Multiculturalism in Aotearoa New Zealand

History of Multiculturalism in Aotearoa NZ

  • Tracking the history of people within Aotearoa NZ is captured on the government's Te Ara website.
  • Māori are considered the first settlers, the indigenous people of Aotearoa.
  • Stories vary by Rohe (region) and tribal stories.
  • A well-known story involves the Māori navigator Kupe, who chased his octopus Te Whikia Maturangi and arrived in Aotearoa.
  • New Zealand wasn't known to Europeans until 1642, about four centuries after Polynesian navigators landed.
  • Settlers from England, Scotland, and Ireland arrived from the late eighteenth century, seeking a better life.
  • From the twentieth century onwards, war, persecution, and the search for better lifestyles brought diverse groups and individuals to Aotearoa.
  • Today's New Zealanders have heritage from The Pacific, Europe, Asia, Africa, and America.

Ethnic Representation in Aotearoa NZ

  • Census data indicates increasing multiculturalism in Aotearoa.

Feelings About Multiculturalism

  • Differing opinions exist regarding multiculturalism.
  • Some believe the state only recognizes the dominant Pākehā culture and indigenous Māori culture, despite evidence of multiculturalism.
  • Some supporters of biculturalism are against multiculturalism promoting that a multicultural policy would diminish the importance of Māori language and culture.
  • The Treaty of Waitangi establishes an expectation for the Crown to protect the rights of Māori.
  • Some prefer New Zealand to be officially multicultural, where the state recognizes and provides for multiple cultures, languages, and rights.
  • Many who support biculturalism see it as a foundation for successful multiculturalism.
  • Debate revolves around which cultures should receive official recognition from the state.

Biculturalism as a Foundation for Multiculturalism

  • Multiculturalism gives the sense of belonging, but there are questions regarding the order of biculturalism vs multiculturalism.
  • Ranginue Walker (2012) stated that becoming bicultural is the first step towards becoming multicultural.

Multicultural New Zealand

  • Multicultural New Zealand is a non-government organization established in 1989 to care for ethnic communities.
  • Their vision is a multicultural New Zealand where people of different cultures and beliefs live safely and in harmony.
  • Their mission is to represent and support multicultural groups through leadership, partnership, capacity building, and service delivery.
  • They are committed to a treaty-based multicultural society, advocating for a society where Māori have particular status as tangata whenua.

Tensions

  • Positives of multiculturalism: intergroup relations, support for immigration, intercultural contact, less racial bias, and negative feelings towards minorities.
  • Negatives: the majority group might feel threatened, generating prejudice and undermining intergroup relations.
  • Tensions arise from whether to prioritize biculturalism or multiculturalism, especially concerning the status of Māori as tangata whenua.
  • Ward (2013) argues that some tensions are due to confusions and misunderstandings of what multiculturalism means.

What is Multiculturalism?

  • The existence of many different restaurants doesn't necessarily mean New Zealand is multicultural, as culture is more than just food.
  • Active participation and acknowledging other aspects of culture are important.
  • Eating ethnic food can signal an openness to cultural difference.
  • Understanding multiculturalism involves embracing and celebrating cultural diversity.
  • Policies are needed to support cultural maintenance and promote a multicultural society.
  • Multiculturalism is not only about acknowledging and valuing diversity but also promoting it.

Key Aspects of a Multicultural Society

  • All cultures and ethnicities are acknowledged.
  • The indigenous rights of tangata whenua are honored and recognized.
  • Full and equitable participation of every individual is promoted.
  • The existence of all ethnic communities, their histories, and heritages are celebrated.
  • Intercultural understanding is promoted.
  • Equity is a key consideration.

Is Multiculturalism a Failure?

  • Some believe multiculturalism has failed, with different understandings evolving over time.
  • The 1950s assumed that people would integrate in their own way if they could keep significant aspects of their culture.
  • The 1980s focused on tolerance and equal rights.
  • Now, there is a positive promotion of religious and ethnic identities.

Concerns

  • Multiculturalism may encourage cultures to lead separate lives away from the mainstream.
  • Questioning whether the goal is tolerance or being one society.

Professor Colin Ward's Interview

  • Professor Colin Ward from Victoria University discusses multicultural societies and distinguishes between multiculturalism and bicultural heritage.

Smith's Experience with Jury Duty

  • Smith's positioning: multiculturalism is a mindset of being aware of differences, open-minded, and willing to coexist.
  • It involves doing our best to get through the day together in the jury room, school, or community.

Final Thoughts

  • Multiculturalism involves being open-minded, willing to do our best, and willing to coexist.
  • It also includes valuing and promoting cultural diversity.
  • Some consider it a complete failure.