Chapter 6 Lectures: Applying Newton's Laws: Banked Curve With Friction

Mechanics of Banked Curves with Friction

  • Realistic curved embankments involve three distinct forces acting on an object or vehicle:

    • The gravitational force or weight (w=mgw = mg), acting vertically downward toward the center of the Earth.

    • The normal force (nn), acting perpendicular to the inclined road surface.

    • The static friction force (fsf_s), acting parallel to the surface of the incline between the tires (or board) and the pavement.

  • Static friction is a reactionary force that adjusts its magnitude and direction depending on the velocity of the vehicle relative to the rated speed:

    • The rated speed (vratedv_{\text{rated}}) is the speed at which a vehicle can negotiate the curve purely due to the radial component of the normal force, requiring zero frictional force.

    • When traveling below the rated speed (v<vratedv < v_{\text{rated}}), the vehicle tends to slide down the embankment. To counteract this downward slip, static friction must point up the incline.

    • When traveling above the rated speed (v>vratedv > v_{\text{rated}}), the vehicle tends to slide up the embankment. To counteract this upward slip, static friction must point down the incline.

  • A practical demonstration of this phenomenon is observed in snowboarding on banked turns:

    • Inexperienced snowboarders who travel too slowly around banked turns slide down the ramp and fall.

    • To negotiate the bank smoothly without relying excessively on friction to prevent slipping down, riders must maintain sufficient speed.

  • Because static friction can act either up or down the slope, there exists a safe range of speeds (vmin⁡≤v≤vmax⁡v_{\min} \le v \le v_{\max}) within which a vehicle can traverse the turn without skidding up or down the ramp.

Coordinate System and Geometric Decomposition

  • For an embankment inclined at an angle θ\theta with horizontal curvature:

    • The center of the circular trajectory lies along a horizontal plane inside the curve.

    • The horizontal centripetal acceleration (aca_c or ara_r) is directed purely horizontally toward the center of curvature.

  • The selected coordinate system establishes:

    • The positive yy-axis oriented vertically upward.

    • The positive radial axis (rr) oriented horizontally toward the center of the circular path.

  • Determining vector angles using Euclidean geometry:

    • The angle of the incline relative to the horizontal is θ\theta.

    • The angle between the inclined surface and the vertical is 90∘−θ90^\circ - \theta.

    • The normal force (nn) is perpendicular to the incline, placing it at an angle θ\theta with respect to the vertical positive yy-axis.

    • The static friction vector (fsf_s) lies along the incline, placing it at an angle θ\theta with respect to the horizontal radial axis via alternate interior angles.

  • Component decomposition of the forces for the minimum speed case (fsf_s pointing up the incline):

    • Normal force radial component: nr=nsin⁡(θ)n_r = n \sin(\theta), pointing in the positive radial direction (toward the center).

    • Normal force vertical component: ny=ncos⁡(θ)n_y = n \cos(\theta), pointing in the positive vertical direction.

    • Static friction radial component: fsr=fscos⁡(θ)f_{sr} = f_s \cos(\theta), pointing in the negative radial direction (away from the center).

    • Static friction vertical component: fsy=fssin⁡(θ)f_{sy} = f_s \sin(\theta), pointing in the positive vertical direction.

    • Weight vertical component: wy=−mgw_y = -mg, pointing in the negative vertical direction (wr=0w_r = 0).

  • Graphical vector constraints:

    • In the vertical direction, the sum of the vertical projections of the normal force and static friction must balance the weight vector: ncos⁡(θ)+fssin⁡(θ)=mgn \cos(\theta) + f_s \sin(\theta) = mg.

    • Vector diagrams must accurately preserve component lengths: the projection of nn onto the radial axis matches the horizontal extent of the vector, and the projection onto the yy-axis matches its vertical extent.

Derivation of Minimum Speed (vmin⁡v_{\min})

  • Minimum speed (vmin⁡v_{\min}) represents the absolute lowest speed a vehicle can travel along the curve without sliding down the embankment.

  • Application of Newton's second law along the radial direction:

    • ∑Fr=mar\sum F_r = m a_r

    • nr−fsr=mv2rn_r - f_{sr} = m \frac{v^2}{r}

    • nsin⁡(θ)−fscos⁡(θ)=mv2rn \sin(\theta) - f_s \cos(\theta) = m \frac{v^2}{r}

  • Application of Newton's second law along the vertical direction (assuming equilibrium without vertical slip, ay=0a_y = 0):

    • ∑Fy=may=0\sum F_y = m a_y = 0

    • ny+fsy−mg=0n_y + f_{sy} - mg = 0

    • ncos⁡(θ)+fssin⁡(θ)=mgn \cos(\theta) + f_s \sin(\theta) = mg

  • Threshold of slipping condition:

    • Static friction reaches its maximum possible value at the threshold of slipping: fs=μsnf_s = \mu_s n, where μs\mu_s is the coefficient of static friction.

