art critique

Students Discuss Switching Majors

  • Some students express interest in changing majors, with one considering public health.

Access Issues

  • A student encounters access problems when trying to use the student mode for a course, indicating possible technical difficulties.

  • Plans to contact IT support if access cannot be restored.

Class Activities and Notes

  • Class begins with a brief discussion on assignments and class activities.

  • Typically, students write notes based on peer discussions about their work; however, this session will focus on individual pieces instead.

  • Activity Instructions:

    • Students have four pieces to discuss.

    • Each student should guess how many principles of design are relevant to their work and write them down.

    • Emphasis is placed on estimation rather than critique at this stage.

Personal Updates Among Students

  • Informal conversations about personal lives:

    • Shared moments about holiday celebrations (Easter) and meals prepared by family.

    • Comments on favorite local foods (cinnamon rolls, biscuits).

  • Encounters with people during holiday gatherings discussed, including instances of confusion or misunderstanding.

Mood Check

  • Faculty asks students about their current mood; one expresses feeling tired and over everything.

  • Acknowledgment of rough experiences during the weekend.

Critique Guidelines

  • The critique session is introduced, focusing specifically on principles of design.

  • Each student is encouraged to share insights without going into detailed explanations initially.

    • The critique will begin by identifying principles relevant to each artwork.

    • Framework: Each student will present, followed by group discussions about additional principles or elements they notice.

Example of Critique Session

  • Specific critique begins on a piece depicting a shark:

    • The artist identifies principles of closure and isolation relevant to their design.

    • Discussion includes the balance of the piece, color saturation, and use of design elements (like teeth as focal points).

    • Feedback on how to enhance contrast and depth in the design through color choices and line work.

Discussion of Design Elements

  • Students discuss the importance of outlining and depth in the illustration of the shark and the positioning of elements like the mouth and teeth.

  • Recommendations include experimenting with various values, line thicknesses, and color washes to create depth and visual interest.

Background Elements in Critique

  • Discussions about the background of the art piece, whether it needs a wash, details on water dynamics, and how it interacts with the subject matter.

  • Specific suggestions about varying line weights and color to effectively mimic natural elements like water and smoke.

Principles of Design Applied in Other Artworks

  • A second piece featuring a campfire and background stars leads to the identification of multiple design principles:

    • Emphasis on movement, enclosure (for smoke), and rhythm through repeating visual elements.

    • Discussions include proposed adjustments to enhance visual balance and cohesion.

Acknowledgment of Areas for Improvement

  • Critique includes highlights on both strengths and weaknesses in each art piece:

    • Suggestions for enhancing texture, color gradients, and silhouetting elements against backgrounds are discussed.

    • Comments on the emotional impact of certain elements (e.g., humor or whimsy) enhance the discussion on viewer engagement.