Criminology notes

AC1.1 - analyse of different types of crime

White-Collar Crime

White-collar crime is crime committed by someone in an honourable position as a professional, manager and so forth which involves financial or occupation misconduct.

This form of crime can include any form of trust, authority, knowledge or professional misconduct.

Example:

. Fraud

. Embezzlement

. Bribery

. Tax evasion

. Insider trading

. Theft by employees or professionals

Case study — Bernie Madoff

Bernie Madoff was an American financier that conducted one of the biggest investment scams in history through a Ponzi scheme. This means he would use funds from his new investors to give funds to previous investors, without actually producing the profit he said he would generate.

He managed to do this using his respectable reputation within the financial industry and the trust that his clients had put in him. He was arrested in 2008 and later on received 150 year prison sentence.

Offender

. White-collar offenders can include:

. Business owners

. Company directors

. Managers

. Accountants

. Doctors

. Lawyers

. Other professionals

. Employees in positions of trust

. Victim

. Victims can include:

. Individual customers

. Employees

. Businesses

. Investors

. Taxpayers

. Government/public services

Public awareness

White-collar crimes can be less visible to the public than regular crime. This is because of the complexity of the crime, the place of operation, lack of physical violence among other factors. Therefore the public could underestimate white-collar crime.

The public may therefore underestimate how widespread or harmful it can be.

Criminal and/or deviant?

White-collar crimes are generally criminal because they break the law. In addition to that, they are also considered deviant because they violate the social expectations from the respectable professionals.

Moral crime

Moral crimes are offences involving behaviour that is considered unacceptable because it conflicts with the moral values or standards of a society.

What is considered a moral crime can change over time a s social attitudes change.

Example – certain forms of prostitution, drug offences, gambling offences in some historical contexts, other offences based strongly on changing moral standards

Offender

Offender may include:

. Individuals involved in illegal drug activity

. People involved in prostitution related offences

. Suppliers or dealers

. People who organise or facilitate illegal activities

Victim

The concept of a victim can be complicated with moral crimes.

Possible victims may include:

. Individuals harmed by illegal drugs

. Families affected by drug-related

. Communities

. People exploited within illegal activities

Some moral crimes may also involve willing participants, making the idea of a victims less straightforward.

Public awareness

Awareness varies depending on the offence.

Some moral crimes receive substantial media attention, while others may receive relatively little because they are hidden or difficult to detect.

Public attitudes can also change over time as society’s values change.

Criminal and/or deviant?

Moral crimes are often considered criminal because the act is prohibited.

Furthermore, these crime are considered deviant due to the fact that they go against social or moral norms.

Nonetheless, deviant doesn’t always lead to criminalisation since there is a difference between social attitudes and laws.

Case study – Operation Julie(1977)

Operation Julie was a major UK police investigations into a large-scale network involved in the manufacture and distribution of LSD. The investigation involved police forces across the UK and resulted in numerous arrest and convictions. It is useful as an example of moral crime because illegal drug activity can be viewed as behaviour that conflicts with society’s moral standards, although attitudes towards drugs can vary between different groups and change over time.

State crime

State crime involves illegal or harmful actions carried out by governments, governments agencies or people acting on behalf of the state.

State crimes can involve serious violations of human rights.

Examples – Genocide, Torture, unlawful killing, war crimes, crimes against humanity, political repression

Case study – Nazi Germany

The Holocaust is an example of state-sponsored mass per suction and genocide carried out by Nazi Germany.

It demonstrates how the power and resources of a state can be used to commit extremely serious crimes.

Offender

Offender can include:

. Governments

. Political leaders

. Military personnel

. Police/ security forces

. Government officials

. Individuals acting under state authority

Victim

Victim can include:

. Civilians

. Political opponents

. Ethnic or religious groups

. Prisoners

. Members of minority groups

. Populations affected by was or government repression

Public awareness

Public awareness is highly considerably.

Criminal activities conducted by the state can be a subject of wide international interest, at the same time, a government can try to conceal information about crimes or control what its publishes.

Criminal and/or deviant?

State crime can be criminal under domestic or international law.

It can also be considered deviant because it goes against accepted social and moral norms.

One of the concerns is that states may have an ability to determine whether something is considered legal or illegal, which makes actions of the states controversial or problematic.

Technological crime

Technological crime involves the use of computers, digital technology, networks or the internet to commit offences.

It is often referred to as cybercrime/e- crime.

Examples:

. Hacking

. Phishing – a type of cyber attack where scammers pretend to be trusted sources to trick people into giving away private information like passwords or credit card numbers

. Online fraud

. Identity theft

. Malware attacks

. Cyber stalking

. Theft of personal or financial information

Example – a criminal could use a fake website or message to trick people into revealing their bank details or passwords.

Offender

Offender can include:

. Individual hackers

. Organised criminal groups

. Fraudsters

. Cyber criminals

. People with specialist technological knowledge

Victims

Victims can include:

. Individuals

. Businesses

. Banks

. Government organisations

. Schools

. Charities

. Other organisation

Pubic awareness

The awareness of technology crimes has been rising parallel to the rising utilisation of the internet.

However there are certain crime that may prove difficult to detect on the part of the victim, particularly when it is hacking or fraud related.

Criminal and/or deviant?

Technological crimes are criminal when they break the law.

They can also be deviant because they violated expectations about acceptable behaviour online and the proper use of technology.

Case study – WannaCry Cyber attack (2017)

The WannaCry Cyber attack was a major cybercrime incident that spread internationally in 2017. It disrupted computer systems in many countries, including systems used by parts of the UK’s NHS causing significant disruption to services. It demonstrates how technological crime can affect individuals and large organisations and how criminals can use digital technology to cause widespread disruption.

Individual crimes – hate crime

A hate crime is a criminal offence motivated by hospitality or prejudice towards a person’s perceived characteristics, such as their race, religion, disability or sexual orientation.

