art critique
Students Discuss Switching Majors
Some students express interest in changing majors, with one considering public health.
Access Issues
A student encounters access problems when trying to use the student mode for a course, indicating possible technical difficulties.
Plans to contact IT support if access cannot be restored.
Class Activities and Notes
Class begins with a brief discussion on assignments and class activities.
Typically, students write notes based on peer discussions about their work; however, this session will focus on individual pieces instead.
Activity Instructions:
Students have four pieces to discuss.
Each student should guess how many principles of design are relevant to their work and write them down.
Emphasis is placed on estimation rather than critique at this stage.
Personal Updates Among Students
Informal conversations about personal lives:
Shared moments about holiday celebrations (Easter) and meals prepared by family.
Comments on favorite local foods (cinnamon rolls, biscuits).
Encounters with people during holiday gatherings discussed, including instances of confusion or misunderstanding.
Mood Check
Faculty asks students about their current mood; one expresses feeling tired and over everything.
Acknowledgment of rough experiences during the weekend.
Critique Guidelines
The critique session is introduced, focusing specifically on principles of design.
Each student is encouraged to share insights without going into detailed explanations initially.
The critique will begin by identifying principles relevant to each artwork.
Framework: Each student will present, followed by group discussions about additional principles or elements they notice.
Example of Critique Session
Specific critique begins on a piece depicting a shark:
The artist identifies principles of closure and isolation relevant to their design.
Discussion includes the balance of the piece, color saturation, and use of design elements (like teeth as focal points).
Feedback on how to enhance contrast and depth in the design through color choices and line work.
Discussion of Design Elements
Students discuss the importance of outlining and depth in the illustration of the shark and the positioning of elements like the mouth and teeth.
Recommendations include experimenting with various values, line thicknesses, and color washes to create depth and visual interest.
Background Elements in Critique
Discussions about the background of the art piece, whether it needs a wash, details on water dynamics, and how it interacts with the subject matter.
Specific suggestions about varying line weights and color to effectively mimic natural elements like water and smoke.
Principles of Design Applied in Other Artworks
A second piece featuring a campfire and background stars leads to the identification of multiple design principles:
Emphasis on movement, enclosure (for smoke), and rhythm through repeating visual elements.
Discussions include proposed adjustments to enhance visual balance and cohesion.
Acknowledgment of Areas for Improvement
Critique includes highlights on both strengths and weaknesses in each art piece:
Suggestions for enhancing texture, color gradients, and silhouetting elements against backgrounds are discussed.
Comments on the emotional impact of certain elements (e.g., humor or whimsy) enhance the discussion on viewer engagement.