  • Substituting fs=μsnf_s = \mu_s n into the vertical equation:

    • ncos⁡(θ)+μsnsin⁡(θ)=mgn \cos(\theta) + \mu_s n \sin(\theta) = mg

    • Factoring out the normal force: n(cos⁡(θ)+μssin⁡(θ))=mgn (\cos(\theta) + \mu_s \sin(\theta)) = mg

    • Solving for nn: n=mgcos⁡(θ)+μssin⁡(θ)n = \frac{mg}{\cos(\theta) + \mu_s \sin(\theta)}

  • Substituting fs=μsnf_s = \mu_s n into the radial equation:

    • nsin⁡(θ)−μsncos⁡(θ)=mv2rn \sin(\theta) - \mu_s n \cos(\theta) = \frac{m v^2}{r}

    • Factoring out the normal force: n(sin⁡(θ)−μscos⁡(θ))=mv2rn (\sin(\theta) - \mu_s \cos(\theta)) = \frac{m v^2}{r}

  • Combining the equations to eliminate nn:

    • (mgcos⁡(θ)+μssin⁡(θ))(sin⁡(θ)−μscos⁡(θ))=mv2r\left(\frac{mg}{\cos(\theta) + \mu_s \sin(\theta)}\right) (\sin(\theta) - \mu_s \cos(\theta)) = \frac{m v^2}{r}

  • Independence of mass:

    • The mass mm appears as a common factor on both sides of the equation and cancels out entirely, demonstrating that minimum negotiating speed is independent of vehicle mass.

  • Solving for speed vv yields the trigonometric expression for minimum speed:

    • vmin⁡=gr(sin⁡(θ)−μscos⁡(θ)cos⁡(θ)+μssin⁡(θ))v_{\min} = \sqrt{g r \left(\frac{\sin(\theta) - \mu_s \cos(\theta)}{\cos(\theta) + \mu_s \sin(\theta)}\right)}

Algebraic Simplification to Tangent Formulation

  • To reduce the number of independent trigonometric terms and facilitate physical analysis, the fractional term is multiplied by unity in the form of 1cos⁡(θ)1cos⁡(θ)\frac{\frac{1}{\cos(\theta)}}{\frac{1}{\cos(\theta)}}.

  • Step-by-step algebraic distribution:

    • Numerator: sin⁡(θ)cos⁡(θ)−μscos⁡(θ)cos⁡(θ)=tan⁡(θ)−μs\frac{\sin(\theta)}{\cos(\theta)} - \mu_s \frac{\cos(\theta)}{\cos(\theta)} = \tan(\theta) - \mu_s

    • Denominator: cos⁡(θ)cos⁡(θ)+μssin⁡(θ)cos⁡(θ)=1+μstan⁡(θ)\frac{\cos(\theta)}{\cos(\theta)} + \mu_s \frac{\sin(\theta)}{\cos(\theta)} = 1 + \mu_s \tan(\theta)

  • Resulting compact formula for minimum speed:

    • vmin⁡=gr(tan⁡(θ)−μs1+μstan⁡(θ))v_{\min} = \sqrt{g r \left(\frac{\tan(\theta) - \mu_s}{1 + \mu_s \tan(\theta)}\right)}

Physical and Mathematical Analysis of Minimum Speed

  • Domain constraints of the angle θ\theta:

    • The banking angle is bounded within 0∘≤θ<90∘0^\circ \le \theta < 90^\circ (road embankments cannot reach or exceed vertical orientation).

    • Within this range, tan⁡(θ)≥0\tan(\theta) \ge 0, ensuring that the denominator 1+μstan⁡(θ)1 + \mu_s \tan(\theta) is always strictly positive.

  • Behavior of the acceleration due to gravity and radius:

    • g=9.8 m/s2g = 9.8\,m/s^2 (magnitude of gravitational acceleration).

    • Radius of curvature r>0r > 0.

  • Mathematical conditions on the numerator tan⁡(θ)−μs\tan(\theta) - \mu_s:

    • Case 1: tan⁡(θ)−μs>0\tan(\theta) - \mu_s > 0 (tan⁡(θ)>μs\tan(\theta) > \mu_s):

    • The term under the square root is positive, yielding a real-valued positive speed.

    • A finite, non-zero minimum speed vmin⁡v_{\min} is required to prevent the vehicle from sliding down the embankment.

    • Case 2: tan⁡(θ)−μs≤0\tan(\theta) - \mu_s \le 0 (tan⁡(θ)≤μs\tan(\theta) \le \mu_s):

    • Evaluating the expression under the square root produces a negative or zero value, which mathematically results in a complex or zero number.

    • In physical terms, an imaginary minimum velocity means that no minimum speed is necessary (vmin⁡=0v_{\min} = 0).

    • The vehicle or object can come to a complete standstill (v=0v = 0) without sliding down the slope.

  • Connection to the classical inclined plane problem:

    • When tan⁡(θ)=μs\tan(\theta) = \mu_s, the minimum speed required is exactly zero.

    • In standard statics experiments, the static friction coefficient μs\mu_s is empirically determined by tilting an inclined plane until an object begins to slide, where the critical angle satisfies μs=tan⁡(θ)\mu_s = \tan(\theta).

    • A banked curve behaves precisely like an inclined plane when the tangential speed is zero, confirming the self-consistency of Newtonian mechanics.