The underlying offence can involve things such as assault, criminal damage, harassment or threats.

Examples:

. Assault motivated by racial hostility

. Criminal damage motivated by religious hostility

. Harassment motivated by disability

. Threats motivated by hostility towards someone’s perceived identity

Offender

Offender can be:

. Individuals

. Groups

. Organised extremist groups

The offender may target someone because of a perceived characteristic.

Victim

Victim can be targeted because of characteristics such as:

. Race

. Religion

. Disability

. Sexual orientation

. Transgender identity

Public awareness

Hate crime can receive significant media and public attention because it can affect both the individual victim and the wider community.

However, one hate crimes may remain unreported, meaning public awareness may not reflect the true level.

Criminal and/or deviant?

Hate crime is criminal because it involves an underlying criminal offence.

It is also deviant because prejudice and hostility towards groups can violated wider social norms and expectations.

Case study – Stephen Lawrence

Stephen Lawrence was murdered in a racist attack in London in 1993. The investigation and its aftermath became highly significant in discussions about racist crime, policing and institutional racism in the UK. The case is useful fro hate crime because Lawrence was targeted because of his race, demonstrating how prejudice can be connected to criminal behaviour.

Individual crimes – honour crime

Honour crime refers to criminal behaviour carried out by individuals who claim they are protecting or restoring their family’s or community’s perceived “honour”.

The concept of “honour” is used by offenders to justify controlling or harming another person.

Examples:

. Violence against a family members

. Forced marriage

. Threats or intimidation

. Other forms of abuse carried out in the mane of family honour

Offender

Offenders can include:

. Family members

. Relatives

. Other people involved in enforcing perceived family/ community expectations

Victim

Victims are often people who are seen by offenders as having brought “shame” on faimly.

They can include:

. Young people

. Women

. Men

. People who reject family expectations

Public awareness

Awareness has increased through media reporting, education and campaigns.

However, honour-based abuse can remain hidden, particularly where victims fear family or community consequences or do not know where to seek help.

Criminal and/or deviant?

The acts themselves can be criminal regardless of whether the offender believes they are justified by “honour”.

They can also be considered deviant because they conflict with wider social expectations about individuals rights and acceptable behaviour.

Important – cultural or religions beliefs do not make violence or abuse acceptable or legal.

Case study – Banaz Mahmood

Banaz Mahmood was murdered by members of her family in 2006 after rejecting expectations placed upon her. Her case became an important example of honour-based violence , where individuals may use violence or other criminal behaviour while claiming to protect or restore family honour. The case contributed to greater awareness of honour-based abuse and the difficulties victims can face when reporting it.

Individual crimes – domestic abuse

Domestic abuse involves abusive behaviour between people who are personally connected, such as partners or family members.

It can include:

. Physical abuse

. Emotional/psychological abuse

. Sexual abuse

. coercive (use of force, threats or intimidation to make someone do something against their will) or controlling behaviour

. Economic/ financial abuse

Examples:

. Physical violence against a partner

. Controlling someone’s finances

. Threatening or intimidating a partner

. Preventing someone from seeing friends or family

. Coercive or controlling behaviour

Offender

The offender may be:

. A current partner

. An ex partner

. A family member

. Another person within a domestic relationship

Victims

Victims can include:

. Partners

. Ex-partners

. Children

. Other family members

Public awareness

Domestic abuse has historically been underreported because victims may experience fear, shame, financial dependence, lack of knowledge, or concern about the consequences of reporting.

Public awareness has increased considerably through campaigns, media coverage and changes in law and policing.

Criminal and/or deviant?

Domestic abuse can involve criminal offences and is therefore criminal where the behaviour breaks the law.

It is also deviant because it violates social expectations about acceptable behaviour within relationships and families.

Case study – R v Challen

Sally Challen was convicted of murdering her husband, Richard Challen in 2010. Her case revived significant attention because evidence of long-term controlling and coercive behaviour within the relationship was considered during later legal proceedings. In 2019, her murder conviction was cancelled an she pleaded guilty to manslaughter on the basis of diminished responsibility.

The case became Significant in discussions about domestic abuse and coercive control, particularly because domestic abuse can involve psychological and controlling behaviour as well as physical violence. It demonstrates how domestic abuse can be difficult to recognise and how the law has increasingly recognised the impact of coercive and controlling behaviour.

AC1.2 – Reasons for unreported crime

Personal reasons

Personal reasons relate to the individual victim’s own feelings, circumstances or attitude, which may prevent them from reporting crime.

Fear

Description – a victim may not report a crime because they are afraid of the offender or of what might happen if they repot it.

They may fear:

. Retaliation or further harm

. Threats

. Intimidation

. Being blamed

. Consequences for themselves or their family

Fear can be particularly important when the offender is someone the victim knows or has power over them.

Example – a victim of domestic abuse may be frightened that reporting their partner could lead to further abuse or threats.

Key point – fear – victim doesn’t report – crime becomes unrecorded

Shame

Description – victims may feel embarrassed, humiliated or ashamed about what happened to them.

This can make them reluctant to tell the police, family members or other authorities.

Shame can be particularly relevant to crimes involving:

. Sexual offences

. Domestic abuse

. Abuse

.financial exploitation

. Crimes where victims feel they nay be judged

Example – a victim of sexual assault may feel embarrassed or ashamed and worry that other people will judge or blame them, so they may not report the offence.

Key point – shame can discourage victims from coming forward even when a crime has clearly occurred.

Disinterest

Description – some victims may simply not feel that reporting the crime is worth the time, effort or stress involved.

They may believe:

. The crime was too minor

. Nothing will happen

. The police will not help

. Reporting it will not make a difference

Example – someone who has had a relatively small amount of property stolen might decide not to report it because they believe the police are unlikely to recover it.

