Psyc363 Week 5: Dissociative and Somatic Symptom Disorders
Learning Outcomes and Case Conceptualisation
- The course material for PSYC363 Psychopathology, presented by Dr Hamish Love (PhD) at the University of New England, covers two primary learning outcomes for this module:
- Outcome 5.1: Summarise the symptoms, aetiological models, and available treatments for Dissociative Disorders.
- Outcome 5.2: Summarise the symptoms, aetiology, and available treatments for Somatic Symptom and Related Disorders.
- The lecture framework employs the 5 Ps of Case Conceptualisation to assess these disorders:
- Presenting Problem (What?): Identifying the primary symptoms and current issues.
- Predisposing factors (Who? / Why?): Factors that make the individual more vulnerable to the disorder before it starts.
- Precipitating factors (When? / Why?): The triggers or specific events that caused the onset of symptoms.
- Perpetuating factors (How do we treat it?): Factors that keep the problem going.
- Protective/Positive factors (How do we treat it?): Strengths or environmental supports that aid in recovery.
Defining Dissociation and the Dissociation Spectrum
- Definition: According to the Oxford Dictionary, dissociation is disconnecting or separating, or the state of being disconnected.
- Dissociation as a Normal Experience:
- It can be a non-pathological experience, such as being ‘off your face’ or certain religious experiences.
- It serves as a normal response to stress and trauma. It is a mechanism to handle frightening experiences where an individual simply does not want to be present, achieved by changing focus or ‘pulling oneself together’.
- Psychological Disorders as Continua:
- Dissociation is viewed as a functional purpose existing on a spectrum.
- In terms of probability density and standard normal distribution, pathological states represent the extremes of these functional purposes.
- The Dissociation Spectrum (from Mild to Severe):
- 'Normal' dissociation: Checking out or zoning out.
- Everyday dissociation: Common instances of mental wandering.
- Depersonalization & derealization: Feeling detached from self or surroundings.
- PTSD/Trauma/Dissociative Amnesia: Memory loss related to trauma.
- Dissociative Identity Disorder: The most complex end of the spectrum.
Measuring Dissociation: The DES-II
- Dissociative Experiences Scale – II (DES-II): A tool used to measure the percentage of time a person experiences various dissociative states.
- Sample Questions from DES-II:
- Suddenly realizing they don’t remember part or all of a trip taken by car, bus, or subway.
- Realizing they did not hear part or all of what someone just said while listening to them.
- Finding themselves in a place with no idea how they got there.
- Scoring: Measured on a scale from 0% (Never) to 100% (Always).
- Average DES Scores in Research:
- General Adult Population: 5.4
- Anxiety Disorders: 7.0
- Affective Disorders: 9.35
- Eating Disorders: 15.8
- Late Adolescence: 16.6
- Schizophrenia: 15.4
- Borderline Personality Disorder: 19.2
- Posttraumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD): 31
- Dissociative Disorder Not Otherwise Specified (DDNOS): 36
- Dissociative Identity Disorder (DID) / Multiple Personality Disorder (MPD): 48 to 49
- Clinical Diagnostic Tools:
- Dissociative Disorders Interview Schedule.
- Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-V (SCID-V).
- A dissociative disorder is likely present if a person reports dissociative experiences 30% of the time or more on the DES.
Depersonalisation/Derealisation Disorder
- What? (Presenting Problem):
- It involves a disconcerting and disruptive sense of detachment from one's self or one's surroundings.
- Depersonalization: Defined by a sense of being detached from one’s self.
- Derealization: Defined by a sense of detachment from surroundings, where things seem unreal.
- Why? When? Who? (Predisposing + Precipitating Factors):
- Symptoms are usually triggered by stress.
- How to Treat? (Perpetuating + Protective Factors):
- MBCBT: Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Behavioral Therapy.
- DBT: Dialectical Behavior Therapy.
- Somatic: Body-focused therapies.
- EMDR: Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing.
Dissociative Amnesia and Fugues
- What? (Presenting Problem):
- The inability to recall important personal information, usually concerning a traumatic experience.
- Information is not permanently lost but is inaccessible during the episode.
- Episodes can last from minutes to several decades.
- Fugue: A more severe subtype involving more extensive memory loss.
- Differential Diagnosis: It is distinguished from dementia fairly easily.
- Four Types of Dissociative Amnesia:
1. Localized: Failure to remember an event or a specific period of time (the most common type).
2. Selective (Patchy): Failure to remember specific aspects of an event or some events within a timeframe but not others.
3. Continuous (Anterograde): The inability to form new memories as events occur.
4. Generalized: Complete loss of identity and life history (rare), covering a long period (months or years).
- Treatment Modalities:
- MBCBT, DBT, Somatic, EMDR, and a Trauma-Informed approach.
Other Specified Dissociative Disorder (OSDD)
- OSDD is a category for dissociative presentations that do not meet the full criteria for DID, amnesia, or depersonalization/derealization disorder.
- Four Types of OSDD:
- OSDD-1: Sub-threshold Dissociative Identity Disorder (DID).
- OSDD-2: Coercive persuasion resulting in a loss of identity.
- OSDD-3: Acute dissociation resulting from stressful events.
- OSDD-4: Dissociative trance.
- Treatment: MBCBT, DBT, Somatic therapy, EMDR, and Trauma-Informed care.
Dissociative Identity Disorder (DID)
- What? (Presenting Problem):
- Formerly known as Multiple Personality Disorder.
- Requires at least two separate personalities or "alters."
- Alters: Different modes of being, thinking, feeling, and acting that exist independently and emerge at different times.
- Usually features one primary personality, which is typically the one seeking treatment.
- Aetiology and Demographics:
- Prevalence: Research indicates between 1% and 3% of the general population meet diagnostic criteria.
- Often diagnosed only in adulthood, though patients report symptoms dating back to childhood post-diagnosis.
- Treatment (Perpetuating + Protective Factors):
- Empathy and safety are critical.
- 3-Stage Treatment Model:
1. Safety and stabilization.
2. Working through traumatic memories.
3. Reintegrating identities and rehabilitation.
- General Features:
- Involves distress and excessive energy expenditure regarding health concerns.
- Tendency to seek frequent medical treatment, often at great expense.
- Patterns include Somatic Symptom Disorder and Illness Anxiety Disorder.
- Aetiology:
- Symptoms often begin or intensify following trauma, conflict, or stress.
- These disorders appear more commonly in women than in men.