4.1: Crime and Social Control

International Crime and Social Control

  • Crime is ubiquitous; no countries are completely devoid of crime.
  • Most countries organize justice systems by police, courts, and prisons.
  • Adult males make up the largest category of crime suspects.
  • Theft is the most common crime and violent crime is relatively rare.
  • Crime rates are usually expressed as number/100,000 people.
    • Violent and property crimes are two major types of crimes.
    • Transnational crime: a crime that occurs across one or more national borders
Understanding Crime and Social Control
  • Inequality in society, emphasis on material well-being, and corporate profit produce societal strains and individual frustrations
  • There has been a recent decline in crime rates.
    • A shift from punitive to prevention policies will reduce the human and economic costs of crime.
  • Restorative justice: a philosophy concerned with reconciling conflict among the victim, the offender, and the community
    • Response to the current state of criminal justice
    • Focuses on repairing the relationship between the victim, offender, and community

Sources of Crime

  • Crime: a violation of a federal, state, or local criminal law
    • The offender must have acted voluntarily and with intent and have no legally acceptable excuse.
Uniform Crime Report (UCR)
  • Sheriff and police departments voluntarily report to the FBI annually the number of reported crimes and arrests.
  • Clearance rate: a percentage of cases in which arrests, charges, and referrals to courts have been made
    • Large numbers of crimes go unreported.
    • Police might not record reported crimes.
    • Crime rates might be exaggerated due to external pressures and policing motivations.
National Incident-Based Reporting System (NIBRS) (Started in 2021)
  • Phases out UCR system
  • Details on every crime incident and separate offenses within incident
  • Collects data on victims, known offenders, relationships between victims and offenders, arrestees, and property involved in crimes
National Crime Victimization Survey (NCVS)
  • Attempts to account for unreported crimes
    • Dark figure of crime: unreported crime
  • Large scale annual survey interviews a representative sample of 150k people over 12 years old in 95k households to collect data about victimization, relationship to and characteristics of offender, and harm.
Self-Report Offender Surveys
  • Surveys that collect data from people about their criminal behaviors.
  • Attempt to bridge the gap between unreported crimes but are still subject to exaggeration and concealment.
  • Reveal that almost every adult has engaged in some criminal behavior.
  • Crime funnel helps us understand why only some are convicted.
    • Behavior must become known to have occurred.
    • Behavior must come to the attention of the police, who then file a report, investigate, and make an arrest.
    • Arrestees must go through a preliminary hearing, an arraignment, and a trial, at which they may or may not be convicted.

Applying Sociological Theories

Structural-Functionalist Perspective (Merton)
  • Functions of crime include group cohesion and social change (Durkheim).
  • Anomie Theory
    • When society limits legitimate means to acquire cultural goals, the resulting strain leads to criminal behaviors.
    • Conformity occurs when culturally defined goals are accepted and socially legitimate means to achieve them exist.
    • Innovation, ritualism, retreatism, and rebellion are expressions of strain.
  • \

 

  • General Strain Theory (Agnew)
    • When a person experiences strain this leads to criminal behavior.
  • Subcultural Theories
    • Some groups have values and attitudes conducive to violence.
    • Members adopt the crime-promoting attitudes of the group.
  • Control Theory (Hirschi)
    • Social bond: the bond between individuals and the social order that constrains some individuals from violating social norms
    • Social bonds prevent some people from criminal behaviors.
    • Social bonds include attachment, commitment, involvement, and belief.
Conflict Perspective
  • Focus is on how laws are created and enforced by those in power to protect the interests of the ruling class
  • Connection between societal social inequality and crime rates.
    • The greater the income inequality, the higher the homicide rate.
    • In cities with high unemployment, unemployed defendants have a substantially higher probability of pretrial detention.
    • Female prostitutes are more likely to face arrest compared to the men who seek their services.
Symbolic Interactionist Perspective
  • Labeling Theory (Becker)
    • Being labeled deviant leads to further deviant behavior.
    • Primary deviance: deviance committed before a person is labeled an offender
    • Secondary deviance: deviance which results from being caught and labeled
  • Differential Association Theory
    • Individuals learn the values and attitudes associated with crime as well as the techniques and motivations for criminal behavior through interactions with others