Reconstruction L13

Overview of Reconstruction

  • Definition: Reconstruction refers to the literal rebuilding of the nation and southern states following the Civil War.

  • Time Period: Generally spans from 1865 to 1876/77.

  • Roadmap: Reconstruction unfolds in stages:

    • Presidential Reconstruction: Initial phase led by Presidents Abraham Lincoln and Andrew Johnson.

    • Radical Reconstruction: Later phase where Congress takes control of Reconstruction policies, often referred to as Congressional Reconstruction.

Presidential Reconstruction

  • Key Figures:

    • Abraham Lincoln: Initiated the Reconstruction process with his vision of a lenient policy toward the South.

    • Andrew Johnson: Lincoln's successor; his approach was less visionary and more lenient than that of Congressional members.

  • Lincoln's 10% Plan:

    • Southern states could rejoin the Union when 10% of the voting population took an oath of allegiance to the U.S. and accepted emancipation.

    • Offered amnesty to most southerners except high-ranking Confederate officials.

  • Leniency criticized:

    • Many felt Lincoln's plan was forgiving and did not sufficiently penalize Confederates.

    • Opposition from radical Republicans like Thaddeus Stevens, who advocated for a harsher approach, including confiscation of property and punishment of Confederate leaders.

Events Leading to Reconstruction's Nature

  • Lincoln Assassinated: Lincoln was killed on April 14, 1865, leading to Johnson taking office.

  • Johnson's Approach: Johnson was initially thought to support harsher terms. However, he granted over 13,000 pardons to Confederates and allowed Southern states to rejoin with minimal requirements.

  • Conflict with Congress: Johnson vetoed critical legislation, including the Freedmen's Bureau and the Civil Rights Act of 1866, showing his lack of support for Congressional Reconstruction efforts.

Radical Reconstruction

  • Radical Republicans: The faction aimed to enforce civil rights and ensure equality post-Civil War.

    • Prominent leaders included Charles Sumner and Thaddeus Stevens.

  • Reconstruction Amendments: The core of Radical Reconstruction policy.

    • 13th Amendment: Abolishes slavery (with the caveat of punishment for crimes).

    • 14th Amendment:

    • Grants citizenship to all born in the U.S., defining birthright citizenship.

    • Establishes equal protection of the laws and mandates due process.

    • Introduces enforcement power grants to Congress.

    • 15th Amendment: Prohibits voting discrimination based on race, color, or previous condition of servitude.

Social Changes and Pushback

  • Black Codes: Laws passed in the South attempting to restrict the rights of African Americans and perpetuating inequalities.

  • Ku Klux Klan Formation: Emerged as a paramilitary organization aimed at terrorizing African Americans and their allies, resulting in significant violence during Reconstruction.

    • Notable incidents include the Colfax Massacre and the New Orleans Massacre.

Freedmen's Bureau

  • An agency designed to assist formerly enslaved people, it oversaw land distribution and labor disputes and was responsible for setting up the Freedmen’s Schools.

    • It was seen as one of the most ambitious government-funded social welfare initiatives.

Conclusion of Reconstruction

  • End of Reconstruction: Often marked by the election of 1876, wherein a compromise led to the withdrawal of federal troops from the South and the cessation of federal oversight of Southern states.

  • Key Questions for Historians:

    • Was Reconstruction a success or a failure?

    • How did it change the landscape of civil rights in the U.S.?

    • What were the long-term impacts of the Reconstruction amendments?