Genomics
Feature | Sanger – Capillary Electrophoresis | Nanopore Sequencing | PacBio HiFi Long-Read | Illumina – Sequencing by Synthesis |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Basic idea | DNA is copied using ddNTPs, which terminate DNA synthesis. Fragments are separated by size in a capillary. | DNA passes through a nanopore; changes in electrical current identify the bases. | DNA is copied repeatedly in a circular molecule; multiple passes create a highly accurate consensus sequence. | DNA is copied one base at a time using fluorescently labeled nucleotides. |
How bases are detected | Fluorescent ddNTPs | Electrical current changes | Fluorescent signals from DNA synthesis | Fluorescence from each incorporated base |
Read length | Short (~500–1,000 bp) | Very long (often 10 kb–100+ kb) | Long (~10–25+ kb commonly) | Short (~50–300 bp) |
Accuracy | Very high | High, but historically lower than Illumina/PacBio HiFi; improving | Extremely high (~99.9%+) | Extremely high (~99.9%+) |
Can sequence long DNA? | ❌ No | ✅ Excellent | ✅ Excellent | ❌ No |
Amount of DNA needed | Relatively small | Small/moderate | Relatively more DNA and careful preparation | Small/moderate |
Speed | Moderate | Very fast / real-time | Moderate | Fast |
Amount of data | Low | Very high | High | Very high |
Best for | Sequencing a single gene/fragment or checking a specific mutation | Very long DNA, structural variants, genomes, repetitive regions | Highly accurate long reads, genome assembly, structural variants | Large-scale sequencing, whole genomes, RNA-seq, many samples |
Main advantage | Simple, reliable, very accurate | Longest reads + real-time sequencing | Long reads + extremely high accuracy | Extremely accurate + lots of data + relatively inexpensive |
Main disadvantage | Low throughput and short reads | Error rate can be higher; DNA quality can matter | More expensive/complex; requires high-quality DNA | Short reads make repetitive/complex regions difficult |
Typical use | “Did this particular DNA sequence change?” | “What does this very long DNA region look like?” | “Give me the long sequence, but make it extremely accurate.” | “Sequence millions/billions of bases very accurately.” |