  • Real-world application:

    • When parking a vehicle on steep hills (such as the hills of San Francisco), the vehicle will remain stationary without slipping down if and only if μs≥tan⁡(θ)\mu_s \ge \tan(\theta).

Formulation and Analysis of Maximum Speed (vmax⁡v_{\max})

  • Maximum speed (vmax⁡v_{\max}) represents the fastest speed a vehicle can travel through a curve without skidding up and out of the embankment.

  • Dynamic adjustments in the free body diagram for maximum speed:

    • Because the vehicle is on the verge of sliding upward, static friction (fsf_s) reverses direction and points down the incline.

    • The radial component of friction points in the positive radial direction (toward the center), reinforcing centripetal acceleration: fsr=fscos⁡(θ)f_{sr} = f_s \cos(\theta).

    • The vertical component of friction points in the negative vertical direction: fsy=−fssin⁡(θ)f_{sy} = -f_s \sin(\theta).

  • Resulting equation for maximum speed:

    • vmax⁡=gr(tan⁡(θ)+μs1−μstan⁡(θ))v_{\max} = \sqrt{g r \left(\frac{\tan(\theta) + \mu_s}{1 - \mu_s \tan(\theta)}\right)}

    • Structurally, the signs in the numerator and denominator are inverted compared to the formula for vmin⁡v_{\min}.

  • Physical analysis of the denominator term 1−μstan⁡(θ)1 - \mu_s \tan(\theta):

    • The tangent function tan⁡(θ)=sin⁡(θ)cos⁡(θ)\tan(\theta) = \frac{\sin(\theta)}{\cos(\theta)} has a vertical asymptote at θ=90∘\theta = 90^\circ and takes values from 00 to ∞\infty over the domain [0∘,90∘)[0^\circ, 90^\circ).

    • Case 1: μstan⁡(θ)<1\mu_s \tan(\theta) < 1

    • The denominator is positive, yielding a real-valued finite maximum speed vmax⁡v_{\max}.

    • Case 2: μstan⁡(θ)≥1\mu_s \tan(\theta) \ge 1

    • When μstan⁡(θ)>1\mu_s \tan(\theta) > 1, the denominator becomes negative, producing an imaginary result under the square root.

    • In physical terms, an imaginary maximum speed means that no maximum speed threshold exists (vmax⁡→∞v_{\max} \rightarrow \infty).

    • The combination of friction and incline geometry ensures the vehicle will never slide up the incline, no matter how fast it travels.

    • Relativistic constraint:

    • While classical Newtonian mechanics permits an infinite speed in this condition, actual motion remains fundamentally bounded by Einstein's theory of special relativity, which dictates that no object can exceed the speed of light (cc).

Derivation Methodology and Protocol

  • A complete derivation of banked curve dynamics under Newton's laws requires the following sequential steps:

    • Step 1: Draw a comprehensive free body diagram clearly displaying the three active forces (ww, nn, and fsf_s).

    • Step 2: Establish the coordinate system with positive vertical yy oriented upward and positive radial rr directed horizontally toward the center of curvature.

    • Step 3: Decompose the normal force and static friction into radial and vertical components using correct trigonometric projections based on the incline angle θ\theta.

    • Step 4: Formulate the equations of motion using Newton's second law along both axes:

    • Radial direction: ∑Fr=mar=mv2r\sum F_r = m a_r = m \frac{v^2}{r}

    • Vertical direction: ∑Fy=may=0\sum F_y = m a_y = 0

    • Step 5: Apply the threshold condition for maximum static friction: fs=μsnf_s = \mu_s n.

    • Step 6: Factor out the normal force nn from both equations, eliminate nn, and verify the cancellation of mass mm.

    • Step 7: Solve explicitly for tangential speed (vmin⁡v_{\min} or vmax⁡v_{\max}) and simplify into tangent form via multiplication by 1/cos⁡(θ)1/cos⁡(θ)\frac{1/\cos(\theta)}{1/\cos(\theta)}.

Questions and Discussion

  • Question (Josiah):

    • In the condition for static friction where the magnitude is bounded by fs≤μsnf_s \le \mu_s n, does the inequality sign flip when solving for the maximum speed case (vmax⁡v_{\max})?

  • Response and Explanation:

    • The sign does not flip. For both the minimum speed (vmin⁡v_{\min}) and maximum speed (vmax⁡v_{\max}) cases, the equation uses the exact equality: fs=μsnf_s = \mu_s n.

    • Static friction is an adaptive, variable force. When a small external force is applied, static friction matches the opposing force exactly to maintain equilibrium.

    • As the applied force increases, static friction increases proportionally until it reaches its upper threshold: fs,max⁡=μsnf_{s,\max} = \mu_s n.

    • Both vmin⁡v_{\min} and vmax⁡v_{\max} represent the extreme outer boundaries of static equilibrium where the tires are on the verge of slipping. Therefore, static friction is operating at its maximum capacity (fs=μsnf_s = \mu_s n) in both scenarios.

    • Once the applied lateral forces exceed μsn\mu_s n, the surfaces slip relative to each other, and the system transitions into the kinetic friction regime.