Key point – disinterest – victim chooses not to report – crime may never enter official statistics

Not being affected

Description – a person may witness or become aware of criminal behaviour but decide not to report it because they do not personally feel affected by it.

If they do not see themselves as a victim and believe the crime has little impact on them, they may not think reporting is necessary.

Example – someone might witness minor criminal damage in an area but decide not to report it because their own property was not damaged and they do not feel personally affected.

Key point – the crime can still have occurred even though the person does not believe it is their responsibility to report it.

Social and cultural reasons

(These reasons are linked to society, culture, attitudes, knowledge, and the way crime is perceived.)

Lack of knowledge

Description – people may not report a crime because they do not know that what happened to them is a crime, or they do not know how or where to report it.

This can be particularly relevant when the offence is:

. Complex

. Unfamiliar

. Hidden

. Committed by someone they know

Example – a person experiencing controlling behaviour within a relationship may not initially recognise that certain behaviours can constitute domestic abuse.

Key point – if people don’t recognise something s criminal, they may not report it

Complexity

Description – some crimes are complicated and victims may be uncertain about what happened, who was responsible or whether the behaviour was actually criminal.

Complex crimes can therefore be more to identify and report.

This can apply to:

. Cybercrimes

. Financial crime

. Fraud

. Corporate crime

. Organised crime

Example – a person who has been affected by an online scam may not initially understand how the fraud occurred or who was responsible, making reporting more difficult.

Key point – the more complicated a crime is to understand, the harder it may be for victims to recognise and report it.

Lack of media interest

Description – the media does not give equal attention to every type of crime.

News organisations often prioritise strokes they consider newsworthy, such as unusual, dramatic or serious offences.

If a type of crime receives little media attention, the public may:

. know less about it

. Underestimate its importance

. Be less aware that it can be reported

. Be less likely to recognise it as a significant social problems

Example – some forms of white-collar or corporate crime may receive less attention than highly dramatic violent crimes, meaning the public may have less awareness of their prevalence and impact.

Key point – low media attention – lower public awareness – potentially less reporting.

Lack of current public concern

Description – people’s concerns about crime change over time.

If a particular crime is not currently seen as an important pubic issue, victims may be less likely to believe that’s reporting it will receive attention or lead to action.

Public concern can be influenced by:

. Media coverage

. Major criminal events

. Political debate

. Changes in social attitudes

Example – if a particular type of crime receives very little public discussion, victims may feel that authorities or society do not consider it a priority.

Key point – what society considers important can affect whether crimes are recognised and reported.

Cultural – bound crime

Description – some crimes are strongly connected to cultural beliefs, traditions or social expectations.

Victims may be reluctant to report these offences because they fear:

. Rejection by their family/community

. Bringing shame on their family

. Retaliation

. Not being believed

. Consequences for other family members

Example – honour- based abuse may go unreported because a victim fears consequences from family or community members if they disclose what is happening.

Key point – cultural expectations can sometimes create pressure that makes victims less likely to report criminal behaviour.

Important – this does not mean a culture itself causes crime or that and entire cultural/religious group supports criminal behaviour. The focus is on how particular social expectations can affect reporting.

AC1.3 -explain the consequences of unreported crime

Ripple effect

Description

The ripple effect refers to how the consequences of an unreported crime can spread beyond the original victim and affect other individuals, families, communities and society.

When crime is not reported, the authorities may not realise the full extent of the problem. This can allow the consequences to continue or affect other people.

Example – if domestic abuse is not reported, the offender may continue abusing the victim. Other family members, including children, may also be affected by the ongoing abuse.

Key point – crime not reported – authorities may not intervene – problem continues – more people may be affected.

Cultural

Descriptions

Unreported crime can have cultural consequences because repeated or widespread unreported behaviour can influence what society considers normal or acceptable.

If certain behaviour is repeatedly hidden or ignored, people may become less likely to recognise it as serious criminal behaviour.

This can contribute to the normalisation of harmful behaviour.

Example – if domestic abuse within relationships is repeatedly treated as private family matters rather than reported, this can contribute to attitudes that such behaviour should be dealt with privately rather than through the criminal justice system.

Key point – unreported crime can affect social attitudes and perceptions of what is acceptable behaviour.

Decriminalisation

Descriptions

Decriminalisation occurs when behaviour that was previously treated as a criminal offence is removed from criminal law, meaning it is no longer treated as a criminal offence.

A high level of unreported crime can contribute to debates about whether certain laws are effective or appropriate.

If a behaviour is widespread but rarely reported or enforced, governments may reconsider how it should be dealt with.

Example - homosexual activity between men was gradually decriminalised in England and Wales, beginning with the Sexual Offences Act 1967 for private acts between men aged over 21 and over.

This demonstrates how hanging social attitudes can eventually lead to behaviour being removed from criminal law.

Key point – decriminalisation does not mean the behaviour suddenly becomes socially accepted by everyone. It means it is no longer prohibited as a criminal offence in the same way.

Police prioritisation

Description

Police forces have limited resources, so they have to decide which crimes and problems should receive the greatest attention.

If certain crimes are frequently reported, the police are more likely to recognise them as significant problems and prioritise resources towards them.

Crimes that are rarely reported may receive less police attention because their true extent is not visible in official data.

Example – if police forces receives many reports of burglary in a particular are, it may increase patrols, investigations or crime-prevention measures there. However, if domestic abuse or sexual offences are heavily underreported, the police may initially underestimate the scale of the problem.

Key point – underreporting – less visible crimes problem – potentially lower priority – fewer resources directed towards it.

Unrecorded crime

Descriptions

One direct consequence of crime not being reported is that it can become unrecorded crime.

If a victim does not report an offence too the police, it will generally not appear in police-recorded crime statistics.

