Language: Meaning and Definition - Definitive Logic Study Guide

Functions of Language: Emotive and Cognitive Meaning

  • Reasoning is formally represented in words, arguments are communicated through linguistic expressions, and logic operates directly within language.

  • Two distinct functions of language in logic include:

    • Cognitive Meaning: Words that impart or convey factual, empirical, or objective information.
    • Emotive Meaning: Words that evoke, provoke, or express feelings, feelings-based reactions, or emotional responses.
  • Examples Illustrating Meaning Types:

    • Mathematical Expression (Pure Cognitive Meaning):     7×5(3x+3)=357 \times 5^{(3x+3)} = 355(3x+3)=55^{(3x+3)} = 5log⁡5(5(3x+3))=log⁡5(5)\log_5(5^{(3x+3)}) = \log_5(5)3x+3=13x + 3 = 13x=−23x = -2x=−23x = -\frac{2}{3}

    • Factual Statement (Cognitive Meaning):

    • The death penalty, which is legal in 36 states, has been carried out most often in Georgia; however, since 1977 Texas holds the record for the greatest number of executions.

    • Emotive Statement:

    • The death penalty is a cruel and inhuman form of punishment in which hapless prisoners are dragged from their cells and summarily slaughtered only to satiate the bloodlust of a vengeful public.

  • Value Claims:

    • Value claims represent the cognitive content embedded within an emotive statement that asserts a moral, aesthetic, or evaluative judgment.
  • Distinguishing Types of Disputes:

    • Factual Disputes: Disagreements that center directly on empirical facts, evidence, or objective realities.
    • Example: Person A states, "The battle of Adwa took place in 1889." Person B replies, "No it took place in 1896."
    • Verbal Disputes: Disagreements arising from linguistic ambiguity, where opposing parties assign different meanings to a key term.
    • Example: Person A states, "We are not free because our behavior is determined by our genes in conjunction with environmental influences." Person B replies, "I disagree. This is a free country. Ethiopians are a free people!"

Intension and Extension of Terms

  • Structure of Linguistic Logic:

    • Arguments consist of statements.
    • Statements consist of words.
    • Words symbolize meanings.
    • Meanings are conveyed through definitions.
  • Definition and Scope of a Term:

    • A term is any word or arrangement of words that can serve as the subject of a statement.
    • Included as Terms: Proper names, common names, and descriptive phrases.
    • Excluded as Terms (Non-terms): Verbs, non-substantive adjectives, adverbs, prepositions, conjunctions, and any non-syntactic arrangement of words.
  • Use vs. Mention of Words:

    • Use: A word is used when performing its proper grammatical function within standard language.
    • Example: "I know what you did last night."
    • Mention: A word is mentioned when it is referred to as a linguistic item or symbol itself. Any word or character can function as a term when mentioned.
    • Example: "'Did' is a three-letter English word."
  • Dual Dimensions of Term Meaning:

    • Intensional Meaning (Intension or Connotation): Consists of the attributes, qualities, or properties connoted by a term.
    • Conventional Connotation: The set of attributes commonly connoted by a term to members of a language community.
    • Extensional Meaning (Extension or Denotation): Consists of the individual members of the class denoted by a term.
    • Empty (Null) Extension: Refers to a term that denotes a class with no actual physical members.
    • Relationship: Intension determines extension, whereas extension suggests intension.
  • Exemplification of Intension and Extension (Term: "Cat"):

    • Intension: Companion animal, mammal/domestic, four-legged, feeds/feasts on rats, carnivorous, meowing (cry of cats), cute, selfish.
    • Extension: All cats in the universe.
  • Additional Extensional Examples:

    • "Dog": Lulu, Bobby, Royal, Cooper, Pluto.
    • "Tortoise": Jonathan, Govinda (Note: Jonathan is recognized as the oldest living land animal/tortoise on Earth with a Guinness record of 190 years).
  • Orderings of Intension and Extension:

    • Increasing Intension: A sequence of terms where each successive term (except the first) connotes more attributes than the term preceding it.
    • Decreasing Intension: A sequence of terms where each successive term connotes fewer attributes than the term preceding it.
    • Increasing Extension: A sequence of terms where each successive term (except the first) denotes a class having more members than the class denoted by the term preceding it.
    • Decreasing Extension: A sequence of terms where each successive term denotes a class having fewer members than the class denoted by the term preceding it.
  • Series Examples for Ordering:

    • Tiger; mammal; feline; animal
    • Doctor of medicine; person; brain surgeon; professional person; surgeon
    • Parallelogram; polygon; square; rectangle; quadrilateral
    • Italian sports car; car; vehicle; Maserati; sports car

Types of Definitions and Their Purposes

  • Voltaire famously stated: "If you wish to converse with me define your terms."

  • A definition is a group of words that assigns a meaning to a word or group of words.

  • Two Core Components of Definitions:

    • Definiendum: The word or group of words being defined.
    • Definiens: The word or group of words doing the defining.
  • Five Main Types of Definitions:

    • Stipulative Definition:

    • Arbitrarily assigns a meaning to a word for the first time.

    • Involves coining a new word or assigning a novel meaning to an existing word.

    • Used to replace complex expressions with simpler ones, establish secret codes, accommodate new scientific/cultural developments, or serve as unique jargon within specific groups.

