Co-evolution

Coevolution

  • Coevolution is defined as reciprocally induced evolutionary change between two or more species or populations.   - Definition: This process occurs when two or more species or populations influence each other's evolutionary trajectory.

Requirements for Coevolutionary Change

  1. Genetic Determination: The traits involved in the interacting populations or species must be genetically determined.

  2. Tandem Variation: There must be variation in these traits such that the two taxa vary in tandem, meaning changes in one coincide with changes in the other.

  3. Mutual Induction: The traits and their variations must be mutually induced. Specifically, genetic traits should not occur in the absence or rarity of the interactive species; each trait should be unique to its species or population.    - Example of this premise: Traits found in species must be exclusive and not arise in isolated conditions where the other species is not present.

Examples Supporting Coevolution

  • While rare, there are some examples in nature that support the coevolution theory. Host-parasite systems are among the best-studied relationships likely resulting from coevolutionary phenomena.   - Gene for Gene Hypothesis:     - Proposed through careful study of host-parasite dynamics, stating that:       - Complementary genetic systems are developed where each host gene affecting defense is matched by a parasite gene affecting attack.       - Example of this process:         - A gene conferring resistance in a plant to a parasite in an abundant population develops rapidly. Then, a gene arises in the parasite to overcome that resistance, allowing a resurgence of infection.         - This cycle continues, leading to an evolutionary arms race with 'blow for blow' adaptations between hosts and parasites, promoting diversity.   - Historical Observations: In 1974, Day cataloged 27 species-species interactions supporting coevolution:     - Plant-fungus Relationships: 19 instances.     - Bacteria-plant Relationships: 2 instances.     - Virus-plant Relationships: 3 instances.     - Nematode-plant Relationships: 1 instance.     - Insect-plant Relationships: 1 instance.     - Parasitic angiosperm-plant Relationships: 1 instance.   - Specific Interaction Examples:     - Leguminous plants and nitrogen-fixing bacteria.     - Wheat and hessian flies.     - Apples and fungi.

Cospeciation vs. Coevolution

  • Cospeciation: This happens when the speciation patterns of a host reflect in the speciation patterns of its parasites. It is primarily characterized by:   - A lack of direct evidence demonstrating coevolution contrary to simply tracking evolutionary history.   - Formal rules have been documented:     - Fahrenholz’s Rule: In groups of permanent parasites, their classification correlates directly with the natural relationships of the hosts (Eichler, 1948).   - Implication: The specificity of a parasite to its host indicates tighter phylogenetic tracking.   - Research Authority: Dan Brooks from the University of Toronto is a leading authority on cospeciation in parasites and their hosts.

  • Key Distinction:   - Coevolution: Reciprocally induced evolutionary change.   - Cospeciation: The phylogenetic tracking of host clades reflected by parasite clades, stemming from host speciation events.

Mutualism

  • Definition: Mutualism is a relationship where two species survive better together than in isolation.   - The relationship typically arises from coevolutionary processes that necessitate adaptive adjustments between species involved.

  • Controversial Perspectives: The conventional understanding suggests that true mutualistic relationships are more prevalent in tropical zones due to stable environments, although evidence of mutualism exists globally.

Types of Mutualism

  1. Intracellular Mutualisms: One organism lives within the cells of another.    - Examples:      - Mitochondria in prokaryotic cells forming eukaryotic cells.      - Chloroplasts in early eukaryotes forming green plants.      - Algal symbionts in various taxa including Protozoa, Coelenterata, Mollusca, and Platyhelminthes.

  2. Intraorganismal Mutualisms: One organism lives intercellularly or within specialized organs.    - Examples:      - Endosymbiosis in insects.      - Endotrophic mycorrhizae.      - Lichens.      - Nitrogen-fixing bacteria and algae in higher plants.      - Digestive symbiosis in artiodactyls, termites, and roaches.

  3. Organismal Mutualisms: Free-living organisms form mutualistic relationships.    - Examples:      - Ectotrophic mycorrhizae and plants.      - Insect-fungus mutualisms.      - Ant-plant mutualisms.

  4. Population Mutualisms: Relationships between populations rather than individuals.    - Example: Pollination systems, where multiple species co-participate in successful reproduction.

Detailed Case Study: Termites and Intestinal Microorganisms
  • Description of Mutualism:   - Termites host protozoa in their intestines possessing cellulolytic enzymes allowing them to digest wood.   - The termite chews wood, protozoa digest it, and in return, the termite provides an anaerobic chamber and a constant wood supply.   - Fermentation Process:     - Protozoa engulf wood particles and ferment cellulose, producing:       - Carbon dioxide.       - Hydrogen.       - Acetic acid.     - The termite absorbs acetic acid for energy, whereas protozoans derive energy from anaerobic cellulose fermentation.   - Additional Symbionts: Large populations of bacteria coexist with the protozoa, with some being nitrogen fixers, aiding the termite’s health by providing nitrogen for protein synthesis.   - Unexplained Dependency: It’s noted that if the bacteria are eliminated, the protozoa perish shortly after, suggesting an unidentified component to this mutualistic relationship that requires further study.