This contribute to the dark figure of crime ( crime that occurs but is not known about or recorded by the authorities).

Example – if someone is a victim of a minor theft but decides not to contact the police, the offence may not appear in police-recorded crime statistics.

Key point – official statistics can therefore underestimate the true level of crime. This is one reason alterative sources of information, such as victimisation surveys, are important.

Cultural change

Description

Unreported crime can contribute to changes in cultural attitudes over time.

As society becomes more aware of previously hidden forms of crime, attitudes can change. Increased awareness may encourage victims to report offences that were previously kept private.

This can then lead to greater recognition of certain crimes as important social problems.

Example – greater awareness of domestic abuse has contributed to changes in attitudes towards violence and controlling behaviour within relationships.

Behaviour that was once more likely to be treated as a private family issue is increasingly recognised as a serious social and criminal issue.

Key point – increased awareness – changing attitudes – greater recognition/ reporting – better understanding of the scale of the problem.

Legal change

Description

Legal change occurs when laws are introduced, removed or amended.

Evidence that certain crimes are widespread, harmful or previously under recognised can contribute to pressure for changes in legislation.

Unreported crime can therefore create a problem because lawmakers may not have an accurate picture of the scale of an offence.

However, increased awareness of hidden crime can eventually contribute to new laws or stronger legal protections.

Example – the domestic violence, Crime and Victims Act 2004 strengthened legal protections and provisions relating to domestic violence and victims. More recently, the Domestic Abuse Act 2021 created a statutory definition of domestic abuse and introduced further protections and measures.

Key point – legal change can occur when society and policymakers increasingly recognised a form of behaviour as requiring stronger legal protection or intervention.

Procedural change

Description

Procedural change refers to changes in the way organisations such as the police, courts or other agencies deal with crime.

If authorities discover that certain crimes are being underreported they may change procedures to make reporting easier, improve victim support or encourage victims to come forward.

Example – changes in police procedures and specialist approaches to domestic abuse have included improved safeguarding, risk assessment and support for victims.

These procedure can make it easier to identify victims and respond to cases that might otherwise remain hidden.

Key point – procedural change = changing the way crime is dealt with, rather than necessarily changing the law itself.

AC1.4 – Describe media representations of crime

Newspaper

Detailed description

Newspaper represent crime though headlines, photographs, articles and stories. They decide which crimes to report and how much attention to give them.

Crime stories can be presented in a sensationalist way, particularly when the crime is violent, unusual or involves a vulnerable victim. Headlines may emphasis danger and fear because dramatic stories are more likely to attract readers.

Newspapers can therefore influence how the public understands the seriousness frequency and nature of crime.

They may also use stereotypes, for example portraying certain groups or young people as threatening or criminal.

Example – tabloid newspapers may use dramatic headlines and images when reporting violent crime or terrorism, potentially making the crime appear more common or threatening than it actually is.

Key terms – sensationalism, stereotyping, news values , fear of crime

Television

Detailed description

Television represents crime through news programmes, documentaries, dramas and fictional crime programmes.

Television can influence perceptions because viewers seem crime represented visually and repeatedly. Crime dramas may exaggerate how frequently serious crimes occur or how quickly crimes are solved.

News programmes can also focus heavily on particularly dramatic crimes, creating the impression that these crimes are more common than they actually are.

However, television can also provide educational and informative representations, such as documentaries explaining the causes and consequences of crime.

Example – crime dramas such as Line of Duty portray police investigations and serious offences. Although fictional, repeated exposure to crime on television can influence people’s perceptions of how common certain offences are and how thee criminal justice system operates.

Key point – television can represent crime as both fictional entertainment and real-world news, so the representation may not always reflect the actual frequency of crime.

Electronic gaming

Detailed description

Electronic games can represent crime through their character, storylines, missions and gameplay.

Some games allow players to take the role of criminal and participate in fictional criminal activities. Crime can therefore be presented as exciting, entertaining or rewarding rather than showing its realistic consequences.

Games can also represent police, criminals and victims in particular ways, potentially reinforcing stereotypes.

However, it is important to distinguish fictional representations of crime in games from actual criminal behaviour. Playing a game involving crime does not mean the player will commit crime.

Example – Grand Theft Auto V allows players to take part in fictional activities such as theft, robbery, vehicle crime and violence.

This provides an example of how electronic gaming can represent crime as part of an entertainment narrative.

Key terms – fictional representation, criminal stereotypes, entertainment, normalisation

Social media

Detailed description

Social media allows crime-related information to be shared rapidly and widely.

Platforms can allow users to share news reports, videos, eyewitness accounts, opinions and rumours. Unlike traditional media, ordinary members of the public can create and distribute crime-related content themselves.

This means crime representations can spread extremely quickly, sometimes before reliable information is available.

Social media can therefore:

. Increase awareness of crime

. Expose criminal behaviour

. Spread misinformation

. Create fear or panic

. Reinforce stereotypes

. Influence public attitudes

Example – videos of street violence or disorder can be shared widely on social media, sometimes attracting millions of views. Repeated exposure can make viewers feel that these events are more common than they actually are.

Key point - social media differs from traditional media because audiences can also become producers of crime representations.

Music

Detailed description

Music can represent crime through lyrics, themes, images and music videos.

Some genres or individual artist may include references to violence, drugs, gangs, weapons, or other criminal behaviour.

These representations can sometimes glamorise or normalise criminal lifestyles, particularly when criminal behaviour is presented as a source of status, money or respect.

However, music can also represent crime negatively, criticising violence, inequality or criminal exploitation.

Therefore, music does not have one single representation of crime.

Example – Some gangsters rap and drill songs have been criticised fro references to violence, weapons and criminal lifestyles. At the same time, artists may argue that their music reflect the realities of their environment rather than encouraging crime.

