Language: Meaning and Definition - Definitive Logic Study Guide
Functions of Language: Emotive and Cognitive Meaning
Reasoning is formally represented in words, arguments are communicated through linguistic expressions, and logic operates directly within language.
Two distinct functions of language in logic include:
- Cognitive Meaning: Words that impart or convey factual, empirical, or objective information.
- Emotive Meaning: Words that evoke, provoke, or express feelings, feelings-based reactions, or emotional responses.
Examples Illustrating Meaning Types:
Mathematical Expression (Pure Cognitive Meaning):
Factual Statement (Cognitive Meaning):
The death penalty, which is legal in 36 states, has been carried out most often in Georgia; however, since 1977 Texas holds the record for the greatest number of executions.
Emotive Statement:
The death penalty is a cruel and inhuman form of punishment in which hapless prisoners are dragged from their cells and summarily slaughtered only to satiate the bloodlust of a vengeful public.
Value Claims:
- Value claims represent the cognitive content embedded within an emotive statement that asserts a moral, aesthetic, or evaluative judgment.
Distinguishing Types of Disputes:
- Factual Disputes: Disagreements that center directly on empirical facts, evidence, or objective realities.
- Example: Person A states, "The battle of Adwa took place in 1889." Person B replies, "No it took place in 1896."
- Verbal Disputes: Disagreements arising from linguistic ambiguity, where opposing parties assign different meanings to a key term.
- Example: Person A states, "We are not free because our behavior is determined by our genes in conjunction with environmental influences." Person B replies, "I disagree. This is a free country. Ethiopians are a free people!"
Intension and Extension of Terms
Structure of Linguistic Logic:
- Arguments consist of statements.
- Statements consist of words.
- Words symbolize meanings.
- Meanings are conveyed through definitions.
Definition and Scope of a Term:
- A term is any word or arrangement of words that can serve as the subject of a statement.
- Included as Terms: Proper names, common names, and descriptive phrases.
- Excluded as Terms (Non-terms): Verbs, non-substantive adjectives, adverbs, prepositions, conjunctions, and any non-syntactic arrangement of words.
Use vs. Mention of Words:
- Use: A word is used when performing its proper grammatical function within standard language.
- Example: "I know what you did last night."
- Mention: A word is mentioned when it is referred to as a linguistic item or symbol itself. Any word or character can function as a term when mentioned.
- Example: "'Did' is a three-letter English word."
Dual Dimensions of Term Meaning:
- Intensional Meaning (Intension or Connotation): Consists of the attributes, qualities, or properties connoted by a term.
- Conventional Connotation: The set of attributes commonly connoted by a term to members of a language community.
- Extensional Meaning (Extension or Denotation): Consists of the individual members of the class denoted by a term.
- Empty (Null) Extension: Refers to a term that denotes a class with no actual physical members.
- Relationship: Intension determines extension, whereas extension suggests intension.
Exemplification of Intension and Extension (Term: "Cat"):
- Intension: Companion animal, mammal/domestic, four-legged, feeds/feasts on rats, carnivorous, meowing (cry of cats), cute, selfish.
- Extension: All cats in the universe.
Additional Extensional Examples:
- "Dog": Lulu, Bobby, Royal, Cooper, Pluto.
- "Tortoise": Jonathan, Govinda (Note: Jonathan is recognized as the oldest living land animal/tortoise on Earth with a Guinness record of 190 years).
Orderings of Intension and Extension:
- Increasing Intension: A sequence of terms where each successive term (except the first) connotes more attributes than the term preceding it.
- Decreasing Intension: A sequence of terms where each successive term connotes fewer attributes than the term preceding it.
- Increasing Extension: A sequence of terms where each successive term (except the first) denotes a class having more members than the class denoted by the term preceding it.
- Decreasing Extension: A sequence of terms where each successive term denotes a class having fewer members than the class denoted by the term preceding it.
Series Examples for Ordering:
Tiger; mammal; feline; animalDoctor of medicine; person; brain surgeon; professional person; surgeonParallelogram; polygon; square; rectangle; quadrilateralItalian sports car; car; vehicle; Maserati; sports car
Types of Definitions and Their Purposes
Voltaire famously stated: "If you wish to converse with me define your terms."
A definition is a group of words that assigns a meaning to a word or group of words.
Two Core Components of Definitions:
- Definiendum: The word or group of words being defined.
- Definiens: The word or group of words doing the defining.
Five Main Types of Definitions:
Stipulative Definition:
Arbitrarily assigns a meaning to a word for the first time.
Involves coining a new word or assigning a novel meaning to an existing word.
Used to replace complex expressions with simpler ones, establish secret codes, accommodate new scientific/cultural developments, or serve as unique jargon within specific groups.
Cannot be evaluated as true or false.
Lexical Definition:
Reports or repeats the established meaning that a word already possesses in a language.
