C5- Attention

COGNITION - CHAPTER 5: PAYING ATTENTION

Lecture Outline

  • Selective Attention

  • Selection via Priming

    • Priming based on Stimulus (no cost) or Expectation (cost if mis-cuing happened)

  • Spatial Attention

  • Divided Attention

  • Practice, Automaticity, and Attentional Resources Required

Understanding Attention

  • The term "attention" encompasses various mental processes, indicating different cognitive functions.

  • Different forms of attention likely have distinct neural control centers and are not interchangeable.

  • The word "attention" originates from Latin: 注意 (Chinese), 주의 (Korean), attendere from tendere meaning "to stretch".

  • While attention can be deliberately controlled, distractions are common.

  • Attention-deficit disorder and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) are notable conditions affecting attention.

  • Unilateral neglect syndrome is an extreme disorder where patients cannot attend to stimuli on one side of their body.

Unilateral Neglect Syndrome

  • Individuals with unilateral neglect syndrome are unable to focus on inputs arising from one side of their body.

  • A common test involves patients drawing a typical clock face, revealing inability to engage with one side.

  • Often resulting from damage to the right parietal cortex, leading to a phenomenon known as contralateral neglect.

Selective Attention

  • Selective Attention: The ability to focus on one input or task while disregarding other stimuli.

  • Dichotic Listening Tasks: A method where different audio inputs are presented to each ear via headphones.

    • Attended Channel: The designated audio input one is supposed to focus on.

    • Unattended Channel: The audio input that is ignored.

    • Shadowing: A technique where participants repeat aloud the information from the attended channel to confirm focus.

  • Some effects of selective attention lead to failure in perceiving stimuli directly in front of the observer.

  • Cocktail Party Effect: The phenomenon where individuals notice pertinent information from the unattended channel, such as their name, despite focusing on another conversation.

  • Participants often remain unaware of the semantic details of the unattended channel but can detect physical attributes and personally significant semantic content.

Inhibiting Distractors

  • Explanation for insensitivity to unattended channels involves a filtering mechanism:

    • Filters shield against known distractors while allowing focused processing of desired stimuli.

Inattentional Blindness

  • Inattentional Blindness: The failure to notice a prominent stimulus when focused elsewhere.

    • Statistical figure: 89% fail to see a change without warning, while only 9% fail with warning.

  • Researchers suggest that people may not remember what they experienced rather than failing to perceive it.

  • Variants include:

    • Inattentional Deafness: Neglecting auditory stimuli.

    • Inattentional Numbness: Neglecting haptic stimuli.

Change Blindness

  • Change Blindness: The inability to detect changes in an environment despite direct observation of that environment.

    • Investigated through experiments revealing failure to notice changes when attention is segmented.

Early vs. Late Selection

  • Inattentional and change blindness arise from either not perceiving the stimulus or failing to remember it.

  • Early Selection Theory (Donald Broadbent):

    • Suggests only attended inputs are analyzed and perceived with unattended information experiencing minimal processing.

  • Late Selection Theory (Treisman):

    • Proposes all inputs are analyzed with selection occurring post-analysis; unattended inputs may be perceived but quickly forgotten.

  • Evidence supporting both theories exists based on differing brain activity and reaction times to stimuli.

Spatial Attention

  • Spatial Attention: The focus on specific locations within space, supported by cuing studies.

  • Repetition Priming: Priming based on prior stimulus encounters without cognitive resource investment.

  • Expectation-Driven Priming: Deliberate priming of expected stimuli requiring mental effort.

  • Example: In Posner et al.'s (1980) study, participants press a button upon stimulus appearance, highlighting attention shifts based on cued expectations.

Selection via Priming

  • Selection behavior results from priming based on expectations where detectors are more sensitive to anticipated stimuli.

  • Biased Competition Theory: Suggests attention creates temporary neuron sensitivity biases, enhancing processing of desired stimuli while inhibiting distractors.

Attentional Costs and Benefits

  • Repetition priming incurs no costs, while expectation-based priming does.

  • When misled, participants perform worse, indicating attentional resources are limited in capacity.

  • Attention as a Spotlight: Conceptualizes spatial attention as a moveable beam across the visual field.

    • Eye movements require about 180 ms, while shifts in attention can occur as quickly as 150 ms.

  • The attention control system includes:

    1. Orienting System: Engages attention on a new target.

    2. Alerting System: Maintains an alert state.

    3. Executive System: Manages voluntary actions.

Attention and ADHD

  • Proposal links ADHD symptoms with neural networks corresponding to alerting, orienting, and executive functions based on different brain areas.

  • Symptomatic behavior is categorized into problems in sustaining attention, susceptibility to distractions, and executive function impairments.

Feature Binding

  • Attention is critical in resolving the binding problem, where multiple features of objects are integrated.

  • Feature Integration Theory:

    1. Preattentive Stage: Parallel processing of features.

    2. Focused Attention Stage: Processing advantages through expectation-based priming.

Divided Attention

  • Divided Attention: Performing multiple tasks simultaneously is constrained by mental resources.

  • Task interference occurs when demands exceed available resources.

  • Performance improves with tasks differing in type, while similar tasks compete heavily for the same cognitive resources.

  • Empirical evidence reveals task interference correlates with task similarity.

  • Example statistics indicate that talking on a phone while driving increases missed signals significantly.

Executive Control

  • Executive control manages cognitive resources across tasks with multi-tasking demands varying in perceptual load.

  • Mechanisms for executive control include:

    • Regulating thoughts, maintaining goals, organizing mental processes, shifting strategies, and inhibiting automatic responses.

  • Damage to the prefrontal cortex may lead to challenges in executive functioning, such as perseveration errors.

Automaticity

  • Automaticity: Refers to skills that have been practiced to the extent of requiring minimal executive control.

    • Example: Stroop interference test where individuals struggle to name ink colors while ignoring printed words.

  • Factors influencing automaticity include the nature of the task, task novelty, and the extent of practice.

Summary of Attention Limitations

  • Tasks demand finite resources; thus, over-demand leads to interference.

  • Attention encompasses a range of processes including selective and divided attention, highlighting its flexibility and complexity.