Key point – music can provide representations of crime that are either glamorised, criticised or reflective of social conditions.

Film

Detailed description

Films can represent crime through characters, plots, dialogue and visual imagery.

Crimes films may portrays criminals as powerful, intelligent, wealthy or successful which can sometimes glamorise criminal behaviour.

Other films present the negative consequences of crime, such as imprisonment, victimisation and harm to families.

Films can also create stereotypes of particular types of criminals, victims or social groups.

Because films are designed to entertain, representations may be exaggerated and are not necessarily an accurate representation of real crime.

Example – The Godfather represents organised crime through the fictional Corleone family and portrays the activities and power of a criminal organisation.

It provides an example of how film can create a dramatic and sometimes glamorous representation of organised crime

Key terms – glamorisation, stereotyping, fictional representation, organised crime

AC1.5 – explain the impact of media representations on public perception of crime

Moral panics

Description

A moral panic occurs when the media exaggerates or sensationalises a perceived threat to society, causing public concern and fear about a particular person, groups, behaviour or type of crime.

Stanley Cohen (1972) developed the concept in Folk Devils and Moral Panics. He argued that the media can portray certain groups as a threat to society and create a folk devil – a group that becomes blamed for wider social problems.

The media may exaggerate the seriousness or frequency of an event, increasing public concern and putting pressure on authorities to respond.

Example – Mods and Rockers

Cohen studied media coverage of clashes between Mods and Rockers in the 1960s.

The groups were portrayed as dangerous and threatening to social order. Media coverage increased public concern, while the groups became associated with deviance.

This demonstrates how media representations can contribute to a moral panic.

Key terms – moral panic, folk devil, sensationalism, Stanley Cohen, public concern

Changing public concerns and attitudes

Description

Media representations can change what the public is concerned about and how people feel about particular crimes.

When the media repeatedly focuses on a particular crime, people may believe it is especially serious or widespread, even if it represents only a small proportion of overall crime.

Media converge can therefore increase – fear, concern, anger, demands for action, negative attitudes towards particular groups

Example – Terrorism

Extensive reporting of terrorist attacks can make terrorism a major public concern.

Although terrorism is relatively rare compared with many other offences, repeated coverage of attacks can make people perceive terrorism as an especially significant threat.

Key point – high media coverage = increased public attention = greater concern = changed attitudes towards crime.


Perceptions of crime trends

Descriptions

The media can influence whether people believe crime is increasing or decreasing.

If news organisations repeatedly report serious or violent crimes, the public may develop the impression that crime is constantly increasing.

This can happen even when official statistics or victimisation surveys show a different trend.

This is sometimes called a distorted perception of crime because people judge the level of crime partly from what they see and hear in the media rather than from actual crime statistics.

Example – repeated reporting of violent crime and knife crime can make people believe violent crime is increasing everywhere.

The actual risk of becoming a victim may be considerably lower than people’s perception suggests.

Key point – what receives the most media coverage isn’t necessarily what happens most frequently.

Stereotyping of criminals

Description

A stereotypes is an oversimplified or generalised idea about a particular group.

Media representations can create stereotypes of who a “typical criminal” is. Certain groups may repeatedly be represented as dangerous, violent or deviant.

This can influence public perception by causing people to associate particular characteristics, appearances, ages or social groups with criminal behaviour.

This may increase – fear, suspicion, prejudice, discrimination

It can also influence how authorities respond to particular groups.

Example – young people wearing hoodies

Yung people wearing hooded clothing have sometimes been represented in the media as threatening or associated with crime.

This can create the stereotypes that young people dressed in this way are likely to be criminals, even though clothing does not determine whether someone has committed an offence.

Example – Muslims and terrorism

Some media represent Iain’s have repeatedly associated Islam or Muslim communities with terrorism.

This can contribute to inaccurate stereotypes and islamophobia, despite terrorism being committed by a very small proportion of individuals and not representing Muslims generally.

Key point – stereotyping = simplifying a group into a fixed image or set of characteristics.

Levels of response to crime and types of punishment

Description

Media representations can influence how strongly the public, police and government respond to crime.

Extensive and emotional coverage can create pressure for authorities to take action.

This may lead to:

. Increased policing

. Tougher enforcement

. Demands for harsher sentence

. Changes to punishment

. Greater political attention

The response may sometimes become disproportionate if public fear is based on exaggerated media representations.

Example – London Riots 2011

The 2011 London riots received extensive media coverage.

Images and reports of disorder were repeatedly broadcast, creating significant public concern.

The events led to major discussions about – policing, punishment, responsibility, how offenders should be dealt with.

The case demonstrates how highly publicised crime and disorder can produce strong demands for an official response.

Key point – media coverage = public concerns = pressure on authorities = stronger response/ punishment.

Changing priorities and emphasis

Description

Major crimes or criminal events can cause the government and police to change their priorities.

When media gives extensive attention to a particular threat, it can increase public and political pressure to dedicate resources to that issue.

This can influence – policing priorities, government policy, legislation, allocation of resources, national security priorities.

Example – 9/11

The 9/11 terrorist attacks in 2001 received enormous international media coverage.

Terrorism later became a much greater priority for governments and law-enforcement agencies, including in the UK.

This contributed to increased emphasis on:

. Counter – terrorism

. Intelligence

. National security

. Preventing terrorist financing

. Surveillance and security measures

Key point – major event + extensive media coverage = increased public concern – political pressure – changed priorities and policies.

Deviancy Amplification (IMPORTANT THEORY)

This links particularly strongly to moral panic, stereotyping and changing public attitudes.

Deviancy Amplification is the process where media attention to deviant behaviour increases public concern and official responses, which can sometimes contribute to further deviance, creating a cycle.

The basic cycle:

Initial deviance – media exaggeration/sensationalism – public concern – police/authority response – more attention and labelling – potential further deviance – more media coverage.