Can be evaluated as true or false based on whether it accurately reflects actual language usage.
Serves to eliminate ambiguity (a word is ambiguous when it can yield two or more distinctly different meanings in a given context).
Examples of ambiguous words: party, light, bank, sound, race, right, bachelor, pool.
Précising Definition:
Designed to reduce the vagueness of a word.
A word is vague when borderline cases exist such that it is impossible to determine whether the word applies to them.
Examples of vague words: love, happiness, peace, excessive, fresh, rich, poor, normal, discipline vs. abuse.
Theoretical Definition:
Provides a theoretical characterization or theoretical picture of the entity or entities denoted by the definiendum.
Constructs a conceptual framework suggesting deductive consequences and ways of interpreting phenomena.
Functions as proposals to interpret concepts; strictly neither true nor false.
Persuasive Definition:
Intended to influence attitudes, engendering a favorable or unfavorable orientation toward the definiendum.
Employs emotionally charged or value-laden vocabulary as an instrument of persuasion.
Examples:
- "Abortion" defined as "the ruthless murdering of an innocent human being."
- "Abortion" defined as "a safe and established surgical procedure whereby a woman is relieved of an unwanted burden."
Definitional Techniques
Definitional techniques are broadly classified into Extensional (Denotative) and Intensional (Connotative) methods.
Extensional / Denotative Techniques:
Demonstrative (Ostensive) Definitions:
Assigns meaning through physical pointing or gestures.
Represents the most primitive form of definition; requires only understanding the gesture of pointing.
Useful across language barriers, but limited when referenced objects are physically unavailable.
Definiens consists of a gesture (or signs in sign language).
Can be partial or complete.
Enumerative Definitions:
Assigns meaning by naming individual members of the class denoted by the term.
Identifies members as single, irreducible units.
Can be partial or complete.
Examples:
- "Planet" means Mercury, Venus, Earth, Mars, Saturn, Jupiter, Neptune, Uranus, and Pluto.
- "Continent" means Africa, Europe, Asia, Australia, North America, and South America.
- "Ocean" means Atlantic, Pacific, Indian, and Antarctic.
- Finite sets: "Actress", "Continent", "Ocean", "Planet". Infinite sets: "Number".
Definition by Subclass:
Assigns meaning by naming subclasses or groups within the class denoted by the term.
Used when individual enumeration is difficult or impossible.
Can be partial or complete.
Example: "Fictional work" means either a poem, a play, a novel, or a short story.
Intensional / Connotative Techniques:
Synonymous Definition:
Defines a term using a single word (synonym) that connotes the same attributes as the definiendum.
Highly concise.
Example: "Physician" means doctor.
Etymological Definition:
Traces the historical development of a linguistic form from its earliest occurrence, transmission across languages, component analysis, or ancestral roots.
Examples:
- "License": derived from Latin licere ("to be permitted").
- "Captain": derived from Latin caput ("head").
- "Principle": derived from Latin principium ("beginning" or "source").
Operational Definition:
Assigns meaning by specifying concrete experimental operations or tests that determine whether the word applies.
Formulated to anchor abstract concepts in empirical reality, though it may capture only part of the full intensional meaning.
Example: One substance is "harder than" another if and only if one scratches the other when the two are rubbed together.
Definition by Genus and Difference:
Assigns meaning by identifying a genus term and one or more specific difference attributes that together convey the term's meaning.
Genus: A relatively larger overarching class.
Species: A relatively smaller subclass of the genus.
Specific Difference: The attribute(s) that distinguish species within a genus.
Examples:
- "Husband" means married man (Genus: man; Difference: married).
- "Skyscraper" means very tall building (Genus: building; Difference: very tall).
- "Tent" means a collapsible shelter made of canvas or other material that is sustained and stretched by poles (Genus: shelter; Difference: collapsible, made of canvas/material sustained by poles).
Criteria for Lexical Definitions
- Standard lexical definitions must adhere to eight foundational rules:
- Rule 1: Grammatical Correctness: A lexical definition must be grammatically correct and conform to proper syntax.
- Rule 2: Essential Meaning: It must express the core, essential attributes of the term being defined.
- Rule 3: Proper Scope: It must be neither too broad (including non-members) nor too narrow (excluding true members).
- Rule 4: Avoid Circularity: It must avoid circular reasoning; the definiendum (or its derivative) must not appear in the definiens.
- Rule 5: Affirmative Formulation: It should be phrased affirmatively rather than negatively whenever feasible.
- Rule 6: Avoid Unclear Language: It must avoid figurative language, obscure phrasing, vagueness, and ambiguity.
- Rule 7: Avoid Affective Terminology: It must remain emotionally neutral and avoid loaded, biased, or persuasive wording.
- Rule 8: Contextual Specification: It must specify the pertinent context or field of application in which the term is used.