Metaethics: Cultural Relativism, Moral Realism, and Logical Fallacies
Course Overview and Schedule
- Central Theme: Metaethics, specifically the debate between metaethical realism and metaethical non-realism.
- Current Focus: Cultural relativism as a primary form of metaethical non-realism, alongside realists' responses to it.
- Readings and Schedule:
- Jesse Prinz: "Morality is a Culturally Conditioned Response" (examines cultural relativism, non-realism, and emotivism).
- James Rachels: "The Challenge of Cultural Relativism" (presents a three-part critique of cultural relativism).
- Martha Nussbaum (Wednesday Reading): "Judging Other Cultures" (from the first metaethics module).
- Topic: Analyzes the widespread practice of female genital mutilation (FGM).
- Core Question: Investigates whether female genital mutilation could ever be justified from a culturally relativistic perspective.
- Louise Hanson (Friday Reading): "Moral Realism and Aesthetic Realism: The Asymmetry Question".
- Topic: Explores the essential connection between moral realism and aesthetic realism.
- Definition of Aesthetics: Philosophical inquiry focused on questions regarding the nature of beauty and the value of art.
- Aesthetic Realism: The affirmation that objective truths exist regarding beauty and artistic merit.
- Core Argument: Hanson argues for an essential connection between moral realism and aesthetic realism—affirming moral realism requires affirming aesthetic realism, and reasons for abandoning moral realism equally motivate abandoning aesthetic realism.
- Sharon Street (Next Week Reading): "Does Anything Really Matter, or Did We Just Evolve to Matter?" (first piece in the second metaethics module).
- Upcoming Focus: The evolutionary debunking strategy against moral realism.
- Core Argument: Asserts that one cannot simultaneously accept the theory of evolution by natural selection and remain a moral realist.
Logical Fallacies and Fallacious Appeals
- Definition of Fallacious Appeal: An improper attempt within an argument to invoke a specific idea, principle, source, or authority for justification.
- Fallacious Appeal to Popularity (Argumentum ad Populum):
- Mechanism: Citing the widespread acceptance of a belief or practice as evidence that the belief is true or the practice is morally justified.
- Principle: The popularity of an idea or practice does not entail its truth or moral justification.
- Fallacious Appeal to Authority (Argumentum ad Verecundiam):
- Mechanism: Citing an individual as an authoritative source who is either not a legitimate authority at all or is an authority in an unrelated, disconnected domain.
- Legitimate Appeal: Invoking a recognized, relevant subject-area expert within their explicit field of expertise.
- Case Study (Anthropogenic Climate Change):
- In 2008, GOP Senator John McCain (Arizona) ran for President against Barack Obama and selected Sarah Palin, then the sitting Governor of Alaska, as his vice-presidential running mate.
- Sarah Palin was an early, outspoken denier of anthropogenic climate change (climate change caused by human activity).
- Argument: "Sarah Palin says there is no climate change, so I am not worried about climate change."
- Fallacy Analysis: Citing Palin's rejection of climate change as evidence is a fallacious appeal to authority because she is a politician, not an expert in climate science. (While she is a legitimate expert on the location of bathrooms in the Governor's Mansion of Alaska, that expertise does not translate to climate science).
- Fallacious Appeal to Ignorance (Argumentum ad Ignorantiam):
- Mechanism: Arguing that because a proposition has not been definitively or decisively proven, the opposite proposition must be true.
- Application in Theistic Arguments:
- "It has never been decisively proven that God exists; therefore, God does not exist."
- "It has never been decisively proven that God does not exist; therefore, God exists."
- Fallacy Analysis: Both inferences are invalid. Lack of definitive proof for one claim does not license the truth of its opposing claim.
- Post Hoc Ergo Propter Hoc Fallacy:
- Literal Translation: "After it, therefore because of it."
- Mechanism: Confusing temporal sequence or correlation with causation.
- Definition: Inferring that because event B occurred chronologically after event A, event B was caused by event A.
- Example: Concluding that making a ham sandwich causes it to rain simply because rainfall repeatedly occurs after making a ham sandwich.
- Metaethical Realism:
- Core Thesis: Objective moral facts and moral truths exist in the universe independent of human beliefs, attitudes, or acceptances.
- Religious / Theistic Realism: Asserts an objective moral order established, instituted, and maintained by God (e.g., divine commands true for everyone regardless of belief).
- Secular Realism: Asserts objective moral facts without relying on supernatural entities or divine command.
- Example: John Stuart Mill in Utilitarianism. Mill argues that the morally right action is universally that which brings about the best consequences for all affected parties. This is advanced as an objective, universally binding truth applicable to everyone, everywhere, all the time.
- Metaethical Non-Realism:
- Core Thesis: Denies moral realism; asserts that morality lacks objective facts, truths, or objective inquiry.
- Radical Global Anti-Realism: Denies the existence of facts of any kind (scientific or moral). Asserts that reality consists entirely of competing human stories and narratives, with facts being a figment of human imagination.
- Empirical Realism with Moral Non-Realism (Jesse Prinz):
- Affirms empirical and scientific facts (e.g., the physical presence of a chair is an objective fact whether accepted or disputed).
- Denies moral facts (e.g., the claim that hitting someone with a chair is wrong is an attitude or opinion, not an objective fact).
Jesse Prinz on Cultural Relativism and Emotivism
- Jesse Prinz's Text: "Morality is a Culturally Conditioned Response".