(This process is sometimes called a deviancy amplification spiral).

Key point – Leslie Wilkins (1967) developed the concept of deviancy amplification, which was later associated with Cohen’s work on moral panics.

AC1.6 – evaluate methods of collecting statistics about crime

The two methods of collecting crime statistics

There are two main methods used to measure and track crime in England and Wales.

Method 1: police – recorded crime (PRC) = the home office publishes statistics based on crimes reported to and recorded by police forces. The figures can be broken down by offence type, location and time period.

Example – police records can show how many burglaries were recorded in a particular area over a year.

Method 2: crime survey for England and Wales (CSEW)

The CSEW is a victimisation survey conducted by the office for national statistics (ONS). It asks a sample of people about their experiences of crime, including incidents that they did not report to the police.

Example – someone might tell the survey that they experienced theft even though they never contracted the police.

The two methods complement each other because they collect different kinds of information. Neither give a complete picture of every crime that occurs.

Key terms:

. Reliability – whether a method produces consistent results when repeated under comparable conditions

. Validity – whether a method measures what it is intended to measure

. Ethics – moral principles that guide research, including privacy, confidentially, informed consent and avoiding harm

. Strength – a feature that makes a method useful or effective

. Limitation – a weakness that reduces the usefulness, accuracy or coverage of a method

. Dark figure of crime – crime that occurs but is not included in official police-recorded statistics, often because it is not reported or recorded

. Sample – the people selected to take part in a survey.

. Representativeness – how closely a sample reflects the population it is intended to represent

Remember – reliability and validity are different. A method an be consistent without accurately measuring the true level of crime.

Method 1: Police-Recorded Crime (PRC)

Reliability

Reliability means consistency. Police-recorded crime is more reliable when different officers and forces apply the same rules consistently.

Strengths:

. Police records provide counts of recorded offences rather than estimates from a survey sample

. Standardised recording rules help police forces classify offences consistently

. They can provide useful information about trends in offences that are commonly reported and recorded

. They are useful for identifying local patterns and monitoring police activity

Limitations

. Different officers may interpret or apply recording rules differently

. Changes in recording practices can affect figures from one year to the next

. Some crimes reported to the police are not recorded, meaning the statistics may be incomplete

. Improvements in recording can cause recorded crime to rise even if the underlying level of crime has not risen by the same amount

Example – if a police force improves its recording procedures and beings recording more reported offences correctly, its figures may rise because recording has improved rather than because crime has increased.

Evaluation – police- recorded crime can be reliable for understanding recorded offences, but comparisons over time and between forces need caution because differences in recording practices can affect consistently.

Validity

Validity means whether the statistics accurately measure what they are intended to measure.

Strengths

. The records provide information about actual incidents that have been reported and recorded

. They include offences that a victimisation survey may not measures, including homicide and offences against society.

. They cover a wider range of people and organisations than the household-based CSEW, including businesses and people living in some institutional settings

Limitations

. Not all crimes are reported to the police

. Not every reported crime is necessarily recorded

. Some victims may not report crime because of fear, shame, embarrassment or a lack of trust

. The figures therefore cannot show the full amount of crime occurring in society

Example – if a person experiences domestic abuse but does not report it, the incident will not appear in police-recorded crime statistics unless it comes to police attention and is recorded through another route.

Evaluation – police-recorded crime has good validity for measuring offences know to and recorded by police, but it is less valid as a complete measure of all crimes occurring in society.

Ethics

Ethics concerns how information is collected, stored, used and published while respecting people’s rights.

Strengths

. Official records can be processed into statistics without publishing individual victims’’ identities

. Appropriate confidentiality and data-protection procedures can help protect victims

. police can use information to investigate crime and identify safeguarding needs

Limitations

. Victims may be distressed by having to provide information about traumatic incidents

. Personal information must be protected from inappropriate access or disclosure

. Inaccurate recording or handling of sensitive information can cause additional harm to victims

Example – information about a sexual offences must be handled carefully so that the victim’s identity and private details are not disclosed unnecessarily.

Evaluation – police records can be collected and used ethically, but this depends on appropriate confidentiality, data protection and sensitive treatment of victims. Ethical practice does not automatically make the resulting statistics complete or accurate.

Purpose of research

Police-recorded crime statistics help the home office, police forces, researchers and the public understand the crimes reported to and recorded by the police.

They can be used to:

. Identify common offences and changes in recorded crime over time

. Compare recorded crime between geographical areas

. Help police decide where to allocate resources and patrols

. Identify patterns that may require investigation or crime-prevention measures

. Inform government decisions and public discussion about crime

Example – if police records show repeated burglaries in one neighbourhood, the police may consider increasing patrols or introducing targeted crime-prevention measures.

Evaluation – these statistics are useful for planning because they contain information about actual recorded incidents and locations. However, an area with more recorded crime does not necessarily have more crime occurring overall, it may also have higher reporting rates or different recording practices.

Method 2: crime survey for England and Wales (CSEW)

Reliability

Reliability means whether the survey produces consistent results when conducted using comparable methods.

Strengths

. The CSEW uses a structured survey with standardised questions

. A large sample helps provide useful estimates for common types of crime

. Consistent methods over time make it useful for examining long-term trends

. It is not directly affected by changes in the number of people reporting crimes to police or by police recording practices

Limitations

. The CSEW surveys a sample rather than every person in England and Wales, so estimates are subject to sampling error

. Respondents may forget incidents or give inaccurate answers

. Changes in survey methods or questions can affect comparisons between different periods

. Rare offences can produce less stable estimates because relatively few respondents experience them

Example – if a respondent forgets a theft that occurred several months earlier, the incident may not be included in their survey answers

Evaluation – the CSEW is useful for identifying long – term trends in common offences within the population it covers. However, its estimates are less precise for rare offences and may be affected by member errors.

