issued by police.
    • Summons issued by a Justice of the Peace.

Preliminary Inquiry

  • A mini-trial to determine whether there is enough evidence to proceed.

Sentencing

  • Occurs after a finding of guilt or a guilty plea.
  • Numerous sentencing options under s. 718 of the Criminal Code:
    • Absolute discharge/conditional discharge.
    • Probation.
    • Suspended sentence.
    • Fine.
    • Incarceration.
    • Earned full parole: one-third of the sentence or 7 years.
    • Day parole: 6 months prior to full parole date.
    • Statutory release: after two-thirds of the sentence.

Courtroom Work Group

  • Informal group of professionals in the criminal justice system.
  • High degree of group cohesion.
  • Shared understanding of normal crimes.
  • Emphasis on speed of process rather than justice.
  • Guilt of the accused is presumed.
  • Secrecy is prized.

Wedding Cake Model

  • Illustrates that the majority of crimes are at the bottom (less serious).
  • Cases become fewer and more serious as you move up the layers.

Informal Organization of the Criminal Justice System

Disparity
  • A difference, not necessarily discrimination, based on legitimate or illegitimate factors.
  • People are treated differently based on our justice system.
Discrimination
  • Differential treatment of individuals based on negative judgments or stereotypes relating to real or perceived membership in a group.

Criminalization

  • Identifying problematic behavior.
  • Defining the behavior as a crime via legislation.
  • Regulating the behavior through law enforcement.
  • Punishing those who commit the behavior.

Substantive Criminal Law

  • Written laws that define specific behaviors as crimes.
  • Based in common values of what is right and wrong.
  • Laws are enacted by parliament.
  • Can be influenced by judicial interpretation.

Procedural Criminal Law

  • Procedures for the processing of cases through the criminal justice system.
  • Principles of fundamental justice: Being fair and equitable.
  • Empowers actions of criminal justice agencies.
  • Safeguards the rights of accused and convicted individuals.
  • Focus on the legal guilt of the offender rather than factual guilt.

Sexual Assault Legislation

Prior to 1983
  • Elements to be found guilty of rape:
    • The complainant had to be female.
    • The accused had to be male.
    • The complainant and accused were not married to each other.
    • Sexual intercourse occurred.
    • The act of intercourse occurred without the consent of the woman.
After 1983
  • Level 1: Least physical injury, unwanted/non-consensual kiss (Hybrid offense).
  • Level 2: Involves weapons, threat of a weapon, or bodily harm (Maximum 14 years’ imprisonment).
  • Level 3: Involves serious bodily harm or endangerment of life (Maximum life imprisonment).

Degrees of Assault

  • Mirrors the sexual assault levels.
  • Common Assault.
  • Assault Causing Bodily Harm.
  • Aggravated Assault.
  • Indictable – most serious punishment.
  • Summary – least serious punishment.
  • Hybrid – the middle of both.

Criminal Liability

  • Crime can be defined by any action:
    • That is harmful.
    • That is prohibited by the criminal law.
    • That can be prosecuted by the state.
    • In a formal court environment.
    • For which a punishment can be imposed.
Legal Elements of A Crime
  • Legality
  • Mens rea (“guilty mind”)
  • Actus reus (“guilty act”)
  • Concurrence of mens rea and actus reus
  • Harm.
  • Causation
  • Punishment

Mens Rea

  • The assumption that a person has the ability to control their behavior and choose a course of action.
Specific Intent
  • The accused had the intent to produce further consequences.
General Intent
  • Inferred from the actions of the accused.

Intent vs. Motive

  • Intent: mental resolve to commit a crime.
  • Motive: reasons for committing a crime.
  • Prosecutor is not required to prove motive.
  • Motive can provide evidence of intent.

Actus Reus

  • The actual action, what happened in the offense.
  • Assumption that the actor alone is responsible for his or her actions.
  • Includes acts of commission (had to have done something) or omission.

Legal Defenses to a Crime

Excuse Defenses
Age
  • Anyone under the age of 12 has no criminal responsibility.
  • Youth between 12 and 18 can be criminally accountable under the Youth Criminal Justice Act.
  • Adults can be fully criminally accountable.
Mental Disorder
  • No person is criminally responsible if they were suffering from a mental disorder that rendered them incapable of appreciating the nature and quality of the act or omission or of knowing that it was wrong.
  • Accused lacks mens rea to commit the offense.
  • Must be a “disease of the mind”.
  • Self-induced states are excluded.
  • Not criminally responsible on account of mental disorder (NCRMD).
  • Mental health services are not liable unless they are negligent.
Automatism
  • Unconscious or involuntary behavior.
  • Requires strong evidence from witnesses.
Mistake of Fact
  • Illegal act committed under mistaken belief about circumstances.
  • Mistake was honest.
  • No offense would have been committed if circumstances were as accused believed.
Mistake of Law
  • Ignorance of the law is not an excuse.
Justification Defenses
Duress
  • Crime is committed because:
    • There is a threat of imminent death or bodily harm.
    • No realistic alternative action.
    • Actions “blameworthy but forgivable”.
Necessity
  • Crime is committed because:
    • There is a danger caused by forces of nature or human conduct other than threats of harm.
    • The accused was in imminent peril.
    • Had no legal alternative.
    • Harm done was proportionate to harm avoided.
Self-Defense
  • Use of force against another person to defend oneself, others, or property is justified.
  • The force used must be proportionate to the threat.
Battered Woman Syndrome
  • Self-defense can be justified in the absence of imminent peril.
Provocation
  • Crime of passion defense.
  • Wrongful act or insult that deprives an ordinary person of self-control.
  • Provocation must be sudden and unexpected.
Entrapment
  • If an agent of state deceives a person into committing a crime.

Sources of Law

Common Law
  • Laws applicable to all, regardless of local custom.
Statute Law
  • Laws that prohibit or mandate certain acts.
Case Law
  • Judicial application and interpretation of law based on facts of case.
Administrative Regulations
  • Rules in areas like environment or competition.
Constitution
  • Supreme law in Canada.
Charter of Rights and Freedoms
  • Investigation of crime: Everyone has the right:
    • Against unreasonable search and seizure – s.8.
    • Against arbitrary detention – s.9.
    • To be informed about reason for arrest/detention – s.10(a).
    • To legal counsel without delay – s.10(b).

Criminal Trial Process

  • Everyone has the right:
    • If charged to be informed without unreasonable delay of the offence – s11(a).
    • To a trial within a reasonable time – s.11(b).
    • Not to be compelled to testify at own proceedings – s11(c).
    • To be presumed innocent until proven guilty s.11(d).
    • Not to be denied reasonable bail – s.11(e).
    • To life liberty and security not to be deprived of the principles of fundamental - s.7.
    • Against cruel and unusual punishment – s.12.
    • Not to have evidence given in one trial used against them in their own/another trial – s.13.
    • Every individual is equal before and under the law – s.15.

Classification of Criminal Offenses

  • Supreme Court exclusive.
  • Absolute jurisdiction.
  • Election indictable.
  • Indictable
  • At Crown’s discretion.
  • Hybrid.
  • Summary Conviction.

Due Process vs. Crime Control

Due Process
  • Individual protections under the charter that limit the power of police and the courts.
Crime Control
  • Power provided to the police and courts to maintain law and order in society.

Criminal Law Reform

Federal Legislation
  • Repealing s.43 of the Criminal Code (“spanking” law).
Provincial Legislation
  • Ontario’s Safe Streets Act (1999): Granted expanded police authority to address issues like homelessness and drug use.
  • Was discriminatory. Gun checks were mainly done on young males and people of colour.