Chapter 11: Elections

Democracy in Athens, c. 508-322 BCE

Citizens ruled directly, not through representatives

What they voted on:

  • The Assembly met about 40 times a year on the Pnyx held about 6,000-8,000 and 6,000 was the quorum for some votes

    • War, peace, treaties

    • Laws and decrees

    • Taxes, spending and the navy

    • Electing the 10 generals

    • Ostracism, exiling one citizen for 10 years

How they voted:

  • In person, as individuals, no parties, no representatives

    • Assembly: show of hands, estimated rather than counted

    • Courts: secret ballot with pebbles, later bronze discs

    • Ostracism: names scratched on pottery shards; at least 6,000 ballots needed

Beyond voting:

  • Sortition: Most offices filled by lot, using a machine

  • Council of 500: 50 per tribe, RAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

The logic of elections

  • High transaction costs → need to delegate

  • But, delegation can lead to corrupt, self-serving politicians

  • Solution? Regular elections

Who voted?

  • With notable restrictions:

    • Each limited voting to property owners

    • Many denied Catholics, Jews, Native Americans, and formerly enslaved people the franchise

    • Women rarely permitted

  • In total, only about half of the free adult male population was eligible to vote at the time the Constitution was adopted

Wider Suffrage for Men

  • Initial restrictions reflected the basic social realities of England

    • Upper-class landed men took for granted their right to govern the less-fortunate masses

    • Granting suffrage endangered the hegemony they enjoyed

  • The reasons for restricting franchise eroded in the colonies:

    • Land much easier to acquire

    • By the revolutionary period any “respectable” man was typically permitted to vote

    • “No taxation without representation,” initially a demand for home rule, also implied suffrage for all taxpayers

    • Men who risked their lives in the Revolution felt entitled to suffrage regardless of wealth

Suffrage for African Americans

  • Formally came with the passage of the 15th Amendment RAHHHHHHHHHHHH

Suffrage for Women

  • Utilized much of the same logic as earning white men suffrage

  • Women’s suffrage movement grew from antislavery

    • Anger that 15th amendment extended voting rights to black men before white women

  • Resistance to women’s suffrage overcome by social change and political need:

    • Expanded education

    • Western territories where women were hoped to vote for “Family values”

  • Tied to the temperance movement

Most Recent Expansion: Youth

  • 1971’s Twenty-Sixth Amendment lowered voting age to eighteen years

  • Young people were the predominant antiwar activists and the majority of the troops fighting in Vietnam

  • Echoed Revolutionary War logic - those paying the price should have a voice


  • While the youth overwhelmingly preferred McGovern to Nixon, Nixon realized that young likely voters would favor him. In 1972, 49% of young voters chose Richard Nixon

Who Votes?

What is a turnout rate?

  • Proportion of voters to the population size of eligible voters

  • Sounds easy!


Possible denominators:

  • Voting Age Population (VAP)

  • Voting Age Citizens (VAC)

  • Voting Eligible Population (VEP)

  • Registered Voters (RV)

Possible numerators:

  • Cast ballots

  • Cast eligible ballots

  • Self-report for casting ballots


  • Example district with a population of 10,000 with 8,000 age 18 and over

    • VAP = 8,000

    • 500 ineligible, therefore VEP = 7,500/10,000 = 75%

    • 7,000 registered, therefore RV = 7,000/10,000 = 75%

Turnout by Age

  • The three younger generations- those ages 18 to 53 in 2018-reported casting 62.2 million votes, compared with 60.1million cast by baby boomers and older generations

  • RAHHHHHHHHHHHHH

Campaigns

Candidates and Messages

  • Campaigners account for voters’ reliance on the free information and shortcuts they provide, tailoring their campaigns accordingly

    • Intensely pragmatic and opportunistic

    • Variable, adapting to differing circumstances

  • Candidate entry is strategic

    • Quality of congressional candidates varies with their prospects of success—talented and ambitious candidates are unlikely to run if their chances of winning are remote

Get Out the Message

  • Message- the answer to the voter’s question: why should I vote for this candidate rather than another?

    • Highlights why a particular candidate is the best choice

    • Campaigns invest in research where they can afford it, making wealthy presidential campaigns sink significant funds into focus groups

    • Focus group- sessions in which a small number of ordinary citizens are observed as they talk with one another about political candidates, issues, and events

  • Campaign messages are chosen opportunistically

    • Depends on national context and who is running against whom

    • Congressional races use the same strategies as presidential ones

    • Campaign ads!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Showing that “IM JUST LIKE YOU!”

  • Candidates want to convey they understand and care about fellow citizens

    • Emphasize impressive credentials but also commonalities

    • Implicit message is empathy, if not belongingness

  • Actions may instead subvert intended messages of unity by showing candidates as out-of-touch or culturally ignorant

Getting Attention (most money is being spent on)

  • Acquiring and maintaining an appropriate image is challenging for presidential candidates under intense observation by their party, opponents, and the news media

    • Campaigns begin shortly after midterms in most cases

  • Candidates with famous names have an added advantage:

    • George W. Bush, Ronald Reagan, Donald Trump, and Hiliary Clinton

  • RAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

Media Attention

  • News organizations increasingly lean on one-on-one, televised “town hall” sessions

  • Televised debates are challenging, especially for those unaccustomed or uncomfortable in front of the camera

    • However, opting out is not a viable strategy as the media and public both expect a deabte

    • Debates remain popular although they rarely cover new ground; they show candidates up close and under sustained pressure

    • Have a minimal effect on outcomes


  • The first debate: September 26, 1960. JFK vs. Nixon

Campaign Money

  • Currently, all money for major federal campaigns comes from private sources

  • Privately sourced election funds raise two problems:

    • Money is distributed unequally, giving it an unequal role in electoral politics

    • Private financing raises the suspicion that elected officials are agents of their contributors and not their constituents

  • Central dilemma: meaningful elections require money, but the pursuit of money subverts democratic political equality

    • Efforts to resolve this dilemma have largely failed

    • RAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

Federal Election Campaign Act of 1971 (FECA)

  • Provided partial public funding for presidential campaigns

  • Required full public reporting of and strict limits on contributions and expenditures

  • Established Federal Election Commission for enforcement and to publish info on campaign contributions and expenditures

  • SC RAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHh

Soft Money: From loophole to Ban

  • 2002: BCRA Bans party soft money- Reformers’ top target. The Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act bars parties from raising or spending soft money for federal candidates

  • Soft money- Unregulated party funds for party-building and get-out-the-vote

  • Hard Money- Raised and spent under FECA’s contribution and spending limits

After BCRA: Money Moves to Outside Groups

  • 2010- Citizens United: No limits on independent spending by any organization, including corporations and union. (Money is a form of promoting opinion!!!)