Module 3: Kinship Relatedness and Gender Study Notes

Module Overview

  • Introduction to ASB 102: Kinship Relatedness and Gender

    • Core sub-disciplines of cultural anthropology examined: kinship and gender.

    • Goals for the module:

      • Explain the term kinship in anthropology.

      • Discuss the centrality of kinship in cultural anthropology.

      • Define important kinship terms.

      • Explain cultural anthropological approaches to gender.

      • Discuss cultural impacts on concepts of biology and the natural world.

  • Activities involved:

    • Two short lectures.

    • Required readings from textbook chapters (one on kinship, one on gender).

    • Short quizzes and a discussion prompt on Yellowdig.

  • Reading guidance: Focus on specific extracts from lengthy chapter on gender.

Lecture 1: Kinship

Understanding Kinship in Anthropology

  • Anthropologists study kinship as a cross-cultural understanding of family and relatedness.

    • Focus on societal definitions of relatives and rights/obligations associated with kinship status.

    • Key kinship roles examined through terms: mother, father, brother, sister, cousin, etc.

  • Interest in social roles that these terms convey:

    • Example: Obligations and behaviors expected from a mother or an uncle.

  • Impact of age and gender on roles within families:

    • Distinctions in rights and responsibilities between oldest son and youngest daughter, such as inheritance and care.

Distinction between Biological and Social Kinship

  • Kinship definitions do not strictly adhere to biological relatedness.

    • Emphasizes social construction of kinship in various cultures.

    • Consanguineal (blood) and affinal (marriage) relationships studied.

  • Importance of cultural context:

    • All cultures have familial structures, but they vary significantly.

    • Example of shifting roles of parents in the U.S. since the 1950s.

Historical Context and Importance of Kinship in Anthropology

  • Traditional centrality of kinship studies in cultural anthropology:

    • Late 19th and early 20th-century ethnographies heavily focused on kinship systems.

    • Kinship structures as essential for understanding social organization.

  • Decline in kinship study's centrality in anthropology in the latter half of the 20th century:

    • Increasing focus on gender studies and the anthropology of the body.

  • Resurgence of kinship studies in the 21st century:

    • Topics include transnational adoption, LGBTQ+ communities, surrogacy, and reproductive technologies.

Concepts of Descent in Kinship

  • Concept of descent as a way to reckon ancestry and define relatives.

    • Unilineal descent: Reckoned through one line (patrilineal or matrilineal).

      • Patrilineal: Descended from the father's lineage.

      • Matrilineal: Descended from the mother's lineage.

    • Bilateral descent: Equal kinship ties on both maternal and paternal sides.

  • Variations in marriage practices based on cultural descent patterns.

  • Incest taboos as rules against marrying close relatives:

    • Human universality observed, with varying definitions based on cultural perspectives.

    • Example: Differences in cousin marriage eligibility based on descent systems.

Endogamy and Exogamy in Marriage Practices

  • Endogamy: Marriage practices within a specific cultural or religious group.

    • Importance in maintaining religious/cultural ties.

    • Example: Orthodox Jewish community.

  • Exogamy: Marriage practices that promote relationships outside one’s group.

    • Dominance of in-group economic and cultural similarities in broader societal contexts.

    • Example: Similar socioeconomic backgrounds in marriages in the U.S.

  • Links to economic factors in kinship:

    • Economic roles in families; connected to concepts of production and consumption.

    • Practical implications of kinship beyond emotional bonds.

Dowry and Bride Wealth

  • Dowry: Goods or money that a bride's family provides to the groom's family upon marriage.

    • Varied meanings in different cultures and economic contexts:

      • Can offset costs of integrating a bride into a new family unit.

      • Seen as a form of women’s property or inheritance in certain cultures.

  • Bride wealth: Payment from the groom's family to the bride's family.

    • Acknowledges the bride’s contributions to the new family.

    • Example from the Maasai culture, where value is determined by the desirability of the partner.

Post-Marriage Residence Patterns

  • Neolocal residence: Expectations for couples to establish their own homes after marriage (common in the U.S.).

  • Patrilocal residence: Newly married women moving to or near their husband’s family (historical norm in several cultures).

  • Matrilocal residence: Newly married men moving to or near their wife’s family (observed in cultures like Hopi and Navajo).

LGBTQ+ Kinship Studies

  • Examination of kinship structures within LGBTQ+ communities:

    • Classic study by Kath Weston in the 1980s about queer kinship in San Francisco.

    • Importance of love and intimacy in chosen families as a critical aspect of kinship.

    • Critiques of traditional definitions of family based on procreation.

    • Insider ethnography: Research conducted by a member of the community studied.

Lecture 2: Gender and Cultural Anthropology

Understanding Gender

  • Cultural anthropologists view gender as a socially constructed identity, distinct from biological sex.

  • Biological sex: Anatomical differences; gender: culturally specific roles, behaviors, expectations.

    • These notions are learned and enacted rather than innate.

    • Example of explicit and implicit teaching of gender norms:

      • Chastised children for violating gender norms (unladylike behavior or manning up).

Cultural Differences in Gender Roles

  • Gender roles vary significantly across cultures.

    • Euro American culture: Women viewed as naturally nurturing, and men as emotional providers.

    • Contrast with AKA culture where men are involved in nurturing and infant care—a non-stigmatized role.

    • Mosuo culture: Women perform labor outside home, while men partake in raising children of matrilineage.

Third Genders and Cultural Performance

  • Hijra culture in India as a recognized third gender:

    • Forms its own gender identity distinct from male and female.

    • Involved in spiritual rituals, but face societal discrimination.

  • The anthropologist Serena Nanda's book illustrates Hijra's roles within societal frameworks.

Influences of Feminist Anthropology

  • Emergence of feminist anthropology from the 1970s advocating for the inclusion of gender relations in cultural analysis.

    • Acknowledgment of women's roles and experiences as essential perspectives in anthropology.

    • Rise of queer anthropology exploring LGBTQ+ identities and relationships.

Cultural Construction of Gender in Biology

  • Emily Martin’s critique in “The Egg and the Sperm” highlights cultural bias in scientific descriptions of reproduction.

    • Male sperm depicted as active agents; female eggs portrayed as passive.

    • Stereotypes about male supremacy versus female passivity embedded in scientific language.

    • Examination of how these cultural assumptions influence understanding of biological processes and gender roles.

    • Examples showcasing the active role of the egg in reproduction that contradicts stereotypes.

Conclusion

  • Kinship and gender studies provide insights into how cultural constructs shape our understanding of family and societal roles.

  • Importance of recognizing the intersectionality of gender and kinship in cultural anthropology research, particularly in the context of broader societal influences.

  • Transition to Module 4 with a promise of continued exploration of anthropological themes.