Validity

Validity means whether the survey accurately measures the crime experiences it aim to measure.

Strengths

. It includes experiences of crime that were never reported to the police

. It collects information directly from respondents about their experiences

. It can reveal patterns in victimisation that police recorders alone may not show

. It is useful for estimating trends in common victim-based among people living in private households

Limitations

. It depends on respondents remembering and honestly reporting their experiences

. It does not cover every person in England and Wales, such as people living in communal establishments or people experiencing homelessness

. It cannot measure crimes without an identifiable victims who can be interviewed, such as drug possession

. Crimes against businesses and some other organisations are outside its household victimisation coverage

. Some sensitive offences require separate survey modules and may be difficult to measure fully

Example – a person might forget a minor incident or feel uncomfortable disclosing a sensitive experience, meaning that the survey may not capture it.

Evaluation – the CSEW can provide a more complete measure of many common victim-based crimes because it captures unreported incidents. Nevertheless, it is not a complete measure of every crime and its validity depends partly on the accuracy and coverage of respondents answers.

Ethics

The CSEW must protect respondents’ privacy and ensure participation is handled appropriately.

Strengths

. Participation is voluntary and respondents should be given appropriate information about the research

. Confidentially helps protect respondents’ identities and personal information

. Sensitive information should be handled carefully and used for legitimate research purposes

. Ethical procedure can help respondents feel safer when discussing victimisation

Limitations

. Questions about abuse, violence or other distressing experiences may cause discomfort

. Respondents may fear that private information could be disclosed

. Some people may fell pressured or reluctant, reducing the completeness of their answers

Example – a respondent who has experienced domestic abuse may feel uncomfortable answering questions about it, even when confidentiality protections are in place.

Evaluation – the CSEW can be conducted ethically through informed participation, confidentiality and sensitive interviewing. However, researchers must minimise distress and protect privacy, particularly when asking about sensitive experiences.

Purpose of research

The CSEW is a victimisation survey designed to measure people’s experiences of crime .it asks a sample during the previous 12 months.

It helps researchers and the government:

. Estimate the extent of crime experienced by the population covered by the survey

. Identify crimes that victims did not report to the police

. Understand the characteristics of victims and their experiences

. Examine longer-term trends in common types of crime

. Inform crime-prevention policies and public services

Example – a respondent ay report experiencing a theft even if they did not report it to the police. This helps researchers estimate crime that police records may miss.

Evaluation – the CSEW provides information beyond police reports, making it particularly useful for understanding victimisation and longer-term trends. However, it cannot measure every crime because it relies on a sample of respondents and only covers certain populations and offences.

Comparing the two methods

Reliability – police-recorded crime = a count of recorded offences but recording practices may vary. CSEW = consistent survey methods help track long-terms trends, but estimates can vary.

Validity – police -recorded crime = measures crimes known to and recorded by police, not all crimes. CSEW = captures unreported victimisation, but relies on respondents and limited coverage.

Ethics – police recorded crime = must protect personal information and handle victims’ details appropriately. CSEW = must protect confidentiality, support voluntary participation and minimise distress.

Main strength – police recorded crime = broad offence and population coverage, useful for local and low-volume offences. CSEW = measures many unreported crimes and long-term trends in common victim-based offences.

Main limitation – police recorded crime = the dark figure of crime and recording differences. CSEW = sampling, recall and coverage limitations.

Neither method is best for every purpose. Using both provides a more comprehensive picture of crime than relying on either source alone.

AC2.1 - compare campaigns for change

Campaign 1: Sarah’s Law

Purpose

Sarah’s, formally known as the Child Sex Offender Disclosure Scheme (CSODS), allows people to ask the police whether a specific person who has contact with a child has relevant information on record indicating a safeguarding risk. Its purpose is to help protect children by allowing police to disclosure relevant information when necessary. It is a scheme, not a separate Act of Parliament.

Driving forces

The campaign followed the murder of 8-year-old Sarah Payne in 2000 by Roy Whiting, who had previously been convicted of a child sexual offence. The case attracted widespread media attention. Sarah’s mother, Sara Payne, supported calls for parents to be able to request relevant information about people who might pose a risk to children.

Methods and media

Newspaper reports, television coverage and Sara Payne’s public campaigning raised awareness of child protection. The campaign called for a way for parents to request relevant safeguarding information. The disclosure scheme provides a practical route for people to approach the police.

Location/coverage

The scheme was rolled out across England and Wales on 4th April 2011, covering all 43 police force areas. It was therefore national rather than local, although arrangements elsewhere in the UK differ.

Success

During its first year, the scheme received over 1,600 enquires and more than 900 applications, resulting in at least 160 disclosures relating to child sexual offences. This demonstrates that the scheme was used and information was shared to support safeguarding. However, these figures do not prove that every disclosure prevented the offence. Its main success was establishing a national process for requesting relevant information to help protect children.

Campaign 2: Brexit – vote leave

Purpose

Vote leave aimed to persuade the public to vote for the UK to leave the European Union in the 2016 referendum. It argued that leaving would give the UK greater control over its laws, borders and decisions. Its main objective was to win the referendum and change the UK’s relationship with the EU.

Driving forces

The campaign grew from long running disagreements about EU membership. Supporters of leaving were concerned about national sovereignty, immigration and the UK’s ability to make independent decisions. These political disagreements led to a referendum in which voters could choose whether the UK should remain in or leave the EU.

Methods and media

Vote leave used television interviews, newspaper coverage, posters, leaflets, speeches, public events and online campaigning. Its slogan “Take Back Control,” communicated its message about national decision – making. Prominent politicians, including Boris Johnson and Micheal Gove, helped attract attention and promote the campaign.

Location/coverage

Vote leave was national UK-wide campaign connected to the referendum held on 23rd June 2016. It used national media and public campaigning to reach voters across England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland.