- Cultural Relativism Thesis: Moral truth does not exist beyond what different cultures teach their adherents. Moral codes are artifacts of cultural socialization, upbringing, and conditioning.
- Emotivism:
- Definition: The view that moral lives and claims are direct outgrowths of internal emotional processes.
- Mechanism: Issuing a moral judgment (e.g., "that is wrong", "that is admirable") represents a report on an internal emotional state triggered by an observation.
- Positively Valenced Emotions: Lead to positive moral reports ("good", "right", "just", "admirable").
- Negatively Valenced Emotions: Lead to negative moral reports ("abhorrent", "forbidden", "disgusting").
- Connection Between Emotivism and Relativism: Emotional responses are subject to extensive cultural conditioning; because moral judgments derive from emotional responses, morality is inherently subject to cultural conditioning and varies across cultures.
- Cross-Cultural Evidence:
- Prinz cites radical cross-cultural variations in moral codes, such as child marriage (adult men marrying young girls).
- In certain cultures, child marriage is viewed as morally permissible or mandatory; in others, it is viewed as abusive, abhorrent, and forbidden.
- Prinz contends this variance proves no single culture possesses privileged moral status or objective correctness.
James Rachels' Critique of Cultural Relativism
- James Rachels' Text: "The Challenge of Cultural Relativism".
- Scope of Project: Rachels does not attempt a full defense of moral realism or establish moral facts; rather, he presents a targeted critique showing that cultural relativism is an unmotivated, bankrupt form of metaethical non-realism.
- Critique 1: Invalidity of the Argument from Cultural Differences:
- Structure of the Relativist Argument:
- Premise: Different cultures hold different beliefs about morality.
- Conclusion: Therefore, there is no objective truth, fact, or objectivity in morality.
- Rachels' Refutation: The conclusion does not logically follow from the premise. The premise concerns what people believe (descriptive), whereas the conclusion concerns what is actually the case (normative/objective reality).
- Counterexamples:
- Shape of the Earth: Different cultures have believed the Earth is flat, an oblate spheroid, or donut-shaped. Differing beliefs do not mean there is no objective fact about the Earth's true shape.
- Vaccine Safety: Differing cultural beliefs regarding the safety and efficacy of childhood vaccines do not mean there is no objective fact regarding vaccine safety.
- Prinz's Response to Rachels: Prinz argues ethics is fundamentally different from scientific/empirical domains. Physical facts (like the Earth's shape) involve empirical observation, whereas morality does not.
- Flaw in Prinz's Response: Begs the question by assuming a lack of objectivity in morality as evidence to prove that morality lacks objectivity.
- Critique 2: The Unwelcome Consequences / Troubling Implications Argument:
- Rachels outlines three unacceptable consequences that logically follow if cultural relativism were true:
- Inability to Execute Cross-Cultural Moral Evaluation:
- Comparison: Culture A systematically disempowers women (bans holding public office, voting, owning/operating businesses, retaining profits, and moving in public without male relatives). Culture B grants full equal rights in these domains.
- Relativist Limit: A cultural relativist cannot coherently state that Culture B is morally better or more just than Culture A, because moral vocabularies are entirely internal to each specific culture.
- Inability to Make Sense of Moral Progress:
- Cultures change over time (e.g., historical changes in Southeastern Louisiana over 200 years, or the women's suffrage movement).
- Relativist Limit: If moral standards are strictly defined by a culture's current norms, historical reformations (such as ending slavery or granting women's suffrage) cannot be categorized as moral progress or improvement, but merely as arbitrary temporal shifts.
- Superficial Account of Moral Deliberation:
- Relativist Limit: Reduces personal moral reflection (deliberating on what is right or how to live) to merely checking standard social codes, rather than engaging in genuine moral evaluation.
Audience Dialogue and Student Interventions
- Intervention on Logical Disagreement (Bradley):
- Point: Clarified Rachels' argument that lack of consensus on moral laws does not logically preclude the existence of an objective moral truth, using the flat versus round Earth analogy.
- Intervention on Empirical versus Moral Observation (Audrey & Student):
- Audrey: Noted that scientific claims (such as the shape of the Earth) rely on physical facts and science to support them, distinguishing them from cultural beliefs.
- Student Response: Supported Prinz by pointing out that while modern science and technology have been adopted globally, immoral practices like human slavery persist. This suggests that moral observation does not compel global practical progress in the same way scientific progress does.
- Counter-consideration: Scientific adoption is also resisted (e.g., modern resurgences of preventable diseases like measles outbreaks due to non-acceptance of scientific consensus).
- Intervention on Cultural Boundaries and Suffrage (Ruby):
- Point: Cited the women's suffrage movement, noting that cultures evolve dynamically over time. Raised the problem of how to define and demarcate the boundaries of a specific culture or society (e.g., Taliban rule versus broader society).
- Complexity of Cultural Identity: Individuals simultaneously inhabit multiple overlapping cultural groups (e.g., contemporary United States, Tulane University, New Orleans, Louisiana) whose codes may conflict.
- Intervention on Moral Metrics and Optimization (Ben):
- Point: Asked whether morality contains measurable metrics (e.g., optimizing happiness/satisfaction) or remains entirely abstract.
- Metrics Context: Mentioned Jeremy Bentham's hedonic calculus ("utils" as units of pleasure/satisfaction) and potential rankings of rights violations (distinguishing basic fundamental rights from secondary rights).
- Analysis: Suggested that the divide between moral realism and non-realism depends heavily on how morality is defined—specifically whether measurable metrics are posited.