    • Cannot be evaluated as true or false.

    • Lexical Definition:

    • Reports or repeats the established meaning that a word already possesses in a language.

    • Can be evaluated as true or false based on whether it accurately reflects actual language usage.

    • Serves to eliminate ambiguity (a word is ambiguous when it can yield two or more distinctly different meanings in a given context).

    • Examples of ambiguous words: party, light, bank, sound, race, right, bachelor, pool.

    • Précising Definition:

    • Designed to reduce the vagueness of a word.

    • A word is vague when borderline cases exist such that it is impossible to determine whether the word applies to them.

    • Examples of vague words: love, happiness, peace, excessive, fresh, rich, poor, normal, discipline vs. abuse.

    • Theoretical Definition:

    • Provides a theoretical characterization or theoretical picture of the entity or entities denoted by the definiendum.

    • Constructs a conceptual framework suggesting deductive consequences and ways of interpreting phenomena.

    • Functions as proposals to interpret concepts; strictly neither true nor false.

    • Persuasive Definition:

    • Intended to influence attitudes, engendering a favorable or unfavorable orientation toward the definiendum.

    • Employs emotionally charged or value-laden vocabulary as an instrument of persuasion.

    • Examples:

      • "Abortion" defined as "the ruthless murdering of an innocent human being."
      • "Abortion" defined as "a safe and established surgical procedure whereby a woman is relieved of an unwanted burden."

Definitional Techniques

  • Definitional techniques are broadly classified into Extensional (Denotative) and Intensional (Connotative) methods.

  • Extensional / Denotative Techniques:

    • Demonstrative (Ostensive) Definitions:

    • Assigns meaning through physical pointing or gestures.

    • Represents the most primitive form of definition; requires only understanding the gesture of pointing.

    • Useful across language barriers, but limited when referenced objects are physically unavailable.

    • Definiens consists of a gesture (or signs in sign language).

    • Can be partial or complete.

    • Enumerative Definitions:

    • Assigns meaning by naming individual members of the class denoted by the term.

    • Identifies members as single, irreducible units.

    • Can be partial or complete.

    • Examples:

      • "Planet" means Mercury, Venus, Earth, Mars, Saturn, Jupiter, Neptune, Uranus, and Pluto.
      • "Continent" means Africa, Europe, Asia, Australia, North America, and South America.
      • "Ocean" means Atlantic, Pacific, Indian, and Antarctic.
      • Finite sets: "Actress", "Continent", "Ocean", "Planet". Infinite sets: "Number".
    • Definition by Subclass:

    • Assigns meaning by naming subclasses or groups within the class denoted by the term.

    • Used when individual enumeration is difficult or impossible.

    • Can be partial or complete.

    • Example: "Fictional work" means either a poem, a play, a novel, or a short story.

  • Intensional / Connotative Techniques:

    • Synonymous Definition:

    • Defines a term using a single word (synonym) that connotes the same attributes as the definiendum.

    • Highly concise.

    • Example: "Physician" means doctor.

    • Etymological Definition:

    • Traces the historical development of a linguistic form from its earliest occurrence, transmission across languages, component analysis, or ancestral roots.

    • Examples:

      • "License": derived from Latin licere ("to be permitted").
      • "Captain": derived from Latin caput ("head").
      • "Principle": derived from Latin principium ("beginning" or "source").
    • Operational Definition:

    • Assigns meaning by specifying concrete experimental operations or tests that determine whether the word applies.

    • Formulated to anchor abstract concepts in empirical reality, though it may capture only part of the full intensional meaning.

    • Example: One substance is "harder than" another if and only if one scratches the other when the two are rubbed together.

    • Definition by Genus and Difference:

    • Assigns meaning by identifying a genus term and one or more specific difference attributes that together convey the term's meaning.

    • Genus: A relatively larger overarching class.

    • Species: A relatively smaller subclass of the genus.

    • Specific Difference: The attribute(s) that distinguish species within a genus.

    • Examples:

      • "Husband" means married man (Genus: man; Difference: married).
      • "Skyscraper" means very tall building (Genus: building; Difference: very tall).
      • "Tent" means a collapsible shelter made of canvas or other material that is sustained and stretched by poles (Genus: shelter; Difference: collapsible, made of canvas/material sustained by poles).

Criteria for Lexical Definitions

  • Standard lexical definitions must adhere to eight foundational rules:
    • Rule 1: Grammatical Correctness: A lexical definition must be grammatically correct and conform to proper syntax.
    • Rule 2: Essential Meaning: It must express the core, essential attributes of the term being defined.
    • Rule 3: Proper Scope: It must be neither too broad (including non-members) nor too narrow (excluding true members).
    • Rule 4: Avoid Circularity: It must avoid circular reasoning; the definiendum (or its derivative) must not appear in the definiens.
    • Rule 5: Affirmative Formulation: It should be phrased affirmatively rather than negatively whenever feasible.
    • Rule 6: Avoid Unclear Language: It must avoid figurative language, obscure phrasing, vagueness, and ambiguity.
    • Rule 7: Avoid Affective Terminology: It must remain emotionally neutral and avoid loaded, biased, or persuasive wording.
    • Rule 8: Contextual Specification: It must specify the pertinent context or field of application in which the term is used.