Chapter 11: Elections
Democracy in Athens, c. 508-322 BCE
Citizens ruled directly, not through representatives
What they voted on:
The Assembly met about 40 times a year on the Pnyx held about 6,000-8,000 and 6,000 was the quorum for some votes
War, peace, treaties
Laws and decrees
Taxes, spending and the navy
Electing the 10 generals
Ostracism, exiling one citizen for 10 years
How they voted:
In person, as individuals, no parties, no representatives
Assembly: show of hands, estimated rather than counted
Courts: secret ballot with pebbles, later bronze discs
Ostracism: names scratched on pottery shards; at least 6,000 ballots needed
Beyond voting:
Sortition: Most offices filled by lot, using a machine
Council of 500: 50 per tribe, RAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
The logic of elections
High transaction costs → need to delegate
But, delegation can lead to corrupt, self-serving politicians
Solution? Regular elections
Who voted?
With notable restrictions:
Each limited voting to property owners
Many denied Catholics, Jews, Native Americans, and formerly enslaved people the franchise
Women rarely permitted
In total, only about half of the free adult male population was eligible to vote at the time the Constitution was adopted
Wider Suffrage for Men
Initial restrictions reflected the basic social realities of England
Upper-class landed men took for granted their right to govern the less-fortunate masses
Granting suffrage endangered the hegemony they enjoyed
The reasons for restricting franchise eroded in the colonies:
Land much easier to acquire
By the revolutionary period any “respectable” man was typically permitted to vote
“No taxation without representation,” initially a demand for home rule, also implied suffrage for all taxpayers
Men who risked their lives in the Revolution felt entitled to suffrage regardless of wealth
Suffrage for African Americans
Formally came with the passage of the 15th Amendment RAHHHHHHHHHHHH
Suffrage for Women
Utilized much of the same logic as earning white men suffrage
Women’s suffrage movement grew from antislavery
Anger that 15th amendment extended voting rights to black men before white women
Resistance to women’s suffrage overcome by social change and political need:
Expanded education
Western territories where women were hoped to vote for “Family values”
Tied to the temperance movement
Most Recent Expansion: Youth
1971’s Twenty-Sixth Amendment lowered voting age to eighteen years
Young people were the predominant antiwar activists and the majority of the troops fighting in Vietnam
Echoed Revolutionary War logic - those paying the price should have a voice
While the youth overwhelmingly preferred McGovern to Nixon, Nixon realized that young likely voters would favor him. In 1972, 49% of young voters chose Richard Nixon
Who Votes?
What is a turnout rate?
Proportion of voters to the population size of eligible voters
Sounds easy!
Possible denominators:
Voting Age Population (VAP)
Voting Age Citizens (VAC)
Voting Eligible Population (VEP)
Registered Voters (RV)
Possible numerators:
Cast ballots
Cast eligible ballots
Self-report for casting ballots
Example district with a population of 10,000 with 8,000 age 18 and over
VAP = 8,000
500 ineligible, therefore VEP = 7,500/10,000 = 75%
7,000 registered, therefore RV = 7,000/10,000 = 75%
Turnout by Age
The three younger generations- those ages 18 to 53 in 2018-reported casting 62.2 million votes, compared with 60.1million cast by baby boomers and older generations
RAHHHHHHHHHHHHH
Campaigns
Candidates and Messages
Campaigners account for voters’ reliance on the free information and shortcuts they provide, tailoring their campaigns accordingly
Intensely pragmatic and opportunistic
Variable, adapting to differing circumstances
Candidate entry is strategic
Quality of congressional candidates varies with their prospects of success—talented and ambitious candidates are unlikely to run if their chances of winning are remote
Get Out the Message
Message- the answer to the voter’s question: why should I vote for this candidate rather than another?
Highlights why a particular candidate is the best choice
Campaigns invest in research where they can afford it, making wealthy presidential campaigns sink significant funds into focus groups
Focus group- sessions in which a small number of ordinary citizens are observed as they talk with one another about political candidates, issues, and events
Campaign messages are chosen opportunistically
Depends on national context and who is running against whom
Congressional races use the same strategies as presidential ones
Campaign ads!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Showing that “IM JUST LIKE YOU!”
Candidates want to convey they understand and care about fellow citizens
Emphasize impressive credentials but also commonalities
Implicit message is empathy, if not belongingness
Actions may instead subvert intended messages of unity by showing candidates as out-of-touch or culturally ignorant
Getting Attention (most money is being spent on)
Acquiring and maintaining an appropriate image is challenging for presidential candidates under intense observation by their party, opponents, and the news media
Campaigns begin shortly after midterms in most cases
Candidates with famous names have an added advantage:
George W. Bush, Ronald Reagan, Donald Trump, and Hiliary Clinton
RAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
Media Attention
News organizations increasingly lean on one-on-one, televised “town hall” sessions
Televised debates are challenging, especially for those unaccustomed or uncomfortable in front of the camera
However, opting out is not a viable strategy as the media and public both expect a deabte
Debates remain popular although they rarely cover new ground; they show candidates up close and under sustained pressure
Have a minimal effect on outcomes
The first debate: September 26, 1960. JFK vs. Nixon
Campaign Money
Currently, all money for major federal campaigns comes from private sources
Privately sourced election funds raise two problems:
Money is distributed unequally, giving it an unequal role in electoral politics
Private financing raises the suspicion that elected officials are agents of their contributors and not their constituents
Central dilemma: meaningful elections require money, but the pursuit of money subverts democratic political equality
Efforts to resolve this dilemma have largely failed
RAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
Federal Election Campaign Act of 1971 (FECA)
Provided partial public funding for presidential campaigns
Required full public reporting of and strict limits on contributions and expenditures
Established Federal Election Commission for enforcement and to publish info on campaign contributions and expenditures
SC RAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHh
Soft Money: From loophole to Ban
2002: BCRA Bans party soft money- Reformers’ top target. The Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act bars parties from raising or spending soft money for federal candidates
Soft money- Unregulated party funds for party-building and get-out-the-vote
Hard Money- Raised and spent under FECA’s contribution and spending limits
After BCRA: Money Moves to Outside Groups
2010- Citizens United: No limits on independent spending by any organization, including corporations and union. (Money is a form of promoting opinion!!!)