Success

Vote leave achieved its immediate objective: 51.9% voted leave and 48.1% voted remain, with turnout of 72.2%. The UK subsequently left EU on 31st January 2020. This was a major political outcome, although the result was relatively close and voters supported leave for different reasons. The referendum result demonstrates success in achieving the campaign’s main objective, while the longer-term effects of leaving the EU are more complex to evaluate.

Campaign 3: Unlock

Purpose

Unlock is a charity that supports people with criminal records. It campaigned to reform the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974 so that some convictions would become spent sooner. This aimed to reduce unnecessary barriers to employment and help people rehabilitate and rebuild their lives after offending.

Driving forces

People with criminal records can face difficulties finding work because they may have to disclose convictions for long periods. Unlock argued that this could unfairly disadvantage people who had served their sentences and were trying to move forward the campaign aimed to balance public protection with rehabilitation and fairer opportunities.

Methods and media

Unlock used research, reports, public information, personal experiences and communication with politicians to support legal reform. It highlighted the difficulties people faced because of criminal-record disclosure rules and used evidence to persuade policymakers that changes were needed.

Location/coverage

The campaign for reform affected England and Wales, where the relevant changes to the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974 came into force. It was a national campaign for legal change rather than a campaign limited to one local community.

Success

Reforms came into force on 10th March 2014, reducing disclosure periods for some convictions. Unlock estimated that more than 1.75 million people benefited from the changes. This provides evidence of a significant legal outcome, although some convictions will need to be disclosed in relevant circumstances. Overall, the campaign helped change the law and reduce barriers for many people with criminal records.

Campaign 4: No Knives, Better Lives

Purpose

No Knives, Better Lives is a Scottish prevention and education programme that aims to reduce youth violence and discourage knife carrying. It helps young people understand the consequences of violence and encourages safer choices through education, early intervention and community support.

Driving forces

The programme developed in response to concerns about youth violence and knife carrying in Scotland. These issues can harm young people and communities. The campaign promotes prevention by helping young people understand the risks of violence and supporting practitioners who work with those who may be vulnerable to becoming involved in it.

Methods and media

The programme uses educational sessions, youth work resources, practitioner training and peer education. These methods help youth workers and young people discuss violence prevention and communicate safer choices. Rather than relying mainly on celebrity endorsements or news coverage, the programme focuses on education and community involvement.

Location/coverage

No Knives, Better Lives operates nationally within Scotland, working with local authorities and community partners. Its resources and activities are delivered locally, allowing the programme to reach young people in different Scottish communities.it is not a UK-wide programme.

Success

The programme reported that since 2009 it has reached 163,500 young people supported 5,778 practitioners with training and resources , and trained 649 peer educators. These figures demonstrate substantial reach and investment in prevention education. However, the number of people reached does not by itself prove that the programme caused knife crime to decrease. Its success is clearer in delivering education and training than in providing a direct reduction in offending.

Campaign 5: Stop Hate UK

Purpose

Stop Hate UK is a charity that challenges hate crime and discrimination, supports victims and raises public awareness. It aims to make reporting hate incidents easier and help people affected by hate access support. The campaign also encourages communities to challenge prejudice and discrimination.

Driving forces

The organisation was established in 1995 in response to concerns about racism and hate. The murder of Stephen Lawrence in 1993 and the subsequent public inquiry highlighted serious problems with responses to racist crime. The inquiry recommended improving how people could report racist incidents, helping drive the development of more accessible reporting services.

Methods and media

Stop Hate UK uses reporting and support services, educational resources, workshops, training and community awareness activities. Its Stop Hate Line launched in 2006, providing another way for people to report hate incidents and seek support. These methods combine practical help for victims withe education intended to challenge prejudice.

Location/coverage

Stop Hate UK is a UK wide organisation, although the availability of particular commissioned services and vary between areas. It works with communities and organisations to improve awareness, reporting and support fro people affected by hate crime.

Success

The launch of the Stop Hate Line in 2006 provided a practical reporting and support route in response to concerns highlighted by the Stephen Lawrence inquiry. The organisation has continued its educational and support work. However, providing a helpline does not climate hate crime, and a increase in reported could reflect greater awareness as well as changes in offending. Its achievements are clearest in providing support and improving access to reporting, while its overall effect on hate crime is harder to measure.

Comparing the campaigns

Changes in law: Unlock campaigned fro changes to criminal-record disclosure rules, while Vote leave (Brexit) sought a change in the UK’s relationship with the EU through a referendum. Sarah’s Law established a police disclosure scheme rather than a separate Act of Parliament.

Changes in policy and agency priorities: Sarah’s Law focuses on child safeguarding, No Knives, Better Lives priorities violence prevention, and Stop Hate UK promotes hate crime reporting and victim support. Unlock highlights rehabilitation and fairer opportunities for people with criminal records.

Changes in awareness: Vote Leave brought EU membership into a major national debate. Sarah’s Law raised awareness of child safeguarding, Unlock highlighted barriers linked to criminal records, No Knives, Better Lives promotes awareness of youth violence, and Stop Hate UK raises awareness of hate crime.

Changes in attitudes: Unlock challenges the idea that a criminal record should permanently prevent rehabilitation. No Knives, Better Lives encourages safer choices, and Stop Hate UK challenges prejudice. Sarah’s Law encourages adults to take child safeguarding seriously, while Vote leave sought public support for a different political relationships with the EU.

Overall comparison: all five campaigns aimed to create change, but their objectives and evidence of success differ. Unlock achieved legal reform, Vote Leave achieved its referendum objectives, Sarah’s Law established a national safeguarding scheme, Stop Hate UK provides reporting and support, and No Knives, Better Lives delivers prevention education. Their effectiveness should be judged against their individual aims.